My thoughts on this app

[liangforstudy]

Found this from Google! I wish this is still in development.

Sound is bad, not as good as musescore. But I guess it's ok because you coded this in your limited time?

To much shadows, I guess you are new?

First of all, I'm not a coder, I was looking as to why the Piano 3D app on ipad got deleted. Couldn't find why, but I found this git page instead

https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PL-CtCy9zQOPaLhA6BTCpGB_fi-lj9R6JO

[MengLinMaker]

At the moment there's not much incentive to improve the prototype app.

If you have a high quality 3D models of a piano, preferably as a GLTF / GLB file with animations, I would consider creating a better version.

I'd much rather create this from scratch to undo the bad technical decision made in this prototype.

Sound is bad, not as good as musescore. But I guess it's ok because you coded this in your limited time?

First time implementing a sampled sound engine - As I mentioned, a prototype.

The sound would be improved with:

• a better sample playing engine like libfluidsynth, used in MuseScore.
• higher quality samples - better SF3 samples than MuseScore 3.

I use a better sound engine and sample on another website: https://www.musidi.org/

MuseScore 4 quality samples are impractical for the web - due to longer loading times of large samples + the lack of VST implementations for the web.

To much shadows, I guess you are new?

Yes, I am new to creating 3D scenes. In hindsight there are better ways of exporting animating and shadows - using the GLTF format.