Skip to content

[TSDD-KNOWLEDGE-01.4–.5] Complete knowledge-aware Wizard and workspace receiver adoption #4642

Closed
14 of 14 issues completed

Description

@EHotwagner

Owner

Programme/root owns full cross-repository acceptance and sole native/PR integration. Existing1115 source owner /root/legacy_pr_adoption,4723 source custodian /root/knowledge_qualification_prep and4727 source owner /root/knowledge_supplier retain their branches, attempts and promises.

Done when

Complete TSDD-KNOWLEDGE-01.4–.5: qualify the selected published producer/provider/Wizard composition in fresh generated workspaces and promised retained upgrades, preserving user content, concise evidence-backed knowledge, the 10 MiB canonical-store boundary and refusal behavior.

Current deliverable

All eleven current native children are CLOSED/COMPLETED, including PLAYER4780: full two-row published provider acceptance #4780 (comment), protected source24c1, verified Project3 Done and native completed closure2026-10-21T20:22:25Z. Accepted4773 and earlier scopes remain. This does not complete the parent; no child runtime or review remains active.

Next action

Programme/root continues the selected PROC/LEARN/UTEL priorities. Reopen the held literal-safe Wizard positives when the existing SDD1113 supplier establishes selected publication and installed adoption. Remaining unselected COMPLETE/provider/Rendering routes and retained upgrades retain the existing priority deferral unless selected as a direct product unblocker; their full contracts require canonical intake before new implementation. Root and the existing PLAYER owner retain actual PLAYER Atlas acceptance capture for the next natural owning source delivery.

Blocked on

The literal-safe Wizard positives require genuine published SDD containing971e and actual installed adoption;1113 Commands occupancy remains Unknown. Other remaining variants/routes/retained upgrades are uncompleted and remain deferred by the existing PROC/LEARN/UTEL priority, not technically proved impossible. No current child operation remains active. Full original Done when, suppliers, history and historical Unknowns are unchanged.

Acceptance evidence

Priority reconciliation2026-10-21: user selected PROC/LEARN/UTEL; additional workspace/provider variants and BAR comparison are deferred unless a direct product unblocker. Protected enrollment PR #4781 mergedf8b2088efcf03f96252dcdd92f8bda7b84983f24. The original installed111 read selected/attempted/observed62 members with zero writes; its report does not establish receiver acceptance or selector activation. Report SHA25627641699e3c4aa7278c2b8ffd5893e9b942892edeab0eda2caa933186ff8a1e4;62/17/8 schema coverage comes from the separately accepted initializer snapshot. All promises, owners and original evidence below remain unchanged. The provider preparation terminal return retains assembly05 review PASS, actual03RuntimeLaunched=false and original01/02 failures; no historical reservation was released. SDD knowledge plan; Wizard plan. Preserve the stopped unlanded bulk-object-store proposal as historical non-delivery; it is not a new queue. Unified v3 outcome index.

Accepted milestone2026-10-20 supersedes the earlier missing Rendering knowledge assertion only:4708 complete, source/report/Atlas delivered. Stable Atlas github/current-public-knowledge-qualification digest253bb17320020b6a5ef8f0958856f6c565a239b4dc246d9e825f8b14da9ca8de. Original Standard receiver/discovery evidence and failures remain distinct. Full original Done when and undecomposed remaining promises are retained; parent4642 remains OPEN.

Next meaningful child materialized2026-10-20:4720 now owns console creation/capture/recovery with complete acceptance, preserving every other provider/raw-template/retained-upgrade assertion. Prerequisite source4721/ae026a75 prepares accepted complete38 enrollment; actual installed109 qualification and source-selection02 plus adjacent facts accepted. The actor owns one isolated source branch; no console runtime result or full parent acceptance is inferred. Earlier next-child4708 wording is historical;4708 remains accepted at its completed scope.

Accepted milestone2026-10-20:4720 complete scoped child, source/report/Atlas delivered26eec966789318d99b20929a67e0990224b66431. Stable Atlas github/public-console-knowledge-receiver digest4be7778c4f491d55154a028d9a9dbb35059953fbcd243e0206902a6e64645efb. This supersedes console CI/integration holds only. Parent whole original Done when, earlier evidence and all undecomposed required promises remain; OPEN.

Accepted source prerequisite2026-10-20: child SDD1115 complete, PR FS-GG/FS.GG.SDD#1116 exactc963 merged971e9e787da1567191168adfd2758107b210166a independently read back. Final required sourceCI/API/format/downstream gates passed; 2771 pass/zero fail/14 explicit skips and real production/causal controls retain their scoped original receipts. This supersedes source-only holds, not publication or installed acceptance. Parent whole remaining promise stays OPEN and Ready pending next supported child operation admission.

Root boundary readback preserves full Done when, existing owners and all original reservations. Child4723 retained recovery establishes22passed/2held; original sourceowner integrates accurate report/Atlas/CI. Child4727 fixture passed, while genuine Python journeys and remaining whole Outcome acceptance stay open.

Root boundary2026-10-20 retains complete scoped Done when and all original ownership/holds. Child4723 accepted supported22/2 report/source via PR4726 protected12a8 and is now Blocked only on two genuine published Python Wizard positives. Whole4642 remains actively executing child4727 coherent source021 and genuine source-candidate prerequisites; all other original assertions stay open.

Historical boundary before public021 qualification (retained verbatim):

Next action: Root may accept scoped4741, then separately admit the existing4723owner reviewed minimal closed021two-held-row continuation and actualpublicPythonWizardtyped/default Matrixjourneys. Preserve original22accepted rows/alloldinputs/refusal414 and fulloriginal parentDonewhen; no genericcompletion or sourcecandidate substitution.

Historical prior current-work fields (superseded as current disposition; retained verbatim):

Current deliverable: Complete scoped4741 acceptance is evidenced. Reviewed current021/110 source PR4748/exact-head requiredCI/protectedmerge and genuine three-member candidate39459556960/artifact12281917883 remain accepted; read-only preflight39461041032 accepted. Root separately admitted publication39462099428/a1, terminal success/all8verified/gen17, promoted release418651768/exactsource12480 and both-feed normalizedpayload57232ac joined. Root accepted scopedpublication and released ONLY its main12480 retention reservation. Actual isolated installation from genuine public signed021archive4326f57d and absolute installedapphost --help passed1.0367s:88files exactpublicpayload,81genuine110source42members,ELFtarget/EOF/reaped/groupsabsent. This is actual published installedcaller smoke proof, not sourcecandidate substitution or PythonMatrix acceptance. This completes only child4741 supplier publication/isolatedinstalledcaller scope; whole4642 remains open and its two genuinepublishedPythonMatrixpositives remain unaccepted.
Next action: Root has accepted scoped4741 genuine021 publication/isolated caller. Source-only4723 continuation PR4755 merged0145217 after exact-head CI and workspace selftest. The existing4723 owner now performs the separately admitted two genuine published Python Wizard typed/default cases, preserving all prior22 accepted rows, originals/refusal414 and full parent Done when. No new runtime or whole-parent acceptance is claimed.
Blocked on: Whole4642 residual acceptance remains with existing scoped owners, including4723twoactualpublicPythonWizardpositives. Child4741has no identifiedremainingacceptancegap; its scopedlimits/history/Unknowns remain retained.

Root disposition2026-10-20: parent4642 remains In progress for active owned intake4759. Accepted4723 is closed at24 subjects; the full parent promise remains uncompleted. No4759 membership, planning initialization, implementation or runtime admission is created by this body reconciliation.

Accepted scoped milestone2026-10-20:4759 CLOSED/COMPLETED at22:43:23Z; accepted full report59f4eaffd64ca02bea9bcd1a58ac51b9101f8c625bc4b3529103da63ce7d1786 and independent full review/retirement joined by root. This supersedes only the earlier4759 not-enrolled/not-selected/raw-player qualification holds. Other variants, routes, publication/installed suppliers, retained upgrades and parent whole acceptance remain OPEN. Root-owned bounded remaining intake is the current meaningful execution.

Prior parent current fields before accepted4759/remaining-intake reconciliation:
Current deliverable: Delivery4723 is accepted/closed at its complete24-subject scope: original22 subjects/979 commands and original414 failure retained, then two genuine public021 Python Wizard rows passed without replay under the merged0145217 adapter and one original600 window. This does not complete4642. New independently meaningful Delivery #4759 was created once and parent4642 link independently read back. Existing knowledge receiver owner /root/knowledge_qualification_prep retains4759; source implementation/runtime are not selected or enrolled yet.

Next action: Root prepares protected55 intake after BAR54 accepted protectedpair, then actual source admission for4759's two current-published RAW Fable-player knowledge receivers: explicittyped and true omitted-defaulttyped/player. Genuine Workspace019/SDD2.2/Fable5.18/Fantomas8.0.5 support standalone knowledge initialization independently of bindings/Governance/browser holds. Preserve completed4723, all original ownership and accepted scope. Repaired-producer release readiness remains a separate source-only opportunity requiring mapped intake and explicit coherent identity selection; prospective2.4 is not selected or allocated by this proposal.

Blocked on: No external supplier blocker is identified for4759 raw standalone knowledge. Protected enrollment/source and later finite runtime admission remain pending. The two deferred public Wizard-bindings positives still require a genuinely published literal-safe SDD containing971e and actual installed adoption; existing1113 original selected2.3 Commands occupancyUnknown remains scoped, unretried and unmodified. Other unaccepted supported Fable-game variants/routes, external Rendering raw/provider/omission routes and preserving retained upgrades remain with full parent acceptance, not narrowed by4759. Source/publication/adoption and per-route evidence must satisfy https://github.com/FS-GG/FS.GG.SDD/blob/971e9e787da1567191168adfd2758107b210166a/docs/roadmaps/tsdd-knowledge-01.md#L158-L178 and https://github.com/FS-GG/FS.GG.Templates/blob/f5fbd06ed9e6df40f9037c7acddf9eca3c6a14fc/docs/roadmaps/tsdd-knowledge-receivers.md#candidate-and-installed-acceptance . Full parent Done when/owners/evidence/history,439 inherited plus46 later Unknowns and all holds remain unchanged.

Accepted scoped milestone2026-10-21:4766 RAW COMPLETE CLOSED/COMPLETED and root-verified Done, following source6e046642, actual report e5a2bd19, independent full review e428f905 and root full acceptance54ee72d4. All177 command receipts/custody and178 known PID/group absence were independently verified; root retired only its current4GiB allocation. This supersedes only4766 COMPLETE qualification holds. Whole parent/provider/Wizard/product, remaining routes and retained upgrades remain OPEN.

Prior parent current fields before accepted4766 reconciliation:
Current deliverable: Scoped raw-player Delivery4759 is fully accepted and CLOSED/COMPLETED after source3378eef9179aea164ce61001e84aaf4ce8608f0f/PR4763, actual14 compiled CI controls, genuine public Workspace019 explicit typed and true lifecycle/bundle-omitted receiver rows,155 actual commands, independent full acceptance review12fab1e223c30c6cb47256834a89d8cec5c623c58fc9613ea2de5dd520858762 and independently verified retirement/custody7882ad64266e3e7554b137cc543e4120e6b0fac57a46bdce0a80e2c6c0b59733. Prior4723 remains accepted at its complete24-subject scope with original22/979/414 history and later two public021 Python rows unchanged. These scoped child acceptances do not complete4642.

Next action: Programme/root has selected one original bounded600-second remaining4642 intake by existing /root/legacy_pr_adoption. Read the full original governing plans and current published support to identify the next independently meaningful remaining route, preserving retained upgrade, or mapped repaired-producer release-readiness opportunity. This is active bounded intake, not native implementation/publication/runtime admission. Do not retry1113 Commands occupancyUnknown, allocate a new producer identity, or create a new child until canonical admission. Retain existing owners, accepted children and all original remaining promises; root reconciles the actual next supplier after intake.

Blocked on: No4759 raw-player supplier hold remains after its scoped acceptance. Remaining parent assertions and their actual supplier prerequisites are unchanged. The two deferred public Wizard-bindings positives still require a genuinely published literal-safe SDD containing971e and actual installed adoption; existing1113 original selected2.3 Commands occupancyUnknown remains scoped, unretried and unmodified. Other unaccepted supported Fable-game variants/routes, external Rendering raw/provider/omission routes and preserving retained upgrades remain with full parent acceptance, not narrowed by4759. Source/publication/adoption and per-route evidence must satisfy https://github.com/FS-GG/FS.GG.SDD/blob/971e9e787da1567191168adfd2758107b210166a/docs/roadmaps/tsdd-knowledge-01.md#L158-L178 and https://github.com/FS-GG/FS.GG.Templates/blob/f5fbd06ed9e6df40f9037c7acddf9eca3c6a14fc/docs/roadmaps/tsdd-knowledge-receivers.md#candidate-and-installed-acceptance . Full parent Done when/owners/evidence/history,439 inherited plus46 later Unknowns and all holds remain unchanged.

Historical prior parent Next action and Blocked on before retired-intake/ready-enrollment reconciliation (retained verbatim):

Next action: Programme/root retains remaining route/prerequisite reconciliation and existing active work under the full original plans. The nearest supported unaccepted Fable slice identified by fresh owning-plan and packed019 inspection is the retained legacy raw product selected explicitly with --svgFoundation false: explicit typed-sdd versus genuinely omitted lifecycle, whose actual packed default is sdd rather than the current template's typed-sdd. This is a read-only next-slice proposal, not new intake, child creation, owner dispatch, implementation or runtime admission. Root must first reconcile the complete remaining inventory/duplicates and retained-upgrade promises, choose a meaningful scope and canonical owner/child, then separately qualify enrollment/source and actual runtime prerequisites. No accepted4759/4766/4723 receiver is replayed.

Blocked on: No4766 RAW COMPLETE supplier or acceptance hold remains. Two deferred public Wizard-bindings positives still require a genuinely published literal-safe SDD containing971e and actual installed adoption; existing1113 selected2.3 Commands occupancyUnknown remains unretried/unmodified. Other unaccepted supported Fable variants/routes, retained legacy product, external Rendering raw/provider/omission routes and preserving retained upgrades remain with full parent acceptance and their actual supplier prerequisites. Legacy raw support is authenticated in existing public019 packed definitions, not a producer publication blocker, but its selection/default/preservation and complete knowledge assertions remain unqualified. Parent provider/Wizard/product and all remaining promises, existing owners/history,439 inherited plus46 later Unknown effects/reservations remain unchanged and unreleased. Parent4642 remains OPEN/In progress for remaining active work.

Accepted RAW legacy milestone: #4769 completed its full asymmetric scope after normal source PR #4772, exact independent source review and 12 actual hosted controls. The genuine public operation passed 119 commands: the explicit typed row completed standalone knowledge capture/recovery and boundary assertions, while genuine omitted raw SDD preserved its owner assets without knowledge initialization, CI or checker. Root accepted the full result and independent retirement, then verified native completion and Project 3 Done. Accepted #4723, #4759 and #4766 scopes remain unchanged. None of these closes the full parent promise.

Selected provider intake milestone: #4773 is a native child with a complete six-field contract. Its provider descriptor defaults to typed SDD, and published SDD 2.2.0 source owns automatic knowledge initialization and a documented structural tool-manifest merge. Exact co-tenant values, types, property presence and modes remain required; layout ownership is limited to that hybrid writer and does not weaken accepted RAW byte-span promises. Project membership appeared with an Unknown actor; no duplicate add was sent. Actual typed planning, authentic pair generation, protected delivery, installed qualification and implementation retain their separate gates.

Historical prior current-action fields before accepted RAW legacy and selected provider intake reconciliation (preserved verbatim):

Current deliverable: Scoped RAW COMPLETE Delivery4766 is fully accepted, CLOSED/COMPLETED and Project3 Done. Normal protected SOURCE PR4768 merged6e0466420a8dfae9ec6fbb976de36a300cd924df with exact independent source review and actual9 compiled controls. Genuine public019 two-row COMPLETE runtime passed explicit typed-sdd and genuinely omitted lifecycle,177 actual commands, complete owner/initial-Git/knowledge/export/bundle/size-boundary promises and independent full reviewe428f90576135c64bcbd4c4b21aeabfcd218d8320e850dff1193bb7628e47ecc. Report SHAe5a2bd194f83398db1b37c5ecd988fe280032cd5380d8385bbd5886dd7f36fb5; root full acceptance54ee72d4b4605d1da93b0913e8b534be83a81238192998bfb1f4a0f4bc260167. Native closure2026-10-21T00:00:46Z and final body5a670fabce93046708e73091fd9d700249bc7e7e6a616bbde35a3e2791c2ae3b independently read back; root Done outcomeae029dc3a428c477f8e75710db6c2522077bb80ca0337b7c830988b70b7b6051 preserved all56/17/8 installed native coverage. Accepted4759 RAW PLAYER and4723 complete24-subject scope remain unchanged; these scoped child acceptances do not complete4642.

Next action: Programme/root has accepted the next asymmetric retained legacy raw scope and owns its canonical enrollment. The bounded read-only legacy intake is complete and retired; no active owner operation remains under4642. Prepare that accepted canonical enrollment when protected-main capacity becomes available after the existing4765 CI/release horizon, then separately select its genuine source/runtime prerequisites. This is a concrete waiting-capacity next action, not active execution or membership/dispatch authority. Do not replay accepted children or invent a release.

