Sovereign Node Key — Production Authorization & Integrity

This document explains what the Sovereign Node Key system is, what it proves, and how to use it safely.

Overview

A Sovereign Node Key is a production authorization credential consisting of:

Node identity — Ed25519 keypair uniquely identifying a provisioned node
Authorization record — Operator-signed proof that this node is authorized for protected operations
Repository commitment — SHA-256 hash of repository state at key generation time
Prior-art timestamp — Tamper-evident record of when this work existed
Signer identity — Public key for signature verification

What It Proves

Node Authorization (NEW)

✓ The PAX-Coder authority has provisioned and authorized this node
✓ The authorization is cryptographically bound to this node's public key
✓ The authorization is operator-signed and cannot be self-created
✓ Protected operations require a valid authorization record
✓ Unauthorized, revoked, or expired nodes are denied

Integrity

✓ The repository has not been tampered with since the key was generated
✓ Every file's hash is recorded in manifest.json
✓ The manifest itself is committed in prior_art.json

Timestamp

✓ This code existed at a specific UTC time
✓ The git commit hash is cryptographically tied to that moment
✓ The prior-art timestamp is tamper-evident (local or Bitcoin-anchored)

Authenticity

✓ Outputs signed with this key were produced by the holder of .node_sk
✓ The public key (node_pk.pem) can verify any signature
✓ No one else can sign with this key (assuming the private key remains private)

Non-Repudiation

✓ The signer cannot later deny having created the signature
✓ The signature proves possession of the private key at the time of signing

What It Does NOT Prove (Alone)

Node Authorization (Without Authorization Record)

✗ Node identity alone does not grant authorization
✗ A valid signature does not grant authorization
✗ Possession of a node key does not grant authorization

Authorization requires: valid operator-signed authorization record + ACTIVE status + valid lifetime + non-revoked status

Legal Ownership

✗ Does the signer own the work?
✗ Can the signer license it?
✗ Are there copyright claims?

Not embedded in the crypto. Use separate legal instruments (licenses, trust deeds, copyright notices).

Work Quality

✗ Is the code correct?
✗ Does it do what it claims?
✗ Is it actually proven?

Not proven by this system. Use formal verification, testing, and code review.

Blockchain Confirmation

✗ Is this anchored to Bitcoin?
✗ Is the timestamp immutable?
✗ Can this be reversed?

Not unless explicitly anchored. The timestamp is local; see prior_art.json status for Bitcoin confirmation status.

Security Properties

Confidentiality

The private key MUST remain private
If compromised, all signatures are worthless
Rotate the key immediately if compromise is suspected

Integrity

The public key is safe to share
The manifest and prior-art record must not be modified after commitment
Verification scripts detect tampering

Authenticity

Only the private-key holder can create valid signatures
The public key proves who signed

Accountability

The public key is permanently associated with all outputs
There is no anonymous signing

Private Key Management

Never Do This

✗ Commit .node_sk to git
✗ Upload .node_sk to GitHub
✗ Email or message the private key
✗ Store in plaintext in cloud storage
✗ Share the private key with anyone
✗ Use weak file permissions (must be 400)
✗ Keep the private key in a public directory

Do This Instead

✓ Generate the key with ./generate_node_key.sh
✓ File permissions are set to 400 automatically
✓ Keep in a secure local directory (e.g., ~/.pax-node-keys/)
✓ Backup encrypted (e.g., to a YubiKey, hardware wallet, or encrypted USB)
✓ Rotate periodically (e.g., annually)
✓ Use environment variables when signing (never hardcode the key)

Example secure usage:

export PAX_NODE_KEY=$(cat ~/.pax-node-keys/node_sk | xxd -p | tr -d '\n')
openssl dgst -sha256 -sign ~/.pax-node-keys/node_sk output.ptx
unset PAX_NODE_KEY  # Clear from environment after use

Verification Procedure

For Your Own Outputs

Verify that all cryptographic artifacts are consistent:

cd sovereign
./verify_node_key.sh

Checks:

Public files exist and are valid JSON
Private key has correct permissions (400)
Git commit is in repository history
Repository commitment hash is correct
No private key material leaked to git

For Someone Else's Outputs

Get the public key
From their node.json:
```
"public_key_hex": "..." 
```

Get the prior-art record
From their prior_art.json:

{
  "git_commit": "...",
  "repository_sha256": "...",
  "created_at_utc": "..."
}

Verify the signature

openssl dgst -sha256 -verify <(echo "PUBLIC_KEY_HEX" | xxd -r -p) \
  -signature output.sig output.ptx

Check the timestamp
The created_at_utc field is when they claimed the key was generated
The git_commit is the repository state at that time
Compare both to independent sources
Spot-check the manifest
Pick a few files from manifest.json and verify:
```
sha256sum file1 file2 file3  # Should match values in manifest
```

Trust Boundaries

Trust Assumption: Private Key is Private

If the private key is compromised, all signatures are worthless. The security model collapses.

Trust Assumption: Public Key is Authentic

If you receive the public key through an insecure channel, you cannot trust the signatures. Use a secure channel (e.g., GitHub, verified fingerprints, institutional databases).

Trust Assumption: Git History is Honest

The system assumes git commits are immutable. If the repository is force-pushed or the git history is rewritten, the timestamps are no longer reliable.

Weaker Assumption: Clocks are Roughly Synchronized

Timestamps are local UTC. No assumption is made about perfect clock accuracy; only that times are roughly correct.

Attack Scenarios

Scenario 1: Private Key Compromise

If someone steals the private key:

They can sign fake outputs
All signatures become untrustworthy
Immediate rotation is required

Mitigation:

Keep private key offline when not in use
Use hardware security modules (YubiKey, etc.)
Monitor signature usage for anomalies
Rotate the key if compromise is suspected

Scenario 2: Repository Tampering

If git history is rewritten:

Repository commitment hash no longer matches
verify_node_key.sh will detect the mismatch
The prior-art record is still valid (git commit hash is immutable once broadcast)

Mitigation:

Repository should use branch protection and signing requirements
Keep clones as offline backups
Publish git commits to multiple sources (GitHub, git server, etc.)

Scenario 3: Timestamp Forgery

If someone falsifies the timestamp:

The created_at_utc field in node.json is under their control
Only verifiable via external sources (blockchain, timestamping service)
The git commit hash is the real proof (git commits are immutable once broadcast)

Mitigation:

Anchor the prior-art record to Bitcoin or a timestamping service (see OpenTimestamps)
The unanchored timestamp is only as trustworthy as the git history
status field in prior_art.json indicates confirmation level

Scenario 4: Man-in-the-Middle Attack

If someone intercepts the public key:

You cannot trust signatures verified with the intercepted key
You may be verifying signatures from an attacker, not the real signer

Mitigation:

Retrieve the public key from an authenticated source (GitHub, institutional database)
Verify fingerprints over multiple channels
Use HTTPS with certificate pinning
Compare public key fingerprints across independent sources

Rotation

When to Rotate

Annually (as part of security hygiene)
Immediately if compromise is suspected
When the key holder leaves the organization
After a security audit recommends rotation

How to Rotate

Generate a new key: ./sovereign/generate_node_key_v2.sh
Create a rotation record that includes:
- Old node ID
- New node ID
- Reason for rotation
- Timestamp
- Signature by the old key (proving continuity)
Commit new key files + rotation record
Keep old private key in secure archive (do not delete)
Announce the rotation (e.g., update documentation)

Rotation Record Example

{
  "old_node_id": "pax-coder-1234567890",
  "new_node_id": "pax-coder-1234567999",
  "old_public_key": "...",
  "new_public_key": "...",
  "rotation_timestamp": "2026-08-18T00:00:00Z",
  "reason": "scheduled annual rotation",
  "signed_by_old_key": "..."
}

Disaster Recovery

If Private Key is Lost

Create a key-loss record (signed by the new key)
Rotate to a new key
Document the loss (for audit trail)
Disable the old key if possible

If Private Key is Stolen

Assume all signatures are compromised
Rotate immediately to a new key
Verify no unauthorized signatures exist
Publish a security notice
Update all dependent systems

If Repository is Corrupted

Verify against a known-good clone
Check the git commit hash in prior-art records
If mismatch, investigate the corruption
Restore from backup if necessary

CI/CD Integration

Add these checks to your CI/CD pipeline:

Secret Scanning

- name: Scan for private key material
  run: |
    if git grep -l "PRIVATE\|BEGIN.*KEY\|-----END" -- sovereign/ \
       | grep -v "\.md\|\.txt"; then
      echo "ERROR: Private key material detected in tracked files"
      exit 1
    fi

Integrity Verification

- name: Verify node key integrity
  run: |
    cd sovereign
    bash verify_node_key.sh

Manifest Validation

- name: Validate manifest JSON
  run: |
    jq . sovereign/manifest.json sovereign/node.json sovereign/verification.json

Permissions Check

- name: Ensure .node_sk is not tracked
  run: |
    if git ls-files | grep "\.node_sk"; then
      echo "ERROR: .node_sk should not be tracked by git"
      exit 1
    fi

Questions & Answers

Q: Is this blockchain-based?
A: No. The timestamps are local. Optional: anchor to Bitcoin via OpenTimestamps for immutability.

Q: Can I use RSA instead of Ed25519?
A: Yes, but Ed25519 is smaller, faster, and more secure. RSA requires larger keys.

Q: What if multiple people have the same private key?
A: Don't share the private key. Generate separate keys for each person; they'll have different node IDs.

Q: Can I sign outputs retroactively?
A: Yes, but the signature will reflect the current date, not the date the code was written.

Q: What about privacy?
A: The node ID and public key are publicly visible. If you want to hide your identity, use a different node identity for different projects.

Q: Can I revoke a key?
A: Yes, through key rotation. Mark the old key as revoked in the rotation record. The old signatures remain valid (you can't revoke history).

References

Ed25519: EdDSA signature scheme
SHA-256: NIST FIPS 180-4
OpenTimestamps: Timestamp with Bitcoin
GitHub Security: Commit signature verification

Last updated: 2026-08-18
System version: 1.0.0
License: BSL-1.1 / AGPL-3.0 / MPL-2.0

FilesExpand file tree

SOVEREIGN_NODE.md

Latest commit

History

SOVEREIGN_NODE.md

File metadata and controls

Sovereign Node Key — Production Authorization & Integrity

Overview

What It Proves

Node Authorization (NEW)

Integrity

Timestamp

Authenticity

Non-Repudiation

What It Does NOT Prove (Alone)

Node Authorization (Without Authorization Record)

Legal Ownership

Work Quality

Blockchain Confirmation

Security Properties

Confidentiality

Integrity

Authenticity

Accountability

Private Key Management

Never Do This

Do This Instead

Verification Procedure

For Your Own Outputs

For Someone Else's Outputs

Trust Boundaries

Trust Assumption: Private Key is Private

Trust Assumption: Public Key is Authentic

Trust Assumption: Git History is Honest

Weaker Assumption: Clocks are Roughly Synchronized

Attack Scenarios

Scenario 1: Private Key Compromise

Scenario 2: Repository Tampering

Scenario 3: Timestamp Forgery

Scenario 4: Man-in-the-Middle Attack

Rotation

When to Rotate

How to Rotate

Rotation Record Example

Disaster Recovery

If Private Key is Lost

If Private Key is Stolen

If Repository is Corrupted

CI/CD Integration

Secret Scanning

Integrity Verification

Manifest Validation

Permissions Check

Questions & Answers

References