ADMB stock assessment models add constraints to their recruitment deviation estimates. For example, the mean and sum of the recruitment deviations from BAM and ASAP are 0. However, the operating model from the model comparison project uses rnorm without constraints. The mean and sum of the randomly generated recruitment deviations will not be zero. The comparisons between OM and EMs could be found here: https://github.com/Bai-Li-NOAA/homework/blob/main/recruitment_deviations_check/recdev_check.md
To do:
Thanks Kyle Shertzer for pointing out the issue!
ADMB stock assessment models add constraints to their recruitment deviation estimates. For example, the mean and sum of the recruitment deviations from BAM and ASAP are 0. However, the operating model from the model comparison project uses rnorm without constraints. The mean and sum of the randomly generated recruitment deviations will not be zero. The comparisons between OM and EMs could be found here: https://github.com/Bai-Li-NOAA/homework/blob/main/recruitment_deviations_check/recdev_check.md
To do:
Thanks Kyle Shertzer for pointing out the issue!