Skip to content

Add ecosystem evaluation docs: Polytician ↔ AgentVault integration status#17

Merged
johnnyclem merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
claude/blissful-hypatia-50g32e
Jul 2, 2026
Merged

Add ecosystem evaluation docs: Polytician ↔ AgentVault integration status#17
johnnyclem merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
claude/blissful-hypatia-50g32e

Conversation

@johnnyclem

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Summary

This repo (johnnyclem/polytician) sits in a broader ecosystem alongside AgentVault,
SmallChat, Stenographer, and Short-Hand, each evaluated from its own repo since no single
session can browse all of them. This PR adds Polytician's side of that evaluation.

  • Adds docs/ecosystem/executive-summary.md and docs/ecosystem/engineering-guide.md,
    matching the structure of AgentVault's own docs/ecosystem/* docs so all repos are
    cross-linkable.
  • Cross-checks AGENTVAULT_COMPATIBILITY_PRD.md (a 7-task spec in this repo describing what
    AgentVault needs to build to support Polytician) against AgentVault's actual main branch
    by fetching the exact files it names via raw GitHub URLs (this session's API scope is
    polytician-only, so no shell/API access to AgentVault was available — everything about
    AgentVault is sourced from specific file fetches, flagged [AV-verified] in the docs).
  • Key finding: 4 of the PRD's 7 tasks are already shipped on AgentVault's side (REST
    bridge routes, the Polytician config parser, orchestrator context enrichment, CLI
    subcommands), 2 are confirmed not started (canister-level MCP server registry, webapp
    dashboard UI), and 1 (AgentVault's test coverage) couldn't be checked from this side. The
    PRD currently reads as a from-scratch backlog; it should be updated so contributors don't
    redo already-shipped work.
  • Confirms AgentVault's own engineering guide is factually correct about Polytician: it
    references src/orchestration/polytician-enricher.ts (which is real and matches this
    repo's expected search_concepts/read_concept MCP contract) and correctly flags its
    hard character-count truncation as the reason to eventually route through Short-Hand's
    CompactionEngine — no changes needed on Polytician's side for that future migration.
  • Links the new docs, the PRD, and the PolyVault spec from README.md's new "Ecosystem"
    section — previously the README made no mention of the AgentVault/PolyVault integration
    at all, despite it accounting for roughly a third of src/ and docs/.

Test plan

  • Docs-only change; no code touched. npm run typecheck / npm test not required but
    unaffected.
  • Verified all internal markdown links resolve to files present in this PR/repo.
  • Verified every AgentVault-side claim against a specific fetched file (see tables in
    docs/ecosystem/engineering-guide.md) rather than repeating unverified README claims.

Generated by Claude Code

Cross-checks the AGENTVAULT_COMPATIBILITY_PRD.md task list against
AgentVault's actual main branch (fetched via raw GitHub URLs, since this
session's API scope is polytician-only): 4 of 7 tasks are already shipped
(REST bridge, config parser, orchestrator enrichment, CLI subcommands),
2 are confirmed not started (canister MCP registry, webapp dashboard),
and 1 is unverifiable from this side. Also links the AgentVault/PolyVault
integration from the README, which previously made no mention of it.
@johnnyclem
johnnyclem merged commit 33432d8 into main Jul 2, 2026
4 of 7 checks passed
@johnnyclem
johnnyclem deleted the claude/blissful-hypatia-50g32e branch July 2, 2026 05:47
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants