Skip to content

Qualify published Fable COMPLETE provider knowledge composition #4798

Closed

Description

@EHotwagner

Owner

/root/knowledge_player_receiver; Programme/root owns source integration, Atlas/packaged registry capture, finite runtime and native acceptance.

Done when

Both genuine published fresh Fable COMPLETE provider rows, explicit typed lifecycle and genuinely omitted/default lifecycle, prove automatic canonical knowledge initialization with authenticated descriptor/precedence/package/source selection; the exact applicable owner inventory of the selected published package (0.19.0: 171 owner files/12 exclusions/53 complete-only; selected 0.19.1 after the Templates#729 supplier fix: 175/12/57) [root amendment 2026-10-22: the count is package-bound, the promise is unchanged] with modes and complete-only content; exact compiled supplier skill union/provenance and preserved authored assets; full parentless initial Git tree identity; all four synthetic evidence-backed findings, get/search/relations/evidence/history/idempotence and expected stale/prohibited-source refusals; no-clobber restore, cache-free clone, private exclusion, ALL-shared export/restore, Git bundle/current/history recovery and ordinary Git inclusion; exact10485760/+1 checker controls. One independent source review, hosted causal controls, exact-head normal PR/check/merge, separately admitted finite actual two-row runtime with full closure/seals/retirement, independent complete result acceptance and native readbacks. Preserve PLAYER original failure and accepted runtime02; no product/browser/WASM execution or claim of Wizard/literal-safe/retained-upgrade acceptance.

Current deliverable

Source slice 1 delivered earlier: PR #4803 merged at c9621e2d6ea65355fb7cf9b973160db2f10b5246.
Re-pin to the published Workspace.Template 0.19.1 and Atlas capture: PR #4804 (open, not merged), exact head c297f2a66136235c750b4161f1721cd9c539cc80 on branch routine/4798-complete-provider-0191; adapter tests/new-sdd-workspace/knowledge-fable-game-complete-provider-public.py is byte-identical to the independently reviewed (ACCEPT) head 6dcda4b32db3210cee9f117e561cc50b8d6305f9; the last commit changes only Atlas/registry files (delta review ACCEPT at the exact head). CI at the exact head: 58 pass, 4 skip, 0 fail.
The fresh finite two-row public runtime against Workspace.Template 0.19.1 and SDD.Cli 2.2.0 PASSED both rows (explicit typed lifecycle, genuinely omitted lifecycle; bundle=complete; no svgFoundation). Independent result review: ACCEPT-WITH-NITS. The earlier 0.19.0 attempt failure on policy.c is retained and not cleared retroactively.

Next action

Root integrates PR #4804 at its exact head (all required checks green; routine marker bound to c297f2a6), then performs native readbacks, amends the Done when counts (171/12/53 became 175/12/57 for Workspace.Template 0.19.1; the four added files are the FourD local-save-replay example), and decides Delivery acceptance/closure. A source merge does not by itself close the Delivery; hosted causal controls for the 0.19.1 re-pin are the existing selftest line plus the opt-in package controls (not hosted CI). Retire the owner staging dirs ~/.cache/p4798-dl-*, ~/.cache/p4798-scratch and ~/.cache/venv-4798 once no longer needed; the retained receivers and private evidence stay.

Blocked on

Nothing external for the runtime. Remaining root-owned: integration of PR #4804, native readbacks, Done-when count amendment and Status. Historical Unknowns, PLAYER original failures and accepted PLAYER/non-SVG acceptance are unchanged; no product/browser/WASM execution and no Wizard/literal-safe/retained-upgrade claim.

