Repository navigation
Conversation
Evidence-backed Identity & Comms listing (agent-identity-communication) from first-party docs, connect, and Connection Kit (@agentel/sdk).
|
I found missing media metadata and/or repo-managed submitter metadata that should be written back to the PR branch. I can't push directly to forked PR branches, but you can generate the same changes locally with: git fetch 'https://github.com/bradvin/agentfirst.directory.git' '755fb203681550170c5bb80014318322d80fe6b4'
git worktree add --detach '../agentfirst-base-84' FETCH_HEAD
npm run sync:tool-submitters -- --base-root-dir '../agentfirst-base-84' --submitted-by 'vpfun' --slug 'agentel'
npm run enrich:tool-assets -- --write --slug 'agentel'
git worktree remove '../agentfirst-base-84'Then commit the updated files to this PR branch. |
Add logoUrl/ogImageUrl enrichment and tool-submitters entry for agentel (vpfun).
|
Outcome: evidence-requested Policy assessment @vpfun Agentel otherwise clears the inclusion test: agents are the core participants, and the documented machine-first registration, persistent identity, authenticated profiles and relationships, public work, and trust-evidence reads support the The evidence record is not yet materially complete for pricing. The profile sets Evidence checked
Checks run On exact head |
|
Thanks for the review. Commit 883ee25 adds the requested official-pricing evidence, distinguishing the available Free tier, activation-gated Builder/Premium plans, and planned, approval-required Creator plan. The latest Enrich Tool Assets check passes. Could you re-review the evidence and have a maintainer approve the pending Validate Content run #222? |
|
Outcome: changes-requested Policy assessment @vpfun The requested pricing evidence has been added, but current first-party sources no longer support two claims in tools/agentel.md. The complete initial-PR-diff review otherwise supports agent-native / web-application / Identity & Comms: agents are the network's core participants, and registration, durable identity, authenticated profiles/relationships, public work and trust-evidence reads provide concrete agent value. The product URL identifies Agentel; the Connection Kit repository contains genuine TypeScript/JavaScript implementation, not a README-only stub. Required frontmatter, evidence structure and documentation-reviewed provenance pass. Please address all of these current findings together:
Evidence checked Every evidence item was checked at its exact submitted URL without redirect substitution:
The independent contradiction pass also covered the homepage, repository README/source/package and releases, https://registry.npmjs.org/@agentel/sdk, official skill metadata, /lab/mcp, Terms and Privacy. No agent registration, credentialed operation or billing was exercised. Evidence requiring correction or removal
Please correct or remove each evidence item above. Checks run Exact head 883ee25 was merged without committing into current main 21adcb7 in an isolated clone. npm run validate:content passed (59 tools, 16 categories); npm test passed 90/90 with Node 26.7.0 and Bash 5.3.20. The initial suite attempt hit macOS Bash 3.2's missing mapfile; the unchanged tree passed after selecting installed Bash 5. GitHub enrichment is successful; no completed GitHub content-validation check was returned. No SEO evaluation, reviewer commit, workflow approval, PR approval or merge was applied. |
|
Thanks for the review. Commit 63c554d addresses the three findings together, and the PR description now reflects the revised listing.
Validation of this commit merged locally, without committing, into current main GitHub's Enrich Tool Assets run for this exact commit succeeded. Validate Content run #246 requires maintainer approval and has not executed its validation job. Could you re-review the revised evidence and have a maintainer approve run #246? Verification remains documentation-reviewed; no registration, credentialed Agent operations, billing, or live MCP tests were performed. |
|
Outcome: changes-requested Policy assessment @vpfun The revision resolves the SDK/channel and MCP-suitability findings: current docs, npm latest, repository package metadata and the official skill index agree on Connection Kit 2.0.0; the listing now accurately bounds the hosted read-only MCP. The five claim-level evidence items support the documentary observations they state. The settled agent-native / Identity & Comms assessment is not reopened. One earlier request remains unresolved: current paid availability. The revised listing correctly discloses the conflict, but disclosure does not reconcile it or establish the current Evidence checked Each submitted evidence URL returned HTTP 200 at the exact URL, without redirect substitution:
The independent contradiction pass also covered the homepage, SDK README/source/package/licence and releases, npm metadata, official skill manifest, Terms and Privacy. The SDK's MIT licence is not a hosted-network open-source claim. No registration, credentialed operation, paid checkout or live MCP session was exercised. Checks run Exact head 63c554d was merged without committing into current main 21adcb7 in an isolated clone. |
|
Thanks for confirming the SDK and MCP corrections. On pricing, two separate points need to be clear: Basic Agentel use is free; no paid Agentel subscription is required to start. The docs mark the Free baseline active for claimed and unclaimed Agents, and Connect documents registration without human login and optional claiming. Free includes identity and profiles, connections, public posts/replies and reactions, Skill discovery, and Trust-evidence reads. The published Free limits are finite:
The published paid tiers describe optional enhancements, not prerequisites for that baseline. Their official names are Builder and Agentel Premium, with higher quotas and additional features. Creator remains planned and approval-required. This describes the published offering, not verified upgrade availability. Rechecked on 2026-10-10, pricing still labels Builder/Premium available, while docs describe gated checkout and Connect/MCP say paid plans are not open. I have not verified checkout or activation. Those conflicting sources do not establish the currently available paid upgrade required by the repository's Commit 9664c56 changes The remote submitted file matches the locally tested file. Content validation passed on the branch and on its equivalent result merged into current main Could you re-review this narrower classification and have a maintainer approve run #252? Verification remains documentation-reviewed; no registration, credentialed Agent operations, billing, or live MCP tests were performed. |
|
Hi @foo-bender, a gentle follow-up on the revised listing in commit 9664c56. It takes the alternative requested in your last review: Could you re-review that revision and, if it addresses the remaining finding, move the listing back to review? Validate Content run #252 is still awaiting maintainer approval; could a maintainer approve it so the repository validation can run? The enrichment check for this head has passed. Please let me know if any further author changes are needed. Thanks for your time! |
|
Outcome: changes-requested Policy assessment@vpfun The narrower pricing revision resolves the prior request: There is one current-source correction in the final evidence array: the MCP page has changed since the prior review and now documents six tools, while its evidence claim still says "Five tools". Please update that count to six or remove the unnecessary count. This is source drift, not a renewed suitability objection or another request to prove paid checkout. No other material issue was found in the scoped revision, direct frontmatter inspection or contradiction pass. No duplicate was found on the published site or in another open PR. Evidence checkedEvery submitted evidence URL returned HTTP 200 at its exact URL, without redirect substitution:
The independent current-source pass also checked the homepage, repository README/source/package/licence/releases, npm metadata, official skill manifest, Terms and Privacy. SDK MIT licensing is not a hosted-network open-source claim. No registration, credentialed operation, payment or live MCP session was performed. Evidence requiring correction or removal
Please correct or remove each evidence item above. Checks runExact head
|
|
Thanks @foo-bender. Commit e9e16e8 corrects the remaining source-drift finding: the MCP evidence now says “Six tools”, and its access date is 2026-10-22. I reopened the exact official MCP page today and confirmed its “Six tools” heading and list_missions entry. The PR description is synchronized. The commit diff changes only those two lines in tools/agentel.md; remote readback confirms the submitted content. The current enrichment check has passed. Validate Content run #300 requires maintainer approval and has not completed content validation; earlier full-test results remain attributed to their original commits. Could you re-review this correction and have a maintainer approve the current validation run? Verification remains documentation-reviewed. Thank you! |
|
Outcome: meets-policy Policy assessment The two-line contributor revision resolves the remaining request: the exact MCP page says Six tools and includes list_missions. The updated evidence count and access date agree. The settled agent-native / Identity & Comms, SDK 2.0.0 and bounded hosted MCP findings are not reopened. The established Free baseline remains distinguished from unresolved paid activation; no purchase is required to take the previously accepted pricing alternative. Direct final-frontmatter inspection and the independent current-source contradiction pass found no new material blocker. The concrete agent value remains persistent authenticated identity, relationships, public work and trust-evidence reads across externally operated runtimes. No published or open-PR duplicate was found. @bradvin for the inclusion decision. Evidence checked
Reviewer-owned SEO metadata tools/agentel.md
Reviewer commit: 1bc95a2 (1bc95a2). The existing description, body and every other non-editorial byte were preserved. reviewedBy is foo-bender; reviewedAt is 2026-10-22. Checks run Exact final head 1bc95a2 merged without committing with current main d5a6bbd in an isolated temporary clone:
|
|
Thanks @foo-bender for the re-review and the editorial metadata. Noted that the final head 1bc95a2 meets policy and is awaiting the inclusion decision. @bradvin, could you consider the listing and approve the current Validate Content run #301 when appropriate? The run still requires maintainer action. The reviewer’s isolated validation is recorded above; it is separate from an executed upstream CI check. Happy to address any further feedback. |
Summary
Evidence-backed listing for Agentel under Identity & Comms (
agent-identity-communication).Agentel is a hosted network layer for AI agents providing durable identity, profiles, relationships, public work, and evidence across runtimes. Classification:
agent-native. Interfaces: REST API, TypeScript/JavaScript SDK (@agentel/sdk), and a hosted read-only MCP surface for eligible public network context.Evidence (first-party)
The MCP page was rechecked on 2026-10-22 and documents six read-only tools, including
list_missions. The other three live Agentel pages were last rechecked on 2026-10-10; SDK repository, npm, and Skill metadata were checked on 2026-10-09.Current docs identify Connection Kit
@agentel/sdk@2.0.0stable, matching npm latest, repository package metadata, and the official Skill manifest. The previous 1.2.1 pin and obsolete channel comparison have been removed. Package name is@agentel/sdk(not the unrelated npm packageagentel).Pricing is
freeunder the repository definition: the usable $0 Free baseline is established, while a currently available paid upgrade is not. Free includes identity, profiles, connections, ordinary public work, reactions, Skill discovery, and Trust reads, with finite API, publishing, media, connection, and reading allowances. Published Builder ($9.99/month) and Agentel Premium ($19.99/month) tiers describe optional higher quotas and features. Pricing labels them available, but docs describe gated checkout and Connect/MCP say paid plans are not open; actual paid checkout and activation remain unverified. Creator remains planned and approval-required.The hosted MCP requires a registered identity and separate read-only information credential. Its six tools read eligible public context under quotas; client interoperability has not been tested for this listing.
Boundaries
documentation-reviewed; no registration, credentials, billing, or live MCP operations were exercisedDisclosure
I am affiliated with Agentel.
Validation
The 2026-10-22 follow-up corrects only the MCP tool count and its evidence access date. Historical test results below apply to the cited earlier commit. Current upstream content validation still requires maintainer approval.
Commit
9664c565ea428ddc007fe8c87d7e8b667c9a664bchanges onlytools/agentel.md. Local validation of the submitted file and existing submitter metadata passed. The equivalent PR result on current main21adcb7a09fad26aa707f061d341e509b270db4dpassednpm run validate:content -- --require-submitters(59 tools, 16 categories) andnpm test(90/90) with Node 26.4.0 and Bash 5.3.0.