diff --git a/.proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md b/.proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..46e95fb9c --- /dev/null +++ b/.proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md @@ -0,0 +1,138 @@ +# Mac Mini Review-Rework Proof + +REVIEW_REWORK_STATUS: fulfilled + +## Scope + +Proof-only rework pass for the Paw Patrol review-rework loop after the worker pull request reuse fix. + +Only this Markdown file is updated: + +```text +.proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md +``` + +No source code, entity spec, WASM integration, Cedar policy, config, lockfile, channel, Discord, Railway, or deployment file was changed. + +The reviewer-requested rework was fulfilled. + +## Live Entities + +| Entity | ID or status | Evidence | +| --- | --- | --- | +| WorkRequest or legacy PatrolRequest | en-019e0588-e4d3-72f1-900a-d138197d2620 | https://openpaw-production.up.railway.app/tdata/WorkRequests('en-019e0588-e4d3-72f1-900a-d138197d2620') | +| FactoryCase | en-019e0589-025d-7c60-8e9e-ee76785ccb66 | https://openpaw-production.up.railway.app/tdata/FactoryCases('en-019e0589-025d-7c60-8e9e-ee76785ccb66') | +| WorkCycle | wc-019e0589-0acc-71f2-98c3-398685b5acf7 | https://openpaw-production.up.railway.app/tdata/WorkCycles('wc-019e0589-0acc-71f2-98c3-398685b5acf7') | +| WorkerRun ids | first pass: en-019e0589-11d7-72a1-8218-dd6627c201f7; rework pass: this local reviewer-requested run, reported by paw-codex-worker after Codex exits | first pass commit `74549487dc22d7c3000087d6de22410186d28640`; current run ID was not exposed to this local process | +| ReviewRun ids | reviewer requested changes for this loop; concrete ReviewRun ID unavailable to this local process | reviewer feedback was supplied in the rework task; unauthenticated OData reads returned HTTP 401 | +| EvaluationRun | queued or updated after the rework WorkerRun reports done | concrete EvaluationRun ID unavailable to this local process before worker closeout | +| ProofPacket | updated after the rework WorkerRun reports done | concrete ProofPacket ID unavailable to this local process before worker closeout | +| Pull request | https://github.com/nerdsane/temperpaw/pull/238 | `gh pr view` returned PR 238, state OPEN, head `codex/paw-patrol-197d2620`, base `codex/paw-patrol-worker-reporting` | + +## State Diagram + +```mermaid +stateDiagram-v2 + [*] --> FirstWorkerRun + FirstWorkerRun: WorkerRun en-019e0589-11d7-72a1-8218-dd6627c201f7 + FirstWorkerRun --> FirstPassProof: create first-pass proof marker + FirstPassProof --> ReviewerGate: worker reports done + ReviewerGate --> ChangesRequested: reviewer observes marker + ChangesRequested --> ReworkWorkerRun: WorkCycle queues same-branch rework + ReworkWorkerRun --> FinalProof: replace status and add rework sentence + FinalProof --> EvaluationRun: run lightweight Markdown verification + EvaluationRun --> ProofPacket: ready visual proof + ProofPacket --> WorkCycleComplete +``` + +## Changed-Files Map + +```mermaid +flowchart LR + Branch["codex/paw-patrol-197d2620"] --> Proof[".proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md"] + Proof --> Marker["REVIEW_REWORK_STATUS: fulfilled"] + Proof --> Mermaid["Mermaid state diagram"] + Proof --> Evidence["PR, entity links, verification notes"] + Proof --> Rework["Reviewer-requested rework sentence"] +``` + +## Red-Green TDD + +Red check was run before the rework edit: + +```text +bash -lc 'set -euo pipefail +file=.proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md +rg -n "^REVIEW_REWORK_STATUS: fulfilled$" "$file" +rg -n "reviewer[-]requested rework was fulfilled" "$file" +! rg -n "^REVIEW_REWORK_STATUS: needs[_]changes$" "$file" +' +``` + +Result: failed as expected before implementation because the fulfilled marker and required sentence were absent. + +Green checks for this rework pass verify: + +```text +test -f .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md +rg -n '^REVIEW_REWORK_STATUS: fulfilled$' .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md +rg -n 'reviewer[-]requested rework was fulfilled' .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md +! rg -n '^REVIEW_REWORK_STATUS: needs[_]changes$' .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md +! rg -n 'REVIEW_REWORK_STATUS: needs[_]changes' .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md +rg -n '^```mermaid$' .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md +git diff --check -- .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md +git diff --check HEAD^ HEAD +awk 'BEGIN{f=0} /^```/{f++} END{exit(f%2)}' .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md +gh pr view --json number,url,headRefName,baseRefName,state,title +``` + +Rework verification results: + +```text +file exists: yes +fulfilled marker: line 3 +required rework sentence: line 17 +retired first-pass marker: no matches +Mermaid code fences: lines 34 and 50 +git diff --check -- .proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md: passed with no output +git diff --check HEAD^ HEAD: passed with no output +Markdown fence balance with awk: passed with no output +changed file scope: +.proofs/mac-mini-review-rework-20260508T030158Z.md +gh pr view: +number 238, state OPEN, head codex/paw-patrol-197d2620, base codex/paw-patrol-worker-reporting, url https://github.com/nerdsane/temperpaw/pull/238 +``` + +## E2E Evidence + +This rework pass touched only a Markdown proof artifact, so no server boot, Discord flow, deployment, or WASM hot-load was relevant. + +Reviewer-requested read-only checks were repeated locally: + +```text +git diff --check HEAD^ HEAD +marker checks with rg +Markdown fence balance with awk +gh pr view +read-only OData curls +``` + +Read-only OData unauthenticated result: + +```text +WorkCycle wc-019e0589-0acc-71f2-98c3-398685b5acf7 endpoint probe: HTTP 401 +WorkerRun en-019e0589-11d7-72a1-8218-dd6627c201f7 endpoint probe: HTTP 401 +ReviewRuns collection probe: HTTP 401 +EvaluationRuns collection probe: HTTP 401 +ProofPackets collection probe: HTTP 401 +Branch: codex/paw-patrol-197d2620 +Worktree: /Users/openclaw/Development/temperpaw-worktrees/codex-paw-patrol-197d2620 +``` + +The rework stayed on the same branch and PR, exercising the Temper-native WorkCycle rework path without adding orchestration code. + +## Risk Notes + +- Architecture: no material architecture change; no ADR required. +- Temper-native boundary: this proof relies on existing WorkerRun, ReviewRun, EvaluationRun, WorkCycle, and ProofPacket entity transitions rather than adding orchestration code. +- Residual proof-only risk: concrete rework WorkerRun, ReviewRun, EvaluationRun, and ProofPacket IDs are not available inside this local Codex process before paw-codex-worker reports completion to Temper.