Removing nodes from association group will add them if none exist

[mbbush]

I was reading through the code to try to learn more about how association groups work, and I found what appears to be a bug in the 4-in-1 sensor driver. I didn't look to see if the same bug is present in other drivers as well.

Hubitat/Drivers/inovelli-4-in-1-sensor.src/inovelli-4-in-1-sensor.groovy

Line 704 in 1b6a550

state."desiredAssociation${group}" = nodes

If state."desiredAssociation${group}" is null, the condition at the beginning of the function which seems designed to avoid a null pointer exception is assuming that the method was called with an attempt to add nodes, not remove them. That's probably true, but not necessarily; you can never fully predict what the user will try to do. As a consumer of the code, I find this behavior counter to what I'd expect. I'd expect an attempt to remove nodes from a null list to either be a no-op or an error.

I think it would be really easy to fix this to be a no-op, using the groovy "elvis" operator ?:. Just replace the entire method body with this:

        switch (action) {
            case 0:
                state."desiredAssociation${group}" = state."desiredAssociation${group}" ?: [] - nodes
            break
            case 1:
                state."desiredAssociation${group}" = state."desiredAssociation${group}" ?: [] + nodes
            break
        }

Note: I haven't tested this.

[apwelsh]

Seems it is a bug, and your solution should work. But as far as bugs go, it is a rather minor one that only results in the remove operation being a toggle.
I think your fix is sound.