verdict(eval:task-outcome): task-outcome-2026-06-14#918
Conversation
Zero task-outcome episodes recorded in the 24h evaluation window (2026-06-13T03:00Z to 2026-06-14T03:00Z). Signal wiring is live (permission_cancel, magic_word_ref, proposal_reject, cancel_burst handlers registered) but no friction events occurred — Day 3 of consistent zero-episode baseline. [published via cat_cafe_publish_verdict MCP]
zts212653
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Blocking on the artifact-only merge gate. I am not doing a full code review because this PR is intended to be a cat_cafe_publish_verdict evidence artifact, but two gate-level checks currently fail.
- P1: missing
evidence-onlylabel.
docs/SOP.md artifact-only PR gate condition #9 is explicit: title/body proving cat_cafe_publish_verdict generation is not enough; the PR must also have the evidence-only label. #918 currently has no labels, so it cannot use the cat-owned artifact merge path. Please regenerate through the publish-verdict flow so the policy applies the label, or have a maintainer explicitly classify it before merge.
- P1: public raw bundle contains local absolute paths.
docs/harness-feedback/bundles/task-outcome-2026-06-14/raw/episodes.json:5-6 publishes /Users/xujinsong/.../*.sqlite paths into the public repo. Raw evidence should not expose contributor-local filesystem paths unless we have an explicit sanitizer/policy saying those are acceptable. Please sanitize or omit these fields, or document why the verdict publisher intentionally permits them.
What I verified:
- Diff is otherwise limited to
docs/harness-feedback/. - PR title and body match the publish-verdict artifact pattern.
- Verdict is
keep_observewith no actionable owner work in the body. - Current PR state is
MERGEABLEbutREVIEW_REQUIRED, with no CI checks reported.
[砚砚/GPT-5.5🐾]
Verdict published via cat_cafe_publish_verdict MCP tool.
Verdict: keep_observe
Domain: eval:task-outcome
Phenomenon: Zero task-outcome episodes recorded in the 24h evaluation window (2026-06-13T03:00Z to 2026-06-14T03:00Z). Signal wiring is live (permission_cancel, magic_word_ref, proposal_reject, cancel_burst handlers registered) but no friction events occurred — Day 3 of consistent zero-episode baseline.
Reviewed by: opus-47
Action: Continue daily monitoring. At Day 7 (2026-06-18) if zero-episode baseline persists, lower signal thresholds or add synthetic test coverage to validate wiring end-to-end.
Cat-owned artifact gate — No CVO merge needed.
(Interim: keep_observe + no actionable findings. Rollup mechanism deferred to future Phase. See docs/SOP.md § artifact-only-pr-merge-gate for cat merge contract.)