P0-08: Define clip pass/fail rules

[McMabee]

Summary

Define exactly how a benchmark clip is judged as pass, fail, or borderline.

Objective

Make clip review objective enough that two reviewers would usually reach the same conclusion.

Scope

• Pass criteria
• Fail criteria
• Borderline criteria
• Must-pass threshold policy

Deliverable

• docs/pass_fail_clip_rules_v1.md

Acceptance Criteria

• Pass criteria are defined
• Fail criteria are defined
• Borderline criteria are defined
• Example fail cases are documented, including:
  • loses track for too long
  • frequent left/right limb swaps
  • lower body missed during core movement
  • skeleton too unstable for coaching review
• Policy is defined for whether all must-pass clips must pass or whether a threshold is acceptable
• Review instructions are clear enough for consistent use

Notes

Complete P0-06 before finalizing this ticket.