Skip to content

Policy check 2026-10-26 - #13

Open
github-actions[bot] wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
policy-check/2026-10-26
Open

github-actions[bot] wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
policy-check/2026-10-26

Conversation

@github-actions

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Updated projects

Apache Airflow

Rules changed, ratings unchanged (AI-friendly with conditions)

  • Added: Documentation: Allowed with conditions (Disclose AI use: State Gen-AI use in the PR description; Review AI output first: Review and understand what the tool produced before including it; Take full responsibility: Be prepared to explain and justify the Gen-AI use)
  • Added: Pull request descriptions: Allowed with conditions (Disclose AI use: PR description must state that Gen-AI tools were used)

Confidence: medium

Needs a closer look:

  • Dropped a quote not found verbatim in https://github.com/apache/airflow/blob/main/contributing-docs/05_pull_requests.rst: "Make sure to run все relevant static checks and tests locally to verify that the generated code works as intended and do"
  • The sources point to more AI rules in https://www.apache.org/legal/generative-tooling.html, which is not a source yet: Apache Software Foundation Generative Tooling guidelines that Airflow requires Gen-AI users to follow.
  • The sources point to more AI rules in ../COMMUNITY_ESCALATION.md, which is not a source yet: Community escalation process describing the further steps, including blocking and appeals, for repeated disregard of the Gen-AI guidelines.
  • summaries: rated "unspecified" but has rules.

Bevy

Rules changed, ratings unchanged (AI-friendly with conditions)

  • First detailed rule list: 19 rules.

Confidence: medium

Needs a closer look:

  • The sources point to more AI rules in Bevy Code of Conduct, which is not a source yet: The AI Policy says the Code of Conduct continues to apply when AI-related topics are discussed.

curl

Area ratings changed, overall rating unchanged (AI-friendly)

  • Added: Translating the software: Allowed (Disclose AI use (recommended): Consider mentioning you used an AI translation tool)
  • Changed: AI-written reports: Discouraged → AI-written reports: Discouraged (Take full responsibility: Write the report yourself and explain the problem as you learned it)
  • Changed: Security reports: Allowed with conditions (Disclose AI use: If AI was used to find the problem, reveal that fact in the report.; Review AI output first: Carefully verify AI findings yourself before reporting them.) → Security reports: Allowed with conditions (Disclose AI use: Reveal that an AI tool was used to find the problems; Review AI output first: Double-check the findings before reporting; Take full responsibility: Write the report yourself and explain the problem as you learned it)
  • Added: Pull request descriptions: Discouraged
  • Added: Comments: Discouraged
  • Issues & bug reports: Mostly friendly (Disclose, Human review) → Mostly friendly (Disclose, Accountable, Human review)

Confidence: medium

Gentoo

Rules changed, ratings unchanged (Not AI-friendly)

  • First detailed rule list: 23 rules.

Confidence: high

scikit-image

Rating changed (Not AI-friendly → AI-friendly with conditions)

  • First detailed rule list: 11 rules.
  • Code contributions: Unfriendly (Disclose, Accountable, License-safe, Minor help only) → Mostly friendly (Disclose, Accountable, License-safe, Limited scope)
  • Issues & bug reports: Unfriendly (Minor help only) → No policy
  • AI-written text: Unfriendly (Minor help only) → Unfriendly

Confidence: high

stb

Rules changed, ratings unchanged (Not AI-friendly)

  • First detailed rule list: 18 rules.

Confidence: high

Traefik

Area ratings changed, overall rating unchanged (AI-friendly with conditions)

  • First detailed rule list: 11 rules.
  • Issues & bug reports: Mostly friendly (Disclose, Human review) → No policy
  • AI-written text: Unfriendly (Minor help only) → Friendly (Accountable)

Confidence: high

Needs a closer look:

  • The sources point to more AI rules in CONTRIBUTING.md, which is not a source yet: AGENTS.md defers to CONTRIBUTING.md and docs/content/contributing/ for everything not covered in the guide.
  • The sources point to more AI rules in docs/content/contributing/submitting-security-issues.md, which is not a source yet: Security reports must follow this page's threat model and submission requirements, including the AI-disclosure rule.
  • The sources point to more AI rules in docs/content/contributing/security-decisions.md, which is not a source yet: Lists settled security positions; reports matching a settled position will be closed.
  • issues: rated "unspecified" but has rules.

Turso

Area ratings changed, overall rating unchanged (AI-friendly)

  • First detailed rule list: 7 rules.
  • AI-written text: Friendly (Human review) → No policy

Confidence: high

Needs a closer look:

  • summaries: rated "unspecified" but has rules.

uutils coreutils

Rating changed (AI-friendly → AI-friendly with conditions)

  • First detailed rule list: 8 rules.
  • Code contributions: Friendly (Accountable, Human review, License-safe) → Mostly friendly (Accountable, Human review, License-safe, Limited scope)

Confidence: high

Vim

Area ratings changed, overall rating unchanged (AI-friendly with conditions)

  • First detailed rule list: 10 rules.
  • Code contributions: Mostly friendly (Disclose) → Mostly friendly (Disclose, Accountable, License-safe, Limited scope)
  • AI-written text: No policy → Unfriendly (Minor help only)

Confidence: high

Needs a closer look:

  • The sources point to more AI rules in AGENTS.md, which is not a source yet: Contains information and instructions for AI coding agents.
  • The sources point to more AI rules in CODE_OF_CONDUCT.md, which is not a source yet: Covers the use of AI in discussions.

vLLM

Area ratings changed, overall rating unchanged (AI-friendly with conditions)

  • First detailed rule list: 11 rules.
  • Code contributions: Mostly friendly (Disclose, Accountable, Human review, No agents) → Mostly friendly (Disclose, Accountable, Human review)

Confidence: high

Needs a closer look:

  • The sources point to more AI rules in tests/AGENTS.md, which is not a source yet: Domain-specific agent instructions for the test suite, referenced from AGENTS.md.
  • The sources point to more AI rules in rust/AGENTS.md, which is not a source yet: Domain-specific agent instructions for the Rust frontend.
  • The sources point to more AI rules in docs/contributing/editing-agent-instructions.md, which is not a source yet: Rules for modifying AGENTS.md and the domain-specific guides it references.
  • The sources point to more AI rules in .agents/skills/pr-checklist/SKILL.md, which is not a source yet: Agent skill checklist that must be run and addressed before opening a PR or requesting re-review.

WordPress

Area ratings changed, overall rating unchanged (AI-friendly with conditions)

  • First detailed rule list: 18 rules.
  • Issues & bug reports: Friendly (Human review) → Mostly friendly (Disclose, Human review)
  • AI-written text: Friendly (Human review) → Mostly friendly (Disclose, Human review)

Confidence: high

Needs a closer look:

  • Statement 22 is not used by any rule: "If a tool seems to output code that looks suspiciously like a well-known library or non-GPL-compatible project, do not s"
  • Statement 25 is not used by any rule: "- Run the test suites that are relevant to your change and note the commands you used in the PR description."

yt-dlp

Rules changed, ratings unchanged (Not AI-friendly)

  • First detailed rule list: 24 rules.

Confidence: high

Review each change against its snapshot diff before merging.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

0 participants