Acceptance evidence

Runtime 2026-10-22 (PASSED, one original attempt per row, no retry): Workspace.Template 0.19.1 nuget.org sha256 5d1886c37b6e6a0d64c3998ee23e76b4c5ba8b8a0c2136200c377d7bbab7d0c6 (commit 1e95dddb6326d276773154df1336599907d8dbfe; the GitHub Release asset fs-gg-templates/v0.19.1 is identical over all 512 non-signature entries), SDD.Cli 2.2.0 sha256 46b4b172eac65df00db43f813bd3d3fbafac5c6376da62a6d3c08fb05750cf28, provider descriptor 10b532da...f5f7 (Templates providers/fable-game.providers.yml at 1e95dddb, source pin 0.19.1 only difference). With both packages supplied 26 controls (23 pure plus 3 opt-in) passed, 0 skipped. Inventory re-derived from the 0.19.1 package: 175 applicable owner files (was 171), 12 exclusions (unchanged), 57 COMPLETE-only files (was 53); the delta is exactly four SvgFoundation/Examples/FourD/LocalSaveReplayExample* files plus README. Both rows: 783 commands, 20.5 s, effective bundle=complete + typed lifecycle, no svgFoundation, policy.c 1308 bytes byte-identical to the package (the 0.19.0 defect), all owner files byte-exact with name/namespace substitution except the three expected supplier overlays, five bundle-gated supplier skills, parentless 322-file initial Git trees (fedf847d, 179dff5b), four findings with get/search/relations/evidence/history/idempotence, 12 expected nonzero exits (stale revision, prohibited sources, no-clobber restore, checker +1 byte), private exclusion, ALL-shared export/restore, Git bundle recovery, 10485760 pass and +1 refusal. Bounds: affinity 4 CPUs, 600 s window, peak process-tree RSS 482,566,144 bytes (cap 6 GiB), both coordination locks held non-blocking, headroom 16.6 GB (>=10 GiB), process census recorded as evidence only. Two earlier admission attempts (11:04 local) were refused before any child, clock or output by BlockingIOError on a coordination lock briefly held by another owner's status-transition process; they are preserved as admission-refusal01/02.*. Independent runtime review (fsgg-critic-normal/sonnet): ACCEPT-WITH-NITS; nits: Done-when counts need amendment, RSS-only monitor (root-approved), affinity not re-observable post hoc, owner staging dir retirement, modes of 22 owner executables rest on the adapter's narrow .sh promotion. Atlas: github/fable-provider-composition-qualification superseded by b8b8c5ca...f7ea0f (both packaged seeds, driver manifest regenerated, Atlas check and skill-view parity pass). Private custody (0700): ~/.local/share/fs-gg-private/coord-clearing-4uszqgge/complete4798-0191-runtime-20261022T090343Z-1790619/ (admission-original.json, root-outcome.json, evidence/, evidence.sha256 over 1602 files, receipts/); receivers retained under ~/.cache/complete4798-0191-runtime-20261022T090343Z-1790619/. Only this attempt's known allocation is retired; no historical Unknown is released.

Prior evidence (retained verbatim): the 2026-10-22 0.19.0 attempt FAILED at row 1 on complete-owner-bytes:SvgFoundation/Examples/Wasm/guest/policy.c (template-engine #if processing, Templates#729; evidence ~/.local/share/fs-gg-private/coord-clearing-4uszqgge/complete4798-runtime-20261022T071703Z-1627983/), independent review HOLD; source slice PR4803 evidence below.

Prior active fields before the 0.19.1 re-pin and runtime (retained)
## Current deliverable
Source slice delivered: PR https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/pull/4803 merged at `c9621e2d6ea65355fb7cf9b973160db2f10b5246` (adapter `tests/new-sdd-workspace/knowledge-fable-game-complete-provider-public.py`). The root-admitted finite two-row public runtime was attempted once on 2026-10-22 and FAILED at row 1 (explicit typed) with `complete-owner-bytes:SvgFoundation/Examples/Wasm/guest/policy.c`; row 2 never started. No runtime acceptance exists. Independent review of the actual result: HOLD. Atlas capture was not performed (it is conditional on runtime acceptance).

## Next action
A disposition owner decision is required before any further runtime. The published Workspace.Template 0.19.0 `bundle=complete` scaffold passes `policy.c` through the .NET template engine's C-style `#if` processing (package 1308 bytes, scaffolded 1130 bytes; the three `POLICY_TRAP/LOOP/MALFORMED` conditional blocks are removed), while `SvgFoundation/Examples/Wasm/build-guests.sh` builds variants with `-DPOLICY_<VARIANT>`. This looks like a Templates/Workspace product defect (template.json declares specialCustomOperations only for `**/*.fs`), not only an adapter assumption. Options: (a) Templates owner repairs and republishes (changes the pinned package identity, new adapter generation), or (b) an explicit, documented adapter acceptance of the engine-rendered form with rationale. Either way the same COMPLETE owner repairs the adapter on the same item through a normal PR with independent review, then root separately admits a FRESH finite two-row runtime (explicitly re-approving the admission census and memory-monitor semantics used here), then independent complete-result acceptance, then Atlas/driver-manifest capture and native readbacks. No automatic retry; the original failure stays retained.

## Blocked on
Template disposition for the `policy.c` conditional processing (owner: Templates/Workspace for option (a); Programme/root plus COMPLETE owner for option (b)). Runtime rows, initial Git, knowledge probes, ALL-shared export/restore, Git recovery, 10485760/+1 checker controls, supplier union/provenance/initial identity against a real COMPLETE scaffold past the first assertion, independent result acceptance, Atlas/manifest capture and native readbacks all remain unproven. Historical Unknowns, PLAYER original failures and accepted PLAYER/non-SVG acceptance are unchanged.

## Acceptance evidence
Actual runtime attempt 2026-10-22 (FAILED, no acceptance). Published packages from nuget.org: Workspace.Template 0.19.0 sha256 `187c995806bb2f22db67c8a9a67c251f46f339bf6350b8051035935d308b497f`, SDD.Cli 2.2.0 sha256 `46b4b172eac65df00db43f813bd3d3fbafac5c6376da62a6d3c08fb05750cf28`, both equal to the pinned identities and prior custody copies. With both supplied, all 23 controls (21 pure plus the 2 opt-in real-package controls) passed, 0 skipped. Sealed source = main c9621e2d (adapter sha256 `b66f2ab8...ba2e7d`), manifest sha256 `10c69f497f4f576078870886ff15d4ce421060f1f04c31c07abe8b41776e7854`, 4,120 sealed inputs, 4,079 SDK files/modes unchanged from the PLAYER custody. Bounds: affinity 4 CPUs, 600 s original window, peak process-tree RSS 355 MB, both coordination locks held, umask 0022. Admission refusal01 (before any child or clock): unrelated other-owner dotnet processes (a coord-1043 test run and persistent MSBuild nodes) were present; the entry was then edited to record rather than refuse unrelated concurrent workloads and to bound by the runner's own process-tree RSS (a weaker monitor than cgroup delta; the independent reviewer flagged this as a runner-side relaxation, immaterial to this outcome). The one original attempt then ran: `fsgg-sdd --version` (2.2.0), `dotnet new install`, and `fsgg-sdd scaffold --provider fable-game --param bundle=complete --param lifecycle=typed-sdd` all exited 0, then the adapter refused `complete-owner-bytes:SvgFoundation/Examples/Wasm/guest/policy.c`. Read-only diagnosis (independently reproduced by the reviewer): of the 171 inventory files exactly this one differs in bytes; modes all match; nothing missing; the cause is template-engine `#if` processing as described in Next action. Row 2 not started; no initial commit or knowledge probes ran; the loop stops at the first mismatch so later boundary checks are unexercised. Independent review (fsgg-critic-normal/sonnet) verdict HOLD: runtime Done when not satisfied; ruled out environment, package drift and caller error; no retry occurred; failure preserved verbatim. Private custody (0700): `~/.local/share/fs-gg-private/coord-clearing-4uszqgge/complete4798-runtime-20261022T071703Z-1627983/` (admission-original.json, root-outcome.json, evidence/report.json, evidence/commands.jsonl, evidence/root-entry.stderr, seals in evidence.sha256); partial receiver retained under `~/.cache/complete4798-runtime-20261022T071703Z-1627983/run`. Only this attempt's known allocation is retired; no historical Unknown is released.

Prior evidence (retained verbatim):

Source slice only, 2026-10-22: PR4803 head `db025bec`. Independent exact-head review ACCEPT-WITH-NITS (first candidate `6b3aa413` was REJECTED for a real defect: the compiled SDD2.2.0 supplier union gains five bundle-gated skills for `bundle=complete`; repaired and re-reviewed). 54 checks pass and 5 skip (no failures), including `new-sdd-workspace-selftest` and `routine-eligibility`. Pure controls: 21 hosted plus 2 opt-in controls verified locally against the genuine nuget.org packages whose digests match the pinned identities (Workspace171 applicable/12 exclusions/53 COMPLETE-only; producer compiled delta of exactly five suppliers). No runtime, receiver, hosted publication or qualification has run; actual two-row execution, hosted causal controls beyond the selftest, independent result acceptance, Atlas/manifest capture and native readbacks remain open. Unknowns: the genuine scaffold has not been observed (supplier delta and effective-provenance keys derive from compiled manifests and SDD source); opt-in controls are not in hosted CI.


Proposed under explicit user authorization on2026-10-22 to clear blockers aggressively and allow redesign preserving security and quality. Parent https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/issues/4642 retains its whole promise. Bounded dedup checked current open native issues and accepted provider4773/4780/RAW4766 or original PROC source/custody; this independently useful result is not already an accepted child. Original failures and Unknowns are preserved.

````text
<details><summary>Prior active fields before enrolled4798-source-selection-ready</summary>

Owner: /root/knowledge_player_receiver; Programme/root owns enrollment, integration and native reconciliation.


Next action: Root completes protected Project3 enrollment and typed planning, then the sole owner implements through one continuous normal PR per repository with independent review and applicable qualification.


Blocked on: Protected enrollment and exact installed caller reconciliation pending. No implementation dispatch follows merely from filing. Live publication/installation effects remain separately gated by actual suppliers and full parent acceptance.

</details>

````

<details><summary>Prior active fields before the 2026-10-22 actual runtime attempt (retained)</summary>

````text
Current deliverable:
PR https://github.com/FS-GG/.github/pull/4803 (open, not merged), branch `routine/4798-complete-provider`, exact head `db025becf65df23f6b12568732b2bf2a77d2e40d`: COMPLETE provider source qualification adapter `tests/new-sdd-workspace/knowledge-fable-game-complete-provider-public.py`, one hosted selftest line and the roadmap section. Source slice only.

Next action:
~~~text
Source scope retained from prior deliverable description: New fixed COMPLETE adapter under tests/new-sdd-workspace; existing hosted selftest workflow; knowledge Wizard roadmap; Atlas provider-composition successor with both packaged mirrors and generated driver manifest. Ten-path declared source scope; existing publishedSDD2.2.0/Workspace019 enables this independently ofSDD1113.
~~~

Root integrates the exact-head merge boundary for PR4803 (independent review accepted with nits, required checks green at that head), then owns the shared Atlas/packaged-registry/driver-manifest integration. Root then separately admits the finite two-row actual runtime, supplying both published archives to the two opt-in controls, followed by independent complete-result acceptance and native readbacks. A source merge does not close this Delivery.

Blocked on:
No external prerequisite for initial source work; installed69 read/selection is the next root action. Actual finite receiver runtime remains separately admitted; SDD1113 is not a prerequisite for ASCII COMPLETE selection.

````

</details>


Activity

  1. EHotwagner commented on Oct 22, 2026

    @EHotwagner
    ContributorAuthor

    Programme/root assigns the current protected source generation at 5a80f1745a54d12f2c8ce7c05c30a57146f661ab to the existing COMPLETE owner /root/knowledge_player_receiver in an isolated new branch. The exact source scope is the new COMPLETE provider qualification, .github/workflows/new-sdd-workspace-selftest.yml, and docs/roadmaps/tsdd-knowledge-wizard.md. Root owns shared Atlas/manifest integration and exact-head reviewed delivery. The two shared workflow/roadmap paths are a prospective source assignment; no old-owner handoff, old runtime retirement, or release of historical Unknowns is asserted. Original source custody and every unlisted path remain retained. Actual69 installed inspection is accepted; selected source fold and adjacent resource/preimage checks still precede dispatch. Runtime qualification and full parent acceptance remain separate required work.

  2. EHotwagner commented on Oct 22, 2026

    @EHotwagner
    ContributorAuthor

    Programme/root (Claude Code session) owner recovery 2026-10-22: the Codex owner assigned at 03:xxZ never created a branch, worktree or PR and its session has been idle since ~03:29Z. The assignment is continued by a Claude Code accountable owner under work-board-coord (canonical implementation route sonnet/high) at protected .github main 61526e9; scope, hard limits and root-owned shared integration from the prior root comment are unchanged. Status Ready → In progress at dispatch. Fresh installed111 full69 read original08 observed this item enrolled, open and Ready before dispatch.

  3. EHotwagner commented on Oct 22, 2026

    @EHotwagner
    ContributorAuthor

    Programme/root 2026-10-22: PR #4803 merged as c9621e2 from exact head db025be. An independent review rejected the first candidate (the five COMPLETE-gated supplier skills), the repair was made, and the re-review returned ACCEPT-WITH-NITS at db025be. CI: 54 pass, 5 skip. This delivers the COMPLETE provider adapter SOURCE. Remaining, root-owned: the finite two-row public runtime with both published packages supplied (so the opt-in controls run), independent result acceptance, and Atlas/manifest capture. Status stays In progress.

  4. EHotwagner commented on Oct 22, 2026

    @EHotwagner
    ContributorAuthor

    Programme/root 2026-10-22: the runtime row-1 failure is a genuine supplier defect in published Workspace.Template 0.19.0 (the C preprocessor in the template engine strips policy.c), confirmed by independent review (HOLD). Filed FS-GG/FS.GG.Templates#729 for the source fix plus a byte-equality regression; it is this Delivery's prerequisite. Re-running needs a fixed, published Workspace.Template, a re-pinned adapter, and a fresh, separately admitted runtime. The original row-1 failure is retained, and row 2 was never attempted. Process note: the runner adjusted its own admission semantics (the census of a concurrent worker, and an RSS monitor in place of the cgroup monitor). That did not affect the outcome; any rerun needs those semantics explicitly root-approved. Status → Blocked on Templates#729 plus publication.

  5. EHotwagner commented on Oct 22, 2026

    @EHotwagner
    ContributorAuthor

    Programme/root 2026-10-22: the prerequisite source fix landed. Templates#729 is delivered by PR #730 (merge 1e95dddb), which keeps C/H sources byte-exact and adds a causal source-fidelity gate; the package version is 0.19.1. Next, each separately admitted: publish Workspace.Template 0.19.1, re-pin the #4798 adapter to 0.19.1, then a fresh two-row runtime. Status stays Blocked on publication.

  6. EHotwagner commented on Oct 22, 2026

    @EHotwagner
    ContributorAuthor

    Programme/root acceptance 2026-10-22: PR #4804 merged as ff75a85 from exact head c297f2a, with main tree readback equal to the head tree. CI: 58 pass, 4 skip. Independent reviews: ACCEPT at the adapter head 6dcda4b; the Atlas delta reviewed ACCEPT. The adapter is re-pinned to Workspace.Template 0.19.1 (nuget sha256 5d1886c3…, byte-identical to the release asset), with SDD.Cli 2.2.0 as producer. The root-admitted two-row public runtime PASSED on exactly the reviewed adapter bytes: explicit typed-sdd and genuinely omitted lifecycle; bundle=complete; one attempt per row; 783 commands; peak RSS 0.48 GB; the fixed admission semantics were honored; 1607 evidence files are sealed privately. policy.c is byte-identical to the package in both rows, so the 0.19.0 supplier defect is resolved at scaffold level. An independent runtime review returned ACCEPT-WITH-NITS (nits retained). The Atlas record github/fable-provider-composition-qualification is superseded and extended (b8b8c5ca…). The Done-when count is amended to be package-bound (0.19.1: 175/12/57); the promise is unchanged. The original 0.19.0 row-1 failure stays retained. Not claimed: product/browser/WASM execution, Wizard acceptance, retained upgrades, or the other parent #4642 routes. Closing as completed.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions