P0-14: Run manual mock evaluation

[McMabee]

Summary

Run a dry-run manual evaluation using the new benchmark and rubric to validate that the review process is actually usable.

Objective

Find ambiguity or missing rules before real model experiments begin.

Scope

• Mock review
• Rubric validation
• Review notes
• Refinement pass

Deliverable

• revised rubric wording
• short mock evaluation notes

Acceptance Criteria

• 2–3 clips are manually reviewed
• The new pass/fail rules are applied
• Ambiguities or vague wording are identified
• Review notes are recorded
• Rubric wording is refined based on findings
• The evaluation process survives a dry run without major confusion

Notes

This ticket depends on the benchmark and evaluation documents being mostly complete first.