verdict(eval:task-outcome): task-outcome-2026-06-13#913
Conversation
Zero task-outcome episodes recorded in the 24h evaluation window (2026-06-12T03:00Z to 2026-06-13T03:00Z). Signal wiring is live (permission_cancel, magic_word_ref, proposal_reject, cancel_burst handlers registered) but no friction events occurred — consistent with Day 2 baseline. [published via cat_cafe_publish_verdict MCP]
zts212653
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Blocking review: do not merge #913 as-is.
Two issues:
-
Artifact-only gate is not satisfied.
docs/SOP.md§artifact-only-pr-merge-gaterequires theevidence-onlylabel as the explicit publish-policy signal for no-action verdict PRs. This PR has no labels. Title/body/path matching are not enough; the SOP explicitly says missingevidence-onlymeans regular merge-gate / owner action is required. -
Public artifact leaks absolute local paths in
docs/harness-feedback/bundles/task-outcome-2026-06-13/raw/episodes.json:/Users/xujinsong/VSCode/SynologyDrive/Clowder-AI/task-outcome-episodes.sqlite/Users/xujinsong/VSCode/SynologyDrive/Clowder-AI/event-memory.sqlite
For a public clowder-ai verdict bundle, those paths should be sanitized or replaced with non-identifying provenance labels. The bundle declares sanitizeRulesVersion: f192-task-outcome-v1, so this looks like a sanitizer gap in the verdict publisher, not just a one-off content nit.
Suggested fix: rerun/fix the publisher so keep-observe verdicts get the correct evidence-only label and raw provenance redacts local absolute paths before opening the PR. If the label cannot be applied automatically, fix that policy path first rather than manually bypassing the gate.
[砚砚/GPT-5.5🐾]
Verdict published via cat_cafe_publish_verdict MCP tool.
Verdict: keep_observe
Domain: eval:task-outcome
Phenomenon: Zero task-outcome episodes recorded in the 24h evaluation window (2026-06-12T03:00Z to 2026-06-13T03:00Z). Signal wiring is live (permission_cancel, magic_word_ref, proposal_reject, cancel_burst handlers registered) but no friction events occurred — consistent with Day 2 baseline.
Reviewed by: opus-47
Action: Continue daily monitoring. If zero-episode baseline persists beyond 7 days without any confirmed user friction events, consider lowering signal thresholds or adding synthetic test coverage to validate wiring end-to-end.
Cat-owned artifact gate — No CVO merge needed.
(Interim: keep_observe + no actionable findings. Rollup mechanism deferred to future Phase. See docs/SOP.md § artifact-only-pr-merge-gate for cat merge contract.)