Skip to content

test(v0.44): record Beta.1 closure verification PASS at dc3ee191 (#1150) #1279

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Merged
SisyphusZheng merged 1 commit into from
Sep 3, 2026
Merged

test(v0.44): record Beta.1 closure verification PASS at dc3ee191 (#1150) #1279

Changes from all commits
Commits
Show all changes
1 commit
Select commit
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension
Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
228 changes: 228 additions & 0 deletions docs/evidence/2026-09-03-v044-beta1-closure-verification.md
View file
Open in desktop
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,228 @@
# Beta.1 closure verification — fresh release verifier (stage #1150)

Independent closure verification of the v0.44 Beta.1 (Framework Qualification +
Governance Freeze) candidate by a fresh release-verifier session with no
implementer conversation history, per the constitution §5.1 release-verifier
role and the release contract §4.1 (fresh release verifier GO). Method per the
configured release-verifier profile under `.agents/`: re-derive every claim,
rerun every gate at the exact candidate SHA, fail closed.

- Candidate SHA: `dc3ee191df803a05d40389a558c2e6a19f50dd11` (branch `dev`).
Verified with `git rev-parse HEAD` (exact match) and `git status --porcelain`
(empty) before and after the battery.
- Environment: macOS arm64, Deno 2.9.0, Node v24.18.0.
- Scope: packets B1.1–B1.6 (issues #1222, #1223, #1224, #1188 Beta.1 slice,
#1187 Beta.1 slice, #1225). This report is the verifier cell of the §4.1
unanimous-GO requirement; it does not by itself close the stage.

STATUS: PASS

## CANDIDATE_SHA

`dc3ee191df803a05d40389a558c2e6a19f50dd11`

- `git rev-parse HEAD` → `dc3ee191df803a05d40389a558c2e6a19f50dd11` (exit 0)
- `git status --porcelain` → empty before the battery and empty after it
(exit 0); the battery leaves the tree clean.

## ARTIFACT_FINGERPRINTS

Dry-run packs built from the candidate tree by `deno task pack:dry-run`
(exit 0), SHA-256:

| Tarball | SHA-256 |
| ----------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------ |
| `packages/adapter-vite/openelement-adapter-vite-0.43.3.tgz` | `8ba8a427299cdfac679338c81c5e386a3b4d343312e45b0604e6540d6cb5cb1f` |
| `packages/app/openelement-app-0.43.3.tgz` | `88431fa73036b368720c17d610d99da7eabf7c7a0e424cdc92c72e34b240c148` |
| `packages/create/openelement-create-0.43.3.tgz` | `9dc5ddba65ae04c88b3e8742febe5a6e55b51a23b136f3cab962e093764bf658` |
| `packages/element/openelement-element-0.43.3.tgz` | `0e9cd0e2af3961a85c9fad35931dcf83b406a3690e57bc4420346641c48ce45e` |
| `packages/ui/openelement-ui-0.43.3.tgz` | `8fc5c36731e016e6baef6bac52b11827fdc61e9c464eeac1f65efb6fc00e3119` |

These are the qualified-artifact fingerprints for this candidate. Per §2.2 the
published bytes must be byte-identical to bytes packed from this same SHA; any
repack at publication time must reproduce these hashes or publication is
invalid.

## CRITERION_TEST_MATRIX

| Battery cell | Evidence | Verdict |
| ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------- |
| 1. Full test suite | `deno task test` at candidate → exit 0 (main suite green; Supabase starter 150 passed, 0 failed) | PASS |
| 2a. Hostile compiler suites | adversarial/convergence/compiled-element corpus → 18 passed (29 steps), 0 failed, exit 0 | PASS |
| 2b. Compiler boundary + provenance | fail-closed matrix, module analysis, semantic-core boundary, intrinsic provenance → 44 passed, exit 0 | PASS |
| 2c. Source-map v3 consumer | `compiler-source-map-v3.test.ts` → 9 passed, exit 0 | PASS |
| 2d. SSR/fresh/claim parity | compiled-claim + compiled-runtime + SSG/request-time admission parity → 98 passed (9 steps), exit 0; `request-time-parity.test.ts` (dev Hono vs build Nitro) → 1 passed (23 steps), exit 0 | PASS |
| 2e. Context interop | `signal-context.test.ts` (real @lit/context provider) → 6 passed, exit 0 | PASS |
| 2f. Route parity | route-manifest, static-paths, route-scanner-enhance/mdx, entry-descriptor → 60 passed, exit 0 | PASS |
| 2g. Security projection | `entry-render-runtime-security.test.ts` → 4 passed, exit 0 | PASS |
| 2h. Remediation parity corpora | renderer-scope-parity (#1271), compiled-escape-parity byte corpus (#1272), page-route-tag-resolution (#1276) → 16 passed, exit 0 | PASS |
| 3. Gate-of-gates | `fmt:check`, `lint`, `docs:truth`, `docs:check-public`, `docs:check-strategy`, `docs:check-current`, `docs:check-claims`, `text-integrity:check`, `package-surface:check`, `interface:snapshot`, `freeze:semantics:check`, `graph:check`, `arch:check` → all exit 0 | PASS |
| 4. Clean-clone + packed consumer | `pack:dry-run` → exit 0 (5 tarballs @ 0.43.3); `package-artifacts:check` → exit 0 (5 packages); `consumer:packaged` → exit 0 (packed starter typecheck + SSG build + import-map smoke) | PASS |
| 5. #1276 regression gate | `deno task fullstack:workspace-qualification` at candidate → exit 0 (starter request-time routes serve; 10001-row dataset, two-page cursor fetch, 1 JWT handoff) | PASS |
| 6. Browser matrix | CI at candidate (below) | PASS |
| 7. Benchmark SHA-gap re-confirmation | see below | PASS |

## CI evidence at the candidate SHA (authoritative matrix, contract §2.1)

- AutoFlow CI run `33718081067` at `dc3ee191…`: conclusion `success`
(`gh run view 33718081067`, exit 0). Job legs: `autoflow-ci` success,
`dist/server Node smoke (Node 24)` success, `dist/server Node smoke
(Node 20)` success, `workspace-qualification` success (the required job
added by #1277). The AutoFlow gate step reports 49 `PASS` gate lines and
zero `FAIL`/`BLOCKED` lines, including the browser legs: `test:e2e`
(Chromium full), `test:e2e:firefox-smoke` PASS, `test:e2e:webkit-smoke`
PASS, `fixture:request-time:gate` (request-time fixture on all three
engines) PASS, and `test:coverage:check` PASS.
- CodeQL run `33718080819` at `dc3ee191…`: conclusion `success`.
- Browser matrix therefore rests on CI evidence per the packet; local browser
rerun not required.

## Battery 7: benchmark evidence SHA-gap proof at the candidate

The B1.6 admission record's benchmark baseline sits at `493548a6`. At the
candidate:

```sh
git diff --stat 493548a6..dc3ee191 -- packages/element/src packages/adapter-vite/src \
packages/app/src packages/ui/src packages/create/src
```

→ exactly 11 files, 85 insertions, 32 deletions, all belonging to the two
parity-proven remediations and nothing else (exit 0):

- #1274 (merge `18778c95`): `element/src/internal/compiled/escape-text.ts`
(new shared owner), `runtime.ts`, `server/index.ts` — the F3 escape-text
convergence. Parity proof: the byte-level corpus in
`compiled-escape-parity.test.ts`, rerun green at the candidate (cell 2h).
- #1277 (merge `dc3ee191`): `adapter-vite/src/internal/ssg/entry-*.ts`,
`route-scanner.ts` — the route-tag binding repair. Parity proof:
`page-route-tag-resolution.test.ts` plus the entry-descriptor tag-binding
tests, rerun green at the candidate (cells 2f/2h), and the
`workspace-qualification` gate green both locally (cell 5) and in CI.

No other `packages/*/src` change exists between the benchmark SHA and the
candidate, so the measured semantics at `493548a6` remain the semantics at
`dc3ee191` except for the two parity-proven remediations. Harness integrity at
the candidate: `deno test -A benchmarks/` → exit 0, 12 passed, 0 failed.

## TESTS_OR_FIXTURES_ADDED

None. This verification added no tests, fixtures or snapshots; it reran the
committed suites at the exact candidate SHA. The only repository write is this
report.

## MEANINGFULNESS_EVIDENCE

- The hostile/adversarial corpora are fail-closed by construction (OEC9xxx
diagnostic matrices, boundary probes) and rerun green; the B1.1 audit's own
negative probes (deliberate boundary-separator drift fails the
renderer-scope corpus; #1271) document that these suites can fail.
- The #1276 regression gate is proven meaningful by the B1.3 record: the same
command exited 1 at `18778c95` (request-time 500s on `/workspace-records`,
`/magic-link`, `/reset-password`) and exits 0 at the candidate — the gate
distinguishes the broken from the repaired binding.
- No assertion was weakened; all exit codes are recorded verbatim.

## COMMANDS_AND_EXIT_CODES

All at `dc3ee191df803a05d40389a558c2e6a19f50dd11`, macOS arm64, Deno 2.9.0.
Scoped test commands used
`deno test --allow-read --allow-write --allow-env --allow-net --allow-run --allow-ffi --allow-sys <paths>`
(the full task permission set; the B1.1 audit showed the reduced set breaks
rolldown native binding loads, not the code).

| Command | Exit |
| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------------------- |
| `git rev-parse HEAD` / `git status --porcelain` | 0 / empty |
| `gh run view 33718081067` (AutoFlow CI) / `gh run view 33718080819` (CodeQL) | 0, conclusion success / 0, conclusion success |
| `deno task test` (full) | 0 |
| hostile compiler corpus (adversarial, when/void convergence, compiled-element-v1) | 0 — 18 passed (29 steps) |
| compiler boundary corpus (fail-closed matrix, module-analysis, semantic-core-boundary, intrinsic-provenance) | 0 — 44 passed |
| `compiler-source-map-v3.test.ts` | 0 — 9 passed |
| compiled-claim + compiled-runtime + ssg/request-time admission parity | 0 — 98 passed (9 steps) |
| `request-time-parity.test.ts` | 0 — 1 passed (23 steps) |
| `signal-context.test.ts` | 0 — 6 passed |
| route parity corpus (route-manifest, static-paths, route-scanner-*, entry-descriptor) | 0 — 60 passed |
| `entry-render-runtime-security.test.ts` | 0 — 4 passed |
| remediation parity corpora (renderer-scope, escape byte corpus, page-route-tag-resolution) | 0 — 16 passed |
| `deno task fmt:check` / `lint` / `docs:truth` | 0 / 0 / 0 |
| `deno task docs:check-public` / `docs:check-strategy` / `docs:check-current` / `docs:check-claims` | 0 / 0 / 0 / 0 |
| `deno task text-integrity:check` / `package-surface:check` / `interface:snapshot` | 0 / 0 / 0 |
| `deno task freeze:semantics:check` / `graph:check` / `arch:check` | 0 / 0 / 0 |
| `deno task pack:dry-run` | 0 — 5 tarballs @ 0.43.3 |
| `deno task package-artifacts:check` | 0 — 5 packages |
| `deno task consumer:packaged` | 0 |
| `deno task fullstack:workspace-qualification` | 0 |
| `deno test -A benchmarks/` | 0 — 12 passed |
| `git diff --stat 493548a6..dc3ee191 -- packages/*/src` | 0 — only #1274 + #1277 files |
| `git log --name-only dd475619..dc3ee191 -- <ADR-0122 frozen paths>` | 0 — only `dc3ee191` touched `entry-codegen.ts` |

## FAILURES

None.

## Known exceptions validated (not relitigated)

- Desktop examples OEC9008 on full vite build — recorded by B1.3 at the base
SHA, deferred to B2.5/B3.8, never consumer evidence. Consistent; not rerun.
- Local-only visual-baseline drift on architecture-islands-deep mobile — the
B1.3 record documents 4 local failures; the candidate CI Chromium leg
(`test:e2e`) is PASS, so CI is authoritative and green.
- SIGSEGV (exit 139) flake in `test:coverage:check` under concurrency — tracked
as #1278 (OPEN, Beta.2 milestone, verified). Dev run `33715486563` at
`73a79000` confirmed `autoflow-ci: failure` with both Node smoke legs
success; candidate run `33718081067` has `test:coverage:check` PASS. The
flake is infrastructure, not a product signal, and the candidate matrix is
green.
- `freeze:semantics` local/CI diff-semantics gap — recorded on #1231 (OPEN,
Beta.2 milestone, verified). Local `freeze:semantics:check` at the candidate
exits 0.
- Benchmark evidence SHA predates the candidate by docs/gates/tests plus the
two parity-proven remediations — re-confirmed in Battery 7 above.

Issue/PR state spot-checks (via `gh`, exit 0): #1222, #1223, #1224, #1225,
#1270–#1272, #1276 CLOSED on the Beta.1 milestone; #1187 and #1188 OPEN on the
Beta.3 milestone by design (Beta.1 slices merged as #1264/#1265); PRs #1264,
#1265, #1266, #1267, #1268, #1269, #1274, #1275, #1277 all MERGED with the
recorded merge commits; stage issue #1150 OPEN awaiting this closure.

## Constitution §6.2 closure conditions

- **No unresolved §4.3 failure.** The B1.1 audit's three findings (F1
unregistered route grammar, F2 renderer scope mirror without parity proof,
F3 text-escape duplicate without owner/corpus) were remediated by #1274:
`docs/current/SEMANTIC_OWNERSHIP.md` gained the three registry rows, the
escape-text serializers converged onto one shared helper, and both surviving
projections carry parity corpora that rerun green at the candidate (cell
2h). #1270/#1271/#1272 are CLOSED.
- **No §5.4 violation.** Enumerating every Beta.1-stage commit
(`dd475619..dc3ee191`) against the mechanical frozen-path list in
`tools/check-frozen-semantics.ts` (`authoring.ts`, `entry-codegen.ts`,
`form-enhance.ts`, `morph-*.ts`, `protocol/data.ts`, `cli/start.ts`,
`cli/build.ts`): exactly one commit touched a frozen path — `dc3ee191`
(#1277) touched `entry-codegen.ts`, and its commit message cites ADR-0151
("amendment authority ADR-0151"), satisfying the in-commit-message citation
requirement. No other stage commit needed the citation.

## RESIDUAL_RISKS

- The SIGSEGV flake (#1278) remains live infrastructure risk for any rerun
under machine concurrency; it did not manifest in this battery.
- Bun runtime evidence remains local-only (no CI Bun leg), as recorded by
B1.3; the runtime-support adjudication there stands unchanged at the
candidate (the only runtime-path change since is the parity-proven #1277
repair, which the workspace-qualification gate covers under Node and
workerd).
- The local full-suite pass/fail count line was truncated in this session's
capture (`tail` window); the authoritative exit code is 0 and the CI matrix
at the same SHA is fully green, so no evidence gap remains.

PRODUCTION_CODE_UNCHANGED: yes

PROMOTION_RECOMMENDATION: GO

This is the fresh-release-verifier GO of the release contract §4.1, bound to
candidate SHA `dc3ee191df803a05d40389a558c2e6a19f50dd11`. Stage closure still
requires the implementer and thinker GOs and the §3.2 closure report on #1150;
this report supplies the verifier verdict, the per-cell exit codes, the
tarball fingerprints and the CI run IDs for that report.
Loading