Description
Split from #168 (Federated Model Training) — bug-fix-and-re-benchmark task rather than the general training/exploration work in the parent issue.
Findings so far (WG meeting, 19 Aug 2026, investigated by @gcordova10 ):
- Hard-coded data-split configuration found in the codebase
- Training/validation filtering mismatch identified
- Ablation studies show camera features currently contribute minimally to results
- Constant-velocity baseline currently outperforms the learned models — ablations point to the data/config issue above rather than an architecture problem
Findings — 25 Aug 2026 (@FLagbusted's run, reviewed by @gcordova10 ):
- @FLagbusted's run confirmed again that the constant-velocity baseline beats the learned model
- @gcordova10's review found: different input was used at each trial, so the code needs to be run consistently before results are meaningful; open questions on how the output was obtained, a right/left trajectory discrepancy, behavior across branches with different ego-motion dropout rates, and how input is supplied differently between training and validation — this lines up with, and sharpens, the train/val filtering mismatch above
- Best BEV fix so far reaches ADE 0.86
- Metric validity flagged directly: ADE compares against human maneuver, which may not be the right basis for comparison when the failure originates upstream in perception/camera rather than in the planner. Route/map/camera ablation (including camera features not fed at all) shows the metric's sensitivity to this. ADE could need to be changed for this aspect, meaning this may call for a new or modified metric
- Proposed directions: a metric that penalizes off-road predictions, ablations broken out by track position (front/right/left, on-road vs. off-road), and a more direct way to evaluate perception quality rather than relying only on end-to-end trajectory error
- Training noise noted: 3 seeds used, compared night by night
- Results expected within the week
Identified To do List:
Description
Split from #168 (Federated Model Training) — bug-fix-and-re-benchmark task rather than the general training/exploration work in the parent issue.
Findings so far (WG meeting, 19 Aug 2026, investigated by @gcordova10 ):
Findings — 25 Aug 2026 (@FLagbusted's run, reviewed by @gcordova10 ):
Identified To do List: