[Question][RSPEC-2208] Is `Wildcard imports should not be used` in js supposed to be marked as 'critical'?

[wootra]

this issue is about this rule page: https://rules.sonarsource.com/javascript/RSPEC-2208/

while I agree that this should not be used for everytime, I still think this is not a critical but up to developer's decision.

for example, if I have 2 files which hold a lot of same functions, and I have to import them at the same time, using wildcard is pretty clear to differentiate those functions instead of importing them with bunch of aliases.

// mobile.js
export const clickButton(){...}
export const selectTab(){...}
export const getImageList(){...}
// desktop.js
export const clickButton(){...}
export const selectTab(){...}
export const getImageList(){...}

// app.js
import * as mobile from './mobile'
import * as desktop from './desktop'
const clickButton(){
  if(screen === 'mobile') mobile.clickButton();
  else if(screen === 'desktop') desktop.clickButton();
}
...

but If we don't use wildcard, we might need to do something like this:

import {
  clickButton as mobileClickButton,
  selectTab as mobileSelectTab,
  getImageList as mobileGetImageList
}
...

I don't think above code is cleaner than the first code.
In my opinion, this should be marked a minor rather than critical or should be removed.