Skip to content

Recover and validate the bioHSI Figure 4g manual ROI coordinates #1

Description

@JVLegend

Blocker

T8c is paused because the official Figure 4 notebook loads manually_defined_rectangle_coordinates.json, but that artifact is absent from the public Zenodo archive, repository, release assets, branches, and Git history.

Author request: itai-levin/bioHSI#2
Reproduction diagnosis: https://github.com/JVLegend/HyperMix/blob/main/results/real_target_reproduction_diagnosis.md

Frozen evidence

The candidate geometry failed the preregistered gate:

  • HyperMix port: MAE 0.156114, Pearson r 0.375901
  • direct tagged source: MAE 0.158137, Pearson r 0.145083
  • gate: MAE <= 0.01 and Pearson r >= 0.99

No detector comparison has been performed.

Acceptable independent bridge

Any one of:

  • exact manual rectangle JSON used for Figure 4g;
  • official output directory or score map with those rectangles;
  • full-scene coordinates and concentration order;
  • deterministic transform linking archived local ROIs to notebook rectangles.

Acceptance

  • checksum and cite the recovered public artifact;
  • rerun the frozen reproduction gate without moving regions by detector score;
  • publish the result whether the gate passes or fails;
  • only then decide whether the detector comparison can proceed.

Do not optimize or visually reposition regions from detector outputs.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    data validationExternal data, metadata, coordinate, and reproduction validationhelp wantedExtra attention is needed

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions