Environment
- OS: Windows 11
- ynab-mcp: prebuilt release binary
- Installed to:
C:\Users\<user>\.local\bin\ynab-mcp.exe
Issue 1: store-token silently fails on Windows Credential Manager
Running ynab-mcp store-token interactively, pasting a valid YNAB Personal Access Token, reports success. Immediately running ynab-mcp status reports:
- Storage method: Environment Variables
- "No valid token found"
Confirmed no credential entry is written:
cmdkey /list | Select-String -Pattern "ynab" -CaseSensitive:$false
returns nothing.
Expected: store-token writes successfully, or surfaces an error explaining the failure. Actual: apparent silent failure with contradictory status output.
Issue 2: Token env var names not documented
When falling back to env vars (via --no-keyring), the README and help text (ynab-mcp --help, ynab-mcp run --help, ynab-mcp store-token --help) do not document which env var the tool reads for the token.
Binary string extraction reveals both YNAB_API_TOKEN and YNAB_ACCESS_TOKEN are compiled in. Precedence and whether both are read is unclear.
Suggested: add an "Environment Variables" section to the README with the exact variable names and precedence order.
Issue 3: No obvious read-only mode
When the MCP connects, all 16 tools including writes (create_transaction, update_transaction, set_category_budget, etc.) are exposed unconditionally. For a personal finance tool, some default safety around LLM-initiated mutations feels appropriate.
If READ_ONLY_MODE exists, it is not documented in README or help. Suggested: add an explicit read-only flag as a first-class option.
Workaround for Windows installers
MCP client config:
"ynab": {
"command": "C:\\path\\to\\ynab-mcp.exe",
"args": ["--no-keyring", "run"],
"env": {
"YNAB_API_TOKEN": "...",
"YNAB_ACCESS_TOKEN": "..."
}
}
Happy to provide more diagnostics if useful! Take care.
Environment
C:\Users\<user>\.local\bin\ynab-mcp.exeIssue 1:
store-tokensilently fails on Windows Credential ManagerRunning
ynab-mcp store-tokeninteractively, pasting a valid YNAB Personal Access Token, reports success. Immediately runningynab-mcp statusreports:Confirmed no credential entry is written:
returns nothing.
Expected:
store-tokenwrites successfully, or surfaces an error explaining the failure. Actual: apparent silent failure with contradictorystatusoutput.Issue 2: Token env var names not documented
When falling back to env vars (via
--no-keyring), the README and help text (ynab-mcp --help,ynab-mcp run --help,ynab-mcp store-token --help) do not document which env var the tool reads for the token.Binary string extraction reveals both
YNAB_API_TOKENandYNAB_ACCESS_TOKENare compiled in. Precedence and whether both are read is unclear.Suggested: add an "Environment Variables" section to the README with the exact variable names and precedence order.
Issue 3: No obvious read-only mode
When the MCP connects, all 16 tools including writes (
create_transaction,update_transaction,set_category_budget, etc.) are exposed unconditionally. For a personal finance tool, some default safety around LLM-initiated mutations feels appropriate.If
READ_ONLY_MODEexists, it is not documented in README or help. Suggested: add an explicit read-only flag as a first-class option.Workaround for Windows installers
MCP client config:
Happy to provide more diagnostics if useful! Take care.