Author input: Gate 1 run commit, --use-case, product rights and archive target (blocks P3) #46

Activity

1. mdenolle

   added this to the Iteration 3 revision milestone on Sep 11, 2026
2. mdenolle

   added

   P3provenance, release, real-data figuresprovenance, release, real-data figures

   needs-authordecision or input only the author can supplydecision or input only the author can supply

   review-iter2from the iteration-2 pre-submission reviewfrom the iteration-2 pre-submission review

   on Sep 11, 2026
3. mdenolle commented on Nov 1, 2026

   

   mdenolle

   on Nov 1, 2026

   MemberAuthor

   More actions

   Answered and acted on in PR #55.

   • All four bands archived. 1-2, 2-4, 4-8 and 8-16 Hz at the three stations are tracked in the repository with their pre-correction originals, digests (CHECKSUMS.sha256, MANIFEST.json) and licence terms. The comparison figure now regenerates from any checkout, so CI checks it instead of skipping it.
   • Rights. paper/data/gate1/DATA_LICENCE.md quotes the SCEDC grant verbatim from its open-data registry entry (right to use, reproduce and publicly display, citation required) and names the two DOIs: 10.7909/C3WD3xH1 for the data center and 10.7914/SN/CI for the network. Both are now cited in the data availability statement. Only derived daily series are redistributed, no waveforms or correlations. One decision is left to you: the licence for our own derived products, proposed as CC BY 4.0 in that file.
   • Use case: groundwater, recovered rather than assumed. The dv/v stage hashes its effective configuration into the config_hash column; that digest is reproduced by the groundwater recommendation on all four bands and by no other use case or fallback. At 2-4 Hz it gives the 2 to 8 s window, as you expected.
   • Commit: be1538b. The products were written at 15:25 on 2026-08-09; be1538b is the last commit to the dv/v stage before that, nothing landed in the pipeline repository in between, and the next change is 567fb8b on 2026-08-17. It is also the latest of the three candidates, so the instruction and the evidence agree.

   Both claims are pinned by tests, so a later change to the use-case recommendations fails a test rather than leaving the paper asserting something untrue. What remains in #41: the licence confirmation and the versioned deposit with a DOI, both at the release.
4. mdenolle

   added a commit that references this issue on Nov 1, 2026

   Merge pull request #55 from Denolle-Lab/iter3/P3-archive

   ...

   5d2d223