Skip to content

Paw Patrol WorkerRun en-019e0589-11d7-72a1-8218-dd6627c201f7 #238

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Open
rita-aga wants to merge 2 commits into
base: codex/paw-patrol-worker-reporting
Choose a base branch
from
Open

Paw Patrol WorkerRun en-019e0589-11d7-72a1-8218-dd6627c201f7 #238

Changes from all commits
Commits
Show all changes
2 commits
Select commit Hold shift + click to select a range
7454948
Paw Patrol WorkerRun en-019e0589-11d7-72a1-8218-dd6627c201f7
rita-aga May 8, 2026
0663807
Paw Patrol WorkerRun en-019e0591-d7d7-72a0-85c0-bf23879053ce
rita-aga May 8, 2026
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension
Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
138 changes: 138 additions & 0 deletions .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md
View file
Open in desktop
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,138 @@
# Mac Mini Review-Rework Proof

REVIEW_REWORK_STATUS: fulfilled

## Scope

Proof-only rework pass for the Paw Patrol review-rework loop after the worker pull request reuse fix.

Only this Markdown file is updated:

```text
.proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md
```

No source code, entity spec, WASM integration, Cedar policy, config, lockfile, channel, Discord, Railway, or deployment file was changed.

The reviewer-requested rework was fulfilled.

## Live Entities

| Entity | ID or status | Evidence |
| --- | --- | --- |
| WorkRequest or legacy PatrolRequest | en-019e0588-e4d3-72f1-900a-d138197d2620 | https://openpaw-production.up.railway.app/tdata/WorkRequests('en-019e0588-e4d3-72f1-900a-d138197d2620') |
| FactoryCase | en-019e0589-025d-7c60-8e9e-ee76785ccb66 | https://openpaw-production.up.railway.app/tdata/FactoryCases('en-019e0589-025d-7c60-8e9e-ee76785ccb66') |
| WorkCycle | wc-019e0589-0acc-71f2-98c3-398685b5acf7 | https://openpaw-production.up.railway.app/tdata/WorkCycles('wc-019e0589-0acc-71f2-98c3-398685b5acf7') |
| WorkerRun ids | first pass: en-019e0589-11d7-72a1-8218-dd6627c201f7; rework pass: this local reviewer-requested run, reported by paw-codex-worker after Codex exits | first pass commit `74549487dc22d7c3000087d6de22410186d28640`; current run ID was not exposed to this local process |
| ReviewRun ids | reviewer requested changes for this loop; concrete ReviewRun ID unavailable to this local process | reviewer feedback was supplied in the rework task; unauthenticated OData reads returned HTTP 401 |
| EvaluationRun | queued or updated after the rework WorkerRun reports done | concrete EvaluationRun ID unavailable to this local process before worker closeout |
| ProofPacket | updated after the rework WorkerRun reports done | concrete ProofPacket ID unavailable to this local process before worker closeout |
| Pull request | https://github.com/nerdsane/temperpaw/pull/238 | `gh pr view` returned PR 238, state OPEN, head `codex/paw-patrol-197d2620`, base `codex/paw-patrol-worker-reporting` |

## State Diagram

```mermaid
stateDiagram-v2
[*] --> FirstWorkerRun
FirstWorkerRun: WorkerRun en-019e0589-11d7-72a1-8218-dd6627c201f7
FirstWorkerRun --> FirstPassProof: create first-pass proof marker
FirstPassProof --> ReviewerGate: worker reports done
ReviewerGate --> ChangesRequested: reviewer observes marker
ChangesRequested --> ReworkWorkerRun: WorkCycle queues same-branch rework
ReworkWorkerRun --> FinalProof: replace status and add rework sentence
FinalProof --> EvaluationRun: run lightweight Markdown verification
EvaluationRun --> ProofPacket: ready visual proof
ProofPacket --> WorkCycleComplete
```

## Changed-Files Map

```mermaid
flowchart LR
Branch["codex/paw-patrol-197d2620"] --> Proof[".proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md"]
Proof --> Marker["REVIEW_REWORK_STATUS: fulfilled"]
Proof --> Mermaid["Mermaid state diagram"]
Proof --> Evidence["PR, entity links, verification notes"]
Proof --> Rework["Reviewer-requested rework sentence"]
```

## Red-Green TDD

Red check was run before the rework edit:

```text
bash -lc 'set -euo pipefail
file=.proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md
rg -n "^REVIEW_REWORK_STATUS: fulfilled$" "$file"
rg -n "reviewer[-]requested rework was fulfilled" "$file"
! rg -n "^REVIEW_REWORK_STATUS: needs[_]changes$" "$file"
'
```

Result: failed as expected before implementation because the fulfilled marker and required sentence were absent.

Green checks for this rework pass verify:

```text
test -f .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md
rg -n '^REVIEW_REWORK_STATUS: fulfilled$' .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md
rg -n 'reviewer[-]requested rework was fulfilled' .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md
! rg -n '^REVIEW_REWORK_STATUS: needs[_]changes$' .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md
! rg -n 'REVIEW_REWORK_STATUS: needs[_]changes' .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md
rg -n '^```mermaid$' .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md
git diff --check -- .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md
git diff --check HEAD^ HEAD
awk 'BEGIN{f=0} /^```/{f++} END{exit(f%2)}' .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md
gh pr view --json number,url,headRefName,baseRefName,state,title
```

Rework verification results:

```text
file exists: yes
fulfilled marker: line 3
required rework sentence: line 17
retired first-pass marker: no matches
Mermaid code fences: lines 34 and 50
git diff --check -- .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md: passed with no output
git diff --check HEAD^ HEAD: passed with no output
Markdown fence balance with awk: passed with no output
changed file scope:
.proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md
gh pr view:
number 238, state OPEN, head codex/paw-patrol-197d2620, base codex/paw-patrol-worker-reporting, url https://github.com/nerdsane/temperpaw/pull/238
```

## E2E Evidence

This rework pass touched only a Markdown proof artifact, so no server boot, Discord flow, deployment, or WASM hot-load was relevant.

Reviewer-requested read-only checks were repeated locally:

```text
git diff --check HEAD^ HEAD
marker checks with rg
Markdown fence balance with awk
gh pr view
read-only OData curls
```

Read-only OData unauthenticated result:

```text
WorkCycle wc-019e0589-0acc-71f2-98c3-398685b5acf7 endpoint probe: HTTP 401
WorkerRun en-019e0589-11d7-72a1-8218-dd6627c201f7 endpoint probe: HTTP 401
ReviewRuns collection probe: HTTP 401
EvaluationRuns collection probe: HTTP 401
ProofPackets collection probe: HTTP 401
Branch: codex/paw-patrol-197d2620
Worktree: /Users/openclaw/Development/temperpaw-worktrees/codex-paw-patrol-197d2620
```

The rework stayed on the same branch and PR, exercising the Temper-native WorkCycle rework path without adding orchestration code.

## Risk Notes

- Architecture: no material architecture change; no ADR required.
- Temper-native boundary: this proof relies on existing WorkerRun, ReviewRun, EvaluationRun, WorkCycle, and ProofPacket entity transitions rather than adding orchestration code.
- Residual proof-only risk: concrete rework WorkerRun, ReviewRun, EvaluationRun, and ProofPacket IDs are not available inside this local Codex process before paw-codex-worker reports completion to Temper.