Blocked on: No4766 supplier/acceptance hold remains, and all eight current native children are CLOSED/COMPLETED. The root-accepted asymmetric legacy scope is ready for canonical enrollment, waiting for protected-main capacity behind4765 CI/release horizon; no meaningful4642 owner operation is currently active. Other full-parent residual promises and actual supplier holds remain: deferred Wizard-bindings publication/installed adoption, untouched1113 occupancyUnknown, other supported routes and preserving retained upgrades. These do not waive the concrete next enrollment or complete the parent. Preserve full Owner/Done when/history, existing owners and439 inherited plus46 later Unknowns. Parent4642 remains OPEN; root separately selects In progress-to-Ready Status, no closure.

Historical current-field boundary before2026-10-21 terminal reconciliation (preserved):

Current deliverable: Nine scoped children are accepted, including RAW legacy #4769, now closed/completed and Project 3 Done. Delivery #4773 owns the next genuine published Fable-game retained non-SVG PROVIDER qualification. Its canonical intake and enrollment preparation are active; it has no implementation PR or receiver acceptance.

Next action: Programme/root selected #4773 after deduplication and public SDD 2.2.0 source inspection. The same sole source/receiver owner prepares canonical cohort 58 enrollment while root sequences the qualified absent-only initializer, authentic constructor, normal protected enrollment carrier and full installed caller 111 qualification of all 58 items. Only then may root admit implementation. Both provider rows must prove automatic typed initialization: explicit lifecycle selection and genuine provider omission, which differs from accepted RAW omission. The proposed source paths are a new knowledge-fable-game-provider-public.py adapter, the existing self-test workflow and knowledge roadmap. This active root-selected intake explains In progress; completed children do not establish parent completion.

Blocked on: The current provider slice needs absent-only native planning initialization, authentic protected cohort 58 enrollment and full installed caller qualification before implementation. These effects need separate root admission and preserved current native facts. No new producer publication is required for ordinary ASCII parameters through the published SDD 2.2.0 direct descriptor. Deferred literal-safe Wizard-bindings positives still need the appropriate genuine published producer and installed adoption; #1113 selected SDD 2.3 occupancy remains Unknown and fenced. Other provider/Wizard routes and promised retained upgrades remain open. Accepted manual extraction and retained console migration are not reopened; no old store is retired.

Historical current-field boundary before runtime02/canonical62 triage (retained):

Current deliverable: Nine scoped children remain accepted, including RAW legacy4769. Provider Delivery4773 owns the next complete genuine published non-SVG provider qualification. Enrollment58/installed111 qualification and normal source PR4776 delivery are accepted; actual runtime01 failed the first scaffold output bound, so no full receiver or parent acceptance follows.

Next action: The existing4773 source/receiver owner and independent reviewer diagnose the original provider scaffold JSON-output bound and select a supported narrow output correction. Root retains source/runtime admission and full acceptance. In parallel, the same owner reconciles the whole remaining provider/Wizard and retained-upgrade promise against the governing plans to identify the next meaningful eligible slice. Enrollment and initial implementation prerequisites are already accepted and are not repeated.

Blocked on: Current4773 actual two-row qualification remains unaccepted after its original output-bound failure; source delivery is complete. Deferred literal-safe Wizard-bindings positives still require the genuine published producer and installed adoption;1113 selected2.3 Commands occupancy remains Unknown and fenced. Other provider/Wizard routes and promised retained upgrades remain open, with their specific prerequisites under bounded source inspection. Accepted manual extraction, retained console migration and prior children are preserved; no old store is retired.

Historical current-field boundary before PROC/LEARN/UTEL priority deferral (preserved verbatim):

Current deliverable: Nine scoped children remain accepted. Legacy-provider4773 has delivered source through4779 and is repairing the diagnosed root caller permission-mask boundary before complete actual acceptance. New unique PLAYER-provider4780 is linked to this Outcome; its four planning fields are initialized and protected cohort62 carrier PR4781 is in normal delivery. These are separate useful scopes, not parent completion.

Next action: Continue existing4773 owner through reviewed caller correction and separately admitted actual two-receiver qualification. In parallel complete protected62 enrollment/full installed111 inspection, then select one source/receiver owner for4780's complete PLAYER provider scope. Sequence shared workflow/roadmap integration and actual CLR operations while allowing disjoint source/design work. The complete remaining provider/Wizard/Rendering/retained-upgrade inventory remains governed by the original plans.

Blocked on: 4773 complete runtime acceptance and4780 protected enrollment/source/actual qualification remain pending. Deferred literal-safe Wizard-bindings positives still require genuine published and installed SDD containing971e;1113 Commands2.3 occupancy Unknown is untouched. Other COMPLETE/provider/Wizard/Rendering routes and exact promised retained upgrades remain open with their actual suppliers; source availability is not acceptance. All accepted children, original owners, failures and historical Unknowns remain preserved.

## Accepted deterministic orchestration integration — 2026-10-21

The user accepted the comprehensive framework and product workspace orchestration design and requested Coordination-board incorporation. That LEARN issue holds the complete design, source findings, replacement contracts, delivery sequence and integrated acceptance.

Workspace adoption integration: qualify the shared deterministic controller in genuine product workspaces as well as framework repositories. The resolved WorkspaceExecutionContract composes SDD lifecycle/model, provider toolchain/capabilities/product skills, Governance obligations, Atlas references and observed host capabilities. Existing framework repositories and local-only products are supported without another scheduler. Generated guidance remains a projection. Preserve the full existing knowledge/Wizard/fresh-and-retained acceptance; this design adds controller integration rather than declaring existing receiver work completed. Do not create unrelated provider variants merely to implement orchestration.

Source incorporation: the existing accountable owner includes this requirement when preparing the relevant next contract/roadmap delivery and captures its durable ADR/Atlas references. No new implementation owner, worker dispatch, runtime activation, publication, issue closure, project-field change or reservation release is made by this issue amendment. Existing original evidence, operations and remaining acceptance are preserved.

Previous priority disposition retained before explicit user reopening, 2026-10-21

Current deliverable: Nine scoped children remain accepted. Legacy-provider4773 retains delivered source and reviewed DISABLED caller assembly05; its preparation is retired and no runtime03 started. Unique PLAYER-provider4780 is canonically enrolled in protected cohort62 and included in the installed111 full62 read, but source is undispatched. Remaining provider/PLAYER continuation is explicitly deferred; these milestones do not complete this Outcome.

Next action: No concrete parent continuation is admitted under the user's current PROC/LEARN/UTEL priority. Programme/root preserves the complete remaining provider, Wizard, Rendering and retained-upgrade inventory and its existing owners. Reopen the relevant same-owner child only after explicitly selecting it as a priority or direct product unblocker and freshly admitting its actual prerequisites and bounded work. Accepted children are not replayed and child milestones do not close the parent.

Blocked on: Explicit priority deferral leaves no active child operation for the remaining provider/PLAYER scope. 4773's full actual acceptance and4780's source/actual qualification remain outstanding. Deferred literal-safe Wizard-bindings positives still require genuine published and installed SDD containing971e;1113 Commands2.3 occupancy Unknown remains untouched. Other COMPLETE/provider/Wizard/Rendering routes and exact promised retained upgrades retain their suppliers and complete acceptance; all original owners, failures and historical Unknowns remain preserved.

Prior active fields before accepted4773 and activePLAYER4795
Current deliverable: Programme/root has reopened existing children4773 and4780 under the user’s explicit authorization to implement the board unblock fixes and continue. Same-owner4773 input/caller preparation is active; PLAYER4780 source ownership is being finalized. Accepted RAW and other child milestones remain at their original scopes.
Next action: Carry4773 through its reviewed caller correction and complete genuine published two-row qualification; implement and qualify4780 with one isolated owner, sequencing shared source integration. Reconcile each accepted Delivery before the parent. Keep all other provider/Wizard/Rendering/retained-upgrade assertions and suppliers in the complete original promise.
Blocked on: The priority-only deferral no longer holds4773/4780. Their remaining source/runtime/independent acceptance gates are active work; other scoped suppliers remain, including literal-safe Wizard positives requiring genuine published SDD containing971e and original1113 Commands occupancy Unknown.
Prior active fields before complete PLAYER child acceptance and remaining-scope reconciliation
Current deliverable: Child4773 is fully accepted and CLOSED/COMPLETED after independent two-row genuine published nonSVG provider qualification; nativeStatusDone verified. [Acceptance](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/issues/4773#issuecomment-6324485155) retains complete product/initialGit/knowledge/recovery/tool evidence and original failures. Existing PLAYER4780 owner has independently reviewed source at62ada85c on [PR4795](https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/pull/4795), with13pure controls passed; hostedCI and disabled full runtime preparation are active. Accepted RAW and other milestones retain original scopes.
Next action: Complete4780 required/material exact-headCI and normal protected source delivery, then separately admit its prepared genuine published two-row qualification and independent whole-result acceptance. Root captures the reusable4773/4780 composition findings through the next normal owning source delivery. Reconcile each accepted Delivery before this parent; all other provider/Wizard/Rendering/retained-upgrade assertions remain.
Blocked on: No blocker remains on accepted4773. PLAYER4780 is active; its source/hosted/runtime gates remain. Other scoped suppliers persist, including literal-safe Wizard positives needing genuine published SDD containing971e and1113 Commands occupancyUnknown. Parent completion is not established.

