task #550: third dial point at band [9,13] nat

eval_results/issue_550/analysis.json

@@ -0,0 +1,79 @@
+{
+  "schema_version": "issue_538_analysis_v1",
+  "pair_aggregate": {
+    "florist__medical_doctor": {
+      "n_seeds": 3,
+      "median_dv1": 0.9959276230548413,
+      "median_dv1_coverage": 1.0,
+      "median_dv2_resid_norm": 0.7241282613069379,
+      "median_dv3_resid": -6.4800326347351085,
+      "fraction_h1_pass": 0.0,
+      "fraction_h2_pass": 0.0,
+      "fraction_dv1_diagnostic": 0.0,
+      "base_cos_centered_L20": 0.0011739598121494055,
+      "gd1_pass_count": 0,
+      "gd3_pass_count": 0,
+      "per_cell_dv4_source_emission_joint_a": [
+        0.0,
+        0.0,
+        0.0
+      ],
+      "per_cell_dv4_source_emission_joint_b": [
+        0.0,
+        0.0,
+        0.0
+      ],
+      "per_cell_dv4_confirmed": [
+        false,
+        false,
+        false
+      ]
+    },
+    "librarian__police_officer": {
+      "n_seeds": 3,
+      "median_dv1": 0.9951271092432205,
+      "median_dv1_coverage": 1.0,
+      "median_dv2_resid_norm": 0.6927056191529641,
+      "median_dv3_resid": -6.228175163269044,
+      "fraction_h1_pass": 0.0,
+      "fraction_h2_pass": 0.0,
+      "fraction_dv1_diagnostic": 0.0,
+      "base_cos_centered_L20": -0.003965806216001511,
+      "gd1_pass_count": 0,
+      "gd3_pass_count": 0,
+      "per_cell_dv4_source_emission_joint_a": [
+        0.0,
+        0.0,
+        0.0
+      ],
+      "per_cell_dv4_source_emission_joint_b": [
+        0.0,
+        0.0,
+        0.0
+      ],
+      "per_cell_dv4_confirmed": [
+        false,
+        false,
+        false
+      ]
+    }
+  },
+  "n_cells_analyzed": 6,
+  "gd1_pass_count_per_pair": {
+    "florist__medical_doctor": 0,
+    "librarian__police_officer": 0
+  },
+  "gd3_pass_count_per_pair": {
+    "florist__medical_doctor": 0,
+    "librarian__police_officer": 0
+  },
+  "h1_qualifying_joint_cells": 0,
+  "h1_denominator": 6,
+  "h1_threshold": 4,
+  "h1_verdict": "FAIL",
+  "band_low_nats": 9.0,
+  "band_high_nats": 13.0,
+  "git_commit": "15ccd521822a39ae1c4bddd84781e6496e547daa",
+  "timestamp_utc": "2026-06-10T10:01:26+00:00",
+  "note": "band_low/high_nats corrected to #550 values [9, 13] nat (round-2 analyzer fix; the H1 verdict + threshold are #538-inherited semantics \u2014 for #550 the kill criterion is per-cell singleton effective rank outside the [1.20, 1.40] envelope on >=3 of 6 joint cells, NOT this H1 count)."
+}

eval_results/issue_550/analysis/florist__medical_doctor__seed137.json

@@ -0,0 +1,128 @@
+{
+  "pair_id": "florist__medical_doctor",
+  "seed": 137,
+  "n_contexts": 19,
+  "base_cos_a_b": 0.0011739598121494055,
+  "dv1": {
+    "per_context_cosines": [
+      0.996089485409966,
+      0.9964414965490911,
+      0.9965659660009021,
+      0.99556748525455,
+      0.9963475540082478,
+      0.995434239052956,
+      0.9965089397089295,
+      0.9953748539437652,
+      0.9960029713400753,
+      0.9963428335177947,
+      0.9952699614242011,
+      0.99607016699148,
+      0.9967011537099979,
+      0.9971031424995779,
+      0.9963542200895501,
+      0.9960836743334047,
+      0.9953823399274664,
+      0.9967906451510999,
+      0.9963710773404699
+    ],
+    "median": 0.9963428335177947,
+    "coverage_at_threshold": 1.0
+  },
+  "dv2": {
+    "residual_raw": [
+      7.92478733796394,
+      6.152657188290312,
+      7.399629292072007,
+      6.891104110828743,
+      7.155824159831255,
+      6.985469783607074,
+      6.860693839778923,
+      7.029300222905836,
+      6.9222294934059345,
+      6.37487454069882,
+      6.683085244214262,
+      6.774933342902555,
+      8.097153968204353,
+      6.273241712351933,
+      5.927043110353414,
+      6.50419576709085,
+      7.076682074398468,
+      7.258871039699126,
+      5.575414847022081
+    ],
+    "residual_norm": [
+      0.7136869801803181,
+      0.6858119830505782,
+      0.7298807787745402,
+      0.7572790089455756,
+      0.7291765226658956,
+      0.650164068211311,
+      0.7288585334653146,
+      0.7569778107481188,
+      0.7241282613069379,
+      0.7186096012081898,
+      0.7108419088158219,
+      0.7211527951012677,
+      0.7616813857165315,
+      0.7136543584754675,
+      0.6831206946688309,
+      0.7364391304368304,
+      0.7398800166037496,
+      0.7232668493970814,
+      0.7388783470025276
+    ],
+    "residual_norm_median": 0.7241282613069379
+  },
+  "dv3": {
+    "magnitude_residual": [
+      -6.523740530014038,
+      -5.819693422317506,
+      -5.192210006713868,
+      -6.80802001953125,
+      -6.595140409469604,
+      -6.725200700759887,
+      -6.5191421031951915,
+      -6.727320957183839,
+      -6.4800326347351085,
+      -6.1824910163879405,
+      -6.482125473022462,
+      -5.873546934127807,
+      -6.638674020767212,
+      -6.197196912765504,
+      -6.199939346313476,
+      -5.658275604248045,
+      -4.719301986694335,
+      -6.509552526473998,
+      -4.669541740417481
+    ],
+    "residual_median": -6.4800326347351085
+  },
+  "dv4": {
+    "source_emission_a": 0.0,
+    "source_emission_b": 0.0,
+    "source_emission_joint_a": 0.0,
+    "source_emission_joint_b": 0.0,
+    "pass": false
+  },
+  "dv5": {
+    "glogprob_gap_a": -0.6272625446319591,
+    "glogprob_gap_b": 0.4338744640350338,
+    "emission_gap_a": 0.0,
+    "emission_gap_b": 0.0
+  },
+  "gating_diagnostics": {
+    "gd1_top1_sv_share": 0.881188510245952,
+    "gd1_effective_rank": 1.284506053189743,
+    "gd1_pass": false,
+    "gd2_singleton_cosine_median": 0.9032470057734099,
+    "gd2_pass": false,
+    "gd3_a_top1_sv_share": 0.8583518619137506,
+    "gd3_a_effective_rank": 1.3520743448379091,
+    "gd3_b_top1_sv_share": 0.8997571138115336,
+    "gd3_b_effective_rank": 1.2330339785920856,
+    "gd3_pass": false
+  },
+  "dv1_diagnostic": false,
+  "h1_pass": false,
+  "h2_pass": false
+}

eval_results/issue_550/analysis/florist__medical_doctor__seed256.json

@@ -0,0 +1,128 @@
+{
+  "pair_id": "florist__medical_doctor",
+  "seed": 256,
+  "n_contexts": 19,
+  "base_cos_a_b": 0.0011739598121494055,
+  "dv1": {
+    "per_context_cosines": [
+      0.9967604414190671,
+      0.9961644519672124,
+      0.9933312118704207,
+      0.9950053073704379,
+      0.9958831610281347,
+      0.9962880449772252,
+      0.9942050429534506,
+      0.9958027321533898,
+      0.9952287914054366,
+      0.9962187160786117,
+      0.9957928908296393,
+      0.9959276230548413,
+      0.9960335860451566,
+      0.996650914088475,
+      0.9952945944532823,
+      0.9956520489853765,
+      0.99648252681411,
+      0.9960848083080555,
+      0.9962601029280885
+    ],
+    "median": 0.9959276230548413,
+    "coverage_at_threshold": 1.0
+  },
+  "dv2": {
+    "residual_raw": [
+      7.419975694012028,
+      5.860926147714847,
+      6.138178615773763,
+      6.059475202103231,
+      6.713187733290885,
+      7.284645250048585,
+      6.515263994505351,
+      6.586458187201213,
+      6.525267575770411,
+      5.706972309271641,
+      6.44864266271246,
+      6.245834436378074,
+      7.065231168270843,
+      5.782736968535602,
+      5.81177788877131,
+      5.696552561878068,
+      6.501665889266399,
+      7.087752308245482,
+      5.066177305684215
+    ],
+    "residual_norm": [
+      0.5739382294960371,
+      0.565619429894598,
+      0.5183635155237513,
+      0.5516500224188426,
+      0.5852804407660136,
+      0.6065810444055547,
+      0.6029001113853726,
+      0.5976402738657491,
+      0.5994703543569626,
+      0.5542640553721414,
+      0.5885195740028056,
+      0.5690531576537817,
+      0.5589307752500038,
+      0.5462057701975318,
+      0.58496377809323,
+      0.557069249917524,
+      0.5933629173360722,
+      0.6116127026632111,
+      0.576614084450753
+    ],
+    "residual_norm_median": 0.576614084450753
+  },
+  "dv3": {
+    "magnitude_residual": [
+      -6.136987924575807,
+      -5.526568746566774,
+      -4.907059764862058,
+      -6.427876615524294,
+      -6.314019632339477,
+      -6.672198247909547,
+      -6.100689697265626,
+      -6.407187843322754,
+      -6.236008167266844,
+      -5.982878637313842,
+      -6.085134792327882,
+      -5.499847507476808,
+      -5.990181255340575,
+      -5.98794150352478,
+      -6.249422883987426,
+      -5.472152042388917,
+      -4.608875274658204,
+      -6.0107000350952156,
+      -4.360668849945068
+    ],
+    "residual_median": -6.0107000350952156
+  },
+  "dv4": {
+    "source_emission_a": 0.0,
+    "source_emission_b": 0.0,
+    "source_emission_joint_a": 0.0,
+    "source_emission_joint_b": 0.0,
+    "pass": false
+  },
+  "dv5": {
+    "glogprob_gap_a": -0.5684084892272949,
+    "glogprob_gap_b": -1.4467520713806152,
+    "emission_gap_a": 0.0,
+    "emission_gap_b": 0.0
+  },
+  "gating_diagnostics": {
+    "gd1_top1_sv_share": 0.8818273703258076,
+    "gd1_effective_rank": 1.282682564126179,
+    "gd1_pass": false,
+    "gd2_singleton_cosine_median": 0.9111914901425139,
+    "gd2_pass": false,
+    "gd3_a_top1_sv_share": 0.856823438565496,
+    "gd3_a_effective_rank": 1.3570668248305817,
+    "gd3_b_top1_sv_share": 0.8927135594104619,
+    "gd3_b_effective_rank": 1.2522722255337635,
+    "gd3_pass": false
+  },
+  "dv1_diagnostic": false,
+  "h1_pass": false,
+  "h2_pass": false
+}