ksh inherits readonly exported variables from the parent, breaking scripts

[vlmarek]

$ ksh --version
  version         sh (AT&T Research) 93u+m/1.0.0-beta.2 2021-12-17

I know, not the latest version so I'm terribly sorry if I report already fixed issue.

$ cat aaa
#!/usr/bin/ksh
VAR=yes
typeset -p VAR

$ chmod +x aaa

$ ksh -c 'readonly VAR=foo ; export VAR; ./aaa' 
./aaa: line 1: VAR: is read only


# similarly integer variables

$ ksh -c 'typeset -i VAR=123; export VAR; ./aaa'
typeset -x -i VAR=0

I would expect the new process inherit the exported variable, but not the type of variable. The script can protect himself against integer variables by running typeset VAR=yes which is not reasonable (to me) to do for any and all variables used. I don't know if there is a way to un-readonly a variable at all.

[McDutchie]

Hi, you reported this to the inactive AT&T repo and this is not where current ksh 93u+m development happens. Please upgrade to the latest release and report any bugs to https://github.com/ksh93/ksh. But yes, this issue has long since been fixed.

In the ksh 93u+m/1.0.x release series, we need to keep inheriting variable attributes through the environment for backward compatibility, but I've disabled it for readonly because scripts have no way to unset that attribute (see ksh93@7954855), and I've also disabled it for all attributes in POSIX mode, i.e., when ksh is invoked as sh (see ksh93@00d4396). In the dev branch (which will become the ksh 93u+m/1.1.x release series), this misfeature has been removed completely (see ksh93@f215b10).

[UST95]

Merhaba, bunu etkin olmayan AT&T deposuna bildirdiniz ve şu anki ksh 93u+m geliştirmesi burada gerçekleşmiyor. Lütfen en son sürüme yükseltin ve hataları https://github.com/ksh93/ksh adresine bildirin . Ama evet, bu sorun çoktan çözüldü.

ksh 93u+m/1.0.x sürüm serisinde, geriye dönük uyumluluk için değişken niteliklerini ortam aracılığıyla devralmaya devam etmemiz gerekiyor, ancak bunu salt okunur olarak devre dışı bıraktım çünkü betiklerin bu niteliği kaldırma yolu yok (bkz. ksh93@ 7954855 ) ve ayrıca bunu POSIX modundaki tüm nitelikler için devre dışı bıraktım, yani ksh sh olarak çağrıldığında (bkz. ksh93@ 00d4396 ). Dev dalında (ksh 93u+m/1.1.x sürüm serisi olacak), bu yanlış özellik tamamen kaldırıldı (bkz. ksh93@ f215b10 ).

111