Activity

  1. EHotwagner commented on Oct 21, 2026

    @EHotwagner
    ContributorAuthor

    Root reconciled all eleven native children after accepted PLAYER4780: every child is closed/completed, while the full parent promise remains open. Full PLAYER acceptance covers only its complete two-row scope. Fresh inspection of the owning SDD .4/.5 and Templates receiver contracts confirms that other provider/Wizard/Rendering routes and retained upgrades remain separate. The literal-safe Wizard supplier still depends on1113 publication/adoption; additional variants retain the existing PROC/LEARN/UTEL priority deferral. No child operation remains active, so root reconciles parent Status from In progress to Blocked on these named supplier/priority prerequisites. A closed-child rollup is not parent acceptance.

  2. EHotwagner commented on Oct 23, 2026

    @EHotwagner
    ContributorAuthor

    fdev decision (user-delegated): evidence for the two deferred Wizard-bindings positives; remainder homes

    The supplier condition is met.

    This replaces the "awaiting SDD1113" blocker.

    Source PR first. tests/new-sdd-workspace/knowledge-public-receivers.py (L156–158) holds both fable-bindings-wizard-* rows at execute=False, under an SDD.Cli 2.2.0 pin. One routine source PR with one independent review must enable them and repin to SDD.Cli 2.4.0 / Wizard 0.21.0 / the current template.

    Then one read-only hosted run (public feeds, isolated HOME, unpinned Wizard):

    Row Assertion
    W-typed --template fable-bindings --lifecycle typed-sdd with explicit bindingTarget, npm package and exact npm version. Literal values preserved byte-for-byte (the #1115 class). Root SDD pin exactly 2.4.0. Canonical knowledge and owner CI present. The #4723 typed checks apply: four captures; retrieval, history and version; cache-free clone retrieval; lossless export/restore; checker at 10,485,760 / 10,485,761 bytes; owner-preserving refusals.
    W-default Lifecycle omitted. Literal values preserved; sdd recorded (the descriptor default); no automatic canonical knowledge or CI.
    Control A wrong-key or insufficient-producer refusal.
    Readback The installed fsgg-sdd --version is 2.4.0. Wizard self-update is best-effort, so this must be read, not assumed.

    Acceptance: fdev, after one independent review of the artifact against hash-matched package identities.

    After acceptance:

    — fdev

  3. EHotwagner commented on Oct 23, 2026

    @EHotwagner
    ContributorAuthor

    Evidence for the two deferred Wizard-bindings positives (per the fdev decision above)

    Source PR. #4826, merged as fa3e87f8d0ee1548c4a57e0d6cb2d17ae04e7f5a with --match-head-commit e785e3c7be6d350ed82c4beaea7a0c605b1e5bd3. One independent fsgg-critic-best review of that exact head returned ACCEPT (record); required CI at the head was 54 pass, 5 skipped, 0 failing.

    Hosted run. https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/actions/runs/39919641656 (workflow_dispatch on fa3e87f8, contents: read, public nuget.org, isolated HOME, Wizard unpinned, no token in any child): success, 59 commands. Artifact wizard-bindings-public-acceptance (report.json plus the command journal and every command's output hashes). One independent review of the artifact returned ACCEPT: all four package archives re-downloaded from nuget.org and hash-matched, all 118 recorded output hashes matched, 59/59 process groups absent.

    Row Result
    W-typed --lifecycle typed-sdd, @babylonjs/core / 9.19.0 / browser; effective parameters exact (key is bindingTarget); root SDD pin 2.4.0; canonical knowledge and owner CI byte-identical to the Workspace.Template 0.19.3 payload; four captures, retrieval/history (2 versions)/get-version, cache-free clone, lossless export/restore, stale-writer, excluded-input and restore no-clobber refusals; checker passes at 10,485,760 bytes and refuses at 10,485,761 (exit 1).
    W-default lifecycle omitted; same literals; sdd recorded; no .fsgg/knowledge, no owner CI.
    Control wrong key target refused at the provider edge (exit 2, provider exit 127, '--target=browser' is not a valid option, zero produced paths).
    Readback SDD 2.3.0 installed first; the unpinned Wizard updated it to 2.4.0 ("updated from version '2.3.0' to '2.4.0'"); fsgg-sdd --version read 2.4.0; tool list Wizard 0.21.0 / sdd.cli 2.4.0.

    Hash-matched identities (SHA-256): Wizard 0.21.0 4326f57dc41ab3feaf6b7b693dcdc2867e818b0567af27da505b571aace4e190; SDD.Cli 2.4.0 1df2e74faebd388f90b813ed9d7497f4247f977718469c9247b37111d791921f; SDD.Cli 2.3.0 (predecessor) 5af05931d7ca0f158d2bfc562047261a38ca098ca6dc3635750eadcc4ed1c3ca; Workspace.Template 0.19.3 9594ec204a26f238a06e016d1cfe1e796a07fda23c16589eceb19366cd4a72a2 (equals the registry's signed raw SHA-256).

    Done-when for this slice. The decision's evidence clauses (source PR with independent review, merge on ACCEPT and green, one read-only hosted run with the four rows, independent artifact review) are met. Acceptance itself is fdev's and is not claimed here. The parent #4642 Done-when is not met: promised retained upgrades and any unaccepted supported route remain on #4822, and #3010's added obligation is untouched. I did not close #4642 or change any board field.

    Caveats for the acceptance decision.

    1. Deviation from the decision text: the rows are enabled in a new dedicated adapter, not in knowledge-public-receivers.py. That file is hash-pinned by the sibling adapters and carries the accepted 24-subject record; it still lists both rows as deferred. Please ratify or direct otherwise.
    2. Workspace.Template 0.19.3 admits only 9.19.0 and browser for these symbols, so the explicit values equal the defaults; the generated files cannot distinguish a passed literal from a dropped one. Routing is shown by the SDD provenance effectiveParameters, and the control shows a wrong key fails.
    3. The no-token claim rests on the reviewed adapter and workflow; the journal does not record child environments. The run is time-sensitive (unpinned inputs, descriptor main).
    4. Atlas capture of this finding is not yet delivered; it stays with the next natural owning source delivery.

    fdev

  4. EHotwagner commented on Oct 23, 2026

    @EHotwagner
    ContributorAuthor

    fdev 2026-10-23: ACCEPTED: the literal-safe Wizard-bindings positives slice. PR #4826 (fa3e87f8, critic ACCEPT on its exact head) and read-only hosted run 39919641656, whose artifact independently reviewed ACCEPT with the package hashes re-matched against nuget.org. The evidence clauses of 6359589826 for this slice are met.

    Ratified deviation: the rows live in a new adapter, tests/new-sdd-workspace/knowledge-wizard-bindings-public.py, rather than editing knowledge-public-receivers.py, whose sha256 is pinned and which carries the accepted 24-subject record. The earlier adapter's "deferred" listing is superseded by this comment, and the next source touch should cross-reference it.

    Recorded limits:

    • On 0.19.3 the explicit values equal the defaults; the passing is shown only by the SDD provenance effectiveParameters.
    • The no-token claim rests on the reviewed code; the journal doesn't record child environments.
    • Reproducible only while SDD 2.4.0 and template 0.19.3 stay current.

    #4642 stays open as the parent. The remaining Done-when (retained upgrades and the unaccepted routes) is on #4822. Status: Ready → Blocked, waiting on #4822's selection.

  5. EHotwagner commented on Oct 23, 2026

    @EHotwagner
    ContributorAuthor

    fdev 2026-10-23: ACCEPTED: #4642 (TSDD-KNOWLEDGE-01.4–.5) complete (CLOSE-WITH-GAPS), after an independent closure review. This supersedes the stale "Current deliverable", "Next action" and "Blocked on" sections.

    Done-when Evidence
    Published producer, provider and Wizard composition in fresh workspaces 14 sub-issues accepted; #4822 closed with its final route mapping (6364409975)
    Literal-safe Wizard-bindings positives run 39919641656 (6360126520)
    Promised retained upgrades R1–R4 accepted
    Concise, evidence-backed knowledge; 10 MiB boundary; refusals the #4723 probe in every typed row
    SDD .5 publication and adoption SDD 2.4.0 (SDD#1119), Wizard 0.22.0 (#4811), registry reconciled

    Transferred and recorded:

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions