Continue coached Atlas team delivery and persistent agent improvements from #428 #429

Current: a5be v15 approved; note schema emits ZodIntersection; source stopped. docs/agent-log.md.

Latest native-team activation failure/approved API repair: treeseed-ai/agent#496 . Canonical existing source-export projection/checks: #441 .

MCP checkpoint — 2026-10-22 (native connection working)

Native TreeSeed MCP discovery and status.show/teams.list/projects.list/topics.list/agents.list/capacity.status now succeed after supported host reconciliation removed unavailable offline_access from OIDC metadata (Identity #42, Deployment #893). No wrapper or copied bearer header. SDK #435 merged at 56de634 (coordinator catalog 56 tools/35 resources; consumer adoption pending). SDK #436 head 627d98e exposes actual workday planning fields while retaining original serialized order; 68 focused checks/build/policies pass. Failed CI39766280349 retained; corrected parser/export projection is in replacement Actions. API #591 head 3ef73b3847f0637926d69c5e7449f7df3c7249f1 supports native2025stateless clients; 32 protocol/signed-token checks pass; old rejection assertion repaired, failed CI39764314002 retained. Required Actions pending for436/591/893. Full mutation→team→proposal/estimates→decision→simulation/review/evaluation unproven. Portfolio paused, no new assignments/team changes. Next: adopt shared catalog, typed proposal update/evaluation and governed team/workday operations; prove real workflow via native MCP before resumption.

Live MCP checkpoint — 2026-10-22 10:36 UTC

SDK435/head920f0b4 narrows139→56tools/65→35resources;21 focusedchecks/build/filepolicies pass, required Actions pending after repaired PR-template/directory/legacy-resource assertions. API591/head6a0d29d repairs actual native2025-06-18 handshake rejection using the SDK's existing stateless legacy mode; signed-Identity HTTP handshake/tools-list/shared-status-call/401 denial plus modern authorization/schema cases pass18/18. Neither candidate is merged/released yet. Native Codex registration and explicit-read login succeeded; appCA trust fixed with supported CODEX_CA_CERTIFICATE. Missing per-server scopes made Authenticate request the whole issuer inventory; explicit scopes=[treeseed:read] now yields only that scope. Refresh initially failed read+offline_access; fresh sign-in/connection refresh reached authenticated protocol negotiation, proving progress but not long-run renewal. Identity42 retains both failures. No one-off runner or new auth implementation. Next: merge/adopt these boundary repairs, verify native MCP read/renewal, then typed proposal/revision/approval and governed team/workday operations before real MCP-only workflow proof. Portfolio stays paused.

Coordinator MCP repair — 2026-10-22

Portfolio execution paused by the owner. Required small slices, through the existing shared backend: (1) connect/authenticate the native TreeSeed HTTP MCP endpoint; (2) narrow MCP declarations to coordinator base operations, removing raw TreeDX push/ref/artifact mutation and unrelated administration; (3) typed proposal revision/approval and workday admission schemas, preserving preconditions/confirmation; (4) typed coordinator observations and governed team-profile/workspace operations; (5) prove discussion → real proposal/own estimates → approval → simulation Engineer/Reviewer → result/usage/cleanup evaluation entirely through MCP before resuming portfolio delivery. No one-off client/runner wrappers, direct assignment insertion, fake work, or new orchestration service. MCP must use the same operation registry/handlers as CLI/SDK/API. Live baseline catalog:139tools/65resources, including overbroad raw custody operations. Current Codex registration added with temporary read-only tool filter; OAuth DCR failed403 Trusted Hosts, retained as a connection blocker rather than bypassing identity policy. SDK/API/Identity own their slices; exact source/PR/Actions/live MCP evidence remains required. docs/agent-log.md records the operating scoreboard.

Architecture-led next slice — 2026-10-21 17:58 UTC

After actual Deployment Architect+Reviewer discussion send529e3cd80c3970b66edcf3cff8988362, distinct real maintenance proposal95dfdfe7-7fae-4cb9-9d16-cf33b8e420ff v3 is accepted as Decision8213cbf4-9e45-4593-b0ca-1d46357a72b5. All4 source-recovery participants completed genuine planning on01b52d54; own Engineer1100/1600 and Reviewer390/600 estimates completed. Scope is privileged idle-warm drain and truthful producer quiescence/restoration, preserving every custody barrier; it does not authorize cold-cache reclamation. Acting is not yet admitted while the API composition window is pending.

Exact prior cache9eddbc9eec86c2f3164ceb82aa2870bbe370637b was retrieved,509 measured active seconds, verifiedteardown,30 owning checks/finalbuild reported; canonical R1iQd failedsource_storage_full. Its affected acting run62df was stopped normally for retained-product continuation; no invented review or duplicate Engineer success.

Portfolio profile audit found platform/architect still named/prompted SDK Architect. Governed correction9fc34e7599feb83460fdc6f1252ac29dba170f8b keeps identity/class/groups/handlers/permissions, corrects name/purpose to Portfolio Architect. Local catalog shows correction; publicationaca327dd failed at pushing with4 Bookv3 validation errors in existing books/platform-delivery-history.md. Normal Book editor migration also refused same validation; draft9c0cadab remains unchanged (diff[]). Upstream profile publication remains unconfirmed. Preserve both failures; do not bypass governed authoring.

API588 head696bb97fd81eb7a408bc6bbcd8344e7fb1f200a6 replacement Verify39644714803 passed the previously failing native relation step and is in final verify:direct. Merge, adoption and real UI→Admin edge read-back still pending. Current detailed records remain UI70/Admin127/Agent496.

Real linked workflow and increased supply — 2026-10-21 17:27 UTC

User cleared daily implementation increase: supported generation45 now57,600sec/day (16h), research14,400, concurrency5. Genuine fresh group-driven estimates and normal Reporter closeout completed for Admina309d6bf v9, Decision694f53b0-b0d4-4ca9-91d7-8bc632554192, and cache recovery04eabfd9 v3, Decision602c7dc9-f88a-4a3d-aba2-954feb5d74b1. Admin own Engineer2400/4200, independent Reviewer1050/1800; cache Engineer780/1100, Reviewer330/500. All4 UI/Admin group planning members contributed; no named-agent proposal targeting or copied failed estimates. Prior failed histories remain retained.

Exact existing governed depends_on note UIv3→Adminv9 published, but real read-back found API relation loader reads the separate authoring ref rather than authoritative published library binding. API PR588 fixes that one owning lookup;16 focused relation checks/3files, build and architecture checks pass locally. Corrected submission and authorization pass; main Verify is pending. Live graph edge and Admin acting remain unproven until adoption and actual reviewed UI product. Detailed exact note/endpoint/product/failure evidence is in UI70, Admin127, Reviewer98 and Agent496 to preserve this nearly full body.

Real cache Engineer assignment_pjc0uR_JWcNVxfkU4HYqLaKOvK2Fs9iC is executing on workday62dfdb5c-da5d-4f56-a487-03aa17eefc02. Three earlier actual Git products were retrieved (Deployment37206cb9, Reviewerb09d25b8, UIdfb543ee); independent Git reviews all source_storage_full. They are not approved/released/adopted. Four unknown-usage provider claims are retained; one API unresolved recovery succeeded, Admin recovery refused original reservation authority conflict. No erased usage or forced cleanup. A bounded source-discussion recommendation permits one cache recovery only after actual verified old-broker drain; it is not canonical product acceptance.

18:25 UTC closure: Admin group run has10 completed records (7planning+2estimating+Reporter),3 preserved failed attempts, all13terminal. All12 participating native planning/estimate attempts have teardown verified. Admin v4 is ready but remains open pending the delivered UI dependency. Fresh Deployment draft send send-60fa7b889f689e3223db4444cf11b6d6 completed/responded on the adopted SDK124 runtime; it identifies the existing manager/supervisor/source-store boundary for a bounded local Git-bundle export and explicitly leaves remote API/MCP authorization/transport for a later slice. Draft needs reconciliation with actual host receipt identities before normal proposal admission; no export implementation or approval claimed. API585/586 package verification passed; required component scenes and587 checks remain running. Exact reviewed UI product retrieval/release and visible chart remain open.

18:21 UTC — current small-slice delivery: SDK rc124 is published/read back; CLI303/304 and Agent503 are merged. CLI rc87 protected39467736197 passed; publication39470648011 succeeded but timed out during read-back. Existing read-back-only recovery39472119869 PASSED; independent registry archive matches SHA256 d5c9fb97699c4a7b10a9d6928364f5d2bad045f196bd70dd835e396c85273641, rc87/latest0.12.58. Primary CLI is clean at9eca706e with installed SDK124; supported existing-session cli.package rebuild passed and global trsd exposes group-only proposal participation. Platform650 merged4c7d1f5; PR39472305674 and protected39472633741 passed; clean merged checkout validates. Original Platform checkout remains unchanged with its divergent history and user AGENTS/docs.

Agent primary now clean at merged1cb2a039 with registry SDK124; base/guest built, guest image sha256:7ae3f9f87532db136508510b7e29a23fd3a1353db8d171d3f69338689c0310c9 imported BEFORE supported provider rebuild, both succeeded after healthy work closed. No guest upstream credentials introduced.

API585/b35 and586/6d4 passed their package/native verification phases and are executing existing component scenes;587/788 fixed-turn follow-up checks pending. API local development candidate788 remains adopted; protected merges/releases are not yet claimed.

Real second proposal proof: Admin127 records seven completed shared-group contributions, genuine650/900 Engineer and150/240 Reviewer estimates, all v4 readiness flags true, integrated exact source6efbadc6/dbea370c. Planning workday1b27d186 is cancelled/ended with completed Reporter report-5435bc7f8467e1dd15ad36bd; original deadline and three failed attempts retained alongside supported coached retries. Both Admin/coordinator discussion and later Admin/UI Engineer discussion completed durable responses. Earlier UI proposal reached normal accepted Decision7fcf2c92 and a real approved Engineer/Reviewer Git productc6b4649f; retrieval/release/browser adoption remain open.

Next mission slice is authorized operator retrieval of that exact reviewed Git product. Artifacts is a disabled command catalog entry before any network operation; no implemented API-endpoint failure is claimed. Coordinator's actual draft recommends existing owners/custody and no new guest privileges/store. Additional Deployment discussion send-d71e3aeb failed per-command clocks; protected trace retained13 successful checks/first/final compliance but multiple commands without a fresh check. Future governed Deployment Architect labels/prompts corrected to its own project and strict clock loop, unchanged class/permissions/group membership/handlers; approved review46f1a6e1, publication19576449 succeeded. A fresh source-backed proposal draft is requested through the shared topic on the adopted SDK124 runtime. This is discussion work, not an accepted implementation or verification-only assignment.

Current progress — 2026-10-20 17:53 UTC

The seven-member portfolio-atlas group completed real UI planning across UI, Admin and Platform; normal estimates produced proposal 07341861-d24b-471c-bf0d-86e68ec2df7a v7 and accepted Decision 7fcf2c92-0c7d-44a9-b1c6-cba49a79ed45. Planning workday d87b0c94-183e-42ff-9b14-8593761fcaef is cancelled/ended with completed Reporter, original deadline retained. Detailed seven-result table remains below.

Real implementation/review completed: acting workday dffaf1cc-6ad2-4acc-85ad-6e747cda990d; Engineer assignment_1WOXUn7Kz1j845WHUKBGA2XK9Z-nsCHC, result result-fef374f071fd65bc15ec2cc1, Git c6b4649f6fa2e3ce06ab92f0a04db0fc6d8bab8f; Reviewer assignment__wLBxQtOWs_do-1XCWCLTZDKgd9F0WCu, result result-dfe51add25119e0762801097, approved, Note/Decision commit e2a2b4f9f2bee28f06b232ad4ebd60b376d580ae. Engineer focused realtime-resource suite and TypeScript passed; standard Astro check failed unresolved forms/client import. Reviewer independently passed TypeScript; focused rerun blocked by localhost DNS. Active usage 562.170s Engineer / 133.201s Reviewer. Reporter report-911c1e6a6e089aefe45a381a completed; workday cancelled/ended after scoped stop.

Actual remaining delivery blocker: supported assignments artifacts returns standards_migration_not_enabled. Host status confirms exact Git candidate published, clean/closure/ancestry verification and teardown; its native Git repository is private to the host. No privileged copy, patch reconstruction or release claim. Next meaningful proposal should enable authorized operator/coordinator retrieval using existing exact assignment/result/product references.

Discussion feedback: API #586, head 6d4e5d3e808135f2418eef4f0c5faaf279d0d4b2, repairs cross-project proposal context through the shared topic, same-team only; adopted locally. Real send send-d71e99491e32661c5e7200b100ad24a2 attached existing Admin proposal and admitted Admin Architect + Platform coordinator. Admin failed assignment_timeout; coordinator response retained but terminal expired_lease_side_effect_evidence_present. Both had only32 active seconds. Public assignment explanation proves 180s fixed model turn calibrated down by20 prior chat measurements (multiplier0.176326875), with233s opportunity available. Narrow follow-up will preserve fixed discussion budgets while retaining supply/deadline limits; no issued authority extended. Coordinator recommended existing Engineer/Reviewer team and exact-product retrieval; its mistaken “project portfolio-atlas” must be corrected to Admin project + portfolio-atlas group.

Delivery checks: SDK rc124 published/read back (SHA256 567559d55bc25cf3101f66c0931aba8228efadcf7cc4625bad3ef244d8b882b1). CLI #303 and #304 merged; rc87 protected run39467736197 pending. Agent #503 merged 1cb2a03928b510ca975eb4d548ca379198f21fb9 after run39464194497 verify + installed-owner-custody passed. API585 head b35e0f4b510619d3d419f30feb6117a3a29286ce repairs one stale native identity-positive fixture using actual groups; run39467147417 pending. API586 remains stacked until585 merges. No group-workflow formal acceptance, published UI product or visible chart claim.

Earlier observations below are retained history; this progress block supersedes their pending-status wording.

Current class / group / topic slices — 2026-10-20, 17:17 UTC

Model: one class per agent; shared proposal groups select participation by governed subscriptions; discussion topics remain separate subscriptions. No individual/class proposal targeting. Real objective remains complete scoped UI activity snapshots, then the visible Admin Atlas chart.

Shared contract delivered: SDK #432, #433, and version preparation #434 merged. Current staging b754118c8035913b20ca9663ca418d48fa4dce05 prepares rc124. PR #434 required 39458491213 and protected staging 39460744562 passed. SDK rc124 publication/read-back 39463261142 passed; npm archive independently read back with SHA256 567559d55bc25cf3101f66c0931aba8228efadcf7cc4625bad3ef244d8b882b1, rc=124 and latest remains 0.12.62. Earlier functional staging 69c07896708deaaed228cc6e14f12c41e5289981 passed 631 tests / 96 files and existing component/product-custody scenes. No managed group-workflow acceptance claim.

Consumer candidates: API #585 head 9c922b2b5c93d158b2a33c3238f168fe243f8fa3; CLI #303 head 419ca416e52b818e480e079c7e1a65f010798ca0; Agent #503 head 2a6c814b8132738963d6093318df9e832c405b23. Local API/provider/guest candidates are adopted through trsd; the built CLI's real --group option is used. CLI #303 is merged at 7bb1746242915f854d60bd0dbba24c30f469b6e5: required run 39459668546 passed 378 package tests and the existing coded component scene. CLI publication/adoption and API/Agent merges remain pending. Global CLI remains older; API independently denies its retired agent/class selectors without creating work. Platform #650 still awaits matching CLI composition.

Real team: group portfolio-atlas published in Team Library db8fcd106bc4c68572754b69aa793f47e2b1e417; seven existing group subscriptions are published in UI 5a23e659648ecaea0bd90877bddfdfe05c36e9ec, Admin b496c0fb3f442666a0f35ddd80f72a44a67f366d, and Platform c8dac48bd9e9c24a97a4b79d20557defe1a8272b. Singular classes remain intact. Only the future UI Engineer planning dependency on an unnecessary Tester was removed; meaningful Admin dependencies remain. All seven also follow topic portfolio-atlas-team-building through normal subscriptions; group and topic records are separate.

Real passed UI slice: proposal 07341861-d24b-471c-bf0d-86e68ec2df7a v2→v4, workday workday-d09f60db-b45b-4fca-8af8-268a667249ed.

• Architect planning assignment_eUyueknjye1yUT-nPNKnGdhYaKUXcr4Z / result-315b8124a46e6577a1a60e9f; Note commit 1c9815f876e791334066c2f3ab02a0add3db6b25.
• Engineer planning assignment_XZoPYFMvJ9ftaWtPqNIRAAoU3AOt7XUF / result-3fc058004138833d99674a9d; Note b76857792746bfde5157c83893119498667c1f70.
• Reviewer planning assignment_C04gQoMDkLpMDGf3EpuYj0ZzH1cw0NwW / result-c879de67bda8e33aa2ba7064; Note f8694d70b5dd34ba8d1b6b6af8b4a046ee8b886a.
• Engineer estimate assignment_Evo1OIoYVxHlkL-mpIYz4wUpwitrRgFA / result-1e454851346a0f88c735f067: 2400 expected / 3600 maximum harness seconds, source 5d43e14388382ed0560b5cde85d176e01209bc37.
• Reviewer estimate assignment_WDiJJoPU5vNlTtelbE43B7YUGztKLl3q / result-f4f913ef82c6a0e228382f8f: 360 / 600 seconds, source 5f369fda3d1c5d1cd639650b2000093bf034ca5a.
• All five completed; native teardown observations passed. Reporter assignment_pOOAB2RLePR1LHYNkUI6NQ6Og1enDkmf / report-a65d876265fd2e98562d1f90 completed; workday cancelled/ended. No implementation was claimed from planning/estimating.

Readiness repair proved live: v4 now blocks approval and names exactly the three Admin members and coordinator still missing. Existing approval fingerprint recognizes the UI contributions across estimate-only revisions. Normal v5 revision 0ab3c6b20224870a2c506f13f09c216aa7690ce4 corrects the circular “review final candidate before estimating/acting” instruction and clears estimates. Live read-back requires fresh participation from all seven for the edited content. No estimates or results were copied forward as fresh work.

Failed observations retained and repaired:

1. Team/Platform publication first failed on legacy Book/Page records; repaired through governed workspaces, then all four publications succeeded.
2. Initial group workday abaaf045-1b78-4cb8-a0f3-8c2432f5c56c omitted groupIds during initial turn-ID compilation. Actual Engineer estimating assignment_lxyTbK9MbU8ViBBtOeJ-9fiZjOhHALqv ran ~30 seconds, then old Agent SDK rejected groupIds at kernel commit. Regression reproduced it; matching SDK/provider/guest repaired. Its original unmaterialized planning IDs also blocked closeout; normal graph projection repaired them. Reporter report-be0e25c0d10765bdef58d933 completed; run cancelled/ended.
3. Retry e5d6f475-986c-4bfb-96b0-87455841d81f selected/claimed all three UI members but guest authorization failed because provider adoption preceded guest import. Correct supported adoption order repaired it. Reporter report-9539564f896b8b737ece4ff8 completed; run cancelled/ended.
4. Group-wide v5 9d95d341-a7a2-4e8d-bb8c-c9294c600828 admitted no contributors: proposal read-back used contributor project binding. Regression reproduced it; owner-project readback fixed with foreign-team denial retained. Reporter report-421fa80d7cf9be815c0d18d3 completed; run cancelled/ended.
5. Group-wide retry 92c5ffb5-c8f8-4746-8146-8a2781d6a5ca admitted no contributors: real Admin planning permits proposal writes, which exposed a foreign proposal grant collision missing from the narrower Note-only fixture. Expanded regression reproduced it; grants now remain in the contributor library. Reporter report-34455dbf2bd65b03443e1929 completed; run cancelled/ended.
   Original ends and every failure remain retained. API restart intervals also produced retained network/discovery/read errors; they are not passing read-backs.

Current prospective v5 workday: normal group preflight 806022fb-cebb-487a-96c2-423bcd00fc16, scheduled 16:52–17:52 UTC across UI/Admin/Platform, maximum concurrency two. It follows verified closure of the affected runs and is fresh authority for the expanded v5 portfolio scope; it is not a passing replay or alteration of their original deadlines. Group-wide results, approval and implementation/review/release remain unproven.

CI/evidence: latest API assignment/workspace/projector set 36 passed; context owner 28 passed; readiness set 8 passed; sets overlap and are not summed. Strict builds and current file policies pass. API's earlier CI retained 158 passes/two stale-input failures; canonical dependency syntax and real group-positive/agent-negative native fixtures repaired. Agent CI retained 1145 passes/two packaging failures: installed Git SDK lacks compiled payload and publish preparation pinned an older SDK Action; published rc124 and aligned preparation are required. Initial Agent test-directory overflow was fixed by folding cases into the existing suite, preserving the rule. CLI's packaged-native case passed on Actions in 23.809 seconds after two retained local 30-second timeouts. Later CLI CI passed package checks, then found stale coded-verifier test names; both bindings now target the group cases without removing requirements or changing allowances. Required consumer checks and release/read-back remain pending.

Still open: full group-wide completed contributions/discussion, v5 genuine estimates → approval → independent UI implementation/review → published UI candidate → meaningful Admin chart work → visible chart. No verification-only assignments, invented outputs, direct assignment insertion or upstream agent credentials.

Latest bounded feedback slice: v5 group workday workday-806022fb-cebb-487a-96c2-423bcd00fc16 is cancelled/ended after scoped stop; Reporter assignment_6Lr632-RVlIApnijvpdhRu2ljCzWamNa / report-12fd6775a9a195680def2d86 completed. UI Architect assignment_nXNUOBPUSkXyXyEcNnm55GUaXdbGyzAb / result-195f30d2ebbd3e6c98496fc6 and Reviewer assignment_7VzG3HpE7VQvzFslurOLUUejSe7cV4Fa / result-775d2200fc57d41422a1607a contributed. Admin Architect assignment_A-uxx3bD4S74943KkHq94cN1s75Myb99 and Platform coordinator assignment_61U-BDrtVekGyDxACXiDri1jGSfN0uqq failed immutable source authorization: only UI Git context was frozen, while the contributor broker attaches its own project source. Regression d0a30b0a reproduces this; API 9c922b2b freezes contributor source at admission through the existing source resolver, preserving shared proposal citations. 28 ready-node tests and file layout checks pass; one wider native PostgreSQL check remains locally blocked by an absent explicit test URL, not a pass. Required new-head run 39462360945 pending. UI Engineer assignment_l4u3Myi6qaeZ03b1yKTRX_Mr1uPTlSfA failed actual per-command clock discipline; no estimate/product substituted. Discussion send-ea733dc8b5a10f9779437e6adadedb95 retains coaching and responses.

Prospective retry: supported API development rebuild of 9c922b2b succeeded. New group-only preflight d87b0c94-183e-42ff-9b14-8593761fcaef schedules workday-d87b0c94-183e-42ff-9b14-8593761fcaef, 17:06–17:52 UTC, same real v5/UI proposal and seven-member UI/Admin/Platform group, concurrency 2; prior original 17:52 deadline retained. One planning preflight during API replacement failed network_error; no assignment was created by that failed request. Actual retry contributions/estimates/approval/acting/review remain unproven.

Passed real group participation and approval — 17:17 UTC: The prospective retry workday-d87b0c94-183e-42ff-9b14-8593761fcaef delivered seven current-content planning Notes and actual owner/reviewer estimates. It was stopped after its bounded objective completed, then Reporter assignment_mJcJ906JyctlrpcHjr8LHOKV1xiOvTM_ / report-210c4fdf78e7f98bc3fd789a completed; workday is cancelled/ended, original end retained. All participants came from portfolio-atlas subscriptions across UI/Admin/Platform; no individual/class proposal filter.

Participant	Planning assignment	Accepted planning result
UI Architect	assignment_8H-EQWMyA-qyVbV8c8k2ewJQdWsFhD4D	result-6fc4f123d8fa5281cf383f75
UI Engineer	assignment_qnZFpbOg-MJDsR47wdZtTSa6Zjj5wec4	result-07ee24b4669300511138cce3
UI Reviewer	assignment_s0iN7a7Se6Tcnt9TjOItom37WwTTmOMN	result-9291ef4f5902407c8b71b792
Admin Architect	assignment_rT1QVhTsbYtK-e0XRksnDiEScFi8IiB_	result-0a82c3e901751e76f7dea950
Admin Engineer	assignment_obQGNIF4BEwAA2vcni9jPjkoMWZGSbMG	result-064039b7ebdf56ac8b8a2cc9
Admin Reviewer	assignment_5BRgWp-qImw8QE3ZhVmdVuQLO3dI_RnW	result-253139bee232a3e3d4089e60
Platform coordinator	assignment_0us9UlY-jRPZ1sZ_ePpuQ5-7Sld9YB6A	result-87f956003e61a8187dd1a6ad

Admin contributors inspected actual Admin b608c6507d49633f99c0eb2dae922d2d2bc2292a and confirmed existing complete producer/frame scope; they did not claim access to the unattached UI checkout or invent UI estimates. UI members inspected exact UI f0ab91091fcb52e8f8e83746fe3438fa9345d410. Coordinator provided Platform adoption sequencing from exact Platform 7bcf0894677cb758bffbf4b52b74b3313c9f1f43.

UI Engineer estimator assignment_kB10aNGd2O_fAFiCeFDmzC-0XiaJdmOJ / result-aa7505e31bcb97be00216223 authored proposal v6 (TreeDX 01e47775b1182edcdc3724e328b8a5b5c678bbcb), expected 5400 / maximum 9000 active seconds. Reviewer estimator assignment_rFvZBCgd-HUB2l9vkfmPB2M34MG2ZQC1 / result-9187a74b1633981db5f2d737 authored v7 (TreeDX 81e207c4acbf4204540fd27b73edfa52090d404e, digest 18a9252b425c47671055696890ce820c92838918e4303c4edafa8961b68a5471), review expected 1800 / maximum 3000 seconds. Seven contributions remained valid across these estimate-only revisions.

Public read-back v7 passed votingReady=true, participationVersionReady=true, authorIndependent=true, executionPlanReady=true, no missing participants or reviewer classes. Existing SDK/REST governance.proposals.evaluate accepted v7 under standing human approval and created Decision 7fcf2c92-0c7d-44a9-b1c6-cba49a79ed45; accepted/read-back confirmed. The operator helper initially expected old status “approved” and failed after the actual mutation returned “accepted”; a read-only correction confirmed the Decision without repeating approval.

Team improvement from evidence: Platform planning attempts assignment_Y_i0M9hMoHf-9q3_8FZM0UsomtLmwIyI and assignment_dv2fgn53jNR1vqijTvxpTYap3zNUw9W3 failed actual per-command clock discipline. A supported retry preserved the first failure. Then only future Platform planning instructions were strengthened with an explicit clock–command loop and Platform sequencing perspective through governed workspace 8a16ac51-d3c1-496c-af22-081119f7a73b, review 418ab5a0-e039-4277-a3bf-756e7773de82, publication operation d22533c6-11bf-4aeb-9a76-0ec207a9916a succeeded, source 85499aa4924126515d09002c0fce4c038cbe58ea. New assignment assignment_0us9UlY-jRPZ1sZ_ePpuQ5-7Sld9YB6A completed. No running work or historical evidence changed. Contributions still overlap; broader autonomous team optimization and automatic group/topic enrollment are not yet proven.

Next real work admitted prospectively: workday-dffaf1cc-6ad2-4acc-85ad-6e747cda990d, 17:18–20:48 UTC, UI project, group portfolio-atlas, Decision above, planningPercent=0, simulation, concurrency 2. Fresh duration accommodates actual 9000+3000 maximum actor/reviewer seconds plus setup/closeout. No old deadline extended. UI implementation, independent review, release, and visible Admin chart are pending.

Release consumers: CLI #303 merged after required checks passed. Small release #304 prepares CLI rc87 with published SDK124, head 49400970c90ea5c1fa6c401890db1dee6e1a21fe; strict build and selection cases pass, required Actions pending. Initial PR checklist validation failed and the exact required checklist was added without changing code/checks. Agent #503 head 2a6c814b8132738963d6093318df9e832c405b23 now pins published registry SDK124 and matches verify/publish image preparation to exact protected SDK source. Genuine installed production archive consumer passes locally (10.06s), workflow alignment case passes; new required Actions pending. Earlier local checks against stale hydrated rc123 and an invalid test-config invocation failed and are retained, not substituted for passes.

Active small-slice delivery: restore class / group / topic authority — 2026-10-20

User direction supersedes targeted proposal orchestration: one class per agent for allocation/class memory; shared groups govern proposal subscriptions/submission and required team participation; topics sequence subscribed human/agent discussions. Do not select proposal participants by individual agent or class. Preserve existing accepted work, exact source refs, original deadlines, failures, golden proposals and the reserved SDK Tester-on-BASE/Engineer chain. No verification-only assignments.

Observed defect: current strict agent/proposal content schemas omit proposal-group fields; workday planning exposes agent/class selectors; estimating participation derives from work-item classes rather than group membership. Active readiness reports participationVersionReady/authorIndependent=true without group evidence. Existing group/group-edge content must be reused; topic subscriptions remain separate.

Deliver in small reviewable slices:

1. Canonical shared group contract (SDK Continue coached Atlas team delivery and persistent agent improvements from #428 #429): add one governed proposal-group membership representation to agent definitions and proposal content, reusing existing group identifiers/models. Keep agentClass singular and topics separate. Preserve historical exact records; new grouped work must not silently become an all-agent/default group.
2. Group-derived admission (API #553 + SDK Continue coached Atlas team delivery and persistent agent improvements from #428 #429): resolve shared proposal groups against governed project-agent memberships, freeze exact membership/source authority per proposal revision, expose actual required/pending participation. Group-scoped workday intent replaces individual-agent/class participant selectors across SDK/REST/CLI/MCP. Keep class allocation weights and work-item owner classes; no additional execution path or status store.
3. Participation before approval (API #553): group-required agents contribute discussion/planning and real estimates or explicit applicability rationale. Proposal edits invalidate affected participation. Approval must retain unresolved/missing participation and independent review, with no hardcoded pass flags.
4. Operator experience (existing UI Supply idempotency keys for all provider protocol mutations #70/Admin Catalog bounded AI GPU mode contracts for Deployment #215 #127): show/select shared proposal groups, team subscriptions, outstanding contributions and allocation; keep topic listeners visibly distinct. Machine clients use the same backend operations and evidence.
5. Real portfolio delivery: use the existing Atlas UI snapshot/Admin chart integration proposals, configure the cross-project team through governed group membership, obtain genuine group-derived contributions/estimates, approve, execute independent work in parallel by dependencies, review, and analyze the simulated release. Do not invent work, estimates, reviews or success. Existing targeted runs prove only the narrow mechanism, not group-driven team participation.

Each slice records exact PR/candidate/Actions/runtime and real workflow observations here and in its owning Issue. User prioritizes the usable process and real portfolio iteration over broad local test campaigns; required CI remains intact and formal acceptance stays unproven until its own requirements pass. No new Issues/status databases/runners are needed.

Current preserved observations: prior API repair assignment assignment_MPjiyvAjl0bvgr4JDj4qKuuyB-eRLit5 failed timing evidence despite creating local Git6a1d5f45c7ccbfb469e9b0a43c4c7a36b6a8d5c1; it is not an accepted implementation. Shared topic send-3465fa04e31c50bba0725108ff7e9b81 produced durable architect discussion recommendations from Admin/UI/Coordinator, not estimates, approvals or group-driven admission.

Current real portfolio process — 2026-10-20

The working shared-backend path now delivered actual portfolio code: Coordinator-selected Admin Engineer -> independent Reviewer; real estimates -> readiness v1/v2/v3 -> accepted Decision89116513-d5bb-49ab-bc7e-df0e673a1056 -> simulation implementation eaa69ef8d3239642936e73ab27705c05082bcd33 -> independent approval26da80f58ef170d92263fef26ee03857662aca78 -> Admin PR131 merged b608c6507d49633f99c0eb2dae922d2d2bc2292a after required Actions39427375609 (263checks/42files, package/Cloudflare builds). Real preparation/catalog failures repaired through merged Agent501/502 and supported guest/provider adoption; no fake/verification-only assignments. Exact products, actual usage, estimates, interventions and remaining UI gap are in Admin#127; API#553 retains readiness local adoption and PR584's unpassed prerequisite timeout.

Coordinator analyzed actual implementation/review/costs and designed UI Engineer+Reviewer first, then Admin Engineer+Reviewer integration. Corrected structured product f3eabc34e327e52657994ccfa3a043ccb843c203 / discussion-messages/portfolio-atlas-team-building/response-6100ba1d524ced4830bdbae7.mdx from assignment_piTNpaAi-1QR4ouYYZ3Ocl92l1fWekCR is exact-read; actual UI draft455126b4-d4e7-42e3-b13c-7eaa209e55c6 v1 was created/read back through public CLI. Integrator omitted one unverified discussion citation and retained the original, with no other plan/source/permission edits. UI profiles are proposed, not adopted; estimates/approval/execution remain next. No autonomous mutation or persistent group membership claimed.

Machine-interface follow-ons through existing SDK catalog/shared backend:

• Expose proposal lifecycle mutations (including evaluate) through MCP with existing OAuth/capability/If-Match/idempotency semantics. Current MCP tools/list omits evaluate; SDK/REST approval was real, not MCP.
• Expose governed knowledge authoring needed for team/profile changes through MCP; reuse existing APIs/TreeDX workspace/review/publication path.
• Give Coordinator exact create/work-item schemas and authoritative project Git bindings. Its first next-proposal draft had unsupported keys/wrong Git identity; correction succeeded with exact schema/context, but one unverified discussion citation still required explicit integrator omission.
• Authorize durable addressed discussion context explicitly. Evidence references alone do not grant cross-project content reads; actual Admin actor reported that limitation honestly.
• Return accepted authority plus recoverable graph-projection failure truthfully; scoped graph refresh/reconcile recovered the already-accepted Decision without duplicate approval.
• Improve supported live tool observation and ordinary operator export of simulation Git. Current authenticated full native tool history is available after completion; transparent diagnostic diff custody was required for delivery.
• Adopt the coordinator's necessary UI governed profile edits, obtain real owner/review estimates, then approve and implement the existing UI draft. Preserve planning/handlers/permissions, meaningful acting work, original deadlines and independent review.

No new scheduler, status database, dispatch path, named runtime role or fabricated execution identity. The producer is locally adopted; visible chart/browser/full scene/release acceptance remains incomplete. Historical evidence below is retained and may describe earlier candidates.

Current delivery — 2026-10-20: SDK431/rc123 published and byte-read-back; CLI302 merged23edbc9e with fresh377CLI+200Reviewer/176scene steps on protected39397784906. CLIrc86 sealed4af08cd5; publisher39400009354 accepted at09:21:38Z then original180s npm-pack read-back timed out while npm reported processing; public404 remains pending, no republish or deadline increase. APIrc113 published/source-and-runtime-byte adopted; signed catalog adoption still pending. Deployment886 protected39394904555 passed1345+213/267steps+packaging and rc322 exact tag540cf263; reviewed Platform composition fba0d13 prepared, not merged. Real accepted v4 Decision2839f4c7 continuation7385096d used new guest43cc, actual TesterCjdPV1 failed before model at locked GitSSH restore, exactly one12s charge/19s elapsed/null result. Workday cancelled/ended with actual Reporter producta61ac72; both failed unpublished work disks retained/detached and actual failed VM/task/container absent. No readiness code result yet. Agent500/Deployment887 now repair original dependency transport preserving exact accepted source. First Agent500 scene-binding check failed because parameterized cases lacked literal names;339f483f gives both unchanged cases explicit names, focused native2/binding1 pass; fresh full39400357011 pending. Deployment887 full39399941236 pending. Original failures retained. Corrected public journal→actual-disk custody withdraws earlier inferred lease-as-disk claims; current exact corrected audit and all new failure/product/review references are in API553 and Agent496. Full objective-to-release acceptance remains unproven.

Verified checkpoint — 2026-10-20 08:40 UTC: Deployment886 merged 540cf263f5e23eeaf7c10d433da13a765603242e, exacttree f655e85f5fff1b601805aa399222bb2d2d8109c2 equals tested92fdeb80 and headef8b3514. Fresh native 39391832003 all3jobs success: actual artifacts prove 1345 Deployment +213 Reviewer prerequisites and267/267 component steps,0fail/skip/todo/blocked/diagnostics. Both final-status absence cases, strengthened real public QEMU child-exit case and previously failed execution-VM custody case pass. Original failure's specific causal attribution remains unproven; no historical failure relabeled. Fresh protected39394904555 running before rc322tag/publication; CI fixture Debian packages are not real composition adoption.

SDK 0.13.0-rc.123 now fully published/read-back: same promotion39392084359 attempt2 succeeded after public registry processing completed; unchanged source08b03809/tag/custody/archive5f1e8718. Public metadata/archive verified before retry; rc123/latest0.12.62 tags correct, npm and unchanged GitHub assets byte-equal to sealed artifact. Original120s propagation timeout retained. CLI302, heada0ef94d04f540141c479cbddfb7cacb977a73007/baseb8635624, is only3files/24insertions14deletions: version86, SDK123/required converter lock, exactSDK39389815909 CIarchive. Strict build, real Platform verify(ok/no diagnostics),6canonical-schema/native-entrypoint integrations, strict npm11.7 ci and production npm ls pass;307 unrelated npm peer-flag regeneration changes kept out of commit after validating no unrelated version/integrity changes. Full39393674623 in scenes. No published CLI86 or catalog adoption claimed yet.

All3Deployment discussion products independently read back with full SDK diagnostics, actual once-only aggregate usage and closedTreeDX; complete owning broker snapshot proves exact ownedVM/task/private overlays absent. OriginalqIHB productd068a506 24.893990295native/25charged, coachedudQ productf487a85e 21.94011274/22, narrowKGdv productc9d7b066 10.322620877/11;3/3/4validclocks respectively. Originalno-source/false denial remains semanticfailure, secondexcerpt approval is not independent-source credit, third has an actual completed source-read command and bounded base-source assessment only. Profile refs are immutable8884733fororiginal, acceptede19c50beforbothsubsequent assignments; no hot swap. No canonical API work-review or release approval fabricated. Aggregate workspace journals still unavailable; original failed coding workdiskdea3b21a remains preserved, separate from these released analysis overlays. Readiness acting implementation remains pending repaired published guest/adoption; no substitute counter implementation authored outside the real chain.

Current integration checkpoint — 2026-10-20 08:22 UTC: Agent499 merged7e8fda56; checked tree dc0827b4 exactly matches a8b77f3c. Fresh PR Actions39384977897 passed 1142 Agent +213 verifier assertions,887/887 scene steps (864 component+23 planning),zero failures/skips/todo, including guest-init native cleanup; installed-owner custody succeeded as a separate component/custody check, not managed-workday acceptance. Protected publication 39390387828 runs the same complete workflow and will seal actual images; duplicate standalone39390387777 was scoped-cancelled, no passing receipt invented.

Deployment 886, head ef8b351416ee1f9c7cae417e1804744123ffea24, base5d0b509: RED d78fedbd reproduced2 final-status ENOENT/ESRCH failures/10passes; minimum doctor fix 8ef0838d adds final independent directory-absence proof and retains live/unreadable/denied/identity/namespace failures. Existing real pinned-QEMU public CLI→manager→supervisor case now requires identical complete inventories during owned ordinary-child exits; both new cases bound to original component scene. 14focused assertions,strict build/source-shape pass locally; no local same-candidate privileged replay because installed runtime bytes differ. Existing early native Actions step is reused, not duplicated. First886run 39390967852 failed before changed native cases: held Reviewer108f spent22.93s installing unused UI production closure and exhausted original25s work budget in PLAN; ETIMEDOUT plus owned subprocess residue/closure unproven retained. CI pin now selects checked protected Reviewer001329f (tree21aff9b3 equalsd42; protected38999382684 passed) with existing owning UI-runtime dependency correctione60ad25. No copied code, raised deadline, removed assertions or skipped prerequisites. Fresh 39391832003 passed the previously failing installed-archive check and early real native host/QEMU/VM-custody checks; full suites/scenes pending. Original885protected present-inventory failure still has unproven exact causality.

Real Deployment Reviewer: first assignment_qIHBdK2OObz7pYY-0d8sFyZwDmlbDrQz returned false publication denial/no source inspection; retained semantic failure. Governed chat-prompt-only correction e19c50be63ab855e80a9ce4fc1077ec386be9249, review4e8d44e0, publication37c504b2 succeeded/pushedcee8d002; SDK schema/deep-only-diff and 26fresh clock/handler assertions pass. assignment_udQDSWVgRD6g2Rh67hkRg4BxP7AiSeAF gives conditional excerpt scope approval explicitly without source inspection (productf487a85e); not independent source-review credit. Narrow follow-up assignment_KGdv3xXhT31nwIAa8xCRXjRSFtlrp08D actually read authorized Deployment5d0 doctor95–115 and supplied a bounded source-based safety assessment, explicitly no proposed-head execution/CI/release approval. Original full-patch discussion was rejected as communication_agent_not_found because scoped package names became mentions; retried with exact executable/test patch and unchanged full commit. Unknown short CLI profiles/communications names and wrong profile extensions were operator lookup errors, not new product passes. All real products/settlements/physical closure audit is pending; don't claim it from terminal status alone.

SDK431 protected 08b0380 passed 624+200 prerequisites/290scene steps, zero failed/skipped/todo, and custody verification binds4artifacts. Sealed123archive 5f1e87184c9f363043452aaf963b4c0dbc9660e21f1835e652345e8af68e4849, byte-identical to checked PR archive. Annotated tag0.13.0-rc.123 pins08b after fresh protected-head check. Promotion 39392084359 npm publisher accepted the unchanged tarball at08:15:53UTC and reported asynchronous processing; unchanged120s read-back failed ETIMEDOUT, public version/archive remain404 at08:21. No verified npm/GitHub release/adoption credit yet. Wait for actual registry byte visibility/hash equality before safe same-evidence retry; never overwrite/rebuild or extend read-back allowance. CLI86 worktree prepared with exact protected SDK123 archive pin, no PR/publication yet. Platform/Deployment rc322 catalog adoption and real counter acting chain remain pending; released catalog remainsrc112. Accepted real proposalv4 retains2actual owner estimates while live backend reports estimateCount1, captured before repair. API readiness implementation has not been substituted by integrator code.

Current slice — v9 accepted; real simulation execution and rc113 release

Composition repair — 2026-10-20 07:37 UTC: Deployment #885 merged as 5d0b509dacd7c4cb0736684584d9226064f05147 after all required checks (1343 Deployment +200 verifier assertions;265 component steps;zero failures/skips). Existing published CLI85/SDK121 and primary CLI85/SDK122 reject the unchanged Platform reportingAgentId schema; public verifyPlatformRepository from exact checked SDK082eb188 returns ok:true/no diagnostics. Do not remove that schema field or overwrite the already-published older SDK122. Next bite-sized release slice: version-only SDK123 from protected082, full Actions/custody/publish/readback; CLI unique release consuming SDK123; normal reviewed Platform/Deployment composition. This is release integration work under this Issue and continuing user authority, not simulated coding output. Agent #499 complete verification remains pending; acting readiness implementation remains unproven.

Real acting checkpoint — 2026-10-20 07:14 UTC: successor e18cbedf-ad27-4859-b696-b08e4db14258 advanced 1→2→3→4 through genuine Tester assignment_ptDEOxx9G7qHijhuSyXan84FbwRng9N7, Engineer assignment_DEsG4OKlzS05h4OEYqJL7jCbVzCkIg4h and Reviewer assignment_WtLR_StyPadkBh_zMpPODtbDYC5Kgffh. Exactv4 source f61830a923ba82f950eadbbf21bf856c4552f1d4, hash fa9b0971d3758ec8199899091bb3a8f6101db56e9e1daee3c8edf7fdaa7faea8; static fingerprint unchanged across all estimates, actual2owner+2independentreview estimates. Human-authorized public approval created Decision 2839f4c7-16bb-4aa4-b6c2-20280108537c, exact f22cdd69aacb0c1aa12bace79f7a364ebeede80c, digest 77b86bc1afa69904de82043a00a8633f0a01dd18131accba6d1d7b1394cc87d0. Original v9 remains historically approved/superseded, not edited in place. New genuine estimates are Tester5400/9000s, Engineer10800/18000s; Reviewer900/1800 and1440/2880s. No operator-authored numeric estimates. Planning workday2a7f6a40 is cancelled/ended after its actual Reporter.

Actual accepted-Decision acting workday workday-c56a19d8-adc3-428f-9341-8d8b76d2645d, original 06:59:47–18:59:47UTC, concurrency1, admitted Tester assignment_3sqH1UpxlCn1t797MJyIxVCa2wE6_QUt with explicit testing capability and real Git write authority on API0df73b. It failed in guest preparation agent_kernel_failed / assignment_subprocess_cleanup_failed, result null, original9000s deadline09:30:23.977UTC untouched. Exactly one 15s aggregate settlement and informational0; no detailed native token usage was available, so none is invented. Scoped stop reached cancelled/ended; actual Reporter assignment_rH_aXwZ2HnKvFeK5hAUVO1fDKSUex5dZ settled once6s. Broker VM/task teardown true/complete physical inventory does not mean source cleanup: private source lease dea3b21a-8cc0-4f4c-b438-ee5eb0348c8e remains retained/active with source_publication_required, no result_artifact_id; preserve its disk and do not credit clean teardown.

Earliest repaired defect is guest PID1 supervision: real-container and native PID-namespace reproductions on exact guest1f3bc6 show original runner exit23, orphan descendant present and cleanup_incomplete; using already installed tini retains originalexit23 and proves ESRCH. Agent PR499, RED 0229f61a, fix f9ed45e2a06c899bdebf814d84ff5dfccb53f986, adds tini entrypoint and a real native case bound to the existing coded component scene. 12 focused tests/3files, strict tsc, build and file policies pass; full Actions39384977897 is pending. Original specific npm-child attribution is inferred, because original failure transport retains only a wrapper message. No runtime guard, deadline or allowance weakened. Initial local harness path/bind failures and missing PR template rejection retained; corrected metadata validation passed. Independent governed Agent Reviewer send send-0c00ecebb8844d37db1dccc6f848f874 requested actual bounded code findings; no review result claimed yet. Readiness-counter implementation and actual Tester→Engineer→Reviewer delivery remain unproven.

For rc113 catalog adoption, Deployment PR885, exact d8ba529b6086ef0a08d2f2f62dab47eb5d1c145c, prepares unique rc322 package identity; Actions39383861614 pending. Platform composition and signed APT read-back follow its required checks; preserve persistent development selections and unrelated components. This is not a claim that the catalog already adoptedrc113.

Admission correction — 2026-10-20 06:54 UTC: v9 was actually approved, then its first acting run was scoped-stopped and reached cancelled/ended because both accepted work items have empty requiredCapabilities. No Tester/Engineer code assignment was issued. The exact owning buildAssignmentAttempt reproduction rejects [] as capacity_execution_capabilities_required; node explanation had nevertheless reported eligible, while authenticated polling admitted nothing. This is a retained executable-plan/readiness-observation gap, not a successful coding chain. Existing v9 Decision remains immutable; proposal was normally superseded by e18cbedf-ad27-4859-b696-b08e4db14258 (source cda28015d5c44d7f5f31ecfe7b2c68802400af99, hash 71336bfc7bba1534af0db5df91139973d19eb11508a319399877d888ec7f4960), same actual counter-repair scope/source, explicit Tester treeseed.engineering.unit-testing and Engineer treeseed.engineering.code-change demand. Original numeric estimates were cleared, not fabricated/copied as new estimates. New genuine estimation workday workday-2a7f6a40-944c-48d9-bb65-7778feb95e4d, concurrency1/original180-second turns and 06:53:52–07:53:52 UTC window; Tester assignment_ptDEOxx9G7qHijhuSyXan84FbwRng9N7 claimed first. Initial run's actual builtin Reporter assignment_PRq1RoPvqENjWGz7IU3mpZwcnND4BJKu completed with product 04ef2d3310614e677baf3ac2611b28f941ec994b and measured 5.068589889999479 active /6 charged seconds; full settlement/TreeDX read-back being checked. No failed observation or earlier approval claim removed.

Current execution — 2026-10-20 06:49 UTC: Human explicitly approved exact proposal v9; public trsd proposals evaluate --if-match 9 accepted it and created Decision af4694c2-44b1-40f6-b4de-2b210a5f1d26, exact Decision TreeDX f18f004358fa63ecbafc8109efc9194783c30c82, digest 12de17e84bca332cfa9010effe2c7732ef53e2a067bb2ebc05c78ddcfc0a8586. Proposal source/hash below remain unchanged. Acting simulation preflight c0ff019d-3f16-4bae-993f-be79960c74df, concurrency1, original 06:48:18–12:48:18 UTC, accepted Decision only; actual coding/review/release remains pending.

API 0.8.0-rc.113 now published: protected candidate 39355399125, protected Verify39355399129, exact promotion 39382209352 all success. Exact0df73b source: fresh 2216 API +200 verifier assertions and998 component steps, zero failures/skips. Sealed/published archive b496b775b3ff5bee2e0e4006a31d54e4bad052ab5d8fd8ee0e688bf97299acf4, release assets byte-identical; registry tags match sealed API fba20c64604a3e38d0aa770ecb0afc1924c69e6d4c56ed85c14945ae97a1c907 and runner 1f6a88e26afa2b596668f4e8b72a7510e84a4524acb9a2ef52e9aa7eddf52616. Fresh persistent development service/runner source+dist+SDK+TreeDX byte equality passed. Released foundation/catalog stillrc112; supported trsd stage --plan explicitly denies standards_migration_not_enabled, host plan is no-op. Do not claim catalog/production adoption.

Before admission, only API Tester/Engineer acting and Reviewer reviewing prompts were governed/coached for exact project scope, intentional Tester RED, fresh clock before every command and honest partial evidence. SDK-schema/semantic-only diff pass; fresh 21 guard/handler tests pass. Review 3bc5cc40-4661-416e-b5b4-ff060fe668dd, definition 4769f3a693da696b0bbf3f81851daac24bde6b70, publication operation 17c27a58-1763-4fbc-a9d3-49b20129e154 succeeded/pushed Git e681e1d6662365d7044c436c540dd14e8b373394. Permissions/handlers/dependencies/estimates unchanged. Old api/tester CLI profile lookup denied; correct project+tester lookup succeeds. Redundant manual publication without If-Match denied; original submission's publication succeeded. Earlier --plan lacking startsAt denied, no workday issued. These interventions are retained; no failed output relabeled.

Achieved — genuine estimates and approval readiness (2026-10-20 02:32 UTC): proposal 46a2982b-7427-4ef0-8583-c5f4843063aa advanced 6→7→8→9 through actual Tester→Engineer→Reviewer assignments. Current exact source 3a74a38218389318553517aceb435a32fc541711, SHA256 db3247c2c5e15cb90942c1246481c872645fabce6236721b8ec7496a14fe04e0, same canonical proposal path/repository below. Content status ready, governance status open, executionPlanReady=true, votingReady=true, Decision null. No proposal approval, acting execution or release is represented by these estimates.

Successful retry workday workday-d416a348-3543-45b2-800d-57d9a2474dde used the accepted dad26c72 profiles, original180-second turn maximum/concurrency1 and simulation isolation. Its single planning round completed without creating an obsolete/duplicate round. After all estimates integrated, operator scoped-stop closed it cancelled/ended, preserving original03:15:34end. All four actual assignments completed; the stopped batch is not mislabeled a completed objective/release guarantee.

Actual role/result	Product commit (proposal path unless Reporter)	Actual charged/native active seconds	Valid clock checks	Estimate supplied
Tester assignment_1anDQ-taeKoEBV9tBntCEUPg9zq8Hvab / result-89a0a2b38e051e1102305241	ec8b31e0e0deae38a363ace29481613cd571488c; SHA2567d68165eef0bcd7ead359022c7bdc53d6687a7db39c26750e30787617092ebc4	82 /81.295683273	8	Regression work1800 expected/3600 maximum seconds
Engineer assignment_5-Udx5NXcT4AXQGVGa2VRwDMAB1iX2tI / result-518eb4a725f1dab91a2f979c	a23bdfe6f11393885e371a44b459f34915159a7f; SHA256a4c0121bfecd4a2ce7b3b7d605795c9eab2b107072796ecec40faaa4bcb41160	34 /33.44676567	9	Implementation3600/7200seconds
Independent Reviewer assignment_YUas2hWWeaaWnJXCug00m1Yjyzc4uf4e / result-732b6c12b0226c1cd9bb4664	9f64f747268d060d99202cf54a3848d18b7243b3; SHA2568fa5ce31bf651a010684b3a8d8a9fd5f99852b96da7a5fc7dea248475ac804f1	28 /27.109163166	4	Tester review900/1800; Engineer review1440/2880seconds
Built-in Reporter assignment_rH4ZYbd588GRUoJxfKDGx7k3DZ2yy4wW	a494621a2a8dc01b452c7707a57c9870d448af6f; notes/assignment_rH4ZYbd588GRUoJxfKDGx7k3DZ2yy4wW.mdx; SHA256599b48d1f69fb9c47f688afd224acf5ec6bd718fa6217b54af3fc4f53b8f25f3	6 /5.319246214 measured handler seconds	Not a model/Kata turn	Real closing report includes all three completed estimator IDs

These are real bounded estimates, not claims of completed implementation or tests. Tester explicitly retained uninspected scene-wiring uncertainty; Engineer allowed substantial native integration/full verification effort; Reviewer independently estimated both review cycles. Both owner results were present in the Reviewer's authorized predecessor context. Completion/claim timestamps prove Tester completed before Engineer claimed and Engineer completed before Reviewer claimed.

All three assignments retain original frozen proposal v6/578916b7/hash46687cd2 and exact dad26c72 profile refs. Actual products change only each class's allowed estimate fields; current v9 combines two owner estimates and two independent review estimates. Existing owning proposalApprovalFingerprint is unchanged: 4e90571a26cddb00ed2d4b93c607c9fbd7b26d29704245683e40a9b4275e6ad8. Issued Engineer authority/result are byte-for-byte unchanged through closing. Every estimator's environment receipt matches published guest1f3bc6296f75f45a650c67bcfe09d1d8901e562f2cd6a515bd047e8aabcca18d and finishes before its original deadline.

Exactly one aggregate settlement per assignment; all informational rows charge0. Two full event pages/200 durable events checked. All four TreeDX workspaces closed and proxies revoked. Complete owning-broker inventory confirms all three acquired VMs/tasks absent, both disk scans confirm private overlays20c952c8-73b3-4a1a-a6cd-7f31f7627b5a /56d8ca65-3020-45ea-9420-bf3b2df1d991 /6484454b-01b3-4630-b48b-33f5b33a5615 absent; shared source caches retained. Initial physical read was incomplete (vm_inventory_unavailable, process3302072 executable ENOENT); retained, not credited. A fresh complete inventory with no errors independently proves cleanup. Aggregate workspace journals remain unavailable. Final provider snapshot has no active assignment IDs and5available workers; no broader cleanup/stop performed.

Final replay after v9: authenticated SDK, installed CLI and official MCP client all recover original send380753ff2429d344349e54318ebff162 / invocation53f86e7e07dc1babbb2af88484ce4407 / assignment_aLC_b856VqXrLMIPENH22VhLc6QWLFe6, keeping exact frozenv1/afb84153 context, responses and events. All139 MCP input/output schemas compile; missing idempotency key, model-owned Authorization and changed input denied (changed input409). Complete before/after global assignment inventories each contain the same 138 IDs over2pages; no new assignment/lease. Original exact usage rows unchanged: one21-second aggregate/native20.507332779 active plus informational0.

Known next repair remains real: backend estimateCount still reports1 despite the two actual owner estimates; independentReviewCount remains0 despite linked discussion products, and participation/author-independence fields still have existing placeholder semantics. These fields are not credited as formal participation proof. The discussed proposal itself assigns the truthful estimate-field repair; it has not executed yet. Formal automatic group membership, objective-specific coordinator approval delegation, acting/release execution and coordinator release evaluation remain later gates.

Read back with existing public boundaries:
trsd proposals show 46a2982b-7427-4ef0-8583-c5f4843063aa --server local --project api --json
trsd library read api proposals/governance/make-real-treeseed-mcp-project-work-recoverable.mdx --ref 3a74a38218389318553517aceb435a32fc541711 --json
trsd workdays show workday-d416a348-3543-45b2-800d-57d9a2474dde --server local --json

Adopted: API580 merged 0df73b38026c80a321abd428a7e78f33dddc72bb, treee711a55589285cbb0d557b8d3febfe596e065246 identical to tested25b6f6263db7d279d4f3bd48ab02bdddea12f767. 39347303717 passed2216API+200verifier assertions/998component steps, no failed/skipped/todo/blocked/diagnostics. Archiveb496b775b3ff5bee2e0e4006a31d54e4bad052ab5d8fd8ee0e688bf97299acf4. Supported development rebuild succeeded; host727sources/1454dist, service+runner727JS each,447SDK/127TreeDX dependency files match checked artifacts. Published036 custody/index/archive verification also passed; immutable installed rc112 metadata preserved. Protected rc113 publication 39355399125 remains separate/pending; no released OCI activation or production promotion claimed. Independent API580 REQUEST_CHANGES outputs, rejected/timed-out reassessments and integrator's concrete canonical-freeze/native-PostgreSQL disposition remain in the PR/history; no agent approval fabricated.

Original three held claims now released after actual measured closeout, still expired/null success result, each exactly one aggregate settlement: bTu41...37 charged/36.668414944 native, eI-Ad...43/42.817446879, 2iaGL...34/33.988576105. Complete public usage pagination1/1/2 checked. Original MCP request recovery passes on adopted0df: all139schemas compile, same invocation/assignment/frozenv1/results/events, invalid missing-key/model-authority/changed-input requests denied. Final SDK/CLI/MCP replay after proposalv9 passed as recorded above.

Real team discussion and proposal: proposal 46a2982b-7427-4ef0-8583-c5f4843063aa v6, exact TreeDX 578916b70247efab8375b5827aedf3c64174bd86, SHA256 46687cd21bf7ae09c3cef1e2417f74faa5b6d9c3f1f9a25602d5e3c8e813c553. Exact API-core objective and all actual discussion products linked. Architect1528498a... and Testerad9707b9... supplied real scope (Tester's false publication denial/failed correction retained). Engineer 53b4db6baf68957292a5f8ca7afe08ef9f7b8de6, response-e1150bd7a829efbcbbee8e69.mdx/hash9bc3daeb16264b13f862cf1090c0acadfe1ea407d5f9f347a9f034f8998f7a54, independently confirmed defect at0df;17 charged/16.659046465 native seconds. Independent Reviewer fad6c977d7f2e0540be57be7dbde53d8102d0ae6, response-9342b3eb7080f8f678497f7b.mdx/hash689043ce191f4b5e00c39328b8f7a58891e140327dafb10fc8f2d74815475084, confirmed count/class semantics and bounded scope;19/18.960973104 seconds. Genuine canonical products, clock evidence, single settlements, exact read-back and workspace/private-overlay/task/acquired-VM cleanup verified.

Two actual work items: Tester regression coverage, then Engineer's minimal API readiness repair, both independently reviewed. estimateCount means owner-estimated work-item count; missing owner classes are unique/sorted while any item of that class remains unestimated; missing reviewer class is reviewer while any required reviewEstimate is missing. review:none requires none. Existing profile Engineer→Tester ordering and generated owner→Reviewer estimate edges govern scheduling. Existing voting/source-denial policy preserved. No fake Architect task, operator-authored estimate or Decision. Broader group/participation/author-independence semantics remain separate gaps.

Guest and governed repair: published Agent2a3 candidate39222422446 custody/registry pass (owner1141+213/863component+23planning); exact guest sha256:1f3bc6296f75f45a650c67bcfe09d1d8901e562f2cd6a515bd047e8aabcca18d imported through supported CLI after all holds cleared/no active work, provider rebuilt preserving identity/selections. Actual Engineer/Reviewer environment receipts match this published image. No running work hot-swapped.

First estimation failed, closed and retained: planning-only simulation workday-14ce1924-4704-44f7-a3d5-a2362bc3f4e0, concurrency1/turnmax180, admitted actual Tester assignment_afwUz9vUkzswNKS3gxP4GVD23el8CFaE on frozenv6. Host correctly rejected timing evidence:3valid initial/final clocks but second source command item_2 lacked a fresh preceding clock. Canonical failure agent_kernel_failed/null result; actual64.337646424 active/65charged seconds, one aggregate plus informational0. No estimate integrated; proposal remainsv6. Scoped stop preserved original03:03:42end and cancelled/ended the workday. Actual configured Reporter assignment_aoFJtoETGNk9JmXfUeMvWFBz2BKvbefJ completed, product da6b60149976208620d9cb3d4ffb9e936bbea894 / notes/assignment_aoFJtoETGNk9JmXfUeMvWFBz2BKvbefJ.mdx, recording original failed node/history;6charged, actual handler5.510379912 seconds, one aggregate plus two informational0 rows. Reporter uses configured built-in handler, no Kata VM; ledger native object is empty, not invented token/resource evidence. All TreeDX workspaces closed/proxies revoked; complete broker inventory confirms owned Tester VM/task and private overlay57c1ec1d-47a2-45d0-86fb-b5a349bd02fa absent; source caches preserved. Aggregate workspace journal metadata remains unavailable, not relabeled complete.

Governed estimating-only prompt coaching published/adopted dad26c721bd61fbfc6a498e60d1130a831b23a5f through workspaceecd78558-eb57-46ee-853d-18c1bc6d0008/reviewc4bc45a4-8ece-435d-bf81-189113dbed76; publication9151151c-5f73-41dc-9b85-545046b9ea7f succeeded, publishedRevisiond285bb92808d3122a975c4d3a50bbd01694754d7. Only existing Tester/Engineer/Reviewer estimating.prompt.system changed: explicit NEW clock before EACH source command/read, reserve original closeout, one final clock, handler-owned persistence. Identity/handlers/permissions/dependencies/limits unchanged. Installed SDK validates all three; semantic-only diff verified; fresh21 timing-guard/handler assertions pass. Original failed workday's frozen018b profiles remain intact.

Completed retry activation: unchanged frozenv6 and same limits were used after verified failed-work closure and fresh public preflight; successful results and closed batch are recorded above. Attempted planning continuation was explicitly denied: continueFromWorkdayId requires exact accepted decisions, not proposal planning. No accepted Decision manufactured to bypass it. With no accepted estimates to reuse, a fresh governed planning workday is the supported retry; original failed run/report/history retained. This is ordinary coached project work, not formal objective-to-release acceptance.

Additional machine-interface gap retained: proposal GET ETag is quoted timestamp; using it for update fails proposal_precondition_invalid because service requires numeric proposal version. Supported explicit If-Match5 plus expectedProposalVersion5 publishedv6; no stale guard weakened. MCP full-diagnostics appended-query form remains separately unproven (original recovery/default resource reads pass). Automatic group membership, formal participant gate correctness, objective-specific coordinator approval delegation, acting/release chain and coordinator release evaluation remain unproven.

Machine evaluation read-back also passed: authenticated official MCP default resources governance.proposals.show and workdays.show return the same semantic result as SDK on real proposalv9/3a74a382... and closed workdayd416a348... (ready with Decisionnull; cancelled/ended with one planning round). This proves shared-backend default proposal/workday observation through MCP as well as SDK/CLI. It does not certify external Codex/ChatGPT host attachment or the separately unproven full-diagnostic query form.

Retained intermediate candidate, review and adoption observations

Active next slice — published adoption and real proposal estimates

Published API036 candidate39339097910 is verified (2210API+200verifier/994components, all architecture builds/sealed custody, exact registry indexes and selected development code read-back). Installed immutable rc112 metadata remains the older release; no overwrite or released-composition activation is claimed. Existing API580, exact a7131944905b3c19da62535d8c742a6d47b0489f/tree e711a55589285cbb0d557b8d3febfe596e065246, prepares rc113 and planning-only closeout recovery. Fresh39347303717 passed complete verification/PostgreSQL supplements and is running all998 component steps. Merge/adoption remains gated by final checks and independent review. No repeated campaign or assertion waiver.

Real proposal46a2982b... remains open v5/exact60f47f37..., no execution estimates or Decision inserted. Genuine Architect contribution1528498a... recommends actual Tester→Engineer work and independent review, with no artificial Architect item. Genuine Tester contributionad9707b9... provides useful regression scope but falsely denies its own durable publication; retain this contradiction, not a test/approval claim. Canonical product/usage/closure details: API553.

Governed API profiles 099061364c29fa142486cb25af2fb1b9faac0e1d adopted through normal workspace/review/staging integration: clarify handler-owned chat publication, remove impossible Tester estimating/acting Architect dependencies, retain Engineer→Tester and independent Reviewer, remove duplicated named-role order from Reviewer prose. Identities/capabilities/handlers/permissions unchanged. No artificial assignments or broader group membership inferred.

The subsequent genuine Tester factual-correction assignment assignment_60npV8ZHH4vsjNsAYgdCbPIaek2l8nMa failed with unattributed Codex exit1. Cause UNKNOWN, original46-second deadline preserved, null result/no approval. Exactly one9-second aggregate failed settlement/native usage unavailable; released lease/revoked proxy/closed workspace and independent task/acquired-VM/private-image absence verified. Affected correction held, no identical retry; owning Agent496 retains missing diagnostics/public-boundary denials. Separate bounded API580 static review requested from configured Reviewer; no passing review inferred. Three original held claims/provider2a3/guestf3 preserved. Published Agent2a3 candidate39222422446 custody and exact guest registry read-back pass; safe guest adoption remains pending original-claim closure.

Next: checked API580 adoption, then freeze the real class-owned estimate-readiness slice and let actual owners/Reviewer estimate it through a planning-only simulation workday. Other participation/author-independence placeholders and automatic group membership remain separate gaps; no full objective-to-release acceptance claimed.

Latest review/coaching evidence (2026-10-20 01:39 UTC): original Reviewer product11bf6ce7311d813e5bdac35d8fd7d68b9d7b23a5 requested changes concerning still-required issued-node authority. The final owning state boundary already freezes it: a fresh composition probe preserved assigned/running/completed/failed/cancelled original refs, and all13 existing living-graph contract assertions passed. No speculative code change was made. Reassessment assignment_1p4tPrLWXxMVMI24o68f5BKkYK0NXnPx failed timing validation; its raw apparent approval is REJECTED, not a canonical review. Supported SDK full diagnostics retain the protected sandbox result and actual28.087386288 active seconds; exactly one29-second aggregate settlement. Five valid clocks did not cover command items5/7/10. Released lease/revoked proxy/closed task and acquired VM, exact private overlay workspace-lease-07c805ee-751c-4c31-ac20-da9cf429c812 absent. No diagnostics-code defect was demonstrated.

Governed chat clock coaching is published/adopted at 018b4b6c444c4f83118d22c4b4b3bf5000453191 (workspace1f75b9e6-2a21-43e1-947b-6956e063e9c3, review7aece79f-490a-4ded-b86b-3118ddd9f4e6). It explicitly requires a fresh pre-command/content-read clock and one final clock; capabilities/permissions/allowances unchanged. Subsequent valid static review assignment_6VMuJwfgXlKu0vYVswaDWwkty1BZVs53 completed with REQUEST_CHANGES for missing complete canonical-path evidence, productc288fe13295fe0b969edf091b8baf1800429a01b/path discussion-messages/mcp-coordination/response-4d3f4b5a74ac7066db5e558b.mdx/hashde6f4e4aa2220e241cf3ab4d4f22d72a4420cbba8f2e744538ff677e5c52b7a7. Three valid clocks,9.873263793 native active/10 charged seconds, one settlement, closed TreeDX workspace and independently absent acquired VM/task/private overlay705757bd-26a2-40c2-b92e-7ad8632d13de. Exact complete reconcile source and canonical freeze supplied in supplemental send-f5ca04cd119dad015a58d0f03092931c; result pending, no approval presumed.

Cleanup clarification for all discussion receipts: private lease overlay directories are independently absent from both broker disk scans; shared cached source imagefe3c29cd74fba46b26282bf78b2039408384b8ac1b90f4ae3ffc26886b213874 is intentionally retained. Aggregate workspace journal metadata remains unavailable; complete task/container/VM inventory and exact owned resources were checked. No claim of complete aggregate journal visibility.

MCP original real-proposal recovery still passes all139 schemas and unchanged original context/result/events after v5/profile changes. A separate exploratory full-diagnostics resource URI with an appended query failed “Communication send not found”; SDK full diagnostics work, MCP query-form contract remains unproven. No extra assignments or passing MCP full-trace claim.

Checked merge reached: API580 merged 0df73b38026c80a321abd428a7e78f33dddc72bb, treee711a55589285cbb0d557b8d3febfe596e065246 equal to tested25b6f6263db7d279d4f3bd48ab02bdddea12f767. 39347303717 passed fresh2216API+200verifier assertions and998 component steps, zero fail/skip/todo/blocked/diagnostics. Archive b496b775b3ff5bee2e0e4006a31d54e4bad052ab5d8fd8ee0e688bf97299acf4. All required authorization/submission/native checks green; protected staging/main fetched immediately before merge. Published rc113 candidate 39355399125 is a separate pending protected publication, not an activated OCI claim.

Independent reviews remain REQUEST_CHANGES. Productd30d34a99c6b43b9f6093c4ad5bac334caad8c82 resolved atomicity but proposed inserting the revision before prior receipt detection. Integrator rejects this: it would trigger exact-match early return before node writes. Exact-candidate native PostgreSQL step api.golden.execution-node-history-postgres-native passed concurrent complete history, duplicate replay and interrupted-observation rollback (evidence f95aafdbd5551cf9db9b8abd72802dfec77b1ceecbc0a96d9b63c17e68c7273a). No actual production defect from these static findings reproduced. Explicit PR disposition retains all findings/failures; no Reviewer approval fabricated.

Follow-up assignment_HEarjYhJb3RYGUgXSmTLqSxdwqrVxXCn failed original32-second deadline, null canonical result/no approval, exactly one30-second settlement/native29.561555307 active. Closed/revoked TreeDX workspace, released lease and independently absent owned task/acquired VM/exact private overlay234453e6-b15d-46f5-a99d-a598c39b5b88. No identical failed review retry; Agent496 records the fatal short-window observation. Still-selected guestf3 is distinct from the already verified published2a3 guest. Broken short-window review work stays held while unrelated healthy capability work may continue under its own original authority.

Primary API fast-forwarded cleanly to0df73b38 and strict build passed. Supported development rebuild is underway; no completed runtime adoption or new estimator activation is claimed yet. Real2-item Tester/Engineer plan draft validates against canonical SDK content schema, has exact API-core objective ref, no invented estimates and no artificial dependency tasks; final source/semantics await checked runtime read-back and actual owner contribution.

Retained earlier preflight and adoption checkpoint

Active next slice — published adoption and real proposal estimates

User request: finish published candidate adoption, then required-agent discussion and genuine estimates toward approval. Current published API036 39339097910 passed fresh2210 API+200verifier assertions/994component steps, all four amd64/arm64 image builds and sealed custody. Registry read-back matches API a94df5a2.../runner6fec27c9...; archive07cbe21d... matches selected service/runner bytes. No immutable rc112 release overwrite: that version is already installed from older source.

Existing API580 is composed onto036 and prepares unique rc113 at a7131944905b3c19da62535d8c742a6d47b0489f, treee711a55589285cbb0d557b8d3febfe596e065246. It prevents obsolete estimating-only rounds and preserves issued closeout custody. Strict build/policies and72 focused assertions/3files pass; all998 scene steps/1019 registry bindings preserved. Fresh 39347303717 running; current head auth/submission pass. Prior1937 submission briefly rejected changed head metadata before push; no check weakened. No new code/runtime/guest adoption yet.

Real proposal46a2982b... updated normally v4→v5, exact TreeDX60f47f37bcc72551453d9715a0d246c620c97053/hash3d6954ec5804b0e3b38c19793bf122b598e3792066e5f0c532fb007c43c2fa18. It records completed transport and remaining truthful participation/estimate readiness; no estimate or approval fabricated. Source036, existing objective/group/history preserved. Plan: one bounded Architect discussion using supplied exact readiness function (reduce irrelevant context/commands), then class-owned work items and genuine owner/Reviewer estimates after checked planning adoption. Bound group currently has no declared membership; no automatic group-team claim. Final execution source must be frozen before estimating.

Live API036/SDK082, provider2a3/guest e4c5 unchanged. Complete public active pages0; fresh broker task/container inventory complete and warm-only, no task/NBD residue. Three older expired held claim IDs remain in provider availability; preserve them and count conservatively, one new isolated task maximum. Workspace aggregate metadata reports unavailable job/candidate/result observations and is not claimed complete; verify exact task workspace separately. No new assignment admitted yet. Full workflow/production acceptance remains unproved.

Next small slice — retry after proposal edits, 2026-10-19

API #582, branch codex/discussion-recovery429, base 19f98bfaf0707cb9a0a97a4d763de0073eaf2f3a, current head 3324372de83609a8f9e265e6c8fe245ae667b3cc. Integrator-authored code/tests. Existing exact message identity and native TreeDX message context are reused; new sends resolve the current proposal. Message/proposal/recipient/parent changes reject. Original invocation digest is unchanged, including exact source/context. No new storage or dispatch path.

Regression-first: 5504413f five intended failures/one pass after correcting the unit mock's module path; 346fe6ae repaired original-message recovery. Real Researcher review then identified a writer/admission race; 29acc606 reproduced it (one intended failure/six passes, replay resolved instead of denial), c6744350 rejects changed exact context at the owning Discussion replay boundary before admission. Earlier invalid-fixture failure reached missing-profile denial; it is not the accepted reproduction.

Focused verification: 74tests/17files initially passed with real disposable PostgreSQL17. The initial no-URL run failed its explicit PostgreSQL prerequisite; rerun passed. Current selected suite26tests/7files passed, zero skipped, after the race guard. Build/declarations, file-length/architecture and diff checks passed. Native PostgreSQL/signed TreeDX integration covers a real proposal update, simultaneous identical recovery, changed-input conflicts, actual SQL-trigger interruption after message commit, mismatched-context denial before admission, immutable invocation/assignment/ledger/event read-back and owned teardown. This new native case is written but not yet locally executed; do not infer a pass.

Existing component cases: api.golden.communication-proposal-recovery-unit, api.golden.communication-proposal-race-unit, api.golden.communication-proposal-recovery-native; owning files capacity/communication/completion/proposal-replay.test.ts and proposal-replay-native.test.ts. Native39287800350 was cancelled while queued to compose with the impending PR581 staging merge, then run complete verification once on the final combined candidate. Superseded39287416140 cancelled, no passing receipt. Test-only3324372d supplies the existing governed proposal type contract and closes native authoring workspaces; it is now pushed, not runtime-adopted. Its pre-base native39290093830 was requested for cancellation as well. Submission contract39290090148 correctly rejected stale head metadata; the PR body was corrected to exact3324372d, without changing the check. No scene was launched locally without full prerequisites.

Real project before-proof: original public SDK send send-380753ff2429d344349e54318ebff162, unchanged key/body and same proposal now v4, still failed on adopted staging19f with409 discussion_invocation_idempotency_conflict, request 90e573f1-5c43-4385-8eac-2b8aff7f9f3e. Original response/assignment/history remain. A passing retry against the real proposal requires verified supported adoption; it has not happened yet.

Meaningful governed research: send send-e9a18e1b0c3d6b3bfc20f723c37a48c5, invocation invocation-15da216edc1b31e94da2eac1ba95bd03, assignment assignment_jjntUo1v0ns3JECJ9qxqZcc0XRIH2rcA, canonical result-c60d45d8f5bf364f61c2cf62. Supplied actual repair diff; no checkout or test claim. Actual source grant remains19f. Product a40428034ba0506877bb28e58c1c42c6224d882e:discussion-messages/mcp-coordination/response-acabc9552759694a98ff8a41.mdx. Its pre-admission race finding directly informed the regression and fix above. This is research, not approval or an execution estimate. Adopted governed chat profile340f222a... / provider37b8a3a1... / guest e4c5d9a0... unchanged. Two valid clocks, one aggregate17-second settlement (native16.818491124active/16.85237389elapsed;93332input/46080cached/255output), separate informational row. Lease released, teardown verified16:40:06.878Z; workspace ws_7W5bg17BzIy9_OanrInef6cfU_DXh-UG independently read back closed at exact product.

PR581: exact head d50ba3320d7e345c761ded92d94a58cf3115238b is unchanged. Authorization/submission checks pass; native39284867284 has passed complete prerequisites and is executing existing component scenes. Merge/adoption remains pending until the required run completes successfully. The original real message was independently read through public library read at f9571698747b3fe7b7a7b607b89057ddadbe0b94:discussion-messages/mcp-coordination/9b3af8d31f0f8f0abb83ca3daecd0f09.mdx. It contains recipientIds=[researcher] and the exact v1 proposal context already retained in the canonical invocation. This corroborates the repair's input assumptions; no passing runtime recovery is inferred. No full objective/release acceptance credit.

A native follow-up in this same thread is active every10minutes to finish the user's conditional merge request and real-proposal proof after checks pass. It must use the existing Issue/Actions authority and pause on actual completion, without duplicate campaigns or routine comments. PR581 remains unmerged pending its required component stage; the previous passing component invocation took64minutes. Delivery-owned local PostgreSQL container is removed/absence checked; branch worktree is clean and the owned dependency symlink is removed.

Active implementation — objective workflow, 2026-10-19

First reviewable increment: MCP mutation metadata

API #581, branch codex/mcp-mutation-context429, exact head d50ba3320d7e345c761ded92d94a58cf3115238b, fetched protected base 19f98bfaf0707cb9a0a97a4d763de0073eaf2f3a. The integrator authored the patch and tests; agents supplied actual research below. This is implemented in a draft PR, not adopted or formally accepted.

REST and MCP share the existing descriptor-based Idempotency-Key / If-Match guards. MCP supports original HTTP headers and model-visible, descriptor-limited headers arguments. A single Zod schema generates advertised header constraints and validates them. Unknown auth/cookie/confirmation/provider headers, malformed metadata and conflicting HTTP/tool values reject; metadata is removed before invoking the existing domain handler. No new backend, scheduler, persistence model, deadline, handler, or golden proposal.

Regression-first history: 4c237629 reproduced missing MCP guards on unchanged staging (1 intended failure / 3 passes), e07a78d3 repaired HTTP metadata propagation; deadf1f1 reproduced absent model-visible metadata (1 intended failure / 3 passes), 7cb59017 added its strict envelope, 4f4130e6 removed duplicate handwritten schema validation; final d50ba332 strengthens native tests against the static-review claims. Production source, README and guarantees are byte-identical to 4f4130e6d7198cb2be45d22755ed3d4db410efdb.

Exact current focused proof: 27 test cases / 5 complete files passed, zero skipped, using official native MCP/Hono and a disposable PostgreSQL 17 instance with independent read-back. Build/declarations passed on byte-identical production source at 4f4130e6. node --import tsx scripts/build/build-dist.ts (including declaration checks), npm run check:file-lengths / architecture policy, and git diff --check passed. No complete-suite/component/live acceptance pass is inferred from these results.

Behavior	Owning unit / integration	Existing component registration
Missing guards; exact key/version forwarding; model-only metadata; malformed/forbidden fields; HTTP/model conflicts; concurrent distinct identities	tests/unit/control-plane/mcp/authorization-equivalence.test.ts, native protocol with controlled handler	api.golden.mcp-write-preconditions-unit
Real service mutation from arguments alone; stale/missing guards preserve SQL state; signed confirmation; exact identity persists; REST read-back and replay without creating an assignment	tests/unit/control-plane/mcp/mutation-postgres.test.ts, real PostgreSQL / owning catalog and service	api.golden.mcp-write-preconditions-postgres

Required Actions: 39284867284, exact head above, queued. Superseded queued native runs 39279399085, 39281695693 and 39282495231 were requested for cancellation before replacement candidates; no passing receipt is claimed. API #580 / native 39264908114 also remains unmerged/unadopted. No merge, release, runtime adoption or new acceptance credit.

Real proposal, products and intervention

API proposal 46a2982b-7427-4ef0-8583-c5f4843063aa, “Make real TreeSeed MCP project work recoverable”, is open v4, no Decision or execution plan. Current exact TreeDX source 8a7a7fa747e4a6859330809ca2c3669451c1eefc:proposals/governance/make-real-treeseed-mcp-project-work-recoverable.mdx, digest 4c0703cf85b5b9003dcbebb044f93d010d3573606dc5601eaa3212107506cf60; candidate Git source is d50ba332.... v1 remains afb84153c10440bd4fbf94a4aa8383fa4edd5205 / digest 190d066522aabe9443d96148aa1a0d633f174410514c1703b3b0f973a083e866; v2 4a6fc81b1bad346a018ba6876de21704637bb1f5 / digest 9bd100f185161de4beea76115ce6a2e835c1292cb6bf1815a343b366e99c9bb5.

All requests use real topic mcp-coordination, accepted profiles and exact source archives; no fake assignments or estimates:

Actual work	Canonical disposition / evidence
Initial API research: send send-e77b39edb565d5c6fe645172a141070a, invocation invocation-e48c02b2772179ad2435efc99b22546d, assignment assignment_9hJ_1jBhZcS2WjxiRAsT3LYQwjmmRcvF	Failed agent_kernel_failed: timing-awareness evidence rejected. First/final clocks valid but raw events show consecutive source commands without a clock. Original 46-second window / 15:31:43.438Z deadline retained. No result or estimate accepted. Workspace ws_F8uGwS5GbTvVdqUSNo3bEOJ9OLxKPeD_ independently read back closed, commit null. One aggregate failed settlement 37 seconds (native 36.919809893 / 36.955360684); 459438 input / 424320 cached / 1616 output tokens; lease released; teardown verified.
Refined research: send send-380753ff2429d344349e54318ebff162, invocation invocation-53f86e7e07dc1babbb2af88484ce4407, assignment assignment_aLC_b856VqXrLMIPENH22VhLc6QWLFe6	Completed canonical result-d1d4781ef692236d9100eee6; TreeDX 5c20746f10ecf8242056913fe2b4f40659083678:discussion-messages/mcp-coordination/response-bf7c4a8001821e27827855dc.mdx. Confirms real header propagation gap and proposes unchanged-send retry assertion. One aggregate settlement 21 seconds (native 20.507332779 / 20.54814727), 153029 input / 127744 cached / 578 output tokens.
Model-client contract research: send send-e3bb4e59fa6df83ef24ef7f2036b191e, invocation invocation-9b6c69b05e41a16475902812393f466d, assignment assignment_-sHb16esuVse7szw5P25ZQ6gyqR5dlPr	Completed canonical result-50322a77b095cceba21ad060; TreeDX d22ec327aad6f18adcfe5f441861ea01355ca4bc:discussion-messages/mcp-coordination/response-b8c72431b9199a68f0041c0c.mdx. Correctly finds tool arguments lack retry/version metadata; consumed in the model-visible repair. One aggregate settlement 11 seconds (native 10.787160078 / 10.828454154), 81195 input / 59008 cached / 511 output tokens.
Failed candidate-citation review	Send send-49fbf9536f9a23c9c9f5f68a829837f2, invocation invocation-33af9a8a9d3befa96c0d2e990f6452c0, assignment assignment_vDqc-ZdPIWkU929ueAOl3ARwc1LyQJPf. Actual source trace attached staging19f, despite proposal v3's candidate citation. Timing evidence also rejected; no canonical result or approval. Original deadline 16:08:05.561Z retained; failed 16:07:50.842Z. One aggregate failed settlement 36 seconds (native35.982360287); lease released, teardown16:07:50.742Z. Workspace ws_qmvUL3GNQhkdgWLenCyTvfz0B9VOwmSj independently closed, commit null.
Supplied real-diff static review	Send send-86bc8664c098d9ea7d558a9a65226e9f, invocation invocation-5d8681101848d891091c1ea9dbc2956e, assignment assignment_XQRaYrIaHL7yt2XYB8h4JjP8p1je3_vM. Completed canonical result-bf9874e3163d87b35de594cc, TreeDX 820bc39846a409c6b2abf006ea0c0a3c84494952:discussion-messages/mcp-coordination/response-28f215eb7fdfaed8ed58f563.mdx. Reviewed supplied four-file implementation diff19f→4f, SHA256 3e4bbc59858b5058aba6f8c59e53575c916aee65ab9d04bbe02a23b0cab4379c; literal at signs displayed as HTML entities to avoid accidental agent addressing, disclosed explicitly. No checkout, tests or full approval claimed. One aggregate24s settlement (native23.405440784), two valid clocks, released lease; teardown16:17:42.426Z. Workspace ws_IKaP9UOJq9f69n8Fy_JtMQ2FEPHoXa9W independently closed at exact product.

The researchers' genuine prose estimates (“1–2 engineering days” for repair/verification and “2–4 hours” for scoped analysis) remain unchanged. The first estimates repair/verification, a different scope from the 21-second research task; do not compare those directly. The second estimates its own scoped analysis at hours despite 11 seconds actual execution, a retained calibration gap. They are not structured participant execution estimates, budget grants, or approval evidence.

Governed improvement: only agents/researcher.mdx:activityProfiles.chat.prompt.system changed after the actual failure; handlers, identity, grants, context and other activities remained identical. Workspace e661e3e0-a8bd-47ed-8d72-58f271e70175, review db4269bf-ab60-44df-a8be-0cbe8f4bc42c, profile 340f222af8ace4fa916b75a0528119f503c5dfe3, publication operation b240b510-e9a4-4ac3-aa74-699c2b3fec0b succeeded; published revision 0d2e58d79f8524c75869c71db6dc52ccb7c2f0ce. Both later assignments adopted that exact profile and completed. Their workspaces were independently read back closed at the exact product commits. Two successive clean source-research completions preceded adding the Reviewer.

Independent review disposition: optional-guard and HTTP-whitespace defect claims were not supported by the shared helper or independent native tests. Final d50ba332 adds key-only optional-If-Match success, matching HTTP/model identity, HTTP whitespace normalization and real PostgreSQL matching-dual-metadata replay. Existing REST quoted/weak If-Match handling was not newly changed; no broad RFC syntax compatibility is claimed. The review's self-report that it could not post a durable reply contradicts its canonical published product; retain this quality failure and improve configuration subsequently. Do not count completed static review as approved code.

Source authority lesson: a proposal evidence citation does not change a discussion sandbox checkout. The integrator's initial assumption was wrong. Prove candidate custody through existing typed work-item/review bindings in chunk7; do not elevate an evidence reference into a grant or hot-swap running work.

Actual remaining blockers and next small repair

1. Durable replay across proposal edits is broken. Public SDK retry of the unchanged real send send-380753... initially returned the identical invocation, assignment, response and topic events with replayed:true; changed message text under the same key correctly returned discussion_idempotency_conflict. After proposal v2, the unchanged original request returned HTTP409 discussion_invocation_idempotency_conflict (request 8692495b-ea7b-4ac5-ae31-fcf7ce9a9763). Owning persistInvocation includes derived messageCommit/contextRefs in requestDigest. Reproduce in focused tests, retain original exact context on unchanged recovery while still rejecting changed declared inputs, then prove real PostgreSQL/native TreeDX and original real-send read-back. Do not weaken digests or accept moved authority. This is the next separate API #553 slice; MCP transport alone does not close chunk1.
2. Proposal update validates required changeReason too late. Actual update authored version2 in TreeDX then failed governance binding with governance_proposal_change_reason_required; governance read-back stayed open v1 with original provenance. A corrected supported update with changeReason bound that same authored source (changedPaths empty) as v2. Preserve the failure; add regression for denial before authoring and exact recovery under chunk6. No orphan content or history was deleted.
3. Full participant readiness, per-objective coordinator delegation, team creation/optimization, approval, dependency/review custody, simulated release and coordinator evaluation remain open in the plan below. No chat prose is used to fill those gaps. No release or complete objective workflow is claimed.

All four delivery-owned disposable PostgreSQL containers were removed after their focused runs and absence checked. Complete owning broker inventories showed only the current unrelated warm pool, no original task/VM, no attached NBD and no inventory errors. Persistent primary checkouts, user AGENTS/guide edits, services, development selections, credentials, old held claims and fixed golden proposals remain preserved. Provider build remains 37b8a3a1...; guest e4c5d9a0... is unchanged. Ordinary coached observations are distinct from formal acceptance; every existing acceptance requirement remains open until its exact semantic proof.

Incremental objective-to-team delivery contract — 2026-10-19 15:20:12 UTC

Human instruction: implement the agreed plan in small useful increments; use real project objectives and meaningful proposals that advance TreeSeed. Simulation performs real work whose products can be rejected. No fabricated assignments, estimates, reviews, usage, or passing outcomes.

Decisions: human delegation of approval is per objective and bounded scope/budget; create or improve YAML-defined agents using existing registered handlers; optimize verified reliability first, measured time/usage second. Coordinator approval is separate from independent product review. Existing provisional approval-before-estimates remains provisional; acting requires complete genuine estimates and one exact published Decision.

Architecture: SDK contracts generate REST/CLI/MCP interfaces; API owns participation, readiness, authorization, graph/admission and accounting; Agent owns execution and configured handlers; TreeDX owns governed content. Use existing objectives/groups/profiles/proposals/Decisions/results/events/reports and native Reviewer machinery. No alternate scheduler, status database, participation snapshot store, or copied plan authority. Exact group/profile/source revisions and canonical results are evidence; issued assignments remain immutable.

Small independently reviewable deliveries

All boxes remain open until exact-candidate evidence exists. Every row records implemented / adopted-and-usable / formally-proven separately. Split a row further at an existing owning boundary if it cannot deliver one bounded useful result; never accumulate an unreviewable cross-package waterfall.

#	Product and owning work	Dependencies and observable completion
1	Recoverable MCP dispatch: API owns idempotency/precondition validation and forwarding through shared operation descriptors; SDK changes only if a portable envelope field is necessary.	Start here. Reproduce missing mutation context first. A real addressed project task admits once; unchanged-key replay after a lost response recovers the same send/assignment; changed arguments or stale preconditions deny. No fake live recipients.
2	Follow one assignment: expose essential existing detail/history reads as tools, retain typed SDK/REST/CLI/MCP authorization, cursor pagination, diagnostics and cancellation. API498/API553; CLI274 consumes generated operations.	Build on 1. Coordinator follows actual task to exact product, independent review, measured usage, settlement and closure; disconnect resumes the original request, unavailable observations are not empty success.
3	Explain required group participation: wire existing governed group/member/profile refs into discovery and proposal participation; derive from exact content, not another status store. SDK/API owning work.	Independent implementation can overlap 1–2. Public read explains required agents, profile refs, missing capability/dependency and why each participant is required. No retired group execution graph.
4	Build one team: coordinator selects existing agents or authors governed YAML with existing handlers using normal library workspace/review/publication and registration.	Uses 3. Real objective receives exact adopted team definitions; replay is noop; missing/unknown handler, invalid dependency, denied permission or moved content rejects. Preserve unrelated teams and running assignments.
5	Complete one collaboratively discussed proposal: draft links objective/group, schedule required contributions and class-owned owner/Reviewer estimates, replace active readiness's unconditional participation success with observed evidence.	Uses 3 and existing planning/estimating. Missing participant, stale contribution, fabricated/unproven estimate, unresolved blocking question or missing required independent review blocks approval. A not-applicable rationale counts only for participation, not an executable owner's estimate. Exact predecessor consumption must be shown.
6	Delegate and approve one objective: bind explicit human delegation to named coordinator, objective, scope and budget under existing governance authority; preserve actual actor identity.	Uses 5. Ready proposal produces exactly one classed Decision. Out-of-scope/budget, revoked or stale authority denies. Revalidate before approval/admission; do not mutate issued work. API577's original Decision-publication recovery remains a separate prerequisite.
7	Prove one reviewed dependency handoff: actor returns exact candidate, independent Reviewer approves or requests bounded correction, successor consumes actual approved predecessor.	Uses exact Decision plus healthy execution/closure. Retain estimator identity/profile provenance; an unissued replacement requires explicit reconciliation and affected re-estimation. No silent role/model/session substitution claimed as continuity.
8	Produce a simulated release: advance accepted engineering work through configured dependencies, independent reviews, Releaser and one Reporter.	Uses 7; API578/579 and Agent496 gate affected activations. Local integrated release contains exact reviewed commits and real verification; original deadlines, actual usage and exactly-once settlement retained. Supported continuation carries only unfinished work and never retroactively passes an incomplete segment.
9	Evaluate and improve: coordinator independently inspects actual release against original criteria, records exact evidence, proposes one governed profile/context improvement from an observed weakness.	Uses 4/8. Later meaningful work proves adoption and measures reliability; storing feedback alone is not improvement. Reject weak products honestly; integrator corrections remain attributed.
10	Full workflow proof: compose existing native package-owned scenes for objective → team creation/selection → contributions/estimates → delegated or human approval → reviewed execution → simulated release → coordinator evaluation/closure.	Add create-team and improve-existing-team variants without altering fixed golden proposals. Complete original SDK, then API, joint, remaining projects, portfolio and controlled failures in their mandated order. No component/coaching pass substitutes for full acceptance.

Test and delivery contract

For each defect: focused genuine regression first, minimal owning repair, unit + real owning integration + existing native scene/guarantee coverage. Before EVERY scene/guarantee invocation run fresh complete unit/integration suites for EVERY participating owner on that invocation's exact candidate; zero failed/skipped/missing/empty/inconclusive prerequisites. Component passes and compilation do not prove semantic delivery. Ordinary coaching may reuse complete receipts only for unchanged runtime candidates with fresh focused/authentication/source/capacity/isolation/observation/cleanup preflight.

Test realistic boundaries: dropped response/reconnect and unchanged-key retry; duplicate/concurrent request; stale proposal/profile/group refs; missing required contributor or estimates; denied approval; genuine review rejection/correction; provider/tool failure; interruption/cancellation/expiry/continuation; publication partial failure; exactly-once accounting and durable physical teardown. Controlled failures belong in native boundary tests, not invented production proposals.

Use meaningful work already needed by the owning project: initially repair TreeSeed MCP dispatch and coordinator visibility; retain the approved pending Atlas activity-feed design as a subsequent real product objective. Discover/reuse current proposals before creating one. Preserve the reserved SDK Tester-on-BASE/Engineer chain, fixed golden requests, all acceptance identities/deferred obligations and historical failures.

Delivery: Issue → fetched protected head → scoped branch/PR → required Actions → staging merge/read-back → exact release/adoption → Platform composition → managed acceptance → main/production under existing policy. No production deployment or new worker harness is implied by a simulated release. Keep persistent services, unrelated selections, original limits and TreeDX's 4 GiB default.

Current execution and evidence

• 1 implemented/adopted for local development: API581/582/583 and SDK430 pass unit/native integration/component checks plus actual SDK/CLI/MCP original-request recovery. Published candidate read-back passed; separately versioned installation and full managed-workflow acceptance remain distinct gates.
• Existing API577/578/579 and Agent496 evidence must be read back before affected admission; old held claims remain retained, not erased or reclassified.
• Formal acceptance counts/requirements are unchanged. No full workflow pass is claimed.

For every completed row maintain its behavior→unit/integration/scene mapping; exact source/profile/proposal/Decision/task/product/review/release refs; commands; Actions run/artifact links; interventions/failed observations; measured usage/settlement and scoped physical closure. Detailed logs stay in Actions artifacts. The full historical body follows unchanged.

Owner authorities: SDK376, API498, API553, Agent368, Agent496, CLI274, Reviewer98, Platform634. SDK376 and Agent368 remain byte-preserved because their bodies are at capacity.

---

Current agent-batch closeout — 2026-10-19 14:58:07 UTC

All admitted tasks are terminal. Fresh complete public pages show zero pending, leased or running assignments. No new Atlas Tester/Engineer or replacement review was admitted after the operator requested a coordination/evaluation reframe.

Actual task	Outcome	Accounting and closure
Atlas activity architecture assignment_tRQyoAsmIsHyyFgiO7bSXvjBjKmhpfrz	Product 6c53e2a9ac84bfe26cc9e7cf3ff7edb426a265c1, independently approved design only	One 88-second settlement; closed workspace
Independent design review assignment_gyJM9qCNX4zAvzazmHk7aA1C2zBbD3z3	APPROVE product fa390f2aa368724aaf1e8eb0e3795aeb8513236a	One 26-second settlement; closed workspace; complete owning-host task/VM absence
Operational-custody review assignment_F0IxiwtR73D7npLx7lqyfl2n4p3hG90q	Failed assignment_timeout, no canonical result or approval	One 41-second settlement 12a262e3-2d50-4fd7-9235-6136ccb23c0c; released lease, closed workspace, complete owning-host task/VM absence
Reserved-closeout review assignment_YooWaVT-IJLaeVATParEq-Ixs0RBRLay	Failed agent_kernel_failed / timing-awareness rejection, no canonical result or approval	One 33-second settlement 665d3533-c144-4d98-9f24-4a4eab8f8f91; released lease, closed workspace, complete owning-host task/VM absence

The latter protected failed evidence contains apparent approval prose, but the original tool history includes successive commands without a fresh clock before each. The host denial is retained; prose is not promoted to a passing review. Agent #496 records the execution follow-up. The earlier independent projector finding remains unresolved pending a valid reassessment of the complete owning operational-state boundary.

Platform #648 delivered these lessons to docs/agent-usage.md: source 27be735979838708c4f5a602f5d8cbd16f00c4f2, checked merge a1cf0717b70edd6620c247563ba136148e54ab66, native 39273277939, ordinary staging merge 5028e68fc5f653152cbdb6d608e6a3df83eb8980. Exact tree/file read-back passed; temporary remote branch and alternate index removed; local user AGENTS.md changes preserved.

Remaining open: API #580 remains unmerged/unadopted at 1937b856d1246c159f811389ce92984191a29567; native 39264908114 is still running and valid complementary independent reviews are missing. Original three expired measured claims and the stopped planning workday remain retained. No guest adoption or live recovery is claimed. Atlas activity-feed implementation/native/Chrome delivery is held; its prepared Tester request was never admitted. The approved Admin Researcher profile remains unpublished due to canonical Book metadata validation failure. Acceptance requirements/counts are unchanged.

Current closeout — 2026-10-19 14:47:37 UTC

The operator asked to finish the currently admitted work, integrate verified products, and then reframe coordination, monitoring and evaluation. No new Atlas Tester/Engineer assignment will be admitted during this closeout. The prepared Tester request is retained as a draft; readiness reads are not an admission.

• Reproduced the reported vitals/chart failure in authenticated Chrome: a genuine completed Researcher assignment and resolvable product are visible, while ACTIVITY reports zero/no executions and METRICS reports no history. The loader currently emits empty deltas and blank feed URLs. This is a reproduced gap, not a passing chart check.
• Admin Architect produced the first concrete assignment-backed activity-feed contract: assignment assignment_tRQyoAsmIsHyyFgiO7bSXvjBjKmhpfrz, product 6c53e2a9ac84bfe26cc9e7cf3ff7edb426a265c1; 88 measured canonical seconds, one settlement and closed workspace.
• Independent UI Reviewer approved that design scope only: assignment_gyJM9qCNX4zAvzazmHk7aA1C2zBbD3z3, product fa390f2aa368724aaf1e8eb0e3795aeb8513236a; 26 measured canonical seconds, one settlement and closed workspace. The design requires real lifecycle intervals, local-day overlap, authenticated scoped reads, truthful unavailable states, and no invented execution identity or historical series.
• Activity-feed production implementation/native/browser delivery: not started. Existing UI Define portable host deployment, runtime, catalog, alias, and receipt contracts #74 inspector and Admin Allow bounded 20-minute component health gates #130 telemetry/history deliveries remain intact.
• Two existing independent API reviews are completing: sends send-cae97c2e08a7a139f3ada9a04689eb2d (issued-assignment operational custody) and send-db4eebfbb67693c5989474c146b51f16 (original measured expired closeout).
• API #580 candidate 1937b856d1246c159f811389ce92984191a29567, tested merge e504e17ea750ff71930a59e630f4ff75d153cb9f: native verification still running. No merge/adoption or recovery claim yet.

The earlier Admin Researcher correction failed semantic review; its original product/findings remain retained. The attempted governed prompt improvement was approved but publication failed canonical Book validation (legacy Book v2 metadata); the prompt is not active. No credentials, history, held usage, original deadlines or unrelated services were changed. Formal acceptance counts and requirements are unchanged.

Vitals and chart repair added to active Atlas delivery — 2026-10-19 14:12 UTC

User explicitly requested fixes for the Atlas vitals header and charts. Actual authenticated Chrome on the completed Admin Researcher workday reproduces: ACTIVITY says zero execution intervals / “No agent executions intersect the current operating day,” despite the genuine completed assignment; METRICS says “No metric history has been recorded” and changes connection from live to degraded. Retain this as unavailable feeds misrepresented as empty observations, not proof that the workday had no activity.

• Current-source reproduction: Admin930a904 sets activity/series upserts empty and their endpoint strings empty. UI f0ab910 polls those endpoint strings. The actual assignment/product/history/inspector path remains usable; agents144 and complete assignment inventory are live, while six aggregate counters remain unavailable.
• Admin Researcher assignment_EHsmx7fodH8yFPdxzArqCm4ifRi08Poq produced exact artifact8a4135b3db06aa0cf3ef4a8b305a5ffdd8f856a8, discussion-messages/ui-atlas-center-live-metrics-research-correction/response-b66958da2e1e60ea394b9950.mdx, SHA2562fcca905080195e704a7f1b87d89e021bc3ff2da2a12e132030a70b6278549b8. Canonical28-second settlement and closed workspace verified; actual Chrome follows the link.
• Its semantics require correction: conservative unknowns are useful, but recommended wiring partly repeats delivered work and the response incorrectly implies handler publication was unavailable. Independent review send-33d143f07c6a7c93b201c9d774779777 is delegated; preserve its findings before refining the governed Admin Researcher prompt and retrying.
• Admin Architect task prepared for a concrete first vitals/activity Tester→Engineer slice using existing canonical assignments and scoped public history; include unavailable-vs-empty, exact team/date/workday/time semantics, replay, permissions and complete pagination. No fabricated metrics, new status database, retired execution route or inferred usage.
• Follow with genuine owning regressions, Engineer product, independent review, native Actions and actual Chrome replay. Do not mark the charts repaired from this reproduction or a design artifact.
• API580 separately runs native39264908114 for the original closeout/planning blockers. Four exact component selections were added, but formal acceptance remains unchanged; no new golden pass or binding-completion credit.
• UI74 remains delivered. Its actual installed dependency matches518 native runtime assets. Completed API576 delivery branch removed after ancestry/read-back; completed verification inventories631/632 compressed losslessly, saving84,472,746bytes. No production data/history or unrelated services removed.

Earlier evidence retained:

Runtime adoption and Atlas checkpoint — 2026-10-19 13:53 UTC

• API #576 merged ordinarily to staging 19f98bfaf0707cb9a0a97a4d763de0073eaf2f3a after native 39247891813: 2,197 assertions/412 files, PostgreSQL and original TreeDX prerequisites, 986 component steps, zero failed/blocked/skipped. Actual service and operations-runner adopted through supported trsd dev rebuild api.service; all 727 runner runtime modules match the exact native archive.
• Authenticated Chrome remains live on the real UI correction assignment/artifact. UI Define portable host deployment, runtime, catalog, alias, and receipt contracts #74 and Admin Allow bounded 20-minute component health gates #130 are delivered; the actual artifact inspector fits and follows the exact product. No further sign-in is needed.
• One historical expired attempt assignment_auKCi2qiwSI58TgUM9E9147NjEGeFl_v now has a released lease and null canonical result; its original failed outcome remains. Final sole-settlement/workspace audit is still required.
• Three original expired attempts remain held with valid retained measured outputs and no settlement. Supported provider restart did not clear them; no further blind restart or unresolved-usage override. Read-only internal diagnostics are explicitly diagnostic, not public acceptance evidence. The API already has an unsettled path; its exact production-shape mismatch is being reproduced before repair.
• API578 held issued-custody correction857238c is integrated with API576 in local ordinary mergeada9c3e. Independent corrected review, complete native verification and actual stopped-workday closure remain open.
• Resume bounded Admin Researcher work on Atlas's remaining live metrics/topology/workday picker with fresh post-adoption preflight; use its product for owning Tester/Engineer repairs.
• Formal acceptance remains 136 mapped / 68 uncovered of 204 selected; all 260 deferred identities retained. This checkpoint adds no formal binding or golden-pass credit.

Earlier observations retained:

Delivered inspector and real Chrome result — 2026-10-19 13:22 UTC

• UI74 ordinarily merged as f0ab91091fcb52e8f8e83746fe3438fa9345d410, exact tested tree ace07d66ad0209dfb01eebdd94fb1ac589d65e2e. Native39257270767 passed233unit assertions/49files and41browser cases, zero failed/skipped. Original native2px failure remains retained.
• Independent final Reviewer 985549e743edc59bbf7619a95cfbd2b552e45f9c APPROVE for exact corrected declarations;21second canonical settlement, closed content workspace and complete task/VM absence. All six useful product/review tasks verified closed. Four failed closeout claims remain conservatively quarantined.
• Actual archive SHA256 1b4de875d3db3b0f0878f8a6c492f536e07ae7c978009e217019d6d9d98f6ae7; all518runtime assets equal the held owning build and actual Admin dependency generation4. Protected fast-forward initially left two stale CSS outputs; package restart was rejected without mutation. Supported trsd dev rebuild ui.package --session dev-5007e344-493 performed atomic adoption and declared consumer reconciliation. All persistent modes preserved; UI/Admin ready. This is explicit rebuild adoption, not a claim that the idle watcher noticed the Git change.
• Actual Admin930a9048 composition against the newly adopted UI passed260complete tests/42files, zero failed/pending. Both actual build markers retain their distinct original clocks; no readiness clock was rewritten.
• Authenticated Chrome follows corrected Engineer assignment assignment_i_tfTkQCQ8Ux-PMNWQxG3OoKhoKFc91a to exact artifact 6bdfe80c4b39f7c433f9abc5399d77dce3192ae9. Full text/commit/path readable. Measured page, outer inspector, inner body and every metadata value:0px horizontal overflow. Escape returns to the completed assignment with32seconds/released/Verified cleanup; clicking its actual Relationships product button resolves that exact artifact again while preserving workday/date. Native fixture phone coverage remains separate from this actual desktop proof.
• Chrome evidence: chrome-ui74-real-artifact.png, chrome-ui74-real-artifact-geometry.json and chrome-ui74-followed-product-link.ax.txt. A fresh tab in the same authenticated Chrome profile recovered one aborted navigation; the stale verification tab was closed. Source/archive/runtime/read-back evidence retained in adopted-inspector-runtime-byte-audit.json.
• Only this UI delivery's remote branch/index removed. Four completed owned host-inventory copies compressed losslessly with original SHA verification;168,805,991bytes saved. No runtime data, keys, workspaces or retained failed claims deleted.
• Remaining visible Atlas gaps: unavailable aggregate counters; inactive configured topology; communication workdays absent from the picker. Continue scoped owner research/tests through supported public operations. API576 native verification still gates original closeout/Decision/guest recovery; API578 corrected held source857238c awaits dependency integration, final independent corrected approval and full native/managed proof.

The actual interface repair is delivered. This is coached product evidence and gives no new formal acceptance binding or golden-pass credit;136mapped/68uncovered and all464requirements remain unchanged.

Earlier checkpoints retained:

Inspector repair and agent feedback — 2026-10-19 13:10 UTC

• Genuine Tester assignment_7GAOg2icsBDM6m_PJ1-uuN6U-PEbGPm2 published eacb978050e438f4babf675add4322dc6e177a43;28second canonical settlement, closed workspace and independent task/VM absence. Exact proposed code retained in952cb4e. Its native ambiguous-selector failure remains historical. Integrator-only p/dd locator correction b5bca950 reached intended315px/371px inner overflow RED. Independent review e641fd4192f372476d92e09eea31d4b407b388b7 APPROVE for exact test scope;23second settlement and full closure.
• Engineer product 809adb2b2c21a04783da2babe5354fa137c52b4d supplied the shrinkable inspector CSS, applied by integrator in cd2befda;29second settlement and full closure. Local unchanged browser case passed four widths, but native39255798477 retained233unit passes/40browser passes and caught2px detail-value overflow at315px. The1px allowance stayed unchanged.
• Coached Engineer correction 6bdfe80c4b39f7c433f9abc5399d77dce3192ae9 replaces ONE declaration with adaptive2:3 metadata tracks.32second canonical settlement, closed workspace and complete host absence before independent repair review. The integrator applied that exact declaration in 6b0965142dca9b2b0e8a096c4b1d6c6afc98a043, tree ace07d66ad0209dfb01eebdd94fb1ac589d65e2e. Approved test blob 86410c2c046389fa9aa908bf8fa1b0c0966932fd remains identical.
• UI74 replacement native39257270767 and independent repair review are pending. Local unchanged four-width browser case passes. All233unit tests also passed with bounded2-worker local execution after the unconstrained local run retained an unrelated5second SSR-import timeout; isolated original SSR case passes without a deadline change. Native full verification remains authoritative. No adoption until required checks pass.
• Actual Chrome followed the new Tester product and observed Engineer running/leased, event-count changes, then completed result on the same page without reload. Live-edge selection was used before evaluating the final state. These observations are distinct from the mocked native fixture and do not establish every transition producer.
• Agent review found a real held API578 defect: 1a964441c530c879c68643aed66dffe1448243d1 REQUEST_CHANGES (18second settlement/closed workspace) identified issued-node checking after a planned-ID skip. New regression538dc8d retained14pass/1RED; held repair 857238c84184fd259d795bd60d87763ce76a841b checks scoped issued IDs before participant filtering.15projector/55focused/6owning SQL and original native PostgreSQL case pass; strict build/policies pass; disposable512MiB container removed. Complete native, corrected independent approval and managed recovery remain open. Source composition retains exactly the one pending API576 governance fixture at592c48cd; no unrelated source changes.
• A complementary API planning review published an INCOMPLETE response and expired: assignment_2iaGLqJ8fiLF8GRHONqsfiaeUGIYVX2Q, original execution deadline12:52:43.458Z, null canonical result, no settlement, informational33.988576105active/34.025048426elapsed seconds. Exact committed workspace ws_KNHKg_P-_a7XpLiSdC6JRSUVPHjoCCS_/04a61ed00fae3eac0234f8b13c6d38a667287f85 and conservative hold preserved; task/VM absence independently verified. It is the fourth quarantined closeout claim, not an approval or affected retry. Original over20,000-character review-request denial was retained before a separate bounded admission; local size validation now prevents repetition.
• Platform646 native39255220110 passed and ordinarily merged as68129e828f9c2e27ce788b74df78e54bf8fd1b7c; exact guide blob/read-back and untouched user AGENTS diff verified; only delivery branch/index removed.

The existing three-task ceiling remains; do not infer three simultaneous clean completions from sequential admissions. Four failed claims stay quarantined pending API576 recovery. Formal binding/golden counts unchanged.

Earlier checkpoints retained:

Current delivered Atlas slice — 2026-10-19 12:40 UTC

• Admin130 ordinarily merged as 930a9048044c0eddd078016f660fb5ed1b079279; tree 01a94e319ad93496130571e114bd548f9d6a7fde matches the tested candidate53568325. Native39249092981:260tests/42files, zero failed/skipped/todo, strict types/build/policies pass. Archive SHA256 7eabeae9fc2667e1897478f0ab1e1a1303bb6d18dbb5cc6bc82dbf58661b2593;231JS/232declarations/139guarantee definitions and532tracked source files read back exactly.
• Independent final source-scope approvals: core c4a92d2bdc9d6f9dbc28ad2df5a737c34a17b92f, corrected header 3d00f21329a8fb2357b1d5012772aa854774aea3, corrected native-test review 5197adfbeea40a28b6182fefa9a81d78380d36d1. Exact21/12/19second settlements, closed content workspaces and complete independent task/VM absence verified. The two corrected reviews used governed profile 2d05cf0e443771781c04456926eedaa10d7dfdf8; original request-changes and incomplete reviews remain retained.
• Existing live watcher adopted the clean protected fast-forward; no restart or persistent selection changes. Adminweb generation12048 remains ready. Authenticated Chrome now shows Connection live,144configured agents, and the real Engineer assignment assignment_hw9VHWRoNWBrmcrRyV-UfAWFDoIqK4BN with its exact product 7ca5d7b2879fbd329d804d1efcced8b622144fd2. Selected-workday event dock displays16non-routine lifecycle/accounting events including creation, lease, execution, closeout and completion. Complete public read separately returned154events/2pages;16is the current filtered display count, not a claim of full producer completeness.
• Actual browser proof retained as chrome-adopted-admin130-live-history.png/.ax.txt; source/archive/runtime evidence in adopted-history-runtime-byte-audit.json. Integrator authored/corrected history tests and implementation after the expired Tester response; no fabricated agent Git commit or successful acting chain is claimed.
• Next bounded UI repair: the real artifact inspector's inner two-column grid and long metadata overflow, despite the outer page fitting. Give UI Tester a precise315/390/1280/1920px inner-body/dd regression, obtain native RED and independent test review, then have Engineer consume that exact test and review the repair before native delivery and Chrome read-back.
• Aggregate metrics, inactive configured topology and communication-workday picker coverage remain visibly unavailable/incomplete; no invented progress or counts. Old stopped workday/API578 and three expired closeout claims remain quarantined under original authority. API576 head592c48cd native39247891813 is still executing component scenes after complete verification passed; merge/adoption, automatic original-claim recovery and verified guest adoption remain pending.

Formal acceptance identities/counts unchanged:464total,204selected/260deferred,136mapped/68uncovered. This working coached slice receives no new binding or golden-pass credit.

Earlier checkpoints retained:

Current checkpoint — 2026-10-19 11:22 UTC

• UI73 delivered: ordinary merge ee32b3e6a4bc4703bc6fa1659d506eb294926a39, tested tree96e250da8ae22c1fea48f8abe6e4fdd2be6c702a. Fresh native39240082801 passed233unit/49files and40browser cases. Independent code/style products ab9b5868998660c31c8141a362aa14a71fb49014 and5409938ca7d6f07b70a41e4f9a12819477e727a5 approved their exact supplied scopes, with canonical29/9-second settlements.
• Actual Admin now resolves UI generation3, all518runtime assets equal verified archive SHA2564776b0dd6cd381106c241552f43e1d97af4ee4d5a4b8113cb54ddead3b8838e8. Admin d4c53aae actual composition passed228full tests/42files/zero skips. Admin health and Identity discovery both200 with normal TLS. Persistent selection reconciled the source fast-forward; no restart or mode change. Only this delivery's remote UI branch/index removed; ordinary test-first lineage preserved.
• All five recent Tester/Engineer/Reviewer/Architect products have exact task/VM absence and closed content workspaces verified against complete guide618 host inventory. Canonical settlements retained. API Architect's first product e951eced... is semantically failed because it falsely claimed no reply was published; its actual published artifact is retained.
• Governed API Architect chat-only refinement ac6388d2b5e30ef159dd466dbc297718960bb53c adopted. Corrected product1824bd615c1345a9066b986ccac4190e6c1458ee used that exact profile:164words,16-second canonical settlement, two pre-read clocks/one bounded source command/finalclock, closed content workspace. It accurately leaves actual recovery unproved. Its physical closure remains a separate fresh check.
• API578 held source candidate03181367d10126638ffb495b2847776950a0156c preserves regression-first lineage692c90b → b1f935e →53ff8f8 →d43b90d. Future-round/pre-retained-custody55focused assertions pass; new owning SQL Reporter integration6pass. Replaying that integration on the original projector retained5pass/1intendedRED.
• Strengthened original native PostgreSQL workday file passed on pinned17.11, independent connections, original deadlines, exact lifecycle observations and unchanged financial inventory. A controlled cancelled never-admitted node unblocks the original Reporter guard without inventing an attempt, result, usage or ended workday. The bounded512MiB/256MiBtmpfs container was removed. This is native component proof with controlled source/profile inputs, not managed/public graph recovery or native TreeDX custody.
• API578 is local/unpublished pending API576 protected dependency integration, independent review and full native verification. No stopped-run state has been changed.
• API576 native39239852510 completed its entire verify:direct step successfully and is executing remaining coded components. Final archive/check completion, merge/adoption, original held-claim acknowledgement and canonical Decision recovery are still gates. Independent project Reviewer task prepared under fresh guide620 preflight.
• Current Chrome still exposes sign-in in the connected profile. Fresh integrated check awaits that session. Header counts, selected-workday activity/history and inspector readability beyond this card fix remain open.
• Formal acceptance requirements/counts are unchanged; no new binding or managed golden pass claimed.

Prior checkpoints and failures retained below.

Current checkpoint — 2026-10-19 10:54 UTC

• Genuine Tester regression independently approved by assignment assignment_CTzAqBTBBXTps7gL0uOdwITX7I7WBNLQ, artifact 929ae0fc8fc63fe238e2c0c6708085dc0795af41;15-second canonical settlement, closed workspace and exact task/VM absence. Governed Reviewer revision8ad63478f7bb26d3b0fbcd2ba65219dce9021568 verified in execution; two clock reads, no source commands. Prior rejected raw approval retained.
• Engineer assignment_hw9VHWRoNWBrmcrRyV-UfAWFDoIqK4BN consumed the approved exact test and produced 7ca5d7b2879fbd329d804d1efcced8b622144fd2. Exact product read-back,21-second settlement and closed content workspace verified. Integrator applied the proposed function unchanged. Test blob04cf1600c4359cd2711809a33fd26a462bd9938d is identical in its descendant.
• Additional workspace/canvas cases first reproduced3failures for NaN/infinities. Combined10focused assertions now pass; strict types and both structural policies pass. Final UI73 head c52e9027e44a2a6d94b34fac09be00ef3a2f4595, tree96e250da8ae22c1fea48f8abe6e4fdd2be6c702a.
• Fresh UI native 39240082801, independent implementation/style review, checked merge/archive/adoption and current Chrome validation.
• One frozen zero-active preflight covers exactly three read-only background tasks: UI non-finite repair review, UI stylesheet/fixture review, and API Architect consuming Researcher3bb4eeb... to assess canonical cancellation of never-admitted orphan round identities. The whole planned batch counts against the3-task ceiling. Existing API admissions and owning limits remain authoritative. These tasks do not assert an accepted managed Actor chain.
• API576 native 39235593230 inspected completely:2196pass/1fail, no additional failed case. The sole failure was an existing UNIT close-error fixture missing created_by_type. New commit 363cad172a74aa3313f35cf171f9a57e2400b146 supplies its actual user owner, preserving every original close-error/journal assertion;14focused authority/governance cases pass.
• API576 fresh native 39239852510, exact treeb34abed19eb526274aa817f2d792f5f6e5f8866c, is running. Live API remains575. Experimental API578 changes are excluded from this delivery.
• API578 future-round regression retained38pass/2intendedRED in test-only692c90b8369c42e7521ff76db2c5d400d1a9a8fb. Minimal prevention now passes40lifecycle assertions locally; source/fixture changes held locally, native integration and existing-run recovery unresolved. No Reporter bypass, fabricated turn or original deadline change.
• Platform 644 passed native 39240004416, merged b5d4806dfa12356a60128db5083a176c0c4e58de, exact guide blob0a795f3fd781ec0470350b14273b9ce6d9b75c93 read back. User AGENTS diff preserved. Only this delivery's remote branch/index cleaned.
• Connected Chrome still needs the authenticated profile; sign-in assistance remains pending. No fresh authenticated browser result claimed.

All prior checkpoints retained below. Formal acceptance counts and requirements unchanged.

Current checkpoint — 2026-10-19 10:36 UTC

• Researcher correction independently approved: product f34832b55cfa85c6af5ffbed2087f24a5b6e3ec5 by assignment assignment_0zfDDFJ08TaGimUkkx33gzxlxP8_20XL; separate Reviewer assignment_C8E8bN-Irj1Nt64LtBEzmGS-Rr1BgSvK published approval 299cb0f75cb975963dd57dc0d8348cf12cd72517. Exact governed Researcher revision b35131ea4fc7902774cf9944b49dc01a5c88dd9e verified. Canonical settlements17/12 seconds, closed workspaces and exact task/VM absence independently checked. Ordinary coached research proof only.
• Real UI Reviewer found non-finite Atlas metric bug: product dfae8acdb24228ce2032527cab28667b1b6d2a6d, REQUEST_CHANGES. Genuine Tester assignment_7NM35FVk2xAxvGU31kXLIvpWEKUKMR8S proposed exact regression in product 6291f453d56a1e14187d4949c4189569cd1f7cb8.
• Integrator applied that test unchanged and retained3passing/1intendedRED/0pending. Test-only commit 61f5ebb366bc9099e6208c7f4b75eacf507c1f71, blob 04cf1600c4359cd2711809a33fd26a462bd9938d, parent UI73candidate9bfb4f4. No production repair yet.
• Independent test review and Engineer repair. Review attempt assignment_fdh9xaxjVYomlF99NuY5Rpk8lBNRZH6M failed timing guard after consecutive source commands without intervening clock; raw approval is NOT credited. Failed observation retained. Governed Reviewer chat-only refinement8ad63478f7bb26d3b0fbcd2ba65219dce9021568 submitted through normal review/publication, adoption and next behavior still to verify.
• API576 replacement candidate 966961681ea22ec87a29a5d43939dff133543e5c, tree f379d3e29ec9bb1fba8b40986e037fcdf06a3b42: local focused8/8 and both structural policies passed; native 39235593230 still running complete verification. Earlier native governance voter/manager/Decision recovery paths passed; previous candidate then failed the file-length policy. No rule weakened and no unchecked adoption.
• Reporter closeout: API578. Public audit09:24:21.726Z reports reporter_workday_authority_required (“ended planning rounds” required). Workday4f2f94a1 round2 contains planned estimator IDs with no nodes/attempts after all four genuine estimates completed. Original10:04:19.882Z deadline retained. No fabricated report or terminal state.
• API Researcher assignment_FgJS4iTihALCJqqp0wi7klvDrjtwdqhj independently identified initial-estimator fallback as future orphan-round cause and explicitly declined to invent persisted-round recovery. Product 3bb4eeb621628b1524be81f05734fa9ceec85c99, exact artifact read-back,21-second canonical settlement and closed TreeDX workspace verified; host absence checked separately.
• Platform guide PR643 merged with native 39231427102. Local guide now records the completed Researcher feedback loop, pending next docs delivery.
• Delivery-owned old host observation copies601–608 losslessly compressed; original SHA verified,335,978,562bytes recovered. No services, retained leases, keys, source or worktrees deleted.
• Current authenticated Chrome check: connected extension exposes TreeSeed sign-in; user reports another logged-in view. Requested connected-profile sign-in; no current authenticated browser proof claimed.
• Formal acceptance unchanged:464total /204selected /260deferred;136mapped /68uncovered. No new formal SDK passing invocation.

Earlier checkpoint and original failures retained below.

Current checkpoint — 2026-10-19 09:45 UTC

• Four genuine UI estimating products and138active seconds reconciled; all four released, TreeDX workspaces closed, exact host tasks absent. Original frozen objectives/work items stayed unchanged at ready proposalv6.
• Ordinary support vote recorded; proposalv6 is accepted with no Decision link because canonical publication failed. API #577 owns this reproduced blocker. Preserve the same proposal, vote and creating Decision; recover through normal evaluate after verified repair. No acting assignments are inserted or falsely claimed.
• Test-first canonical Decision regression retained:4passed/1intendedRED, then8passed/0failed/0skipped including existing proposal custody. Actual direct manager authority is preserved; automatic administrative chamber votes retain real voter refs/positions/timestamps. Existing native governance case now proves both forms with publication/SQL interruption and independent pool recovery.
• Combined API #576 head05d8ba3fb2787b79e7a546c54c41d2cf571d4c47, tree569d3a92d63595d5e07605e6147252c19a3d4b31, native 39231051690 in progress. Early parameterized credential suite passed; closeout/native governance and complete verification remain required. Previous replacement39229783046 was cancelled to batch this newly reproduced defect. No runtime adoption yet.
• Independent UI73 review attempt assignment_BVNJ2yvL7go_IdB6mmPEjaNBmB5anvpM was correctly rejected: two Git commands had no fresh clock between them. Its raw APPROVE is not approval. Canonical failed/null result, one21-active-second measured settlement, closed workspace and exact task/VM absence are verified. Before admission, an oversized request failed the existing20,000-character boundary without creating an assignment; compact source extraction retained all changes and escaped accidental mentions.
• Researcher correction assignment_suP0iVfbui6vOzWbeJ4WH0Mdo6Am3ARm completed/released: artifactce18e9343be93cb5c20f3756aa751d788fcec524, path discussion-messages/ui-atlas-center-bounded-research-correction/response-1a480719402762707e0bd947.mdx, SHA25665b2745e20076efe59dc609b40d400544970387b8b8fdb6605d2ea9c4f5876fa; one19-active-second settlement and closed workspace. Its actual text includes corrected criteria but misleading publication/lookup caveats; independent review is required, not assumed.
• Governed Researcher prompt-only improvement submitted/reviewed/published through existing library flow: reviewb8e6244a-17e4-4bf0-94c0-010795bde4bf, revisionb35131ea4fc7902774cf9944b49dc01a5c88dd9e. Exact submitted YAML matches catalog; no grant/handler/model/dependency/deadline change. Later assignment adoption/effectiveness remains unproved.
• Usage guide Platform #643 passed native39231427102, mergedcb83bd7a56aad0d05395521c7fab8e42a83a1f39; local guide blob357601f258e76aac2f707abcc4173ec2ef0e0150 matches staging. User's dirty AGENTS.md changes preserved; only this delivery's remote branch/index removed.
• Stopped estimating workday remains closing with one ready Reporter node and no newly assigned Reporter; do not claim workday ended. Investigate normal admission rather than fabricating closeout.
• Current Chrome authentication proof remains pending. Development status reports Identity/Admin/API/Agent/TreeDX ready; preserve services. UI73/Admin130 remain held, no formal acceptance counts changed.

Live checkpoint — 2026-10-19 09:27 UTC

• The configured UI Architect, Tester, Engineer and Reviewer each completed a genuine estimating assignment under planning-only workday workday-4f2f94a1-13ca-47c9-9a6c-0fbaee02121e. All four are completed/released, have one settlement each (37/41/43/17 active seconds; total138), exact proposal artifacts and closed TreeDX workspaces. A complete owning-host inventory shows their exact task resources absent; separate VM identity inspection remains distinct.
• Proposal fb21c041-0dab-4b64-830c-45f6224458d7 advanced v2→v6 through those agents, content a0451d4b54041e95bd0e006d4ca7640533f1a5da, SHA256 21fcba6a7f31873b16e3dc315344cae370d1995cd316207fee4fc78b6c054592. Independent read-back confirms every static proposal field/work item stayed unchanged; only genuine estimates and ready status changed. Voting/execution readiness is true. This is estimation evidence, not an accepted or delivered Actor/Reviewer chain.
• Supported scoped stop requested for the estimating workday after all four products; terminalization found zero unfinished assignments and zero settlement errors. Its immediate read-back is closing/running pending normal Reporter closeout, not falsely complete.
• Accept current ready authority through ordinary governance, then run the configured reviewed Architect→Tester→Engineer chain on frozen UI 1ebf34a3f8dd64cc2be4b878959c183b14e8bc0e. Original one-hour estimating deadline is retained; a separate acting run must fit the existing workday profile and genuine bounds.
• API #576: native 39224467577 passed the focused37 assertions including PostgreSQL closeout; complete suite2179passed/1failed because thirteen native credential fixtures were aggregated inside one30-second test. Replacement head 496c662998b56a28e3a87f9d02663f7dc1122a7f parameterizes every original denial independently without removing assertions or changing any timeout/deadline, and runs that entire file early. Native39229783046 is running. Duplicate dispatch39229847753 was cancelled. LiveAPI remains verified575.
• Installed workdays watch actually returned standards_migration_not_enabled; observations use supported paginated events, assignment/status reads and complete owning inventories. No persistent CLI watcher is claimed. Timestamp display order differs from canonical event indices; run-level null workdayId events retain exact runId and must be validated against that contract.
• Chrome extension tab still shows sign-in while the user reports being logged in elsewhere/temporary backend outage; service/session diagnosis and current authenticated browser proof remain pending. CLI work continues.

Current authority and operating guide

Continuation of #428 because its retained body is near GitHub's limit. Preserve all original failures and delivery history there. The operating guide is https://github.com/treeseed-ai/platform/blob/staging/docs/agent-usage.md; the user authorized starting the team process, up to three active tasks within actual supply, and measured prompt/context/definition improvement before every run. Formal acceptance identities and the reserved SDK chain remain unchanged.

Objective and current checklist

• UI Add communication send and provider response contracts #72 is delivered/adopted at1ebf34a3f8dd64cc2be4b878959c183b14e8bc0e; native226unit/39browser,518runtime assets and real Chrome live updates/result read-back were checked. Preserve the user's current shell; the supplied mockup directs the center only.
• Finish readable inspector/card layout, selected-workday live history, genuine independent reviews, integrated Chrome verification and truthful cleanup. UI Add communication lane contracts #73 and Admin Allow bounded 20-minute component health gates #130 remain held without passing independent review/adoption. Source scope and unavailable-data behavior remain explicit.
• API #575 merged f97156777e21c89ba44d223dbd012ff30da08c10/tree e484aa25af3471720130b34bee0bf21e46016006 after native39208336761, authorization and validation passed. Native archive da0265aa7170da4a2a6127857539b0fde7f3d0f8f2d9e48043e00dc5fdf3e329 matches727compiled modules and1466tracked source files. Adopted public service and operations runner bytes match.
• Agent feat: bind service-scoped sandbox control to exact grants and replies (#488) #498 merged2a3c08fe931254f1509c98abcc00f0dccc2652f0/tree08f9188781cc61abd763e20f9ec2274515ebe301 after native39214220967 (1141assertions/182files,886component/planningsteps,sixactualinstalledarchives/22assets). Both adopted provider containers match56compiled modules; current provider build sha256:37b8a3a1adbf8c0994ee1172d2a7f3057984d5d205a3baf20471e137a0825b22.
• Guest replacement remains blocked by two retained expired recovery claims. The verified existing guest remains sha256:e4c5d9a053147dca78c2348650ae3800946a4fcac9f24b23c618ac907b32b1e8, sourcef3f1033c2220a5981e38a5256ae5b1b307913a67. Do not call the new short-window guest repair adopted. Original attempts remain expired/null-result; no deletion, manual release or invented approval.
• Actual failure diagnosed after adoption: original canonical result assembly is220ms/71ms after teardown. API575 incorrectly required the opposite order. API #576 retains test-first f2bc0cc392c31e0eda1dacf715461e4f45a31cbe and repair2352fadba99eacae12342c39acfc92e84206d3f0. Unchanged source14passes/2intendedfailures; repaired16passes/zero skipped, strict build/file policies. Existing independent PostgreSQL and selected component cases strengthened. Native39224467577 is pending; live API remains the checked575candidate.

Coached team work: observed results

The current UI proposal fb21c041-0dab-4b64-830c-45f6224458d7 is open v2, TreeDX5eef0cb16df28aa7740423a39b34deec39970173, all Git work-item refs1ebf34a.... No accepted Decision or full Actor/Reviewer-chain completion is claimed. Current YAML acting order is Architect→Tester→Engineer→technical Writer→Releaser with applicable reviews; Researcher independent.

• Improve from prior Researcher clock failure: reduce the157-word task to one38-line source file, one bounded read, explicit clock→command→clock→answer and <=100-word result. Avoid minified CSS and extra searches; preserve deadline/permissions. This is a task/context improvement, not yet a published standing profile update.
• Actual send send-35b750428459bcd4106be5bb822dab13, Researcher assignment_qJQJszIyKFoyRo1dLDedkq3wDy3AjAxl completed on source1ebf34a.... Exact product76bd7e726652ed8eae68e710f374250ed324be94 / discussion-messages/atlas-ui-team-objective-planning/response-b1db720a390f938e8c2403eb.mdx, SHA25600da054bcf4d054d441d9efea55104551b904bbb6ba4a59b86e86c16ca92ff99. Product99words identifies render order and two concrete browser regression criteria. Valid first/final clock evidence, one18-second native settlement, closed content workspace, exact task and acquired VM absent in complete owning inventory. Source citation precision and semantic approval remain for independent review.
• Original independent Reviewer send-e67f18d4d395a1e2afdf11587b39742d / assignment_cQAkDRjF5o_wqI7EE4mikw68oPuSUjfk failed assignment_timeout/subprocess cleanup. Trace shows one source read then five clock polls without final findings; original49-second guest deadline retained. One47-active-second settlement (native46.619912337elapsed), closed workspace and exact task/VM absence in complete owning inventory were verified. No approval.
• Normal governed profile repair: workspace6532f94f-1024-4874-9b3a-a68bde868499, approved review60fc0b86-a382-4d51-a7a3-4100793314cd, successful publication operation3a6bd869-331f-4c2d-a1dd-5a383c1a40de, exact UI definitiond3c130f9b8999a095962d15de630799ddedb4073/upstream58ca9d26642952bd57fcd10f6023af7de242fb6c. Only Reviewer chat.prompt.system changed; parsed catalog read-back proves handler, grants, dependencies, model and original deadlines unchanged. Stop idle clock polling and return findings after the required final check.
• Subsequent send-14d70d23c607daa2c2cfe61dea629c74 / Reviewer assignment_xj0lGAyT7x3h_L0THAOvDxMKs4sJQT6w actually froze that exact new profile/prompt and completed with one numbered source read and two clock checks instead of seven. Exact productd0c0f57763cbeae3f45f136c88c071735c3490d1 / response-d8f50a4f86c4bfc9202c2955.mdx, SHA256f9a37a4c692d4f85d53c7abbb684262dc3e9d35142c34caa58690530b9e83e85. Genuine REQUEST_CHANGES: preservation assertions must explicitly cover units, labels/values and navigation targets; source citations corrected to31–36. One15-active-second settlement vs16canonical elapsed seconds, matching native14.971083665active/15.013651679elapsed separately; closed content workspace. Final owning-host absence check is pending. This is one observed profile/behavior improvement, not general reliability or approval of the Researcher product.
• Operator audit corrected its own erroneous equality between billed active seconds and elapsed seconds. Owning API authority stores actualSeconds=active_seconds; the helper now independently matches both native measurements and their respective rounding, preserving the original failed audit. No product accounting or result bytes changed.
• Have Architect consume actual reviewed Researcher/Writer products; obtain genuine proposal estimates and accepted authority, then let the configured test/implementation/review chain advance. Communication bootstrap is distinct from that graph.
• Review/publish reusable bounded-inspection/clock/context improvements through existing governed YAML/Knowledge, reconcile subsequent assignments and verify actual retrieval plus behavior. Saved feedback alone is not proof of learning.

Fresh focused preflight: UI16,Admin18,Agent52,API8 assertions pass; complete public pending/leased/running pages and owning inventory are retained per activation. Exact unchanged complete-suite receipts are reused only for ordinary coaching. No formal acceptance scene launched and no binding counts changed.

Next gates

Finish the current independent review, retain measured feedback, improve the responsible definition/context, and delegate focused Atlas regression/repair work. Complete API576 native/archive/staging/adoption, acknowledge only original failed custody, then adopt/verify the new guest. Keep healthy unrelated work/services operating, preserve every selection and TreeDX4GiB/env-configurable cache budget, and clean only delivery-owned disposable resources. Platform #642 / native39226015598 delivered the per-run refinement rule and observed lessons at9c2e4ab54e439a1abb8d158c4e58e0f28f3d925b; exact staging/local guide read-back and temporary branch cleanup verified. Update this Issue and docs/agent-usage.md when the process changes. A scoped browser session check is pending; do not claim current integrated Chrome proof from CLI/component results.

2026-10-19 — current selected-history repair and coaching checkpoint

• Existing UI73 card repair is merged/adopted at ee32b3e6a4bc4703bc6fa1659d506eb294926a39; native233 assertions/40 browser cases and Admin composition228 assertions pass. This does not establish selected-history or complete mockup fidelity.
• Independent Admin history review assignment__Lc38Xv4IAMZ2DA1xj6KrpfrSKN4os70 published3493aecda3c30b0c44968121f6eac49e721203d7 with REQUEST_CHANGES: canonical runId permits nullworkdayId, sort contiguous indices after complete cursor pagination, preserve timestamps/title fallback, include history in revision for SSE, retain visibly unavailable incomplete histories. Researcher891172d31db1ba1c47c0a805d96ad3d93b139bf5 remains research evidence, not implemented code.
• Tester assignment_yco7mJj9In6sKW1OwMUk13MyTZBR6bCe product3aba3420d7e9765e90ae79c6c953833ec0f40184 is semantically REJECTED: no requested tests and false publication-unavailable claim. Its actual40second settlement, closed content workspace and complete owning-host absence of task/VM are retained.
• Governed Admin Tester chat prompt64c2731d411dbc6e7d824a996c708b4f19fc5490 was reviewed/published through existing workspace/review operationbddb86f9-560e-4a22-816f-11b354e10a26; actual catalog confirms adoption. Onlychat.prompt.system changed. Require substantive executable proposed tests and accurately describe handler publication; no grants/deadline/model changes.
• Correction send-9294d21c490cb782894385235adbbde6 / assignment_eI-AdymH93dLBGZ7EDfHkPExLUuevdOE is admitted after fresh guide623 focused checks and owning preflight. Check actual profile/context, product, intended RED, independent test review, Engineer consumption, real public integration and existing scene coverage before delivering history. No test product is assumed.
• Admin130 header candidate c1ae6f8f5719fc7f9337b5b2a53666c9f08a7c01 remains held; preserve its existing native evidence and old Btu failure quarantine. Batch compatible history work only with exact source/independent review evidence.
• API576 native39239852510 passed2197 complete-suite assertions then failed closed on a stale aggregate credential test selection (zero assertions). Current592c48cd32e8d1caae0c9837f3cb973adba9f8cf explicitly maps all13 unchanged native denial cases; fresh native39247891813 is running. No merge/adoption is claimed.
• Current Admin health and Identity realm discovery return200 with normal CA validation. Connected Chrome remains on sign-in, so fresh authenticated browser proof is outstanding; user reports an already-authenticated view and temporary backend outage. Preserve that distinction.

No new formal binding credit, managed golden pass, synthetic result or team-chain completion is claimed. SDK429 is the active continuation linked from SDK428.

2026-10-19 12:19 UTC — live-history candidate verified, review corrections pending

• Admin130 current source5356832533774283d2a8677bfc4d12d216ec0ec7, tested merge0ae7307042542bebfd3d3d76d1edc87789221eb6, tree01a94e319ad93496130571e114bd548f9d6a7fde. Native 39249092981 passed260 assertions/42files/0failed/skipped/todo, build, strict tsc and owning policies.
• Actual native archive SHA7eabeae9fc2667e1897478f0ab1e1a1303bb6d18dbb5cc6bc82dbf58661b2593:231JSmodules,232declarations and139definitions match held source. No adoption yet.
• Held Admin history reader consumed154 actual public events/twopages for completed UI Engineer run conversation-invocation-865295351be3382a2892ee5941c55977. All canonical indices contiguous after sorting; original times retained. This is actual service read-back through an operator verification adapter, not Chrome proof or producer completeness.
• Old stopped workday4f2f94a1 history exceeds the unchanged100page budget and remains unavailable. Retained failed observation belongs with API578 lifecycle/history investigation; no allowance increase or partial-success claim.
• Tester correction assignment_eI-AdymH93dLBGZ7EDfHkPExLUuevdOE expired/null with original informational42.817446879active/42.851826504elapsed seconds and no settlement. Its committed TreeDX workspace ws_FAuvOH9dXLjxSpKobRest71tLmNsOOTE / fbd016b60b7ce0c6615c1fb96ed90275945ac33e remains retained; complete owning host inventory proves task/VM absence, not content/accounting closure. No retry or approved Tester product is claimed.
• Independent history-core review assignment_rULJ-SXL9ydmtS2pasNpLBcgALAR83up publishedc4a92d2bdc9d6f9dbc28ad2df5a737c34a17b92f APPROVE supplied exact source.21second settlement, content workspace closed. Complete host absence remains next fresh inventory gate.
• Header review assignment_WEq93l2npq8kDkaAcfdxDYgOm2Ag2a3e /95ca380723dc73d782508835375387b8f30ec222 REQUEST_CHANGES: supply unchanged authorization/cache helpers omitted from its context.19second settlement/content workspace closed; no approval yet.
• Test review assignment_N2BnsUinGkuBw94guFZdf6wyYu0QV1PK /c515f4b6179c4fef83d6d415bc04e21bc3049b76 incomplete: falsely claimed publication unavailable and demanded implementation outside its bounded test-review context. Actual30second settlement/closed workspace retained. Governed Reviewer refinement and context correction are being prepared; no verdict is invented.
• The three independent UI reviews fit fresh guide624 capacity with5availableworkers,0activeassignments and3retained expired claims. All old reservations/usage/workspaces preserved. Actual execution intervals show at most two reviews overlapping; three-task operating authorization is not a fabricated three-way completion proof.
• Operating-guide Platform645 mergedff0c53142406ccd868f3860c52a2972123a9f673 after native39250483623; doc blob7365d08c33828e7756acf6f6d8dca2976b501ea4 read back. User AGENTS.md diff unchanged. Delivery branch/index removed.
• Six additional delivery-owned host observation copies compressed losslessly with originalSHA verification;252,793,120bytes saved. No runtime data, keys, retained leases, source or worktrees deleted.
• API576 current592c48cd32e8d1caae0c9837f3cb973adba9f8cf native39247891813 has reached component scenes. All selected case names were checked against actual discovery, including the environment-conditional native workload case. Collection is wiring evidence only. Merge/adoption and original closeout/Decision/guest recovery remain pending.
• Chrome authentication remains pending in the extension-connected profile, despite current Admin/Identity health200. Keep browser proof separate from native/CLI evidence.

Formal binding counts and golden status are unchanged. Header/history delivery remains held for actual review, exact merge/adoption and browser verification.

Foreground completion checkpoint — 2026-10-19 (completed23:07UTC)

Current outcome: merged/adopted; real SDK/CLI/MCP recovery passed. The chronology below preserves earlier failed and superseded in-progress observations; final closure is at the end.

The user explicitly requested checking, fixing, merging and adopting API581/582, then proving recovery on the real proposal. The same-thread heartbeat is paused to prevent concurrent delivery writers; foreground work continues. API581 exact d50ba332 remains in native39284867284: complete prerequisites passed, component scenes in progress, no failed step. API582 authorization39290286292/submission39290286083 passed; cancelled native39290093830 is not a failed assertion or a passing receipt.

Prepared local composition5b8fb784ebfa7f6f1b7733e0d8ba4b7e593aecaa, tree4aab962654ec4fbf80abf2818d30183251da7bdc: clean merge of581 into582, not pushed/adopted. Source/declaration build, structural policy and diff checks passed. Broad focused run passed102 tests/22files and failed the one signed-native case's explicit missing TreeDX URL/token prerequisite; the exclude flag did not exclude it. This run is not fully green and gives no native or scene credit. Final582 campaign requires the actual581 protected staging merge ancestor, exact PR metadata, all complete owner prerequisites and registered scenes.

Actual official MCP client authenticated through the existing CLI session, discovered139tools and read original completed send380753ff... through the discovered communications.sendStatus resource. On current adopted19f, communications.send advertises no model header fields. This is authenticated read/discovery evidence, not mutation recovery. SDK and native MCP original-send/changed-input proof scripts await supported verified adoption; no new fake assignment or proposal is created.

Meaningful governed native-test review failed: send-d76ae3de549188d81af12d6256152ffc, invocation-fd0b7e764851868bdd255c59f890db0b, assignment_7o91cD6ZETQKXgyoTzOAHtBXiIyvOFKc. Supplied actual test source on unchanged accepted profile340f222a/provider37b8a3a1/guest e4c5d9a0; no checkout or test claim. Original window17:07:29.444Z–17:08:03.444Z (34seconds); closeout began17:07:57.444Z, failure assignment_timeout17:08:04.708Z. Ten valid clock observations, canonical result null, no publication/approval. Exactly one aggregate32-second settlement plus one informational0-second row; native usage/token measurements unavailable, not fabricated. Lease released, teardown verified17:08:04.557Z; workspace ws_vaiDNzmmrp7Dsats6B4eZvOAfbadgVV9 independently closed with null commit. Fresh complete owning broker inventory is healthy, warm-only, no task/container/NBD residue. No retry of this failed capability; Agent496 retains the timing defect while healthy PR verification continues. Three older held assignments and all original evidence remain unchanged.

17:38UTC actual delivery: PR581 required native 39284867284 passed:2199/2199 API prerequisite assertions,200/200 verifier-owner assertions,988/988 component steps;0failed/skipped/todo/blocked, both MCP metadata cases passed. Tested merge34a5f85f9dfcfe3c4530886d0a64b58495f588c4/tree b8b9cec81cef14bf0b818fe6bb859f06598a08fc; source archive SHA256625a0488d4cdc99e1ae8bc2cbbdd243e496ae20afd84c069a09a07f437fe1f03. Guarded d50 merge succeeded at protected staging cd7ef960ecd5424bd874e1f788f58ca48da7eea7, independently fetched/read-back with identical tree; main9356 unchanged. No failed research was counted as approval; automated prelaunch gate passed.

PR582 actual final head 7bed374c3d3af74909d17637e10f0447587ce055 includes exact cd7 staging ancestor, combined tree4aab962654ec4fbf80abf2818d30183251da7bdc unchanged from local preparation. Fresh complete native39295746387 is running; authorization39295768226/submission39295768240 pass. Intermediate581 staging duplicate verify39295689673/candidate-source39295689555 were requested for cancellation to batch delivery at the final582 composition; no replacement receipt fabricated. Runtime remains19f until checked final adoption. Original real proposal CLI read-back still open v4/hash4c0703cf..., nullDecision. SDK/installedCLI/nativeMCP replay probes await adoption, retaining original v1 authority. Local PostgreSQL container removed/absence verified; only owned dependency symlink remains for branch checks.

PR581 adopted17:41UTC: fresh complete pending/leased/running assignment lists each0/no nextCursor; primary clean API fast-forwarded to cd7ef960 after protected heads fetched. Supported trsd dev rebuild api.operations-runner --session dev-5007e344-493 --json completed ok, no blockers/manual actions; unrelated targets preserved. Exact fetched tested merge34a5 and protectedcd7 trees both b8b9cec81cef14bf0b818fe6bb859f06598a08fc. All727 mounted API source files match cd7 Git bytes; all727 compiled runtime modules in both actual API service and operations-runner match native archive625a0488...; all1454 host JS/declaration files match, SDK447/447 and TreeDXclient127/127 match sealed dependencies. Normal-CA readiness200/database+OpenBao true. Official MCP client authenticated read of original completed send passed again,139tools, communications.send now advertises Idempotency-Key. Proposal-edit recovery is deliberately still pending582, not inferred from metadata adoption. Current582 native39295746387 remains in native prerequisites without failed steps.

18:18UTC actual582 failure/correction: native39295746387 on7bed/tested merge015026b8d293fdfbedf24411b5885044e1114394 failed the complete API suite:2203passed/4failed,413passed/2failed files. No component scene ran. Actual signed TreeDX first-send lookup returned404 not_found / File not found.; the new exact recovery lookup incorrectly required an original message to exist. Three older unit catalog fixtures lacked the newly required content-read dependency. Preserve this full failed observation; initial gh cached partial logs were incomplete, raw run ZIP and check annotations independently supply final failures/counts.

Focused regression fd5fdb53:9passed/1intended missing-file failure. Owning reader repair c24aae89ae625385a4b038453d55606ef76e40f2, tree 6acf5a95e633b2aa213ec5bfd70484d4849435f8, allows only one exact branch-message lookup's native404/not_found/File not found. response to mean absence. Known-path and multi-message reads, missing repository/ref, denied authorization, unavailable service and missing immutable journal source still propagate. No blanket catch, new policy field, runner or storage. Catalog unit fixtures explicitly provide their controlled empty-history boundary without removing assertions. Unit/scene map: discussions/discussion-targeted-read.test.ts → api.golden.communication-proposal-absence-unit. Native real first-send/proposal-edit/interruption case remains api.golden.communication-proposal-recovery-native.

Current local24assertions/3files and61assertions/13files passed, zero skipped; latter uses actual disposable PostgreSQL17.11 and original native MCP/Hono boundaries. Source/declaration build and owning structural/diff checks passed. Disposable database removed/absence verified. Signed native case remains unproved locally. Fresh native39301342001 on exactc24 is running; submission39301339555/39301339638 and authorization39301339557 pass. Existing workflow now runs the exact retry/native/catalog/absence regressions early before full verification; full fresh prerequisites and component scenes remain required, all timeouts unchanged. Runtime remains verified/adopted581 cd7ef960; no582 adoption or successful real-proposal retry yet. Foreground completion continues; heartbeat remains paused.

18:33UTC native integration pass: On unchanged c24aae89,39301342001's early Verify proposal retry recovery before complete verification step passed. This command includes the actual signed TreeDX/PostgreSQL first-send→proposal-edit→concurrent replay→SQL-trigger interruption→frozen-context recovery case plus unchanged catalog/absence/race unit assertions. Native prerequisites had passed; full API verification is now running. This is a genuine native integration pass, not completion of the full prerequisite/registered-scene invocation, adoption582, real proposal recovery or a managed golden workday. Required final gates remain open.

18:51UTC complete API prerequisites pass: Unchanged c24aae89 native39301342001 passed npm run verify:direct, real PostgreSQL backup migration, identity mapping and concurrent pool/workday allocation checks after the early native retry case. Required component scenes are now running. Exact counts/final semantic receipt await the native Actions artifacts; no final pass or merge582 is inferred from this phase alone. Healthy adopted runtime remains581, all original claims/results/usage preserved.

20:16UTC API582 delivered/adopted: native39301342001 passed2208 API assertions/415files,200 verifier-owner prerequisites,992/992 component steps,0failed/skipped/todo/blocked. All four new recovery/race/absence cases and both MCP metadata cases pass. Tested merge9bc9acd69de810835715804b954c9fc7c22c514d and protected staging merge 24548c93387835aecd6269ab78502b8a582c5140 independently fetched with identical tree6acf5a95e633b2aa213ec5bfd70484d4849435f8. API archive SHA256f30023d23f1ce180466d05e218b9e7ffc4793bf85ce055e1a924b19452ed8cad. Authorization/submission passed before guarded merge. Actual complete pending/leased/running pages each0; normal-CA readiness200/database+OpenBao true, sandbox doctor all8 checks true. Primary API clean fast-forward, supported trsd operations-runner rebuild completed ok/no blockers/manual actions. All727 mounted source files,727 runtime modules in each actual API container,1454 host JS/declarations,SDK447/447 and TreeDX127/127 files match exact checked artifacts. No new guest/provider/issued authority.

Real-proposal SDK/CLI proof passed: original proposal46a2982b... remains v4 while original send380753ff..., invocation53f86e7e..., assignment_aLC_b856VqXrLMIPENH22VhLc6QWLFe6 reuse the frozen v1 commitafb84153c10440bd4fbf94a4aa8383fa4edd5205/digest190d0665.... Unchanged replay returns replayed=true and exact original identities; changed text rejects409 discussion_idempotency_conflict. SDK independently compared original id/assignment/request_digest/scope_hash/content_refs_json/response_json/metadata_json/final_message_ref, responses and topic events unchanged. CLI same recovery/negative result passed. Initial operator CLI probe incorrectly parsed only stdout; error receipt is correctly structured JSON on stderr with exit1. Corrected probe passed; this was not a product failure. Public full API usage page38rows/no cursor read-back preserves the exact original aggregate21-active-second settlement and one informational0-second row; native20.507332779active/20.54814727elapsed, no fabricated usage.

Real MCP remains failed, new owning repair active: official native client rejected communications.send output schema before dispatch: ProtocolError -32602, exclusiveMinimum value must be number. No MCP mutation/recovery pass is claimed. API regression5ad6bbf2 reproduced two failures, enumerating12 affected advertised input/output schemas (communications send/status/timeline, capabilities, inbox, projects/execution/assignment queries, team clone/recovery). Shared SDK projector is intentionally OpenAPI3; MCP needs a declared JSON Schema dialect. An API-local direct converter attempt passed26 focused cases but failed strict TS2589 across Zod ownership; it is discarded without casts/disabled checking. Correct earliest owner SDK430: base0f78a658d646d961282fc7039e212a5622732fe4/head e2ac20c. SDK regressiona32827d3 gave1intendedfail/14passes; existing projector now optionally emits jsonSchema7 with default OpenAPI unchanged and rejects unknown/null/empty/malformed dialects. Unit15/15, strict build/policies, existing real npm-installed/strict declaration case1selected pass/5filtered pass locally; full native39320058445 running. New SDK unit component case plus existing native archive case retained. API consumer branch codex/mcp-schema429 is prepared locally: request owned JSON7 in existing adapter, declare dialect on input/output, compile all139 advertised tools with default official validator and exercise actual communication.send via native Hono/PostgreSQL/signed TreeDX in existing retry integration. It must pin the checked protected SDK artifact and run fresh complete owners/scenes before adoption; no unverified dependency touched live API.

Final API582 duplicate standalone verify39317691603 was requested for cancellation; candidate-source39317691909 also cancelled once this additional real MCP defect required a replacement composition. No published OCI/release credit. Foreground work continues, heartbeat paused. Both requested original PRs are merged/adopted and SDK/CLI recovery is real; complete MCP proof and full objective-to-release acceptance remain unproved.

20:49UTC owning format follow-up: SDK430 e2ac20c has passed Verify package and is in existing component/product-custody scenes (39320058445); submission passes. The prepared API consumer branch is durable at c2f28b24ec3781c0bc1d3fdff2482cff6b41b76a, treef05d11c2263dce80698adfe6702cf495ec092930; it has no PR/campaign yet because the final checked protected SDK dependency pin is pending. Existing API worktree reused, independent node_modules copied (513MiB within measured61GiB free tmpfs); live API245 and user SDK selection remain untouched. Local existing hydrate script installed the SDK430 local built archive only into this isolated candidate. Host npm9.2.0 rejected the existing Git override comparator; the same helper completed with isolated npm11.6.2, without changing global tools or skipping its npm-ls validation. This is prototype evidence, not final exact-dependency/native acceptance.

With APIc2 + SDK430 e2 local archive: strict source/declaration build and structural policies pass;26 assertions/3files pass; then complete MCP/protocol selection29assertions/6files passes with actual disposable PostgreSQL17.11, no skipped cases. Docker codex-schema429-postgres removed. Unit5ad6's12 schema failures now compile with the unchanged official client validator, including positive/negative native bounds, nullable unions, tuples and strict-object denials; OpenAPI assertions remain intact. Existing signed-native retry integration is strengthened to perform its first communication.send through the real Hono/MCP route and default official client before all original proposal-edit/concurrency/interruption/SQL-read-back assertions. It remains unexecuted locally for lack of the original disposable signed TreeDX fixture; final fresh CI must prove it.

Read-only real-project check: fetch the unmodified raw REST receipt for original send380753ff... using normal authenticated public boundaries, then evaluate candidate JSON7 projection with the official default validator and original SDK native schema. Both validations pass; receipt complete, descriptor confirmation=never, no data filtering or MCP mutation. This independently checks actual completed-result fields before the expensive final composition; it is not a live adopted MCP pass. SDK local installed-package result is exactly1passed/5filtered, not a complete-suite receipt. API/SDK source heads are held while verification runs. Next: mergeSDK430 only on required full checks, read its protected exact artifact, pin that same commit in API dependency/lock/action, create the small API consumer PR, run fresh owners/scenes, adopt and execute actual MCP original-send recovery with original usage read-back.

20:58UTC final MCP composition submitted: SDK430 required native 39320058445 passed624 assertions/94files,200 verifier-owner assertions and290/290 component/product-custody steps with no failure/skip/todo/blocked. Guarded merge produced protected 082eb18, tree6de69daca83605d9f7bcebc2bb3dc059d94bb80a, matching fetched tested merge8e2ae43b...; PR archiveSHA256c9efa02546f10f8c33dd7db944ed09ea82487d0d35bac4bb7eff4cc678757522. Fresh protected artifact run 39322886413 is executing existing scenes after complete verification passed. User SDK checkout remains121d959b, untouched.

API 583 now pins that exact SDK protected SHA in dependency/lockfile/installer action at head b71f882ccc6a57f2b98e97e1bd59685b892c13e5, treea93016ea1637e831d2959d0b8b60c72940dcbb22, base24548c93. Fresh full native invocation 39323566687 is running; no changed timeout, deadline or assertion. Node24 local strict build passes; focused schema/authorization/recovery selection13 assertions/3files passes (one earlier local command selected only2files/9assertions due to an incorrect authorization filename, corrected explicitly; no full-suite credit). Checked protected SDK artifact hydration and final live MCP proof remain pending. Healthy adopted API24548 remains unchanged and both original PRs remain delivered.

21:24UTC final native MCP integration gate passed: Protected SDK 39322886413 passed624/624 SDK and200/200 verifier prerequisites,274/274 component plus16/16 product-custody steps, no failure/skip/todo/blocked. Protected082 archiveSHA256c9efa02546f10f8c33dd7db944ed09ea82487d0d35bac4bb7eff4cc678757522 is byte-identical to the checked PR archive. Existing helper hydrated this checked artifact into isolated APIb71 candidate; Node24 strict build and13/13 focused checks pass. API 39323566687 consumed exactSDK082, passed all original credential/closeout/native lease/workspace/promotion early regressions and Verify proposal retry recovery before complete verification. This includes actual official-client MCP send through Hono/Postgres/signedTreeDX before proposal edits/concurrent replay/interrupted admission read-back; no custom validator. Full API verification is running; component scenes, merge583, adoption and actual real-proposal MCP replay remain pending. No new assignments admitted; live245 remains healthy. Existing operational MCP proof will also compile every actually advertised tool schema with the default official validator after adoption, independently of unit coverage.

21:37UTC: Fresh native39323566687 on unchanged b71f882c has passed exact SDK082 artifact consumption, complete native TreeDX server/client prerequisites, strict build, all early original credential/closeout/lease/workspace/promotion/retry regressions, npm run verify:direct, real PostgreSQL migration closure, transactional identity mapping and concurrent pool/workday allocation. Registered component scenes are now running; exact suite/scene counts await final Actions artifacts. Protected staging24548 and main93563 fetched unchanged before this phase; local worktree clean. No merge583, final runtime adoption or actual real-proposal MCP pass claimed yet.

23:07UTC COMPLETED: API581/582 and SDK430/API583 are merged. Final API03632d96890231b806d2f8c3046244682bbfd576 has identical checked treea93016ea1637e831d2959d0b8b60c72940dcbb22; native39323566687 passed2210API+200verifier assertions and994component steps, zero failure/skip/todo/blocked. Supported trsd API service/runner adoption and exact source/modules/SDK082/TreeDX hashes passed. Real authenticated SDK, CLI and MCP replay of the original proposal46a2982b... passes with original send/invocation/assignment and frozenv1context/results/events unchanged afterv4edits. All139 live MCPschemas compile with standard validator; key/authority/changed-input negatives deny. Complete2-page121-assignment IDs unchanged, zero active work; original aggregate21sec+informational0sec usage rows exactly unchanged. Proposal remains openv4/no decision. Full exact receipt table, command/probe corrections and limits are preserved in treeseed-ai/api#553 and treeseed-ai/api#583. Service rebuild retained manual agent.provider notification; no provider/guest/issued authority changes. No full objective-to-release or production acceptance claim; final candidate-source39339097910 still running. Heartbeat stays paused. Prior failures remain historical evidence.

2026-10-20 — Real coordinator team/proposal flow; precise MCP mutation gap

Readiness repair has actual Engineer implementation and independent Reviewer approval (API#553 / API PR584), locally adopted candidate01d0264ff917a9028437fe66096e66f2b0a57bbc. Agent PR501 required Actions passed and merged to staging42e0c3c42ce6f903e9a8e9d431769ada55f2cacd. Current real portfolio proposal is Admin93fc3490-ae8b-4c20-9f2e-ddae05f456e4, authored by Portfolio Coordinator platform/architect through actual assignment_dxEmhZAk2DXruQVDzknWr189AYb91FaE / TreeDXad9fdaee3e7da525c6e641a34cff3d3cca3a6ff0. Selected existing Admin Engineer and Reviewer profiles are published at8a65fb959f57ec13247c5d12900fb67fbe4bd6af; no new role/runtime model, no synthetic Tester work.

The real proposal transitioned v1(count0, missingEngineer+Reviewer) -> v2(owner count1, missingReviewer only) -> v3(owner count1, no missing estimates, executionPlanReady/votingReady=true). CLI, authenticated SDK/REST and MCP readbacks agree. Owner estimate was produced by assignment_TN5McT0WZ2dSHXz3hzLvufZ0H1WKr4sk; independent Reviewer estimate by assignment_euTD5WD5xIy8eK3-rLGQ1BZ9geg23irH. No operator-authored estimates.

Actual MCP approval attempt stopped BEFORE mutation: governance.proposals.evaluate is absent from tools/list. Earliest owning SDK descriptor explicitly declares only surfaces=[rest,cli]. The same applies to update/open/start-voting/vote/feedback/withdraw/supersede and governed knowledge authoring operations. This is an exposure gap, not a second-backend requirement. SDK/REST evaluation remains available and is used for the real authorized approval so portfolio work continues. Do not count MCP approval/team-profile mutation as proven.

Next small delivery chunks (preserve existing requirements/history):

• Expose proposal lifecycle mutations through the existing operation catalog/MCP bridge, retaining current authorization/capabilities, exact If-Match and Idempotency-Key handling. No adapter, duplicate policy, storage, or new runner. Prove update/open/evaluate against the NEXT actual portfolio proposal; no verification-only assignments.
• Expose the existing governed library workspace/read/write/submit/review operations to MCP so coordinators can propose and adopt YAML teams through the same backend, preserving authority and simulation external-mutation boundaries. Prove with necessary real team changes.
• Repair durable addressed-discussion context authorization: mentioning an exact earlier response reference alone did not grant access. Correction assignment_XebN53uWC8ybW-rS1eXNGCw9PuEnZWqT honestly returned the denial; supplying the full authorized JSON enabled the succeeding correction. Preserve this failed observation; do not fabricate a cross-project context-access pass.

These are bounded follow-on gaps, not claims of autonomous coordinator mutation. Admin#127 retains exact proposal/team/adoption evidence. Broad coverage/guarantees are deferred for this process-first iteration, not erased from acceptance requirements.

2026-10-21 — real reviewed UI retrieval and shared team admission

API585–587 retained failures 39467147417/39467610835/39469798828: native package steps passed; coded scene stopped after73 passes on a stale exact test-name binding. Repaired existing selection and moved project-workspace bindings without removing assertions. Fresh heads585 2a145d52586892e3f3e8ecec02bc056c4a42ae1a,586 0daf6e36c1f17f651638f0e4efa43e67b09fc3ab,587 2fd0f4f88c571ecdbaec82d883a312b5aa7c97a2; required Actions pending. Retarget and merge in dependency order only after green.

Coordinator and Deployment Architect discussion send-86150ea550532ff262213bc33b460c7f: both durably completed; recommend existing Deployment Engineer + independent Reviewer + Architect coordination. Published shared group subscriptions (classes unchanged) and corrected copied SDK labels/Tester dependency through reviewed workspace423eaa03; publication operation4de49629 succeeded, source9fc9807a4af6f9240ae4a13fa4012e4d87758526. Canonical API result/review authority remains separate from host source journals. Proposal creation first rejected missing implementation contract (requeste9aeb639); published existing unchanged required-review contract through reviewed workspace30bf5930, operation098a0c13 succeeded. Explicit statusopen then rejected model enum (requestfd4de3e4); draft followed by normalopen succeeded. No persistence/assignment bypass.

Real Deployment proposal 4d06411c-d5c0-41ee-8061-ed3762106927 v1 atff2d1c8e39d9319fe237f73339ceff79004600de requests bounded exact-commit source export through existing manager/supervisor, from Deployment68b6600f. Groupportfolio-atlas; no agent selectors or fabricated estimates. UI reviewedc6b4649 remains private and unretrieved; UI release and Adminv4 approval/acting remain downstream. Full group planning preflight6a88c101 requested UI/Admin/Platform/Deployment at concurrency2; no claim of completed implementation or acceptance.

Retrieval admission observations: first started run workday-6a88c101-f2b9-4cca-8d34-4319d259201b failed on copied Architect estimating dependency. Published only Deployment Engineer/Reviewer estimating prerequisite removal (planning dependencies retained), sourceb16392986bef5dc7974eadbc2922af846cdd2af5, operationa9645ace succeeded. Replacement shared group run workday-8ffbe604-6bfc-4465-9fc1-2c52ab23654e started05:00:38UTC–05:25:38UTC, originaldeadline unchanged, concurrency2; ten actual subscribed members visible in readiness. UI/Admin/Deployment architects and UI/Admin/Deployment Engineers already delivered planning contributions. Coordinator assignment_-1-wgisdTSC1WeFwztvSsxlT85bpZcr6 failed provider_runtime_event_payload_too_large (existing1MiB final protected evidence limit), settled33active/44elapsed seconds with teardown; prospective bounded-inspection coaching publishedf7ac212f724469356055ba87c06802bd82b6df0a viaoperation33a795a6 succeeded, supportedretry requested. Discussion send-24aedaad9b962b1bceb54641c28f6187: coordinator durably confirmed minimal scope with explicit evidence limits; Deployment Architect chat failed timing-awareness validation, retained. Its separate governed planning completed, so no fabricated chat disposition or duplicated assignment is needed.

2026-10-21 — ten-member planning and semantic estimate correction

Closed real retrieval planning workday8ffbe604:10completed planning contributions (including successful bounded coordinator retry),1retained failed planning attempt,2retained clock-invalid estimates and completedReporter report-1ef92f26bd90b9e6c61ef026. All13observed sandboxes teardownverified; settlement observations cover14assignments. Agent PR504 ff5f5804 clarifies existing per-command clock instructions without weakening validation; focused40/build passed, full Actions pending. Reversible local development candidate selected from cleanAgent1cb(detachedff5), guestsha256:3a5a998186c20c9991884598589a7cfe1b05e8daca575bda6e80cae73d8520eb imported before supported provider rebuild; rebuild/freshdoctor passed. Protected merges/releases remain gated on Actions.

Fresh estimating-only group workday49de2ad9: Engineer assignment_dbwTCoH3X2poVcu_80x7Umk6MOSHlmwB completed and integrated genuine1050expected/1500max active seconds atv2/af34df52. Reviewer assignment_ugZj5N_uHtzbKpgYTT4omXqYxplFu21K completed with valid clock evidence but incorrectly sized implementation as reviewEstimate1050/1500. Structural readinessv3 was green; integrator refused semantic approval rather than invent a replacement. Discussion send-f9ac1672caaf6b79c507b57530b24a93 completed with Reviewer/coordinator scope corrections and provisional review-only ranges (not canonical estimates). Prospective Reviewer-only scope profilec66fe149 published viaoperation6fb2d684. Normal proposal revisionv4 removes only the wrong-scope reviewEstimate, retaining Engineer estimate and every request/group/permission/criterion. First revision requestbdd11cec failed execution_graph_dependencies_unavailable (“Graph is not ready”); read-back remainedv3. Exact retry recovered authoredcommit3660413047017f775700e16184557cd10af4abc1 and boundv4 without recreating the product or faking history. Workday49de2ad9 closing normally; next group admission requests missing estimating activity only. No completed assignment is illegally requeued.

2026-10-21 portfolio execution checkpoint

• Retrieval proposal 4d06411c-d5c0-41ee-8061-ed3762106927 reached v5 through real group contributions, Engineer estimate 1050/1500 active seconds and corrected independent review estimate 360/540. The earlier implementation-shaped review estimate remains retained and was removed through normal revision, then re-estimated; it was not accepted as review work.
• Accepted Decision 224bd575-4a74-45a3-a74c-eb9d69ddb7fd, exact Decision source 1f9f5a3a3503aa092c1441742b1ab26c7b54cded. Approval response encountered graph-not-ready after persisting acceptance; canonical proposal and Decision read-back confirmed the result without duplicate approval. Public TreeDX graph refresh restored the missing Deployment canonical staging graph, after which estimating workday closeout reached ended.
• Acting workday workday-8f1b992f-e79a-443e-8b3d-a483e9987d7e is running in simulation from that Decision; Engineer assignment_ra_Lh5frAn7nQoUdDmU7xSBgySssDVln was claimed. No acting/review completion claimed yet.
• Agent test: audit null-bound static contract assertions #504 merged after required verify and installed-owner custody checks passed (39548255212); merged e22633544e0c955f38ea9525e1c56ef7e1a78e0b. Provider still uses the exact tested clock-clarification guest digest 3a5a998186c20c9991884598589a7cfe1b05e8daca575bda6e80cae73d8520eb.
• UI original reviewed Git c6b4649f6fa2e3ce06ab92f0a04db0fc6d8bab8f is retrieved through the fixed local manager/supervisor source-export operation. Bundle full history verified; 6,128,091 bytes; SHA-256 13b4a0c69f518edbca020804f955861ed2088446cfb12de0448e3401ec22a7ee. Wrong owner, wrong commit, and caller-selected path requests rejected. This uses the explicitly identified integrator bootstrap draft Deployment #889; it does not replace the agent implementation/review chain. UI Add unified host deployment contracts #75 retains the agent commit unchanged plus a version-only rc.21 commit. Local package build, TypeScript, and 7/7 realtime tests passed; required Actions/publication/adoption pending.
• API #585/#587 fresh CI failed before component scenes: full API prerequisites killed after the existing 1200-second limit. Ordinary verify itself took 21m20s in #585. Preserve failures 39546125209/39546209826; no budget increases or blind reruns. API Architect discussion send-c0760c693feb958cf339d51e17c3c587 ruled out an obvious nested-checkout discovery path, and send-711c5db90ece981692474a01ebbcd189 investigates real suite cost.
• Admin proposal fbd7342a-dbb1-4ee3-84dd-bf7ffa1c3a1c v4 now correctly requires contributions from the three newly subscribed Deployment group members. Proposal-bound discussion send-da5fc1780c5f9b231da6ab64d1857674 requests substantive participation. Existing Admin Engineer/review estimates remain unchanged; approval, implementation, release and authenticated chart outcome remain unproven.

2026-10-21 delivered UI and batched API candidate

UI #75 merged034b8811e42d7bededb8e2444ca4c099d79de4a3, preserving actual agent Git c6b4649f. Required PR/staging Verify39554551710/39555114873 passed. Release0.12.18-rc.21 publication39555732614 and immutable npm read-back passed; local ui.package adoption generation12532 ready. Admin chart outcome remains separate.

API delivery is batched under #585 candidate452a30b178eaeda31268696fd2d836e60e567bf5 (rc.114), retaining #586/#587 heads as Git ancestors through32998e17. #586 is merged into the non-protected stack branch by that integration; protected staging delivery is still pending required Verify39557555920. Superseded partial runs39546171260,39555919991,39557236399 were explicitly cancelled to avoid duplicate expensive campaigns; cancellations are not passes. Earlier failure artifacts remain. The owning test-only fixture repair restores a pristine empty PGlite image into new isolated instances, retaining all migrations/assertions/budgets/workers; isolation plus original proposal checks9/9, central fixtures37/37, build/architecture passed. Original8 proposal tests24.7s→19.1s locally. Existing rc.113 remains immutable at0df73b38.

Retrieval Engineer first attempt assignment_ra_Lh5frAn7nQoUdDmU7xSBgySssDVln failed runner-observed focused verification, active589s/elapsed595s, teardown verified. Failure text lost the useful assertion behind Git hints; no passing product accepted. Bounded Engineer discussion send-24691441753fc4d0ce5122f7a282b556 distinguishes actual source from unavailable failed private source and recommends repeatable fixtures/retained raw output. Supported retry created actual new acting assignment_IurS5bPoPdW2WteXjtnkDQjHT4yiH-v0 under the same accepted Decision and original workday deadline, now running. Original failed assignment remains terminal.

Prospective Deployment Architect/Engineer chat coaching published4073b4a58b6060b228e885d5be57caddf31854d7 via operation6dc03396-6dce-43ca-8964-2b8d51d47211 succeeded: the configured writer handler publishes final replies, so agents must not demand a separate discussion-write tool. Classes/groups/permissions/handlers and issued authority unchanged. Actual Architect reply in send-bcb04577e8d810e9514ef70b7269ee12 now acknowledges the correct contract.

Corrected Admin group planning workday-76700a56-0ff4-4e98-9a94-42381d1be272 has genuine Deployment Architect and Engineer contributions, reducing missing subscribers3→1 (Reviewer). Original Admin v4 estimates unchanged. Owner-only project-scope operator mistake was stopped and closed through its Reporter before the four-project workday. A timing-failed new UI Architect attempt is retained; its earlier valid contribution remains recognized. Proposal approval and Admin implementation/review await that last required contributor, not an integrator override.

2026-10-21 model/coaching and managed recovery intervention

Admin v4 was accepted normally as Decision da5efaf8-dae3-453a-a78c-97d74c6060d7 after all required current-content group contributions; implementation650/900 and review150/240 estimates unchanged. First Admin acting assignment_I-NfuBoC9tyG8U0goGHFtEcQMt-Wz722 failed timing: retained protected result has72 successful authoritative checks but one unclocked source-inspection command. Actual702s active/elapsed; teardown verified07:07:30.281UTC. Reporter report-7d10f66b31d4aae765e6af6a completed; workday cancelled/ended. No product/review accepted.

Retrieval retry assignment_IurS5bPoPdW2WteXjtnkDQjHT4yiH-v0 failed provider_runtime_event_payload_too_large after1259active/1273elapsed seconds. Source microvm-executor.ts timing-rejection path copies full sandboxResult into one protected event; this obscures the underlying timing failure when transcript exceeds1MiB. Private host candidate2738651d3c74f216f461f68d62d8c1032e987813 is observed published/object-closure/ancestry verified, but no canonical accepted result/review exists. Supported export of that failed candidate was denied; no private filesystem bypass or reconstructed product. Retrieval workday reached completed/ended with report closure, not feature completion. Discussion send-cb1b8c6bdc141eb3b6e47c0f4272d67b: Agent Architect failed timing; Platform coordinator recommended bounded rejection diagnostics but could not verify team catalog under current sandbox grants. Those are real remaining interaction gaps.

Provider manifest used gpt-6-luna/low. Prospective governed host config generation43 now selects gpt-6-sol/medium for both existing adapters, without changing limits/deadlines/permissions/classes/groups or issued authority. Public availability reports new model and healthy=true, two active executors. Normal host-config apply unexpectedly performed a whole managed backup/quiescence/reconciliation despite package noop plan; operator acknowledges this broader service interruption. Apply completed known-good with no blockers. Previous TreeDX candidate, Agent provider, Reviewer companion, Market API/Skill/template source-check targets restored through public trsd commands. All prior target modes and ready states restored except agent.sandbox bookkeeping remains stopped: its trust replacement guard retains three older recovery claims. No forced cleanup or fabricated settlement.

The three claims belong to older assignments euTD5WD5xIy8eK3-rLGQ1BZ9geg23irH, ugZj5N_uHtzbKpgYTT4omXqYxplFu21K, -pfS11armLi__P8HJt9bRqc1zJlG1mjt. Normal provider restart recovery retains them as control_plane_unavailable despite availability publication working. Manager session recovery separately failed No unique owned process for cli.package, no state changed. Sandbox doctor passes all checks; current provider is healthy, guest trust unchanged. Follow-on team discussion send-1e3d6b9fb9527d47b6b6d06687e6c6f2 scopes canonical provider recovery read/error repair. Full restoration/accounting claims remain unproven.

Fresh real Admin simulation workday-7709290d-ee14-4bca-9f34-10a2bcbe272f admitted under the same accepted Decision after all prior participating workdays closed, using the new advertised model. Engineer assignment_AIDO-r6K0QmoG9RIRjyUHgYzKzbsTOP3 claimed07:24:23UTC. Authenticated browser reload works, shows actual new assignment and335 catalog assignments/44 workdays; visible activity chart remains0 intervals until actual Admin product delivery. No browser fix claimed.

Live workflow checkpoint — 2026-10-21 08:18 UTC

The repaired simulation runtime has now produced real Admin work through the accepted group-driven proposal, without an integrator-authored replacement. Proposal fbd7342a-dbb1-4ee3-84dd-bf7ffa1c3a1c v4 / Decision da5efaf8-dae3-453a-a78c-97d74c6060d7 admitted workday-128a7c89-4854-4bf8-a764-010eec8ff46d. Engineer assignment_hJ2HH7IaeIvrQV9-p8HNoQMxFQhV_xPa completed as result-c3926da486db1eadfe43f7a7 with Git 79e3325cbdaf846c399b49428a5f4cae61ea223e, parent b608c6507d49633f99c0eb2dae922d2d2bc2292a. It pins UI rc.21, connects the scoped activity endpoint, maps catalog display names, replaces complete snapshots, and distinguishes unavailable from empty. Its focused Atlas test and diff check passed; 76 authoritative clock checks were recorded. Actual elapsed 468 seconds; this is not full-suite or browser proof. Reviewer assignment_m-7Jwf973EpRTrbKzOMPfXHZPH2WRory was claimed automatically at 08:15:46 UTC and remains pending. Both native sandbox.created events identify guest sha256:2f23058d53eadaee09faa2cb515758215fba28859a97b3105a035978f373d503. No Admin review, release, adoption, or successful chart browser result is claimed yet.

Runtime interventions and retained failures: managed host configuration reconciliation restored an older guest selection; native events prove the earlier Admin EPIPE used guest 304a3e2e1e8229424993727eea308b5c048ae57d2e075c71b9662d2180451219. gpt-6-sol was actually rejected by the ChatGPT-authenticated provider; a subsequent old-guest retry also reported gpt-6-luna unsupported. Configured/model-cache availability did not prove actual account compatibility. Generation 44 uses the existing gpt-6-luna/high configuration, and the current repaired guest has actually completed the Engineer product. Preserve these failures rather than treating advertisements as execution proof.

Agent PR505 (2624b7f21c70b16d07f22fca98e0a7c37bbb3881) is an explicitly labeled integrator repair of the earliest shared blocker: bounded redacted recovery diagnostics and recognition of an API-recovered completed receipt only when the retained canonical result, closeout, exact reservation/authority, released lease, measured usage, and verified teardown agree. Focused regressions failed before repair; 32/32 focused recovery/native-boundary checks and build passed afterward. Normal provider rebuild and guarded sandbox restoration succeeded without private claim edits or forced cleanup. The latest restart reports no pending recovery items; the three individual first-release receipts were not captured and are not invented. Full required Agent Actions 39566182456 remains pending. Temporary primary Agent development selection is detached at this exact candidate until protected merge/adoption.

A shell assertion previously failed while checking old workday-3b1e263b-c4e6-446a-9fed-4facb140c8d9 closure, but the shell lacked fail-fast and continued to the new admission. Retain this operator mistake. The old workday is failed with appliedPlan closing; its Reporter was explicitly terminalized workday_failed and has verified teardown. It is not falsely reported ended. Current admission passed the backend's normal fresh preflight; no authority, deadline, result, or persistence was manually changed. Further closure diagnosis remains outstanding.

UI rc.21 is released and active; API cumulative PR585 candidate452a30b178eaeda31268696fd2d836e60e567bf5 retains586/587 ancestry and ordinary full verify passed in12m21s, but component scene Actions39557555920 remains pending. Neither API protected delivery nor complete semantic acceptance is claimed. All existing acceptance requirements and failures remain applicable.

2026-10-21 08:44UTC: reviewed UIrc21 remains released/active. Original Admin Git79e3325 completed but actual independent review result-5bdd7e665a4c06e699560f41 requested product changes. Exact original product is preserved unchanged in draft AdminPR132; source-export receipt SHA2567e88cd96584705192331eb5de6d9c0f424a776dbf2e823389beaddb7b105c98a. Normal group continuation proposal a2e66315-1bc0-4493-881b-941f6c86d4f3v3 completed all10required group contributions and genuine Engineer420/660 and Reviewer estimates, readiness fullytrue. Decisionc1955f8f-f6bb-4169-a5bb-a0245895e1d4 approved normally; workday73af8dd1 Engineer_sFghL_BlSxPAcU-CAP4isD5vgEwt2uVX now acts with exact original79e3325base. Both prior productive/planning workdays verified cancelled/ended with real Reporters; original requested-changes review retained.

Authenticated original-candidate browser FAILED:350catalog assignments/76scoped observations, producer unavailable, chart sayszero/No agent executions. Admin/UIarchitect discussion91c3fd30 identifies separate chart availability gap and proposes minimal UIwork. Proposal330cb22a-fa1d-462b-8f2e-55898d447fa0 is open; group planning workday2998798b-c5e1-414f-afaa-3a63307f475b runs real contributions/estimates. This is loading/unavailable/stale-versus-confirmed-empty product work, with no agent selectors or verification-only assignments. Current active governed subscriptions were not changed. Full exact evidence and failures are in Admin127's08:44checkpoint.

API Verify39557555920 prerequisites passed and992/998componentsteps passed; stale unit/native replay test-name bindings failed/blocked the tail. Candidate38892d88397e3bd577e30f3097dfa1afc40b1d5b adds exact bindings for both parameterized project streams, assertions/runtime unchanged. All8tail selectors matched exactly one actually collected test; focused local21pass/2nativefail due absent disposable TreeDX. Fresh required Verify39569564428 pending. Agent505 Verify39566182456 pending. API585-587 are not yet protected-delivered. Repository auto-merge is disabled, so no automatic future merge is claimed. New Deployment workday1a827d36 admitted zero assignments because prior failed actor state persists; stopped and verified cancelled/ended. No authority reset, private source bypass or deadline extension. Current Admin local source is temporarily detached at original79e3325 for real browser exercise; final review/release/adoption remain pending.

Real portfolio checkpoint — 2026-10-21 09:10 UTC

Agent505 required Actions39566182456 passed; component reports2passed guarantees/890passed steps,0failed/blocked/skipped. Merged protected stagingf33e44d07dfe253c892962331080818184c75409 after fresh head check. Merge tree exactly equals tested2624b7f2; clean primary source restored to staging, active issued runtime not hot-swapped. Existing Agentrc57 is already published; no package overwrite/new durable release claimed.

Admin finish repair4be03546e5e16fb3f436e3e3442cbd7679f1aad4 completed as result-3675dee989cf5474f19b3cd7; independent Reviewer result-d763aed59fa6fe16097c4253 / TreeDX68f475d0d6d031f3595d6d7c1b6aaeacc7fa5cb3 approved exact code and independently reran unit/nativeTLS integration checks successfully. Real browser STILL FAILED. Reproduction using actual public records isolates the next catalog defect: projectAtlasActivity returns1interval, projectAtlasMonitorActivity throws catalog unavailable. Assignment.agentId=admin/engineer; same-project agents.list has agentSlug=engineer and canonical definition.id=admin/engineer. Old slug-only index cannot resolve the qualified ID and cannot safely distinguish repeated engineer roles in other projects. Required AdminActions39571712323 passed265tests/failed1live-monitoring catalog-envelope fixture; no assertion weakened.

Agent-drafted continuation81a70c79-907c-4fd9-8686-6f11ec331d53v3 received all10genuine required group contributions and admitted Engineer360/540 plus Reviewer180/300 active-second estimates. Normal approval produced Decision89ddc5ae-4d15-485b-b1b9-1bb0dff34f83. Planning ae639d96 closed cancelled/ended with actual Reporter. Acting workday21a25a77-6ff7-4173-bdcd-718b8ce5c975 Engineer assignment_xpsFin1DPpa8ml59_ywn4uTTtLj4bjig completed227elapsed/226active seconds as result-ad843a66e2a55619f3503a71 / Gite3773036c0975ef7c3d054670242f2ef2348179d. It reuses project-scoped canonical definition identity, preserves prior ancestry, repairs public-shaped fixtures, and reports focused unit+contract and nativeTLS integration checks passed. Reviewer assignment_SIv5AY_eOYZzR0_rPRTeLKLZ9Iwp6KJ8 claimed09:07:58UTC; approval/browser/merge/release remain pending.

UI proposal330cb22a-fa1d-462b-8f2e-55898d447fa0v3 also completed all10genuine group contributions and admitted UIEngineer840/1500, Reviewer540/900 estimates. Normal approval Decisionf555eac4-4216-4fc2-8678-9a58d8c25eb0; planning2998798b verified cancelled/ended. First start correctly rejected stale preflight. A direct SDK start required its exact normal confirmation; authenticated operator honored the unmodified backend confirmation using the existing SDK encoder and standing human approval, matching CLI--yes. Fresh normal admission succeeded workdayc353147c-3ce5-4929-b0ab-1a561059757c; UIEngineer assignment_6YiJAJ-mYqeNpzHWgXfKk3lIeXfrvWDi acts. No authority/deadline bypass or direct assignment insertion.

Real MCP client connected to published /mcp with official client/protocol2026-07-28 and existing authenticated authority: all139tools and58resource templates discovered, no unconsumed tool cursor. MCP read the actual Admin proposal and matched SDK id/status/version/contentHash/Decision exactly; read the real workday and its accepted Decision binding; assignments.list returned actual completed Engineer and leased independent Reviewer. This proves live MCP observation through the shared backend, not mocked equivalence. Concrete remaining machine-direction gap: the only advertised governance tools are proposals.create, proposals.list, decisions.list; open/update/evaluate/approval mutations are not advertised MCP tools, although SDK/CLI paths worked. Subsequent small SDK/API surface work should expose existing lifecycle operations with their same authorization/version/confirmation semantics; no alternate orchestration backend.

Coordinator discussiond9e1e0ee4255a4ad51e0d5e5eea1ffe4 recommends future six-role product-repair group (UI/AdminArchitect,Engineer,Reviewer), retaining broader portfolio-atlas and separate discussion topic. No current subscriptions/profiles/issued authority changed. Required APIcorrected candidate38892d88397e3bd577e30f3097dfa1afc40b1d5b Verify39569564428 remains in component scenes; API585-587 protected delivery pending. Full existing requirements and failed observations remain retained.

Reviewed Admin delivery and retained UI follow-up — 2026-10-21 09:50UTC

AdminPR132 merged4e9307fed7226c4a33004ea5a159a70e993423fd after required Verify39576581709 on version-only head7a19f0dccdc9d5d68595ce4f11a73631540a7cd2. Functional producte3773036c0975ef7c3d054670242f2ef2348179d is the unchanged original Engineer output, with79e3325/4be ancestry preserved. Independent Reviewer first failed timing as assignment_SIv5AY_eOYZzR0_rPRTeLKLZ9Iwp6KJ8 (released, verified teardown); supported operator retry produced assignment_xSqHYcEt-YEAbtioqmMupseIJMMCnr_0 / result-c343000b9d2800a83f2224c4 / TreeDX03b7512ab5bff7397372e4037e87b03d724f9fdf approving exacte377, with actual independent focused unit/contract and nativeTLS integration reruns passed. Retry used unchanged accepted Decision89ddc5ae and original workday09:33:42UTC authority; failed attempt/result/usage/history were not rewritten. Workday21a25a77 verified cancelled/ended with actual Reporter8wgzkRZO.

Protected staging Verify39577156198 and sealed candidate39577156323 passed, including managed package/Pages builds, amd64+arm64 images and release custody. Tag0.12.59-rc.39 at4e9307fe promoted successfully in39578944809. Release https://github.com/treeseed-ai/admin/releases/tag/0.12.59-rc.39 . Initial independent npmview returned404; retained, not called a pass. Subsequent direct exact-version public-registry read downloaded246,144bytes and verified SHA512d2oHFodhdE6azvCUTtRQohTknDq1XvLh9QeBus1NSivLngmwsFOjXihN8y329TKmVqhGwTkMiTXEzkeO0JwU4Q== and SHA2561ee6edd3b8e0c0c9becef8bbe5c751dabc7bce39277f9e5797f13a3ae483f2e9, exactly matching the sealed npm artifact and source4e9307fe. Stable npm latest stayed0.12.58 in promotion. OCI identitytreeseed/admin@sha256:a917a46daa4a1ff36e76d4753505b515670aa92b9cafd84e329966723cf170ff. Clean primary Admin restored to protected staging4e9307fe; supported dev rebuild admin.web passed, live generation12101ready, preserving the user's live development mode. This is local source adoption of the reviewed release commit, not a production-environment promotion or new Platform composition claim.

Authenticated actual browser: producercomplete:true140real intervals initially, visibly increased to150+ during subsequent genuine planning. Selecting actual Admin workday21a25a77 reduced the chart to exactly4real intervals: completed Engineer, failed Reviewer, completed supported Reviewer retry, completed Reporter; correct project/agent names and individual assignment links were visible. This proves useful workday scoping and failure-history retention in the real chart. A transient browserERR_NETWORK_CHANGED occurred during navigation; the observed target URL subsequently loaded and4intervalscope verified. Remaining real UX gaps are explicit: picker workday titles are blank/aria says no selection despite effective URL scope, some Reporter YAML names still say SDKReporter in other projects, and expanded chart overlaps sticky controls at the current narrow425pxbrowser width. These are follow-up product work, not fabricated full-UX acceptance.

UI availability Engineer assignment_6YiJAJ-mYqeNpzHWgXfKk3lIeXfrvWDi completed474elapsed seconds as result-812634f39d1aeb6e9ec18d55 / Git8ca01c42f1d64ccd099496fbfa9c16e27440a6aa. Focused monitor/realtime checks and TypeScript passed. Exact6,172,674byte bundleSHA25602157b8a8decdee436686f7cc98916c1ed20eec2f89d782c2505a23a681edc1b retrieved unchanged into draftUI PR76. Independent Reviewer_tmYMyuu4yxFyaPtOIclj9Hj4Yk1U2o3f failed before model execution withsource_storage_full, teardown verified; no approved review/release claimed. Affected workdayc353147c verified cancelled/ended, original UIrc21 remains active for the successful Admin delivery.

Real source-cache repair proposal21bc6ba5-619a-4ea7-a46a-89338921d619 came from owning DeploymentArchitect discussionb22223bc and completed all10group contributions/genuine estimates. Engineer3000/4500 incorrectly bundled Reviewer/integrator work; addressed clarificationdd66d76c acknowledged this and recommended2400/3600Engineer-only. Those chat numbers are NOT admitted estimates. Normal estimate-only revision and fresh genuine estimating are required before approval; independent Reviewer420/660 is separately retained. Inactive Git-cache maintenance must use the existing fixed manager/supervisor fencing, preserve bundles/products/journals/overlays and quotas, and resume the real UIreview through normal authority. No operator private-file deletion or fake review.

Official live MCP client also successfully sent a meaningful addressed coordinator question via communications.send, canonical send-f544b01a24982821dc88b0cb7e2dd5d1; this complements the successful real MCP observation proof above. Complete discovery still advertises only3governance tools (create/list/listDecisions), so full lifecycle opening/approval via MCP remains a concrete follow-up gap. API585 cumulative corrected Verify39569564428 remains in component scenes; protected API585-587 merge/release not yet claimed.

2026-10-21 protected API stack and prospective team update

API585 merged as protected staging d0d726be81701eb1b157b348697834b7358e3068. Exact586 0daf6e36 and587 2fd0f4f8 are verified ancestors.586 had merged into the stack;587 closed as already delivered, not falsely reported individually merged. Required Verify 39569564428 passed on38892d88; downloaded scene report:1guarantee,1000/1000steps passed,0failed/blocked/skipped. Earlier failures remain retained. Local clean API checkout detached at protectedD0 to preserve the existing staging branch; supported trsd dev rebuild api.service succeeded and API service live / operations-runner candidate modes remain ready. TreeDX transient network errors during rebuilding caused two prospective UI workspace writes to fail without a version change; public library status recovered and normal writes then succeeded. Staging Verify39584213370 and candidate build39584213555 remain pending; no rc114 publication or production adoption claimed.

Cache maintenance proposal21bc6ba5 v6 restored the original objective/evidence refs through a full public update. Required group participation is ready, Reviewer420/660 retained, only Engineer estimate missing. Two prior Engineer estimates included independent review/integration time and were not approved. Prospective governed Deployment estimating prompt repair published as06e81b76 via review89282018 / operationce4017e3 SUCCEEDED. Fresh normal group-selected estimating workday workday-c4bdfff9-83a7-437b-98fb-2159f84e42b3 now has genuine Engineer assignment assignment_Afha-UPp-SrjCj4liUUyGmXZM-3-fNpg; no copied chat estimate or acting approval yet.

Coordinator-recommended focused product-repair group is being published prospectively to UI/Admin architect/engineer/reviewer (six subscribers), retaining existing portfolio-atlas, one class, topics, permissions and dependencies. UI workspaceef46c298 source6c4bcdee review891da54e / publication operation4d077913; Admin workspacec8636640, publication pending. Only groupIds changes semantically; issued work is unchanged. Next real product scope is the observed blank workday-picker label and narrow chart overlap, after genuine proposal discussion/estimates. UI76 independent review remains blocked by source_storage_full; no approval/release fabricated. Admin132 rc39 and reviewed UI75 rc21 remain the delivered chart composition.

Focused-team readback and next real admissions: UI publication operation4d077913 and Admina50ede35 both SUCCEEDED (source6c4bcdee /03f55929). Public project agents.list confirms precisely six product-repair subscriptions: UI and Admin architect/engineer/reviewer, retaining portfolio-atlas and one class each. Source-grounded discussion send-8ee46aa778953ab5ddfcf34529139347 completed for both architects; Admin's crossproject UI read denial is retained, and UI's actual owning-source answer supplements it. New open product proposals: Admin eccf02c3-c988-44da-b347-b691fb1ab8c8 (map real workday records into existing selector labels/selection), UI a0f33707-a5e4-4f78-b802-e7fca0464e18 (shared focus-surface clearance at425px). Both use product-repair, genuine owner/reviewer estimates not copied advisory durations. Group planning workday workday-26e13d21-5d87-4ac0-b678-9bf144335fb4 admitted normally.

Cache proposal v7 accepted as Decision 4ee5fda3-f3d1-414b-92e9-f7c0ec1abdb5, canonical Engineer2100/3300 excludes other roles and Reviewer420/660 remains separate. Estimating workdayc4bd Reporter assignment_JGgPUguxktYmNITNWCG9nJ5of2DYT1d_ expired after a12second execution reservation, reasonexpired_lease_settlement_without_success_evidence; actual diagnostic usage retained. Supported retry returned no demand and run became failed/closing. First separate acting start was correctly denied selection overlap while old run still running; continuation was denied because no Decision had executed in the planning lineage. After original run became terminal failed, fresh normal admission succeeded as workday-cda68d1a-dce5-4b4b-8be5-cd2a3614c08e; genuine Deployment Engineer assignment_b1sQjL72Qj0HAt7iSRTsdoitusvCjyJW is executing. No private state edit, fabricated Reporter, or extension of original authority. Reporter retry/terminal-closeout remains a real unresolved owning defect.

Latest real group observation: all six product-repair subscribers completed actual source-grounded contributions to UI proposala0f33707 (readiness participationVersionReady/authorIndependent true, still waiting genuine Engineer/Reviewer estimates). Admin pickereccf02c3 has four completed contributors and both Reviewer-class subscribers executing. Workday26e13d21 remains active. UI Engineer asked about sticky controls; integrator reproduced via authenticated browser and replied in discussion send-5845cbce312277168ec6d075e4965b3f: screenshot425x454, DOM viewport440x469, sticky product header425x72 at0,0,z25; focused surface440x744.328125 at0,72,z200, overflow hidden, with picker/navigation visibly painting through chart. Measurements are observations, exact CSS cause still unproven. Chart returned to docked usable view. Source-cache Engineerb1sQ remains genuinely executing; no product, independent approval or cleanup claimed. Native host inventory read succeeded; no private cache deletion performed. API required PR synthetic merge5205f700, candidate38892d88 and protectedD0 all have exact same Git tree0a49d0cdd9eeaaeb4123439159fbe8e49a57cfd5. Staging release pipeline remains in full prerequisite verification; no rc114 release claimed.

2026-10-21 resumed delivery: actual review, approved product scopes, rc114 failure

Cache Engineer b1sQ produced exact ae642361e81f08b0aef13a57ff26dcf5baba6d7c from68b6600f; own build,34tests across5files and source-shape passed. Independent Reviewer B5LS completed result3ef4f6f32744cbac771dd162 / TreeDX83c4713a with REQUESTED CHANGES: acquisition-lock check→unlink race, and silent non64hex root filtering. Neither approval nor activation claimed. Original exact product retrieved unchanged through supported bootstrap (2726464bytes,sha256:d22b247ce52c3f9afad1cef7300c862914eac7b24f9fb420269affb054887aa1), published draft Deployment890. Discussion send-9865fca11c3592b23ff6fd919e76c2f8 completed all3Deployment roles; they clearly distinguish inspected68b source from supplied ae review. Normal follow-up proposal 891ea893-b892-4ea0-81ac-71b8255b518d selects portfolio-atlas and exactae Git context; genuine planning workday29eda49f is active. Original workdaycda68d1a has completed real Reporter but remains failed/closing; no disposition/history rewritten.

Both product-repair proposals v3 have all6genuine contributions and separate canonical estimates, now accepted: UIa0f33707 → Decisionc4cd135c-e534-44f9-89a6-28b6a23667d4, Engineer3600/5400 and Reviewer1200/2100; Admineccf02c3 → Decision8ba52990-c22e-453f-b845-4bd8b21a2515, Engineer1800/3600 and Reviewer900/1800. Planning26e13d21 closed cancelled/ended with actual completed Reporter. Acting admission is intentionally sequenced after idle-host cache repair, avoiding known source-preparation failures and conflicting maintenance.

Protected API Verify 39584213370 FAILED: API full prerequisite exit1 despite2232/2232assertions recorded passed,0failed/skipped/todo; Reviewer200/200exit0. All1000scene steps BLOCKED, none passed in this invocation. Existing full job log/native/scene artifacts inspected; no Vitest failure stderr/fullJSON retained. Cause is unproven; not a blind-rerun justification. Original passing PR1000/1000 remains historical, not a replacement for this failed protected run. Candidate publisher39584213555 still running; rc114 not published/adopted. Source-grounded API/coordinator discussion send-fc34767c5ed59fc118a34469594912fc recommends owning Reviewer prerequisite diagnostics retention. Current protectedReviewer001329f still deletes tempJSON and omits captured process diagnostics; API pins olderReviewere60ad258. Prospective focused release-repair team publication prepared in Reviewer/API/Platform; Reviewer98 owns this real diagnostic product repair, no gates/bounds weakened.

Explicit local recovery bootstrap before further guest admission

Cache revision3440f4ea is the genuine descendant Engineer product (H8lbbx7C / result retained),330elapsed seconds; build,3focused owning files and ancestry checks passed. Independent ReviewerKr2M / TreeDX072d3e03 confirmed both original source defects fixed and criteria1–3met, but withheld approval solely over a standalone archive verifier not required by this cache proposal. The exact cause is Agent isReleaseReview: reviewing activity + any acceptance criterion matching bareword pack OR release. Criterion2 says 'Do not release uncertain/live ownership'; it incorrectly triggers automatic package-release/archive policy. This is a real shared-runtime defect, not a new cache requirement. Both requested-changes dispositions remain unchanged. Agent discussion send-21871a8233364330e9c73ce9fb52bc40 could not start its3Agent roles: all failed source preparation with source_storage_full, so the runtime repair is now blocked by the very cache recovery it would unblock.

Use the original accepted cache proposal's explicit integrator-bootstrap authority for this local recovery step; do not claim approval, merge or a released product. Exact3440 collector/test bytes are unchanged in integrator composition 1ea20ad3 with existing source-export bootstrap1daa97a7. Sole functional conflict resolution carries the exact local-only fixed collection dispatch into bootstrap's already-extracted sandbox-commands.ts (no argument/path/config input). Both parent histories retained. Composition build and14focused collection/source-export tests passed. New worktree /home/adrian/Projects/.worktrees/codex-cache-bootstrap834/deployment; activation plan binds existing guest2f23058d explicitly to avoid a guest regression. Prior active generationdev-1792562709961 remains rollback reference. Next activation/maintenance only after public workdays/assignments and native host idleness preflight; use fixed manager/supervisor collector, preserve bundles/products/journals and independently reread actual UI8ca afterward. No private filesystem deletion, force unmount or quota changes. Formal scoped review resumes after Agent classification repair; PR890 remains unapproved/pending.

Reviewer diagnostics008ee26b v3 now genuinely ready with all5release-repair contributors, Engineer600/900 and Reviewer360/600; accepted Decisiona61ea54d-2ccc-4019-982c-8e825453eb5a. Planning5a83cb89 is closing normally before idle maintenance. Real setup failures retained: missing implementation type reconciled through workspaceb6c80de1 (exact existing243-byte contract, publication69aa9009 succeeded); two failed starts due copied Architect estimating dependencies were corrected prospectively for Engineer/Reviewer, operations6100ce95 andb0397a23 succeeded, no running workday/assignment from failed starts. Current Reviewer metadata publication retains classes/permissions and normal planning Architect dependency; SDK reserved chain untouched.

21 Oct continued delivery: API 0.8.0-rc.114 published from protected staging d0d726be81701eb1b157b348697834b7358e3068. Candidate39584213555 succeeded: both full prerequisites exit0 (API2232/2232, Reviewer200/200), native component guarantee1passed/1000steps passed/0failed/blocked/skipped, four multiarch image builds and seal. Promotion39600567850 passed. Five published assets read back byte-identical to sealed candidate. API OCI sha256:9bf8c5e6ee9c2381ae9806223926e06368b0409688581b69bc72c4fa5ac9b384 and op-runner sha256:37026187de2608fab3558219b7684b650eab676e38a2e891e8d17402db5b2432 both match tag read-back. Earlier duplicate Verify39584213370 remains failed; do not reinterpret it. Local supported source adoption is exactD0 with api.service live/ready generation13391 and operations-runner candidate/ready13216; immutable managed Platform composition adoption remains separate/unproven.

Cache retained-work eligibility proposal 0cea3372-7b3c-40eb-94c3-45c692dd8260 v4 accepted as Decision 1bc7db68-e5c7-449b-bfad-a7357a321939, after four source-recovery members' actual contributions and genuine Engineer420/600, Reviewer240/360 estimates. Planning a854b83f closed normally; functional implementation workday workday-1dd02923-c4d5-493c-93dd-bc236f8aa063 admitted Engineer assignment_JlOgTbxfkGFXpZGjvC3sD2rAPs186jmA. Scope splits idle Git eligibility from46retained work leases within existing cache operation; preserves all work/image custody and actual race fixes. No successful maintenance or UI cold-source recovery claimed yet.

Reviewer diagnostics original Engineer OY7i failed mandatory real integration replay near original deadline; no accepted product. Old run68d15ef3 is cancelled/ended with actual Reporter. Retry before continuation failed honestly with capacity_assignment_requeue_conflict / stale node revision59. Supported continuation workday-2b615ead-7e2b-469f-9cd8-ad8c65ad91a7 restored same Decision a61ea54d eligibility and admitted Engineer assignment_xdXV-HqAlvjvUyVI14srDyuMjQr8ubvD, unchanged estimate/task maximum. A subsequent redundant retry correctly rejected assigned revision60; no duplicate admitted through retry. Original deadline/failure and scratch custody retained. Discussion667d supplied bounded real subprocess fixture correction; implementation and independent review remain pending.

Live recovery findings, 21 Oct: Exact cache product ff659afe792fa8fe0fb3abe7edb8553c522b800e (Engineer JlOg / result9353335f; direct3440descendant) passed build and14collector regressions. PR890 required run39601300159 now succeeded (verify, secret-custody, uninstall-vm); qualify and development-backup also passed. Independent Reviewer assignment_-fu49hJEDQAv8FZP5PhMUpFR7jARzTZp failed source_storage_full beforemodel. Run1dd02923 cancelled/ended with Reporter. Exact unchanged bundle2728898bytes sha25622307daed68301068a95fd7a7ac730eede6b8c692ba95bd2bf3f0bc28e192f99 retrieved and pushed unchanged to PR890.

Labeled local recovery composition e711e8b5ef2526b27ef983c41d812c403ebe8791 combines exactff with existing source-exportbootstrap. Build +14collector +2export contract checks passed. Supported host activation dev-1792586719832-6f260541 succeeded preserving guestsha2562f23058d53eadaee09faa2cb515758215fba28859a97b3105a035978f373d503. First physical preflight retained an idle warm VM denial; normal activation drained it. Fresh physical inventorycomplete0tasks0VMprocesses,6200leases (47active retainedwork),50disks,215readyimages. Actual fixed maintenance DENIED again; no reclamation claimed. Public inventory6295jobs:5799stopped,14attached,482metadata-null under full-schema validation. All14attached leaseIDs correlate to released analysis catalogleases. Current unfinishedJobs predicate necessarily rejects those records; exact first helper error is hidden behind generic400 and helper journal was unavailable. No private mutation/deletion or fake closure. Source-recovery discussion send-3d238c64204574c63f04e45a7956be05 supplies exact counts and distinguishes actual source68b inspection from suppliedff facts. Open proposal 520bf90e-ccf3-488b-9c7a-7a6070a34738 v1 corrects exact released-history correlation without weakening live/unknown ownership, broker/acquisition/transport guards or retainedwork custody. Actor cached3440 source and exact unchangedffdelta are explicit to avoid cold-source dependency; any new ancestry must be reported honestly, originalff remains retained. Creation returned proposal_initial_version_unbound409, but publiclist/show and exact TreeDX read proved boundv1; normal open succeeded, no duplicate. First planning start workday-3e224135-64ac-417d-9cd1-b6c237ca99d6 failed execution_graph_revision_conflict with0assignments; runstatusfailed/planactive, stop correctlyrefusedworkday_not_active. Preserve this failed no-work run; fresh bounded normal start follows.

Reviewer diagnostic 720e6947df35b2f864ccb863795feff1f3ef1c87 retrieved unchanged and exposed as draftPR128, bundle1345314bytes sha256ccbaa59d886cd4c3e3ae5658b9b1dd7ddcd51e1c79512ad69b48b5e6de6eff8e. Typecheck/filelength passed; Engineer honestly did not claim owning Vitest. Independent Reviewer q4ZlZ0UX failedsource_storage_full; continuedrun2b615ead cancelled/ended with Reporter. Integrator actual2owningfiles:23tests/22passed1redactionfailed,3real subprocess integrationspassed. Actions39602106006 failed2tests/215passed. Known Bearer tokenlabel leaks abc.def.ghi. Second failure traced to new malformed/missing-report fixture unlink/write through node_modules/vitest directory symlink, replacing sharedinstalledlauncher; later collection fixture cannot execute realtests/order. Restore completed: exact registryVitest4.1.10 tarballintegrity verified, launcher43bytes sha25639db22f579acf5639bbb17a261408debbde03f4692c0c439e77e7f13aeba74d6; observedstub retained, only integrator-created node_modules symlink removed. Do not rerun destructive original fixture. Owner discussions send-3bcdb7f40d083ca4bdf16bde80ff63ba / send-f6fe99965f5a29c03919c18f5d0bdc6e drive actual redaction+privatefixture functional proposal, not a verification-only assignment. Both fixes must preserve existing assertions/failuregates.

API rc114 release/custody success above stands. Local exactD0 source adoption remains api.service live/ready13391, operations-runner candidate/ready13216. An attempted dev verify correctlyrefused because no frozen localdevelopmentcandidate exists; no localcandidate/fullmanagedcomposition acceptance inferred. UI original8ca checkgreen, independentreviewstillblocked; approved UIlayout/Adminpicker E→R remain held for actual sourcecapacity recovery.

13:27 UTC current governed work (supersedes pending statuses above): Released-analysis-history proposal 520bf90e v3 had all4source-recovery contributors and genuine E540/720, independentR300/420 estimates. Accepted Decision ebfde4b9-4650-4189-8e22-dbc479eed31c. Planning workday-2c1a3d81-afdb-429f-93a0-05db17ffbe10 Reporter assignment_h5t5a6-9If1lnLj_HlkVSxc4WtDb8F09 stalled after original8second execution window13:08:29; original lease expired13:13:20. Pre-terminal operatorrecover rejectedauthority, scopedcancel rejectedmissingmeasuredactiveSeconds; no fabricatedreport/zero usage. Canonical lease recovery later markedexpired/operator-action. Exactversion4 supported operator recovery 13:19:53.827Z released terminalslot with usageStatus:unresolved, settled:false, preservingperiodholds and informationalevidence. Nativeworkspaceclosure is required by this public operation. Planning runstatusfailed/planclosing remains a failed closeout, not successfulReporter evidence. Earlier failedacting start workday-d30a1015-ca46-46e7-bd61-050f93bf69c1 rejected simultaneoussimulationoverlap while oldrunclosing; no work admitted. After terminalslotrecovery, normal actual implementation workday-59529dcf-e114-4ff5-9bb1-33293fdd6594 admitted Engineer assignment_VL0W54JxpxQ053tDw2MFXM3goHO6-GfX, sourcecached3440, originalestimates/tasklimitsunchanged. Product/review/nativecleanup stillpending.

Coordinator currentexact7bprofile was preserved and only group union restored source-recovery/release-repair/portfolio-atlas. Workspace2760f943, source 7149330423568ece0045e6c8dec935e7fa7fbabd, publicagents.readback proves all3operational subscriptions. Publication 29f064a0-62ff-45e6-a53b-419174a01928 failed legacyBook validation atbooks/platform-delivery-history.md (v3/projectId/revision/topics); noGitmirrorpublicationclaimed. Restoredmembership unblocked actual5member diagnosticplanning f3cedebf; that runcancelled/ended with actualcompletedReporter DBSjtvvk / report0f0c4730.

Integrator caught a real semantic mistake after premature approval: diagnostic proposal 9548f5fe v3 / Decisionda3f50bc Reviewer estimate960/2100 actually described Engineerimplementation and explicitlyexcludedindependentreview. Noimplementationwasadmitted. Normal supersede transitioned9548 tosuperseded with successor 3582f61e-ba61-4fcb-bcf7-3bc0dcdacb69, preservingoldDecision/history. Prospective YAML-only Reviewer estimating prompt nowexplicitlyowns independentcandidateassessment/necessaryfocusedchecks/disposition andexcludesEngineerwork. Workspace8094c831, source f200e97087c9fbee8a8e7c75570a30a2baa9f8de, publication f6c4f0aa-2de8-451e-a03c-5b578be8e75f succeeded, publicreadbackprovespromptandrelease-repairgroupretained. Newactual diagnosticproduct proposal3582 retains exact720delta, realredaction/privatefixturedefects and original001cachedsource, with honestnewancestry requirement. Normal5memberplanning workday-f5d81761-5f77-4b70-abc0-2a7271dd9a77 is obtaining fresh class-owned estimates. Do notuse superseded9548 approval or describe its R estimate as validownscope. UIlayout/Adminpicker remainapprovedrealworkheldforactualsourcecapacity; APIrc114publication/readback+exactD0localsourceadoption above remainvalid; nofullmanagedcompositionorliveguarantee passinferred.

2026-10-21 14:35 UTC — real products and current blockers

• API rc114: protected publisher 39584213555 and promotion 39600567850 succeeded. Fresh API prerequisites 2232/2232, pinned Reviewer 200/200, native guarantee 1000/1000 steps. All five published assets read back byte-identical; API/op-runner OCI digests read back. Exact API source d0d726be81701eb1b157b348697834b7358e3068 rebuilt locally ready. Immutable Platform composition and managed acceptance remain unproven; earlier Verify39584213370 failed process exit remains preserved.
• Cache: genuine Engineer1a297f53, integrator PR890 merge8fecc199 preserves both source histories and the original 46-lease assertion. Local bootstrap90da3db6 passed build and18 collector/export checks. Third native collection DENIED, no bytes reclaimed: supported host event13:37:53.363 reports unfinished source jobs. Physical inventory complete0tasks/0VMs;6238leases/47active retained-work;50disks/215images. Three failures trigger owning review; no fourth blind collection. Discussion send-2d9daa9f07cd4bcbb80af6f8560afe72 completed6answers. Four source-recovery members planned proposal72e8e53e v3; actual Engineer720/980s and independent Reviewer360/510s read before approval. Decision0ac19453-0777-4a8b-bf67-832a5e3c3756; normal acting workday-c549bef1-d2be-46cb-9215-e2592ca4cdae; Engineer xoa4723e claimed14:30:58. Implements actionable bounded blockers in same public path plus complete source identity bindings, preserving all guards.
• UI: Engineer6Rd actual4bdb9cee retrieved; draft UI77. Real signed-in 440x469 viewport exercise FAILED: requested425x397 frame rendered440x492.328 beyondviewport, page paint-through, no bottom-nav. Published034b source restored/rebuilt after temporary candidate exercise. UI/Admin discussion f5eed gives source-grounded sharedCSS100vw override and ancestorclip findings; Admin shared imports present. UIEngineer discussion produced durable source answer but terminal expired_lease_side_effect_evidence_present remains failure. New real containment proposal ea623257-52f2-4511-ac23-9d88a16c9960, product-repair6, planning workday15d92f79-8279-44ff-b8d8-a435b8608569. No UI acceptance/release claimed.
• Admin: actual Engineer dD_jeHW product31637e01 direct4e,489elapsed, owning view-model check reported passed; bundle retrieved unchanged. Draft Admin133 opened. Independent ReviewerHcpEY failedsource_storage_full beforemodel. Real picker candidate exercise pending.
• Reviewer: proposal9548 had wrong-owner estimate and was superseded without acting. Corrected prospective estimating YAML publication f6c4f0aa succeeded; new3582 v3 genuine E840/1500,R240/420 approved Decisionaa79247e. EngineerLuW delivered FE026f35 direct001 in980elapsed; ReviewerjTF failedsource_storage_full. FE safe fixture repair reported passes but replaced original double-Bearer negative input and removed strict integration output/count assertions. Integrator restored original assertions in separate regression:23passed/1failed; credentialabc.def.ghi still leaks. SharedVitestlauncher unchanged. No merge/approval. Correct exact input and failed regression sent to actual team via send-918fbe39751acd9f3429c11b22180103; original integrator description error retained. Original720/FE products and failedActions39602106006 preserved.
• Reporter cache planning2c1a recovered only terminal slot after lease expiry with usage unresolved/settledfalse, periodholds retained; not successful settlement. Other actual Reporters closed healthy runs. Coordinator group union source-recovery/release-repair/portfolio-atlas operational, but publication29f failed legacy book schema; do not claim Gitmirror success.

2026-10-21 14:54 UTC — review found real cache defect; planning intervention corrected

Cache Decision0ac19453 real Engineer xoa4723e delivered8ae3b8a73c95c3e65cac1374fd209c88ecb52078 direct3440 at14:43:27;732elapsed/730.970active,67timechecks, build/focusedcollector/diffcheck reported passed. Bundle2731374bytes SHA16a0f5a295710efb80ecd001c1b15656c824c9b4a6d65dad6524ff87deb76650 retrieved unchanged. Canonical ReviewergdI8 failedsource_storage_full beforemodel; run stopped normally for Reporter. Integrator found new256-record scan cutoff that labels all later journals unfinished/malformed without reading; actual6295history would always deny. Also stopped-state shortcut precedes schema validation and actual filesystem/catalog test was replaced by predicate checks. NO8a activation/merge/nativecollection. Discussion0097dcd has independent DeploymentReviewer REQUEST CHANGES source feedback confirming cutoff; author-reported checks distinguished from independent execution. Draft genuine correction proposalb9d94604-1ca8-476c-b36d-f104b315f5f4 created from owning drafts, not started while architectural scope question pending. Separate actual question asks whether global historical-journal guard is necessary for independently acquisition/mount-fenced Git caches; QCOW2 custody guards remain required. No speculative relaxation, no fourth blind collection. PR890 requiredverify39609180223 passed but no canonical approval.

UIplanning15d: initial operator inferred budget exhaustion from360admitted/project versus450share and180turns. That inference was NOT established: fresh history shows AdminReviewer NXqh claimed14:41:34 and UIReviewer dWBM14:41:40, Engineer estimateQEWT14:42:34. Operator stop then cancelled dWBM/QEWT; preserve this material intervention and do not call them spontaneous failures. Actual ReporterCl0F completed report39d9a33ee. Public continuation rejects planning proposals (exact decisions only); fresh normal same-proposal planningfc2ed7bd-1f4d-43ba-93df-8029cb5153c3 started with1800s,UI60/Admin40. Prior contributions remain governance history; new run nevertheless repeats class contributions. No original deadline extended. UIE o1AT and AdminE QIgJ active14:52; genuine estimates not yet complete.

Admin actual316 browser temporary rebuild confirmed blank-label repair, but50real rows all profile:default/statusonly. URL changed21a tolatest15d during exercise, causeUNKNOWN. Primary4e restored/rebuilt success and old21a browser restored. Actual AdminArchitect/Engineer draft from discussion6a6e2ab requests public starttime/stable-ID differentiation and one URL selection authority, with no invented fields. New proposala309d6bf-1a49-47cb-92de-238230906ac3, six contributors completed in workday6a3f5648-6604-45fa-b508-f70771e23825; v2 Engineer estimate integrated, independent Reviewer estimate pending. Admin133 retains original product and observed limits.

Reviewer corrected-path discussion425e46fd: Architect/Engineer source-grounded prerequisite-only draft; independent Reviewer conversation failed timing-awareness evidence, not approval. Proposal create returned409proposal_initial_version_unbound but public list/show recovered SAME f6a5771c-32d0-4911-a27a-89a12cea6f30 v1 with contentReady true. Same-key recreate returned source_path_occupied, no duplicate new proposal. Normal release-repair planningfff78b20-648d-4b1a-84b2-9188cbce1509 started; still genuine contribution/estimate pending, no approval. Source context labels actual FE delta and integrator restored assertions honestly. Earlier918 discussion Engineer had inspected unrelated browser-redactor; corrected explicit owner/path before new admission. No fabricated review or source output.

Communication findings retained: exact code diff containing npm scoped import was rejected as nonexistent agent @treeseed/sdk; encoded literal scope marker for discussion and trimmed functional excerpt under existing20k limit. No bypass/new communication path. Provider diagnose healthy at14:50, workday activity continues; do not equate queue wait with failed provider. PrimaryAPI D0rc114, Admin4e and UI034 verified; root user modifications untouched. Earlier14:38/14:40 checkpoint headings were operator wall-clock labels, not authoritative event times; exact event times above come from public records.

2026-10-21 15:22 UTC — current teams, real approvals and continuation references

External Codex remains the portfolio coordinator/integrator/operator. There is NO independently autonomous internal portfolio coordinator. The consulted agent is platform/architect, classarchitect; current catalog name/prompts still SDKArchitect, definition7149330423568ece0045e6c8dec935e7fa7fbabd, groups source-recovery/release-repair/portfolio-atlas. Current read-back of Platform, Deployment, Reviewer, UI, Admin, API shows8 configured roles each: architect,researcher,tester,engineer,reviewer,technical-writer,releaser,reporter. Many retain staleSDKnames; ready catalog status is not proof all capabilities work. Operational proposal cohorts remain source-recovery4 (DeploymentA/E/R+PlatformA), product-repair6 (UIA/E/R+AdminA/E/R), release-repair5 (ReviewerA/E/R+APIA+PlatformA). Topics are separate discussion routing. Required Platform membership currently adds a mandatory contribution gate; do not describe it as an autonomous coordinator or silently remove it from issued authority.

UI containment ea623257 v3: all6 contributions, actual E900/1500 and independentR240/420 read; approved Decisioneb2829ec-9fe9-49b6-9908-a8897a1897ab. Planningfc2 closed cancelled/ended. Normal acting workdayecdfc5da-df29-4841-9d17-3a167ee6f117 started. Last15:17 graph actingnodeExMQ ready with canonicalDecision; no Engineer assignment yet, not implemented. Local approval helper initially asserted statusopen unnecessarily; actual backend evaluate explicitly permits draft/open/voting with readiness, so helper aligned with supported contract, then approval succeeded. No policy bypass.

Reviewer prerequisite repair f6a5771c v3: all5 contributions and genuine own-class E2700/4200,R1200/1800 read, approved Decisioncf3ec6da-e584-422f-8538-c4119fdde6b4. Planningfff78 closed cancelled/ended. Normal acting44b27e2b-94de-41a8-be13-78c4651587a7 started; actual claim/result still to observe. Preserve720/FE originals and failed restored-regression. No canonical review success claimed.

Admin a309 v3 reviewEstimate described Engineer implementation and excludedreview, so never approved. Returned estimates only through supported proposal update to v4, retaining v2/v3 history. This invalidated group contributions: re-estimation alone cannot restore readiness. Prospective AdminReviewer prompt-only YAML source13ccb064 and UIReviewer91abae10 published successfully (operatione3706368 andc28728bd); all other YAML fields preserved includinggroups. Fresh normal estimating workdayc761edda-429a-4999-9f03-c2e9e3d44d7f produced v6 E4200/6300,R1200/2400; R nowownsreview. E still conservatively overestimates versus prior489elapsed, actual measurement mustcalibrate; chat recommendations are not copied estimates. c761 stopped normally after both completed; fresh planning-only activityplanning workdaye80c75a7-6c67-42d4-a48d-043e63fc2dec started to collect required current group contributions. No acting approval.

Cache architecture discussion170087e COMPLETE6 replies: owning producer createsdirectory/recovery before internal lock, so fence mustliveoutside reclaimed directory and coverbothproducer/collector/recovery beforeaccess. OnlythenGitcleanup can use no-guests/builds+percacheguardswithoutglobalhistoryclassification; QCOW2 retains strictjobs/leases/ancestryguards. New smaller proposald52bd2e4 v2 readable narrowed request carries genuineff delta onto3440, NOT8a/historyclassifier. Draftb9 unacted. Workdayd54f7393-6cc2-4094-9bc8-a1dba10ea191: DeploymentA/E/R completed, PlatformA aMcvm failedtiming. Publicfull diagnostic contains8valid first/finalchecks, but replay shows two consecutive commands catAGENTS then gitshowpackageownership withoutinterveningclock; provider enforcesclockbeforeEACHcommand inadditiontofirst/final. Thisisidentifiedcause, not an unexplainedmissingreceipt. Originalfailure/usage/verifiedteardown preserved. Public assignmentsretry succeeded after discussioncoaching516a057; new wTnEuJz7 completed real contribution underoriginalworkday authority. All4 currentcontributions; actual E900/1350,R420/660 read; approved exactv4 Decision5b5e4468-4663-4372-8da7-f1356c2d5684. Planningstop requested, lastread running/closing; mustobserve Reporterterminal before normalactingstart. Temporaryrecoverycomposition permitted onlyafterexactindependenttechnicaldiscussionfeedback andquiescentpublicpreflight; then resumecanonicalreview. NO8aactivation/fourthblindcollection/nativecleanup/releaseclaimed. Activebootstrap90da remains unchanged.

PrimaryAPI D0rc114, UI034b, Admin4e retained; root user changes untouched. API rc114 published/readback/local-sourceadoption remains complete, immutablePlatformcomposition/managedacceptance unproven. Agents read via public catalog; no new worker path or named-agent proposal targeting introduced.

2026-10-21 15:32 UTC — cross-project coordination read-back

User authorizes prospective portfolio profile/group design and agrees architects need not participate in every fix, recovery or research task. Preserve issued cohorts and authority; do not use membership changes to bypass current failed/missing contributions.

Current backend facts checked against API D0rc114 source and its installedSDK contract: each proposal has one projectId; work items have agentClass and exactly one mutable primary repository but no per-item owningproject selector. Graph chooses configured class profiles from proposal.projectId. A shared crossproject group gives planning/estimate participation, not crossproject write authority. Use one shared objective/discussion with project-owned proposals and Decisions. Decision dependencies validate current accepted authority across projects; these are distinct from work completion. Exact TreeDX note depends_on links join proposal work-item anchors across projects; projector creates predecessorReviewer(orActor if no review) -> dependentActor edge. Both exact endpoints and library read grants must resolve; stale/missing refs fail. Assigned downstream context includes actual predecessor result refs, while source-write custody remains sole primary repository. These code/native-test capabilities are not a fresh proven real multi-repository release campaign in this thread; most live crossproject use here has been shared discussion/planning with coordinator-integrated delivery.

Existing shared execution graph/read/watch/explain/reconcile operations advertise REST/CLI/MCP surfaces in the installedSDK catalog. Exposure does not itself grant source/library access or prove native execution/release. Coordinator still performs decomposition, grant/scope preparation and final package/Platform integration. A single project-scoped proposal is not currently a native multi-project work package; provide a cohesive objective view over linked proposals rather than inventing parallel authority.

Cache stable-fence planning d54f closed cancelled/ended. Complete public leased-assignment page at15:30 returned0. Approved Decision5b5e4468 normal acting workday-f09d428d-c594-441c-a770-09473ebde3ca started through shared preflight/start, one concurrent worker constraint, simulation, deployment/source-recovery, duration3600. Exact Engineer900/1350 and Reviewer420/660 estimates retained. No claim, product, canonical review or native cleanup success yet; next observe this run and existing UIecdf/Reviewer44b/Admin e80c. Bootstrap90da unchanged; no fourth blind collection.

2026-10-21 15:52 UTC — live admission and allowance-change observation

All three approved acting runs (Deployment f09d, UI ecdf, Reviewer44b) still had zero assignments at the latest read. UI Actor node_ExMQwUtQKqTeFfVzcGb_voXLmHRqb0-- explained ready/eligible with no blocking reasons and satisfied authority predecessor. Provider status healthy is not execution proof. Latest model accounting15:41:44 showed25615.088 active +361.260 reserved of28800 seconds; no claim that exhaustion caused the stall. Public capacity lanes all currently identify codex-research; synthesis reads embedded provider lanes, so this normalized view alone does not establish an admission defect. Need exact synthesis selection/deferred evidence from public capacity audit.

User expressly authorized increasing implementation daily allowance. Supported host provider limits set codex-implementation --daily-active-seconds57600 --expected-generation44 --yes wrote generation45; independent limits show confirms57600 implementation,14400 research. Completion receipt pending. This command calls serializedReconcile after configuration.replace. Actual host events at15:49:18 backup.begin then15:49:20–33 stop treedx/agent/admin/api/identity/postgres/lab; subsequent identity discovery502 and operator reads401. Preserve this configuration-path disruption as failed evidence; do not call allowance activation/recovery complete until read-back and services recover. No private state edits, deadline extensions or new execution path.

Real shared discussion send-8793f358915feafe2ec13e9c8d529558 addressed UI/Admin Architect/Engineer to propose a genuinely dependent picker visibility delivery using existing WorkdaySummary timestamps/id and actual Admin integration. Four targets running when admitted; no reply or acting product confirmed yet. Existing independent Admin label proposal a309 v6 remains ready but unapproved; do not invent a dependency on UI containment. No team membership/profile change in this observation.

2026-10-21 16:03 UTC — actual admission counter and interrupted-provider recovery

Supported public capacity.audit read confirms the pre-change transactional model-day counter committed28545.334/28800 while requesting941 seconds; repeated claimLost counters retained. This is the immediate admission constraint despite the higher-level provider observation showing remaining supply. No assertion of lane/capability failure. Allowance change completed known-good receipt-1792597943651 atgeneration45; implementation57600/research14400. Its broad backup/reconcile stopped persistent targets and interrupted real discussion: AdminArchitect failed expired_lease_settlement_without_success_evidence (a reply exists but is not a successful completion); AdminEngineer TreeDX503/context_read_failed; UIArchitect terminal_conversation_without_assignment; UIEngineer stillpending.

Identity recovered200. Development boot resume failed. Supported dev session recover --plan refused Market process custody without mutation. Supported treedx.service restart succeeded; API restart during busy custody refused, while boot recovery subsequently restored API/Admin/Market/TreeDX. Agent remains stopped: host events give exact refusal Managed Agent development cannot interrupt2 active/recoverable claims; sandbox start refuses3 claims. Public leased assignment list complete0; native sandbox status complete physical0tasks/0VM at15:56:59. No claim journal edits, forced cleanup or deadline changes.

Minimal integrator recovery bootstrap Deployment5a783f624 on90da: existing start boundary resumes both stopped original containers only after existing session/mount/runtime receipt/build/guest-trust verification, retaining selected runtime and complete claim bytes. Actual source remains original while replacement source differs. Running handoffs retain refusal. Focused existing Docker-isolated owning-boundary regression reproduced cannot interrupt1 before repair; after repair18cases pass (14 unrelated cases excluded by explicit filter), build+diff-check exit0. Changed-runtime, foreign-session and guest-trust denial cases pass. Docker transport simulated in disposable fixture; not live-manager or formal acceptance. Exact commands/logs retained locally pending Actions; no merge/release claimed. Supported host development activation of this labelled temporary recovery bootstrap started; outcome pending. This bootstrap restores the sole normal agent path, not an alternative assignment path. Full governed implementation/review and prevention of global limit-change reconciliation remain gaps.

2026-10-21 16:18 UTC — capacity increase effective, real acting resumed, team configured

Recovery bootstrapd17b8c670 (on5a783f624/90da) active via supported host generationdev-1792598924471-f1bb2cf3, same guest2f23058d. Existing development provider start resumes selected stopped containers with verified session/mounts/runtime receipt/build/trust; and recognizes only daily model/capability limit changes for prospective manifest reload, preserving issued claims and original code. Provider reads manifest every poll. Different identity/model/capability-set/assignment-limit/lane changes do not qualify. Exactd17 focused owning checks:27passed,14explicitly excluded unrelated cases,2files,26.28s tests; build/diffcheck0. Docker command transport is simulated in disposable owning-boundary fixture, not live semantic acceptance. Temporary integrator bootstrap remains unreviewed/unmerged; no release claim. The limits setter still needs a governed repair preventing global reconciliation.

Live public providers.status at16:09:36 now advertises implementation57600, research14400. Original stopped runner resumed with unresolved JGgPUgux/h5t5 claims retained: original measured recovery/closed-clock evidence unavailable. Do not call them settled or delete holds. Actual UI outageReporterFvO02y failed timeout. Fresh exactDecision UI simulation workday2162aaf7-810d-4313-a4c3-02426ae3def8 started normally, EngineerpakI6oLJa0xxtMS7MXwOHBb_MAdavCYn claimed16:11:27.534. CacheEngineerKmtMGxIMqmxNdTwc0kMoxvnR6Ds6cBd1 claimed16:09:22.028 onf09; ReviewerEngineerFw_eTjNCZElhDvU_FYjMQ7CJKI7srxvL claimed16:09:19.886 on44b. Public broker events show current tool/clock activity; no product/review completion yet. Selection read-back restored all prior targets; only the three preexisting AI targets remain stopped. No further host activation while these source tasks execute.

Prospective work-visibility team: UI/AdminEngineer+Reviewer only. YAMLgroupIds add only; all classes/prompts/permissions/prior groups preserved. UIa0f6c92c02c6612b09f9204d9fafde121945648b/pub1a281479/op5b167fad succeeded; Admin75eed9aa8a1f749a1163b46a4e628e9e2ead1f11/op92123217 succeeded. Catalog confirms allfour exactrevisions/group membership. Issued cohorts unchanged; architects remain discussion advisers. Real scope questions toUI/AdminEngineers send-4952a0000c49c2bb24a53a7a8d256eef running. Reuse/improve existing Admina309 rather than duplicate work, UI project-owned picker display upstream then Admin typed realrun mapping/adoption downstream, exactreview-completion work-itemlink after finalproposal snapshots. Genuine estimates/approval/linked acting/reviews/simulated release remain pending; track owning UI70/Admin127 bodies.

MCP checkpoint 2026-10-22 12:14 UTC

SDK435–438 and Deployment893 merged; native75tools/35resources read back. Real MCP discussion send-bdb63932c838e5e3b990fc63a42bd6dd completed (gpt-6-luna,51.24active seconds, teardown reported verified); denied library reads retained. Governed MCP profile publication d585bc3b309aefcc45b0d9eb356ef728ddaa08e1 read back for API A/E/R; classes/groups/permissions/handlers/allocations preserved. API proposal12b52c0e v1 contentReady, genuine group estimates/plan/approval pending. Native start refused: stateless2025 cannot elicit confirmation; no workday created. Small repairs: SDK439 canonical open projection (43focused), API593 read-POST body projection (28focused), API594 existing signed confirmation receipt as data (29focused); builds/policies pass, Actions/live retry pending. Local PostgreSQL mutation prerequisite absent remains failed evidence. Current log Platform654 merged07f5724d; docs/agent-log.md retains exact products/vitals/failures. Full MCP workflow proof0; portfolio implementation paused. No wrapper or persistence bypass.

2026-10-23: SDK442 prepares rc125 for CLI305; delivery evidence CLI274.