Skip to content

Orchestrator registration always rejected with orchestrator_not_routable - requirements undocumented #1

Description

@saurabhp1801

Setup: hotkey 5GbhZBYMunT3Rv7Bd1twYjHPNX6v7af4Zi4LMqJJLJgBLzcW (UID 254, netuid 105), repo v0.2.1, Python 3.10, mainnet endpoints from docs.

What works: /auth/challenge + /auth/verify succeed (API key issued), NATS control connects to tls://orch-gateway.b1m.ai:4222, worker registration works (worker connects to our gateway).

What fails: every register message returns register_error: orchestrator_not_routable.

Evidence it is not a reachability problem:

  • Advertised url/gateway_url tested as both http://212.43.154.172:8000 and https://212-43-154-172.sslip.io (valid TLS cert)
  • GET /health returns 200 from the public internet on both; WebSocket upgrade on /ws/... responds correctly
  • Tested regions EU/europe/north-america, uid set and unset - identical rejection
  • Across 5,000+ registration attempts, access logs (direct and via reverse proxy) show zero inbound HTTP requests from BeamCore to the advertised URL - the check never contacts the orchestrator

Questions: What does the routability check validate? Are new orchestrator registrations open, or is onboarding gated/allowlisted? If gated, what is the approval process?

Client-side bugs found while debugging (separate but related):

  1. SubnetCoreClient.start_polling() is awaited during FastAPI lifespan startup, before uvicorn binds the port - any live probe at first registration would always fail; a fresh install can never register if the check probes synchronously.
  2. Field(env=...) names in neurons/orchestrator/core/config.py are silently ignored by pydantic-settings v2 - e.g. documented ORCHESTRATOR_WORKER_GATEWAY_URL does nothing; only WORKER_GATEWAY_URL (the uppercased field nameworks. Same forORCHESTRATOR_UIDvsUID`.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions