From 6ba46e02e7537794abb59804823379696236d4e1 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: skippy Date: Thu, 23 Jul 2026 23:59:41 -0500 Subject: [PATCH] =?UTF-8?q?chore(run-17):=20acceptance=20fixture=20+=20ric?= =?UTF-8?q?h=20classifications=20=E2=80=94=20first=20P0a-lane=20action?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Run-17 refresh of the vsdd-factory #312 board: watermark 753→758 (4 new issues, 1 P0b integrity #756), 10 maintainer PR merges + 4 tracked-defect closes, and the board's first P0a-lane action (#342 drew maintainer-authored PR #759, E-21 W1 — A4 discharged for #342, residue #365/#358 at 6/6 windows). Hard acted-on ceiling moves past P0b one window after the failed ramp prediction's horizon; result stays FAILED per the falsification protocol, movement reported descriptively. Gate passed clean against the run-16r3 canon. --- .../vsdd-factory-312-curated-run17.md | 711 ++++++++++++++++++ ...actory-312-run17-classifications-rich.json | 105 +++ 2 files changed, 816 insertions(+) create mode 100644 docs/fixtures/vsdd-factory-312-curated-run17.md create mode 100644 docs/fixtures/vsdd-factory-312-run17-classifications-rich.json diff --git a/docs/fixtures/vsdd-factory-312-curated-run17.md b/docs/fixtures/vsdd-factory-312-curated-run17.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4a77852 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/fixtures/vsdd-factory-312-curated-run17.md @@ -0,0 +1,711 @@ +# 📋 beadle — Triage Dashboard · drbothen/vsdd-factory + + + +**Direction verdict: 🟢 ON-COURSE** (instrument v2, capacity-adjusted) · watch: **A4 residue #365/#358** · this window: **first P0a-lane action on record (#342)** + +Revised 2026-07-22 (r2/r3, operator-ratified recalibration — beadle PRs #44/#45). Verdicts +are conditioned on maintainer capacity: **two humans holding this repo as one of hundreds +of projects** (episodic-side-project, the modal OSS shape). Prior results are preserved, +never re-scored. + +| At a glance | Result | Detail | +|---|---|---| +| PR acceptance | 🟢 **97%** (30/31, zero rejections) | agent/bot population baseline is 37–45%; human band 68–73% — the channel now clears both bars; #729 is the only open measured PR | +| Engagement cadence | 🟢 **6 attention windows / ~3.5 weeks** | per-window volume 3→5→31→2→22→14 actions — sustained top-percentile for a lightly maintained project | +| Merge latency | 🟢 **≤ 2 windows** | holds — #714 merged one day after its two-finding review round; the 07-23 wave merged 8 PRs same-day | +| Ramp prediction (aae-orc#65) | 🔴 **FAILED** (under v1 — permanent) | evaluated run-16, result stands — even though the ceiling moved ONE window later (below); no post-hoc re-scoring | +| Selection depth | 🟢 **first DEEP pick** | **#342 (P0a/SDL) drew a maintainer-AUTHORED fix — PR #759 (S-21.01 WASM staging guard + merge pre-check, E-21 W1) — no measured-side diff existed.** The window's 4 defect closes were all diff-attached; the deepest pick was not | +| Next decisive move | **ours, still** | A4 residue #365/#358 (6/6 windows): ship the SDL fix PRs — the maintainer just demonstrated the lane moves | + +Carried caveat: **#244 auto-closed by a stale `Closes` keyword in #731's squash commit** — +math-test criterion residual, reopen-or-refile offered. Watermark **#753 → #758**: run-17 +intake is #755–#758 (#754 resolved to a maintainer PR, merged 2026-07-22); one P0b integrity +(#756), zero SDL, zero speculative. +_Updated 2026-07-23 · watermark #758 · run 17 · intent vsdd-factory@0.4 +· finding-005/009 axes + attn facet · vocabulary.json contract (beadle PRs #34/#35) · +skills-based refresh (binary render retired per run-10 regression)_ + +> **vsdd-factory is a self-referential factory — engine == product.** Engine process-gaps and +> meta findings are **on-mission**, scored on leverage + provenance, not dismissed as +> self-reference. Run-17's intake holds **4/4 `advances`, 4/4 pilot-derived** (third +> consecutive zero-speculative intake; run-15 was 13/13). Run-11's integrity-block reading, run-12's sweep-chain +> reading, run-13's checkers-lie reading, and run-14's maintainer-files-into-the-corpus +> reading are unchanged and carried below. + +> **THIS RUN — the maintainer turn CONTINUED, and went DEEP.** 10 PR merges + 4 defect +> closes across 2026-07-22/23, including the board's **first P0a-lane action**: #342 (merge +> silently deletes a served `.factory` file — on the A4 alarm since it was filed) drew a +> **maintainer-authored** fix, PR #759 (S-21.01 WASM staging guard + orchestrator merge +> pre-check, E-21 W1). Three quick-win-lane members converted (#567 #629 #631) plus the +> two-month-old #204 strand; #714 (mandatory story-CHANGELOG) merged after a two-finding +> spec-conformance review whose companion-BC ask the intake answers same-day (#758). +> Run-16's zero-new window and run-15's 13-issue intake are folded to their indexes below. + +## Baseline (counts — a starting line, first rates unlocked) + +| Metric | Value | Outcome pairing | +|---|---|---| +| Open issues | 479 | arcavenai 427 · Zious11 27 · arcaven 16 · drbothen 8 · slabgorb 1 | +| Filer concentration | arcavenai ~89% | the measured filer resumed modestly (4 new, one answering a maintainer review ask); the maintainer drained 4 more | +| New this run | **4** (#755–#758 · watermark 753→758) | 1 P0b integrity (#756) · 2 P2 · 1 P3 flake — 4/4 pilot-derived `advances` | +| Maintainer engagement | **72 actions (+14 this run — second-biggest window on record)** | 10 PR merges + 4 tracked-defect closes across 2026-07-22/23 — incl. the **first P0a-lane action** (#342 via maintainer-authored PR #759) | +| Closes against tracked defects | **17** (+4: #204 #567 #629 #631) | every close paired with a merged measured-side fix PR (#735 #728 #720 #727); #204 is the oldest conversion on record (a 2-month-old session-stranding bug). #637 #690 #473 still open pending reporter confirmation | +| filed-vs-acted gap | 427 open : 72 acted | trend: 12.9:1 → 12.1:1 → 7.4:1 → **5.9:1** — second consecutive sharp narrowing, still all from the acted side | +| Δ since last run (#753→#758) | **net 0 open** (+4 new − 4 closed) | intake and drain balanced exactly; open count holds at 479 | +| Maintainer capacity (v2) | **episodic-side-project** — 2 humans, one of hundreds of projects | all verdicts/streaks capacity-adjusted per intent v0.4 + SKILL §6b; attention windows observed: 6 (Jul 8 · 15 · 19 · 21 · 22 · 23) | + +## 👤 Needs human reading — direct attention (NEW lane · orthogonal to priority) +> A small group whose **special nature benefits from the maintainer reading them directly and +> in full** — the value is in the prose and cannot survive summarization into chips. Orthogonal +> to priority: an item here can be P2 on impact yet first in your reading queue. Ordered by +> reading priority: **reply-needed** (a counterparty is blocked on your answer) → +> **gates-work** (the decision unblocks other open work) → **standing** (context that improves +> everything downstream). Never quick-win-eligible; never folded into cluster rollups. + +| What it is | # | attn · order · why direct reading | +|---|---|---| +| **External contribution flow proposal (ArcavenAE)** — first external contributor asks how to route artifact-bearing changes; proposes artifact-content-via-issue backed by a 2000-trial simulation (tables + charts in comments) | **#510** | `attn.governance` · **reply-needed** · consent/relationship decision only maintainers can make; ArcavenAE holds artifact-bearing PRs until your ruling (also P2 · **no response after 18 days** — 36 actions across the two biggest windows, none here; PR #524 even references #510 without ruling on it) | +| **Platform-envelope mismatch (tracking)** — the dark-factory requirements profile vs the Claude Code plugin envelope; seven named limits (#411–#417), now generating live gate failures (#458 #461 #473 #474) | **#410** | `attn.direction` · **gates-work** · re-platform / amend-constitution / risk-accept is an architectural fork only you can take; 11 open issues wait on it (also P1-KEYSTONE) | +| **Fleet-mining evidence brief** — 4,602 dispatches across 3 factories, 169 bad-outcome chains hand-classified: 84% of real bad outcomes are NOT model capability; four engine asks derived | **#463** | `attn.evidence-brief` · **standing** · external empirical corpus you cannot re-derive from this repo; weighing adoption of the four asks is a judgment over the full method + numbers (also P1-KEYSTONE) | +| **Factory-graph proposal** — derived traceability graph rehydrated from `.factory/` markdown | **#671** | `attn.direction` · **gates-work** · **your co-maintainer's keystone proposal** — one ruling reframes the traceability lane (also P1-KEYSTONE) | +| **Reviewer-calibration divergence** — severity vs code-freeze state | **#686** | `attn.evidence-brief` · **standing** · third calibration facet, Zious11 field-data already attached — the cross-project evidence lives only here | +| **V-model verification-planning gap** — N-consecutive-clean counts absence-of-findings | **#710** | `attn.evidence-brief` · **standing** · 🛑 also P0b — carries the empirical convergence dataset the repo cannot re-derive | + +
🤖 agent channel — attn.* facet screens (runs 12–17) + +``` +Facet defined in beadle SKILL.md step 3b (2026-07-06). Initial subtypes grown from these +three exemplars; growth rule = codify a new subtype on its SECOND instance, generic +attn.other until then. Candidates screened this run and NOT tagged: #508 (worktree config +poisoning — serious but a defect, chips carry it), #507 (consolidation terminus — engineering +judgment, not relationship/direction), #464 (evidence volume but derivable from this repo's +own telemetry). The bar: would the maintainer LOSE something decision-relevant if they only +read the chip row? Keep the lane in single digits or the facet stops meaning anything. +``` +``` +Run-13 screen: 104 new issues, ZERO new attn.* tags. Nearest candidates and why not: +#584 (learning-loop, maintainer-authored — the maintainer wrote it, direct-reading is moot); +#568 (variants-gallery proposal — speculative, chips carry it); #583 (cost ledger — bounded +enhancement). The lane stays at 3 items, all carried, all still unanswered. reply-needed #510 +ages to 7 days with maintainer activity landing elsewhere — the first conversion target +remains unchanged. +``` + +``` +Run-14 screen: 72 new issues, 3 new attn.* tags (lane 3 → 6, at the ~7 bar — tighten next run). +Admitted: #671 (direction — maintainer-authored, but it is a PROPOSAL awaiting the other +maintainer's ruling: direct reading is the decision path, not moot per the run-13 +maintainer-authored screen); #686, #710 (evidence-brief — cross-project field data not +re-derivable from this repo). Nearest misses: #687 (citation-coherence class — chips carry +it); #695 (release CHANGELOG enumeration — bounded process ask); #634 (drbothen's own +holdout-gate feature spec — author == reader, moot). External-signal note: an outside +analysis flags #681 as the strongest filing of this batch. B3: outside analysis is demand to +reconcile, never equate — recorded here as provenance-annotated signal; #681's board +placement (P1 operational-halt, dual-cluster) derives from the grader axes + curator read, +which happen to agree with it. +``` +``` +Run-15 screen: 13 new issues, ZERO new attn.* tags (lane holds at 6 — the run-14 "tighten +next run" note is honored by admitting nothing). Nearest candidates and why not: #747 +(convergence-seal bypass — highest-stakes new item, but it is a defect with a cited cheap +remedy; chips + the P0b row carry it); #750 (errata-artifact gap — process defect, chips +carry it); #752/#753 (axis proposals — engineering adoption calls, not judgment-over-prose). +The six arcaven fact-check comments are thread-level signal, recorded in the classification +rationales, not an attn trigger. reply-needed #510 ages to 17 days. +``` +``` +Run-16 screen: 0 new issues, no candidates to screen — lane holds at 6, all carried. The +notable negative: 22 maintainer actions landed this window and NONE touched this lane. +reply-needed #510 stays unanswered at 17 days while the merge wave passed it by; #410's +11-issue dependency cone and the two evidence briefs (#463 #686 #710) likewise untouched. +The lane is now the cleanest witness of the selection function: items needing a READ + +RULING sit; items arriving with a mergeable diff move. +``` +``` +Run-17 screen: 4 new issues, ZERO new attn.* tags (lane holds at 6). Nearest candidates and +why not: #756 (highest-stakes intake, but a defect — chips + the P0b row carry it); #755 +(protocol-interaction design gap — chips carry it); #758 (companion-BC tracking task filed +in ANSWER to the maintainer's own #714 review ask — direct reading is moot, they wrote the +ask). Selection-function note: the function DEEPENED this window (#342 drew a maintainer- +AUTHORED fix with no measured diff) — yet still zero of 14 actions touched this lane. +Read-and-rule keeps sitting even as read-the-mechanism-and-fix starts moving. #510 ages to +18 days. +``` + +
+ +## Action plan — grouped by INTENT, integrity-first (finding-004 precedence) + +Rows lead with **what the issue is**; `#NN` is the agent's fetch reference; trailing chips are +status. `repro` badge feeds the effort estimate; `⏸ halt`/`💥 panic` = operational-impact +(finding-009); `🛑` = source-of-truth integrity (finding-004); `💾` = data-loss. Verdicts cited +against the v0.3 rubric. Board rows verified against live state this run; the four issues +closed in this window's maintainer wave (#204 #567 #629 #631) are struck where they appear — +the prior window's nine remain struck — see Maintainer progress for the close-by-close +pairing. + + +### 🔴 P0a — Silent data-loss (highest severity: irreplaceable state destroyed/stranded with no signal) + +> Each is **integrity × data-loss** (or pure SDL): a system-of-record silently diverges from +> reality AND destroys or strands state behind a green check. Sits **above** everything else +> by precedence. **THE LANE MOVED THIS WINDOW — first P0a action on record:** #342 drew +> **PR #759 (S-21.01 `validate-factory-path-staging` WASM guard + orchestrator merge +> pre-check, E-21 W1) — maintainer-authored, merged 2026-07-23; no measured-side diff +> existed.** The issue stays open pending the epic's remaining waves; per finding-016, +> engagement discharges the alarm — **#342 leaves A4.** **A4 residue (v2 denominators):** +> #365/#358 untouched across **all 6 windows** (8 runs shadow); #523/#588 at 5 windows; +> #635 (the maintainer's own SDL filing) at 3. The ramp prediction (evaluated run-16 under +> v1: **FAILED, permanent**) is not re-scored by this — the ceiling moved **one window after +> the pre-registered horizon expired**; the meter reports it whichever way it points (see +> Direction Health). **Discharge path for the residue is still ours — SDL fix PRs.** No new +> SDL this run. + +| What it is | # | Type · repro · verdict | +|---|---|---| +| Product-branch merge silently `rm`s a `.factory` file the nested worktree was serving | #342 | bug · Bohr · **🛑💾 INTEGRITY + DATA-LOSS · ADVANCES · systemic · E-21 W1 guard MERGED (PR #759, maintainer-authored) — open pending epic waves · A4 discharged** | +| Rebase auto-merge silently drops 4 production lines (no conflict markers, clean `--continue`) | #365 | bug · Mandel · **🛑💾 INTEGRITY + DATA-LOSS · ADVANCES · systemic** | +| PR base not locked to trunk → orphan merge: `state=MERGED` while `origin/main` lacks the commit | #358 | bug · Bohr · **🛑💾 INTEGRITY + DATA-LOSS(orphan) · ADVANCES · systemic** | +| Story-worktree `.factory` artifacts silently lost at teardown — worktree removed with unsynced state | **#523** | bug · Bohr · **🛑💾 INTEGRITY + DATA-LOSS · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Factory-side PR strands the shared `.factory` worktree on a chore branch — served state silently wrong for every consumer | **#588** | process-gap · Bohr · **🛑▲ INTEGRITY + SDL(strand) · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| CLEAN passes/streak never persisted mid-gate; crash loses position | **#635** | process-gap · Bohr · **🛑💾 DATA-LOSS · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | + +### 🔴 P0b — Source-of-truth integrity (gates EVERY functional verdict, incl. convergence) + +> A PASS/"converged" verdict computed over a corrupt substrate is **unfalsifiable** +> (finding-004). **Run-17 adds #756: a creation-only dispatch with an explicit do-NOT-merge +> instruction ran the full 9-step lifecycle and merged onto the protected integration branch +> before Step-4.5 convergence — no convergence certificate existed** (BC-5.39.001 / +> AUTHORIZE_MERGE anchor; the #747 seal family attacked from the dispatch side). The class +> got its third kill last window (#623 via PR #718 — input-hash upsert — following #465/PR +> #532 and #724/PR #725; the P0b lane is where fixes with PRs attached reliably land). +> Run-15's two new P0b carry: **#747** — production edits +> merged after the 3-CLEAN convergence seal with no gate re-entry (nothing binds the seal to +> the merged HEAD; the #313 false-certification family at story scope; thread suggests a +> `converged_sha` mirroring BC-5.42.001's `covered_sha`), and **#750** — errata cited as +> normative authority by five sibling artifacts exist only as changelog rows, unresolvable by +> any grep/listing/graph-walk (the anchor-integrity family, except the authority existed as +> an event, not an artifact). Note on #750: its grade is contested between graders +> (P0b/integrity vs P2/none) — held at P0b per the safety-conservative rule, flagged for +> re-grade when new evidence lands. + +| What it is | # | Type · repro · verdict | +|---|---|---| +| Creation-only dispatch ran the full 9-step lifecycle — merge authorized with NO convergence certificate in existence | **#756** | process-gap · Mandel · **🛑 INTEGRITY (convergence gate) · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW run-17) | +| Post-convergence production edits merge without gate re-entry — seal not bound to merged HEAD | **#747** | process-gap · Bohr · **🛑 INTEGRITY (convergence seal) · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Errata cited as normative authority exist only as changelog rows — unresolvable by construction | **#750** | process-gap · Bohr · **🛑 INTEGRITY (learning) · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Live sprint-state assertions gated every PR on base drift — data + gate both fixed | ~~#724~~ | ci-build · Bohr · **🛑 INTEGRITY (spec_process) · RESOLVED ✓ 2026-07-21** (NEW+CLOSED) | +| $(cat) strips trailing newlines — input-hash false-drift hard-block | **#637** | bug · Bohr · **🛑 INTEGRITY (spec_process) · fix MERGED (PR #715) — open pending reporter verify** | +| Finding-ID scheme not canonical — G-less form collides, enables fakes | **#638** | process-gap · Bohr · **🛑 INTEGRITY (learning) · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Writer crash mid-burst leaves changelog overclaiming unedited body | **#647** | process-gap · Mandel · **🛑 INTEGRITY (spec_process) · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Full-file Write leaks stray tag into committed spec artifact | **#650** | bug · Bohr · **🛑 INTEGRITY (spec_process) · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Identifiers retyped from memory silently corrupt records | **#663** | process-gap · Mandel · **🛑 INTEGRITY (learning) · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Review verdicts accepted without ground-truthing components | **#664** | process-gap · Mandel · **🛑 INTEGRITY (learning) · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Decompose omits terminal input-hash --update; hash wrong from birth | **#672** | process-gap · Bohr · **🛑 INTEGRITY (spec_process) · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Blocking validators' fix-instructions coerce fabricated record text | **#673** | process-gap · Bohr · **🛑 INTEGRITY (spec_process) · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Spec's false API claim steers code toward invariant violation | **#680** | process-gap · Bohr · **🛑 INTEGRITY (spec_process) · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Fix-phase self-attestation: DONE report false, guard test neutered | **#685** | process-gap · Mandel · **🛑 INTEGRITY (learning) · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Interleaved delivery leaves STATE.md next-pointer aimed at already-merged story | **#692** | process-gap · Mandel · **🛑 INTEGRITY (spec_process) · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Pipe to grep masks runner exit code; post-summary crash reads green | **#704** | process-gap · Bohr · **🛑 INTEGRITY (spec_process) · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Convergence counts clean passes without vector-coverage novelty | **#710** | process-gap · Mandel · **🛑 INTEGRITY (spec_process) · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | + +
🤖 agent channel — P0b prior detail (49 issues, runs 9–12) + run-13 reading + +Prior P0b: **#465 CLOSED with a validated fix (PR #532 — the first P0b close)**; the rest open. Maintainer comments beyond #428 (Zious11 evidence-add +2026-07-08). Full rows in the run-11/12 renders (docs/fixtures in ArcavenAE/beadle) and the +store; fetch `#NN` for bodies (B1): #313 #314 #330 #331 #332 #333 #337 #339 #341 #348 #355 #356 #370 #372 #373 #374 #379 #381 #399 #404 #412 #421 #425 #427 #428 #430 #433 #434 #437 #440 #441 #448 #452 #465 #468 #470 #474 #475 #477 #479 #481 #483 #485 #486 #488 #491 #492 #494 #496. + +``` +Run-13 reading (14 new): +- The gate layer is now the dominant corruption target: #599 (agent-authored lint gates ignore + their args and under-scan — vacuous green), #614 (GNU BRE inverse detectors false-GREEN on + macOS), #600 (index sweep lands partial, report asserts full), #592 (async adversary verdicts + dropped or bound to superseded HEAD), #517 (Drift Items marked satisfied advance with no + verification gate). finding-004's "the green check IS the defect" arc: run-11 proved records + lie, run-12 proved prose survives sweeps, run-13 proves the checkers lie. +- #576 (maintainer-authored) + #513 (run-12 keystone) now bracket the same fix from both sides: + verdicts must derive mechanically from evidence (findings count / pasted gate output), never + from narrative. Land these two and the largest false-green subclass loses its mechanism. +- Write-protection sub-family: #589 (frozen artifacts writable — 27 misdirected appends, + forked v1.97), #537/#538/#544/#546/#547/~~#623~~ (state/attestation/protocol corruption + paths; #623 CLOSED 2026-07-22 via PR #718 — the third P0b close). +- All 14 HARD-EXCLUDED from quick wins per finding-004. +``` +Fetch each `#NN` for the full body (B1). +
+ + +### 🟠 P1 — Platform-envelope mismatch (#410–#417 + new evidence) + +> arcaven's 8-issue constitutional critique (#410 tracker) — decision still open: re-platform / +> amend constitution / record risk-acceptance. **This run adds four evidence issues from the +> pilots:** #458 (Phase-4 gate arithmetic assumes machine-observable ACs; 6 of 7 akey holdout +> scenarios need hardware/humans), #461 (auto-mode classifier vetoes the "standing merge +> authorization" the doctrine promises — permission-laundering workarounds appearing), #473 +> (workflow step tasks the write-denied orchestrator with a write — constitution-vs-workflow +> contradiction), #474 (routed to P0b — the gate that can only pass by waiver). The +> envelope-mismatch cluster is no longer just an argument; it is generating gate failures. + +| What it is | # | Type · repro · verdict | +|---|---|---| +| Tracking issue — dark-factory requirements exceed Claude Code plugin envelope | **#410** | tech-debt · n/a · **P1-KEYSTONE · ADVANCES** (prior) | +| No external supervisor — orchestrator and orchestrated share one failure domain | **#411** | tech-debt · Mandel · **⏸ HALT** (prior) | +| CAP-012 loss bound unverifiable · session lifecycle = REPL · no introspection/bulkheads · actor-topology mismatch · resource opacity | **#413 #414 #415 #416 #417** | (prior — see run-10 detail) | +| **Hardware/human-gated holdout criteria need a first-class category + resume-queue** — Phase-4 halts on physical products | **#458** | enhancement · Bohr · **⏸ HALT · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| **Auto-mode classifier blocks agent merge — doctrine promises an affordance the substrate denies** (self-flagged scope doubt: factory vs Claude Code ownership) | **#461** | possibly-out-of-scope · Bohr · **⏸ HALT · NEUTRAL · systemic** (NEW) | +| **Scenario-rotation step tasks the write-denied orchestrator with writing a file** — unexecutable as declared | **#473** | bug · Bohr · **⏸ HALT · fix MERGED (PR #717) — open pending reporter verify** | +| Research-agent declares MCP tools absent at spawn; halts split-dispatch | #516 | bug · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Phase-4 holdout budgets frozen without target-build capability canary | #601 | process-gap · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Validate-pr-review-posted unreachable on single-identity project | #651 | bug · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | + + +### 🟠 P1 — Operational: halts the autonomous pipeline (`⏸ impact.halt` · finding-009) + +> The liveness axis. **A second kill this window: #204 — the oldest halt-class strand on the +> board (orphan-branch recipe strands the session) — closed via merged PR #735**, following +> #658 (STORY_ID regex, PR #719) last window — the halt lane's first close. #681 (dual-validator deadlock — following +> either shipped contract hard-blocks the agent; external analysis flags it +> strongest-of-batch, see agent channel) remains the natural first pull. Panic #647 rides +> P0b as integrity-primary; run-13's panic trio (#541 #548 #569) carries unchanged. + +| What it is | # | Type · repro · verdict | +|---|---|---| +| Lock RENEW still repo-relative in state-burst/state-manager — unreachable in installed-plugin context (completes merged #526; the #472 class) | **#732** | bug · Bohr · **⏸ HALT · ADVANCES · systemic · ★** (NEW run-15 · arcaven) | +| Validate-pr-review-posted unreachable on single-identity project | #651 | bug · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Validate-pr-merge-prerequisites STORY_ID regex misses named story IDs | ~~#658~~ | bug · Bohr · **CLOSED ✓ 2026-07-22 via PR #719** | +| Validate-burst-log vs shipped template: dual-validator deadlock | #681 | bug · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Red-gate tests asserting stub artifacts are un-greenable by design | #684 | process-gap · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Single-account deployments can't post formal PR approval the 9-step process assumes | #696 | process-gap · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Guard removal breaks tests that depended on guard's no-op | #702 | process-gap · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Run-13 lane (panic trio #541 #548 #569 · halts #543 #555 #604 #626) + run-12/11 lanes (#503 #508 #513 · #457 #451 #469) + older halt tail (#321 #326 #343 #346 #347 #349 #357 #380 #386) | | (carried — #472 CLOSED ✓ this window; see index + maintainer progress) | + +
🤖 agent channel — #681 external signal + halt-lane reading + +``` +#681 (validate-burst-log dual-validator deadlock): an outside analysis of this batch flags +#681 as its strongest filing. Recorded per B3 as signal-to-reconcile: the grader +independently scored it systemic/P1/halt with dual cluster (operational-halt + +spec-propagation-drift) and the curator concurs — both shipped contracts hard-block the +agent, the escape hatch is validator-source archaeology, and the body carries four concrete +fixes. It is the natural first pull of the halt lane. Panic #647 is P0b-primary (integrity) +and rides both lists. #637 renders in P0b (integrity outranks halt on the same row). +``` +
+ +### 🟠 P1 — KEYSTONE consolidations + +> Single highest-leverage actionable items — each closes a whole class upstream. + +| What it is | # | Type · repro · verdict | +|---|---|---| +| Mandatory deterministic pre-review lint layer (~63-pair external pilot) — **#466 (adversary runs the linter) is a direct subset; fold it in** | **#336** | enhancement · Bohr · **KEYSTONE** (prior) | +| **Product-level defect register** — no mode has a post-ship defect log; the shipped-broken-demo class (#432/#433) has nowhere to land | **#432** | gap · Bohr · **KEYSTONE · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| **Probe variance, not pass count, drives convergence quality** — hostile-input structure axis + path-component enumeration; the 3-clean-pass certificate is vacuous on a narrow probe distribution | **#462** | process-gap · Mandel · **KEYSTONE · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| **Fleet-mining engine asks** — model_rationale frontmatter, per-dispatch outcome telemetry, escalation ladders, uniform lessons registry (4,602 dispatches, 84% of bad outcomes not model capability) | **#463** | proposal · n/a · **KEYSTONE · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW · arcaven) | +| **Remediation disposition-sweep contract** (7-pass sibling-miss pattern + wrong-value-propagated-with-fidelity) — also P0b above | **#470** | (see P0b) | +| **Smoke sentinel gate: quality-green ≠ operator-green** — nothing between `git add` and `gh pr merge` executes the artifact at the operator boundary | **#487** | enhancement · Bohr · **KEYSTONE · ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| **Steady-state enforcement surface** — also P0b above; #489/#491/#493 are its facets | **#488** | (see P0b) | +| POL-003 dispatch tables · impl-adds-API lint · defense-in-depth input provenance | #406 #419 #426 | (prior keystones — see run-10 detail) | +| Adversary CLEAN verdict can contradict non-empty findings list | **#576** | process-gap · Mandel · **🛑 INTEGRITY (spec_process) · ADVANCES · systemic · KEYSTONE — pairs with #513: mechanical verdict derivation from both sides** (NEW) | +| Factory-graph: derived traceability graph from .factory/ markdown | **#671** | proposal · n/a · **ADVANCES · systemic · KEYSTONE — maintainer-authored; 👤 attn.direction; one ruling reframes the traceability lane** (NEW) | + + +### 🟠 P1 — Convergence soundness (methodology + propagation) + +> The methodology wave matures from cataloging failures to specifying the missing +> verification steps: quantity-assertions on drain loops (#697), mutation-verified +> security invariants (#676), full-suite semantics (#677), per-state-class fix sweeps +> (#679), pipeline-authored gate independence (#698). Read #710 (👤) as this run's +> consolidation anchor — it carries the empirical dataset for WHY absence-of-findings +> convergence under-measures. + +| What it is | # | Type · repro · verdict | +|---|---|---| +| Canonicalize SAP-3 + SID-2 probes from prism into agent specs | #633 | proposal · n/a · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Story-level holdout gate — three-tier holdout in per-story delivery | #634 | enhancement · n/a · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Mutation restore hits last commit, silently drops uncommitted fix | #645 | process-gap · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Red Gate stub panic on shared path regresses existing tests | #662 | process-gap · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Step (f) silently degrades to self-review without spawn capability | #674 | process-gap · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Seam-covered ACs can mask unwired production entrypoint | #675 | process-gap · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Security-invariant ACs need mutation verification of the guard | #676 | process-gap · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| 'Full suite green' claims require --no-fail-fast enumeration | #677 | process-gap · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Class-scoped fix verified only on representative members: false green | #679 | process-gap · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Internally-unsatisfiable spec (signature vs sibling postcondition) passes all consistency audits | #693 | process-gap · Mandel · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Feature-gated verification test silently excluded from CI — headline proof never runs on gate | #694 | process-gap · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Error-return negative tests must assert discriminator; timeout backstop fakes non-nil error | #699 | proposal · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| AC obligation names multiple paths but its test exercises only one — sibling path unimplemented, green | #700 | process-gap · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Prior methodology core (#593 #462 #497 #500 #467) + cascade pair (#445 #446 #449) + prior cluster (#390 #391 #429 #327 #322 #305 #309 #310 #297 ~~#300~~) + run-13 wave | | (carried — **#300 CLOSED ✓ 2026-07-22 via PR #723**; see run-13 fold + indexes) | + +### 🟢 P2/P3 — Run-17 findings (NEW · 3 rows here, #756 rides P0b) + +> Small, surgical intake — 4/4 pilot-derived `advances`, zero speculative. #758 is the rare +> **responsive** filing: it tracks authoring the companion BC (SS-07 class) that the +> maintainer's own #714 spec-conformance review asked for. #755 names a protocol interaction: +> mandated probe hygiene (restore + scratch-clean) erases exactly the evidence stall-recovery +> needs to tell a completed review from an unstarted one — so recovery orders duplicate work. +> #757 is a load-dependent e2e flake (fixed sleep vs event wait). + +| What it is | # | Type · repro · verdict | +|---|---|---| +| Probe hygiene makes a completed review indistinguishable from an unstarted one — stall recovery orders duplicate work | #755 | process-gap · Mandel · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Flaky e2e: async-hook sink test misses terminal event on loaded runner — fixed sleep vs event wait | #757 | flaky-test · Mandel · **ADVANCES · minutiae · P3** (NEW) | +| Author companion BC (SS-07) for the mandatory story-CHANGELOG task — answers the #714 review ask | #758 | task · Bohr · **ADVANCES · minutiae** (NEW) | + +### 🟢 P2 — Run-15 findings (NEW · advances, no SDL, no panic) + +> 9 new P2s (+ P1 #732 above). The downstream-pilot burst dominates: two adversary-axis +> proposals (#752 boundary-sentinel inputs, #753 channel-lifecycle asymmetry — both grounded +> in concrete S-3.02 instances, not speculation), the narrated-verification class (#746 — +> read the thread: the root cause was corrected in-flight, the surviving defect is sharper +> than the filing), version-qualifier drift (#749 — thread points at generalizing +> BC-5.39.003 rather than new machinery), and reverse symbol→anchor coverage (#751 — +> overlaps #419, thread suggests scoping together). Repo-hygiene pair #734/#741 are ★ +> quick-win-eligible. #733 (arcaven) reconciles the #532 clause with the adversary's +> read-only toolset — two prose-only shapes offered. + +| What it is | # | Type · repro · verdict | +|---|---|---| +| Adversary compile-state clause unsatisfiable for read-only agent — false-CLEAN edge on the #532 class | #733 | process-gap · unknown · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW · arcaven) | +| Author-absolute /Users/jmagady paths in shipped skill examples (13+ sites; class guard proposed) | #734 | bug · Bohr · **ADVANCES · ★** (NEW) | +| Self-referential .lazyclaude gitlink on develop — git 128 warning on every CI job, breaks --recurse-submodules | #741 | bug · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic · ★** (NEW) | +| pr-manager step-9 cleanup verified by narration, not output — step 9 inherits step 8's conclusion unverified | #746 | process-gap · Mandel · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Adversary coherence-lens verifies status flags but not description/call-path columns — wrong prose survived 5 passes | #748 | process-gap · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Version-qualifier drift in prose citations invisible to input-hash detection — 2 instances in one run | #749 | process-gap · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Exported symbols added during rework escape BC/architecture anchoring — gate never walks symbol→anchor | #751 | process-gap · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Axis proposal: boundary-sentinel inputs — out-of-range test params fake coverage of the production path | #752 | proposal · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | +| Axis proposal: channel-lifecycle asymmetry — divergent teardown sets across graceful/exceptional paths | #753 | proposal · Bohr · **ADVANCES · systemic** (NEW) | + +### 🟢 P2 — Run-14 process/policy/test-writer findings (advances, no integrity, no halt) + +> 36 run-14 P2s, grouped by primary cluster — act by lever, not one-by-one. Per-issue chips in +> the run-14 classification index below; ★ items also appear in the quick-wins lane. + +| Cluster (count) — representative | Issues | +|---|---| +| **verification-methodology** (15) — e.g. Base-branch fixes invisible to PR CI without actual branch update | #641 #643 #648 #649 #652 #654 #661 #667 #668 #669 #678 #687 #695 #705 #713 | +| **spec-propagation-drift** (4) — e.g. Story ACs must enumerate per-variant test-function names (recurrence 3) | #653 #656 ~~#660~~✓ #708 | +| **dispatch-contract** (4) — e.g. Resume prompt must include worktree path + branch + pre-commit assertion | #655 #666 #683 #707 | +| **test-writer-gaps** (4) — e.g. Stale RED-gate docstrings survive Red→Green; no gate catches them | #665 #682 #697 #701 | +| **state-manager-hygiene** (2) — e.g. Story index row accumulates unbounded per-revision changelog prose | #711 #712 | +| **artifact-containment** (1) — e.g. Demo-recorder protocol lacks host-path scrub; /Users paths committed | #636 | +| **operational-halt** (1) — e.g. PR-close guard can't distinguish abandon vs close-reopen-for-CI | #642 | +| **authority-substrate** (1) — e.g. Shared git identity defeats per-role commit attribution forensics | #644 | +| **adversary-sweep-enumeration** (1) — e.g. Finding decay is non-monotone; only N-consecutive-CLEAN is sound | #686 | +| **false-green-convergence** (1) — e.g. validate-count-propagation mis-parses epic ID E-11 as count '11 stories' | #690 | +| **plugin-pack-ci** (1) — e.g. Pipeline-authored coverage gate: maximal-coverage default + hand-rolled YAML scan ignores list-form | #698 | +| **dispatch-race** (1) — e.g. Fixed attestation port makes concurrent lanes' port tests flake | #703 | + +### 🟢 P2 — Prior clusters (unchanged this run) + +Run-12 P2 detail (24 rows incl. the #504→#507 sweep chain + #435 #442 #443 #459 #480 #484 +#490) carried in the run-12 render (docs/fixtures) + indexes below. Older tail unchanged — +abbreviated to protect the body budget: dispatch/test/spec tail (#368 #369 #371 #375 #376 +#377 #378 #328 #329 #334 #335 #338 #344 #345 #350 #351 #352 #353 #354 #359 #360 #361 #362 +#363 #364 #366 #367 #382 #383 #387 #388 #392 #393 #394 #395 #398 #400 #405 #407 #417 #420 +#422 #423 #424), observability thread (#317–#325, root cause #415), CI-cost cluster (#308, +read WITH #336), trust-scope reminder (#316). + + +## 🟦 Quick wins — safe to act on (low-caution lane · orthogonal to impact) + +> **This lane is now the proven channel — three MORE conversions this window:** **#567** +> (count-drift false positive → PR #728), **#629** (7-char-SHA false negative → PR #720), +> **#631** (cwd-independent cas-push → PR #727), joining #660/#566 last window and +> #472/#724-fix before that — six lane members closed, every one via a merged measured-side +> fix PR. Run-17 admits **0 new** (all four graded ineligible — see rule check). Eligibility +> is **derived** (mechanical + bounded blast + cited fix + alignment ≠ drifts). **Lane +> exclusion is RULE (SKILL §7a, beadle PR #34):** integrity anchors (#747 #750 #756), SDL, +> and panic never ride here regardless of mechanical eligibility. Remaining on-ramp: **#732** +> (completes #526's own conversion — two missed sites), then #741, #734. + +| What it is | # | Type · repro · priority | +|---|---|---| +| Lock RENEW repo-relative in state-burst/state-manager — apply #526's own conversion to 2 missed sites | **#732** | bug · Bohr · **⏸ P1** (NEW run-15 · arcaven) | +| Author-absolute /Users/jmagady paths in shipped examples — replace + /Users/-literal content guard | **#734** | bug · Bohr · **P2** (NEW run-15) | +| .lazyclaude gitlink: `git rm --cached` + .gitignore + mode-160000 health check (covers #263 too) | **#741** | bug · Bohr · **P2** (NEW run-15) | +| Canonicalize SAP-3 + SID-2 probes from prism into agent specs | #633 | proposal · n/a · **P1** (NEW) | +| Demo-recorder protocol lacks host-path scrub; /Users paths committed | #636 | process-gap · Bohr · **P2** (NEW) | +| Decision-citation hook regex false-positives on look-alike IDs | #641 | bug · Bohr · **P2** (NEW) | +| Base-branch fixes invisible to PR CI without actual branch update | #643 | process-gap · Bohr · **P2** (NEW) | +| Mutation restore hits last commit, silently drops uncommitted fix | #645 | process-gap · Bohr · **P1** (NEW) | +| Story ACs must enumerate per-variant test-function names (recurrence 3) | #653 | process-gap · n/a · **P2** (NEW) | +| Bundle-scoped mutation runs need --timeout 480 / --jobs 2 heuristic | #654 | process-gap · n/a · **P2** (NEW) | +| Resume prompt must include worktree path + branch + pre-commit assertion | #655 | process-gap · n/a · **P2** (NEW) | +| Story-writer must count params on pinned signatures vs lint threshold | #656 | process-gap · n/a · **P2** (NEW) | +| Validate-changelog-monotonicity doesn't normalize 'v' version prefix | ~~#660~~ | bug · Bohr · **CLOSED ✓ 2026-07-22 via PR #722** | +| Red Gate: uncommitted stubs then tests-alone = non-compiling commit | #661 | process-gap · n/a · **P2** (NEW) | +| Dispatches recommend safer form instead of mandating it | #666 | process-gap · Mandel · **P2** (NEW) | +| MUST-before-X obligations lack explicit discharge records | #667 | process-gap · Bohr · **P2** (NEW) | +| 'Full suite green' claims require --no-fail-fast enumeration | #677 | process-gap · Bohr · **P1** (NEW) | +| String-grep seam-exclusion check blind to control-flow-only seams | #678 | process-gap · Bohr · **P2** (NEW) | +| Stale RED-gate docstrings survive Red→Green; no gate catches them | #682 | process-gap · Bohr · **P2** (NEW) | +| Red-gate tests asserting stub artifacts are un-greenable by design | #684 | process-gap · Bohr · **⏸** · **P1** (NEW) | +| Validate-count-propagation mis-parses epic ID E-11 as count '11 stories' | #690 | bug · Bohr · **fix MERGED (PR #716) — open pending reporter verify** | +| Fixed attestation port makes concurrent lanes' port tests flake | #703 | process-gap · Mandel · **P2** (NEW) | +| Overlapping attestation controls make pixels contradict code | #705 | process-gap · Bohr · **P2** (NEW) | +| Step guard counts STEP_COMPLETE per stop-event, forces re-emission | #707 | process-gap · Bohr · **P2** (NEW) | +| New BC error code not registered in canonical error-taxonomy | #709 | process-gap · Bohr · **P1** (NEW) | +| Story index row accumulates unbounded per-revision changelog prose | #712 | process-gap · Bohr · **P2** (NEW) | +| Prior lane (run-13: #533 #539 #545 #549 #557 #558 ~~#566~~ ~~#567~~ #580 #581 #582 #583 #591 #593 #594 #597 #598 #622 #628 ~~#629~~ #630 ~~#631~~ · run-12: #515 (partial fix landed, PR #524) · run-11: #436 #444 #447 #450 #453 #466 #469 #471 #476 #478 #482 #495 #498 #499 #501 · older: #396 #397 #401 #402 #403 #389 #407 #408 #409 #352 #323 #320 #209 #239 #256 #280 #282) | | (**#472 #418 #566 #567 #629 #631 CLOSED ✓** — #567/#629/#631 this window via PRs #728/#720/#727 · rest open) | + +
🤖 agent channel — quick-win §7a rule check + exclusion audit (runs 14–17) + +``` +§7a RULE CHECK (run-17): +- 0 admitted of 4 graded: #755 (design-architectural — nature excluded), #757 (Mandelbug + flake — repro excluded), #758 (spec-requirements — authoring a BC is spec work; its + ride-along RELEASING.md one-liner is the only mechanical fragment, not lane-worthy alone). +- integrity HARD-EXCLUDE (1): #756 — grader-set integrity=true (convergence-gate anchor). +- SDL / panic rule-exclude: none this run. +- Curator overrides: NONE in either direction (grader and rule agree 4/4). +- Lane outcome: #567/#629/#631 converted this window — second consecutive window validating + the lane (mechanical + diff-attached converts fastest). +``` +``` +§7a RULE CHECK (run-15): +- 3 admitted: #732 #734 #741 — all mechanical/bounded with cited fixes, none flagged. +- integrity HARD-EXCLUDE (3): #724 #747 #750 — none grader-admitted (contract enforces); + #724 additionally already resolved. +- SDL / panic rule-exclude: none this run (0 SDL, 0 panic in the batch). +- attn never-QW: no attn tags this run. +- Curator overrides: NONE in either direction. Grader-vs-rule agreement on all 13. +- Note: #746's proposed fix was refuted in-thread (would regress the exact-line match the + shipped check already has) — a reminder the lane requires the CITED fix to be correct, + not just small; #746 stays out on that basis (quick_win_disqualification recorded). +- Maintainer on-ramp order: #732 (your own #526 conversion, two missed sites) → #741 + (two-command repo hygiene) → #734 (path scrub + guard). +``` +``` +§7a RULE CHECK (run-14, first run under the rule, beadle PR #34): +- 21 admitted: #633 #636 #641 #643 #645 #653 #654 #655 #656 #660 #661 #666 #667 #677 #678 #682 #684 #690 #703 #705 #707 #709 #712 +- integrity HARD-EXCLUDE (13): #637 #638 #647 #650 #663 #664 #672 #673 #680 #685 #692 #704 #710 — none were grader-admitted (contract enforces). +- SDL rule-exclude: #635 — grader did not admit (silent_data_loss=true blocks eligibility at grading). +- panic rule-exclude: #647 — grader did not admit (integrity + panic). +- attn never-QW: #671 #686 #710 — none grader-admitted. +- Curator overrides this run: NONE in either direction. Rule and grader agreed on every lane + decision; the audit exists because §7a now requires it whenever they disagree. +- #684 (halt + grader-eligible, un-greenable stub-artifact tests) admitted WITH ⏸ chip per + run-11/13 precedent (#469/#472-class: bounded fix to a halting surface — the #472 close + validates the pattern). +- Maintainer on-ramp order: #690 (your own count-parser bug) → #653/#654/#655/#656 (your own + process asks) → #661 (v-prefix normalize) → #660 (changelog monotonicity) → rest. +``` +
+ +## Direction Health — corpus-level (the led-by-the-backlog check) + +Computed under **instrument v2 (capacity-adjusted, SKILL §6b — operator-ratified +2026-07-22)**; baselines: `_kos/ideas/capacity-adjusted-direction-baselines.md`. Verdict: +**🟢 ON-COURSE** · watch: **A4 residue #365/#358**. v2 red-verdict gate: 🔴 requires a red +band AND a falsified cost explanation — neither holds. **Falsification meter (aae-orc#65), +reported every run:** the run-14 ramp prediction stays **FAILED** (evaluated run-16 under +v1 — permanent, never re-scored). **This window the hard acted-on ceiling moved past P0b +for the first time — to P0a:** #342 drew maintainer-authored PR #759 (E-21 W1, merged +2026-07-23), **one attention window after the pre-registered horizon expired.** Recorded +descriptively; the evaluated result stands unchanged. Soft ceiling: P0b (maintainer prose +again landed on PRs, not issue threads — the #714 two-finding spec-conformance review). +No new prediction is registered — that remains the operator's move (§6b rule 5: +window-denominated horizon, 4–6 windows default). + +| Signal (v2) | Verdict | Reading | +|---|---|---| +| `pr_acceptance` band | **GREEN** | 30/31 = **97%, zero rejections** — human band ~68–73%; agent/bot baseline **37–45%**; only #729 open | +| `engagement_cadence` band | **GREEN** | **6 windows in ~3.5 weeks**, volume 3→5→31→2→22→14; episodic band: ≥1 window/month | +| `merge_latency` band | **GREEN** | ready PRs merged within ≤2 windows; #714's two-finding review round → merge in one day | +| `maintainer_action` (the compass) | **deepening — first P0a action** | +14 actions (10 merges · 4 closes); cumulative 72; the compass now points INTO the SDL lane (E-21 opened against #342) | +| `selection depth` (was: severity ceiling) | **mixed — first deep pick** | acted-on ceiling **P0a this window** (#342 — maintainer-authored fix, NO measured-side diff existed); the window's other 4 defect closes were all diff-attached. The depth question opened in the right direction | +| `A4 silent-data-loss zero-engagement` (finding-016) | **partial discharge — residue drifting (signal-level; headline-gated per §6b)** | **#342 DISCHARGED** (PR #759 engagement). Residue: #365/#358 **6/6 attention windows untouched** (8 runs shadow); #523/#588 at 5; #635 (maintainer-authored) at 3. Discharge path for residue: measured-side SDL fix PRs | +| `integrity-density` (B) | watch (1 new) | #756 (1 of 4 intake); open P0b net +1 → 77 open of 80 class members; #637 fix still pending reporter verify | +| `silent-data-loss share` (C) | on-course | 0 new; open lane holds at 6 — but with the first in-lane maintainer action on record (#342 W1) | +| `filing_density` | modest + responsive — within governance | 4 this run after a zero-new window; net open growth 0 (intake = drain); #758 answers the maintainer's own review ask | +| `filed_vs_acted_gap` | narrowing again | 427:72 = **5.9:1** (12.9 → 12.1 → 7.4 → 5.9) — movement still entirely on the acted side | +| `convert_finding_to_guard_unbounded` · `over_engineering_fingerprints` | clean | 4 filings screened — no unbounded guard conversions, no invented machinery (#755/#757 cite observed runs; #758 cites the review thread) | + +- **What changed in r2 and what did not:** the recalibration changes the *population* + this project is measured against — from an implicit full-time-maintainer standard on + beadle's run cadence to the observed reality (episodic attention, the modal OSS shape: + 65% of popular projects have truck factor ≤ 2; 60% of maintainers unpaid, 78% at + ≤ 10 h/week across ALL their projects). It changes NO recorded fact: the prediction + stays failed; the selection-function observation (diff-attached moves, read-and-rule + sits) stands. +- **Run-15 addendum (fix-delivery-cost hypothesis) — run-17 twist:** the strong form + ("only diff-attached items move") is now **contradicted by the board's most important + datapoint**: the first P0a action arrived with NO measured-side diff — the maintainer + authored S-21.01 themselves (E-21 W1 against #342). The weak form (diffs lower activation + energy) still stands — the window's other conversions were all diff-attached. The live + experiment continues on the residue: ship #365/#358 SDL fix PRs; merging discharges A4; + sitting ≥2 windows falsifies what remains of the cost explanation. + +## Classification index (finding-005 + finding-009 + attn facet) + +### Run-17 index (NEW) + +report-type · defect-nature · repro · alignment · flags. Axis records ingested to the store +(vocabulary.json contract); cited-evidence rationale per row carries the stale-checkout +disclosure (local checkout at 531dacfb — post-checkout artifacts graded from body narrative, +no hallucination signals). Follow `#NN` for bodies (B1). + +| What it is | # | chips | +|---|---|---| +| Probe hygiene makes completed review indistinguishable from unstarted — stall recovery orders duplicate work | #755 | process-gap · design · Mandel · adv | +| Creation-only dispatch merged before Step-4.5 — no convergence certificate in existence | **#756** | process-gap · design · Mandel · adv · **🛑** | +| Async-hook sink e2e flake on loaded runner — fixed sleep vs event wait | #757 | flaky-test · concurrency · Mandel · adv | +| Companion BC (SS-07) for mandatory story-CHANGELOG — answers the #714 review ask | #758 | task · spec · Bohr · adv | + +**Run-16 (carried): zero new issues — nothing to classify.** State changes that run were +closes/merges, recorded in Maintainer progress. + +### Run-15 index (carried forward — most recent detail) + +report-type · defect-nature · repro · alignment · flags. Axis vectors ingested verbatim +(vocabulary.json contract). Rich fixture: +docs/fixtures/vsdd-factory-312-run15-classifications-rich.json. Six rows carry in-thread +arcaven fact-checks (recorded in the store rationales) — read the thread before acting on +#746 (root cause corrected) and #741 (gitlink is self-referential, not dangling; impact +unchanged). Follow `#NN` for bodies (B1). + +| What it is | # | chips | +|---|---|---| +| Live sprint-state assertions gated every PR on base drift | ~~#724~~ | ci-build · design · Bohr · adv · **🛑** **⏸** · **RESOLVED ✓** | +| Lock RENEW repo-relative in state-burst/state-manager (installed-context) | **#732** | bug · logic · Bohr · adv · **⏸** **★** *(arcaven)* | +| Adversary compile-state clause unsatisfiable for read-only agent | #733 | process-gap · spec · unknown · adv *(arcaven)* | +| Author-absolute /Users/jmagady paths in shipped skill examples | #734 | bug · syntax · Bohr · adv · **★** | +| Self-referential .lazyclaude gitlink — git 128 on every CI job | #741 | bug · lifecycle · Bohr · adv · **★** | +| pr-manager step-9 cleanup verified by narration, not output | #746 | process-gap · spec · Mandel · adv | +| Post-convergence production edits merge without gate re-entry | **#747** | process-gap · design · Bohr · adv · **🛑** | +| Coherence-lens verifies status flags, not description/call-path columns | #748 | process-gap · design · Bohr · adv | +| Version-qualifier drift invisible to input-hash detection | #749 | process-gap · design · Bohr · adv | +| Errata cited as authority exist only as changelog rows | **#750** | process-gap · lifecycle · Bohr · adv · **🛑** | +| Exported rework symbols escape BC/architecture anchoring | #751 | process-gap · design · Bohr · adv | +| Axis proposal: boundary-sentinel inputs (false coverage) | #752 | proposal · design · Bohr · adv | +| Axis proposal: channel-lifecycle asymmetry (teardown leaks) | #753 | proposal · lifecycle · Bohr · adv | + +### Run-14 index (carried forward — folded) + +72 issues (#633–#713), chips unchanged — full per-issue rows in the run-14 body +(docs/fixtures/vsdd-factory-312-curated-run14.md) + store records (verbatim vocabulary +ingest, beadle PR #35; rich fixture vsdd-factory-312-run14-classifications-rich.json): +#633 #634 #635 #636 #637 #638 #641 #642 #643 #644 #645 #647 #648 #649 #650 #651 #652 #653 +#654 #655 #656 #658 #660 #661 #662 #663 #664 #665 #666 #667 #668 #669 #671 #672 #673 #674 +#675 #676 #677 #678 #679 #680 #681 #682 #683 #684 #685 #686 #687 #690 #692 #693 #694 #695 +#696 #697 #698 #699 #700 #701 #702 #703 #704 #705 #706 #707 #708 #709 #710 #711 #712 #713. +Cluster rollup: integrity 13 (🛑) · SDL #635 (▲) · panic #647 (💥) · keystones #671 #576 · +quick wins 21 (★) · attn #671 #686 #710 (👤) · Zious11 filings 12 · neutral pair #642 #707. + +### Run-13 index (carried forward — folded) + +104 issues (#516–#631), chips unchanged — full per-issue rows in the run-13 body +(docs/fixtures/vsdd-factory-312-curated-run13.md) + store records (impact re-canonicalized +by migrate-impact): #516 #517 #518 #519 #520 #521 #522 #523 #525 #533 #534 #535 #536 #537 +#538 #539 #540 #541 #542 #543 #544 #545 #546 #547 #548 #549 #550 #551 #552 #553 #554 #555 +#556 #557 #558 #559 #560 #561 #562 #563 #564 #565 #566 #567 #568 #569 #570 #571 #572 #573 +#574 #575 #576 #577 #578 #579 #580 #581 #582 #583 #584 #585 #586 #587 #588 #589 #590 #591 +#592 #593 #594 #595 #596 #597 #598 #599 #600 #601 #602 #603 #604 #605 #606 #607 #608 #609 +#614 #615 #616 #617 #618 #619 #620 #621 #622 #623 #624 #625 #626 #627 #628 #629 #630 #631. +Cluster rollup: integrity 14 (🛑) · SDL pair #523/#588 (▲) · panic trio #541/#548/#569 (💥) · +keystone #576 · quick wins 22 (★) · Zious11 filings #576–#584. + +### Run-12 index (carried forward — folded) + +13 issues (#503–#515), all still open, chips unchanged — full per-issue rows in the run-15 +body (docs/fixtures/vsdd-factory-312-curated-run15.md) + store records: #503 #504 #505 #506 +#507 #508 #509 #510 #511 #512 #513 #514 #515. Cluster rollup: sweep-chain quartet +#504/#505/#506/#507 (#507 KEYSTONE-adjacent terminus) · degraded pair #503/#508 (worktree) · +keystone #513 (evidence-paste, pairs with #576) · 👤 #510 (governance / reply-needed) · +★ #515 (partial fix PR #524, .gitignore half open) · minutiae #514. + + +### Run-11 index (carried forward — folded) + +66 issues (#432–#502), all still open, chips unchanged — full per-issue rows in the run-12 +body (docs/fixtures/vsdd-factory-312-curated-run12.md) + store classification records: +#432 #433 #434 #435 #436 #437 #440 #441 #442 #443 #444 #445 #446 #447 #448 #449 #450 #451 +#452 #453 #457 #458 #459 #460 #461 #462 #463 #464 #465 #466 #467 #468 #469 #470 #471 #472 +#473 #474 #475 #476 #477 #478 #479 #480 #481 #482 #483 #484 #485 #486 #487 #488 #489 #490 +#491 #492 #493 #494 #495 #496 #497 #498 #499 #500 #501 #502. Cluster rollup: integrity +block 23 (🛑) · methodology trio #462/#497/#500 · keystones #432 #462 #463 #470 #487 #488 · +quick wins 16 (★) · halts 8 (⏸) · neutral scope-doubt pair #460/#461 · #263 gitlink +containment precedent (with #341/#515). + +## Maintainer progress (outcome-paired — NOT a leaderboard) + +Surfaces resolution **against beadle-discovered defects**, rewarding the verified fix-outcome +(flagged → fixed → validates), never close-rate / time-to-triage / volume (B3 + no-Goodhart). +**This window is the second-largest drain on record — and the first to go DEEP (a P0a action with no measured-side diff).** + +| Outcome signal | Count | State | +|---|---|---| +| **Defects closed with a validated fix** | **17** | **+4 this window:** #567 (PR #728 — count-drift false positive on historical sections) · #629 (PR #720 — 7-char-SHA false negative) · #631 (PR #727 — cwd-independent cas-push) · **#204 (PR #735 — the board's oldest conversion: a 2-month-old orphan-branch session strand)** · prior 13: #418 #472 #465 #724 (through run-15) + last window's nine — #623 (**third P0b close**) #658 #660 #566 #300 #296 #243 #229 #244 (⚠ keyword auto-close, caveat carried) | +| **P0a lane — FIRST ACTION (not yet a close)** | **1 / 6** | **#342: PR #759 merged 2026-07-23 — maintainer-authored S-21.01 `validate-factory-path-staging` WASM guard + orchestrator merge pre-check (E-21 W1).** Issue open pending remaining epic waves; A4 discharged for #342 by engagement — the first maintainer-authored fix against the measured backlog | +| **Fixes merged, close pending reporter verify** | **3** | #637 (🛑 P0b — PR #715) · #690 (PR #716) · #473 (⏸ — PR #717) — all merged with `Refs` per the reporter-confirm discipline · adjacent hardening merged this window without close keywords: #737/#738 (worktree-mount gating) + #740 (state-manager idempotency contract docs) — issue sweeps land next run | +| **Partial fixes landed + engaged** | 4 | #515 (PR #524, fix 1 of 2) · #434 (PR #529, part 1) · #424 (PR #531 + correction #691) · #475 (PR #530, part 1) | +| **arcavenai PRs merged** | **30 / 31** | 8 (2026-07-19) · #725 (2026-07-21) · 13 (2026-07-22) · **+8 this window: #728 (07-22) · #714 #720 #727 #735 #737 #738 #740 (07-23)** · 1 still open (#729) | +| **Correction/review cycle** | active | #691 corrects #531 (run-14) · this window: **#714 merged after a two-finding spec-conformance round** (MEDIUM: no governing BC → answered same-day by intake #758 · ADVISORY: RELEASING.md drain step) · **#759 carries a two-pass self-review (REQUEST_CHANGES → CLEAN / APPROVE)** — the channel reviews hard and merges fast, including its own work | +| Field-data comment-events on measured issues | 23 | unchanged two windows running (run-13 trio #298 #428 #507 pattern holds) — maintainer prose keeps landing on PRs (reviews), not issue threads | +| Silent data-loss (P0a) closed with validated fix | **0 / 6** | **but the lane took its FIRST action: #342 W1 guard merged (PR #759, maintainer-authored) — A4 discharged for #342.** Residue: #365 #358 (**A4: 6/6 windows untouched**; 8 runs shadow) + #523 #588 (5 windows) + #635 (3 windows, maintainer-authored). Ramp prediction stays FAILED (evaluated run-16, permanent); v2 discharge path for the residue: measured-side SDL fix PRs | +| Source-of-truth integrity (P0b) closed | **3 / 80** | #465 ✓ #724 ✓ #623 ✓ · 77 open (incl. #747 #750 + NEW #756; #637 fix merged pending verify) | +| Halt/panic (P1 operational) closed + validated | **3 / 40** | #472 ✓ #724 ✓ #658 ✓ (+ pre-classification-era #204 strand closed this window via PR #735) · panic 4 open (#541 #548 #569 #647) · #473 fix merged pending verify | +| Envelope decision (#410) taken | 0 / 1 | 13+ issues wait on it (👤 attn.direction) — untouched by the wave | +| **Needs-human-reading items answered** | **0 / 6** | #510 (reply-needed — **18 days**, counterparty still holding PRs) · #410 · #463 · #671 #686 #710 — zero of the 36 actions across the two biggest windows touched this lane | +| Keystone consolidations accepted + wired | 0 / 17 | 16 prior + #671 (your co-maintainer's own — accept it?) | +| Quick wins exercised | **6 / 79** | #472 ✓ #660 ✓ #566 ✓ · **this window: #567 ✓ #629 ✓ #631 ✓** · #690 fix merged pending verify · on-ramp: #732 #741 #734 | +| **Measured-side hygiene** (not maintainer credit) | 5 | #226 self-closed not-reproducible (2026-07-20) · arcaven's 6 in-thread fact-checks (run-15) · #244 residual-scope comment (run-16) · **#758 filed same-day answering the #714 review's companion-BC ask** · **post-merge verification comments posted on all 7 measured fix PRs merged this window** | + +_Cold-start lifted for engagement metrics (the wheel completed verified turns); rate/streak +claims start accruing against this run's baseline. Still no per-human ranking — the metric +moves only when a real defect gets a real, validated fix._ + +## Controls + +Derived from authoritative state each render — never hand-authored. The next run parses +`- [x] `, dispatches, then resets the box (eventually consistent). + +``` +# Tier 1 — per-issue verbs (bounded to one artifact) +``` +- [ ] Read & rule on #510 (👤 reply-needed — **18 days**; external contribution flow; counterparty holding PRs on your answer) +- [ ] Fast-track #635 (🛑💾 NEW P0a — **your own filing**: mid-gate streak counter wipes unpersisted CLEAN passes) +- [ ] Verify #342 W1 + scope remaining waves (🛑💾 P0a — **E-21 W1 MERGED, your own PR #759**: WASM staging guard + merge pre-check live · A4 discharged · measured-side verify + later waves open) +- [ ] Fast-track #365 (🛑💾 P0a — rebase silently drops production code · A4: 6/6 attention windows untouched · v2 discharge path: our fix PR) +- [ ] Fast-track #358 (🛑💾 P0a — orphan merge; merge-base --is-ancestor assertion · A4: 6/6 attention windows untouched · v2 discharge path: our fix PR) +- [ ] Fast-track #523 (🛑💾 P0a — story-worktree .factory artifacts lost at teardown) +- [ ] Fast-track #588 (🛑▲ P0a — factory-side PR strands shared .factory worktree) +- [ ] Rule on #671 (👤 KEYSTONE — your co-maintainer's factory-graph proposal; gates the traceability lane) +- [ ] Deep-investigate #681 (⏸ P1 — dual-validator deadlock; strongest-of-batch external signal; four cited fixes) +- [ ] Deep-investigate #647 (🛑💥 P0b+panic — mid-edit burst death leaves corrupted continuation baseline) +- [ ] Read #710 (👤 evidence-brief + 🛑 P0b — the convergence under-measurement dataset) +- [ ] Deep-investigate #576 (🛑 KEYSTONE, your own filing — mechanical verdict derivation; pairs with #513) +- [ ] Deep-investigate #513 (KEYSTONE — evidence-paste requirement kills the false-green class) +- [ ] Deep-investigate #599 (🛑 P0b — vacuous agent-authored lint gates) +- [ ] Deep-investigate #614 (🛑 P0b — GNU-BRE gates false-GREEN on macOS) +- [ ] Deep-investigate #592 (🛑 P0b — async adversary verdicts dropped/stale-bound) +- [ ] Deep-investigate #488 (🛑 KEYSTONE — steady-state bypasses every gate) +- [ ] Deep-investigate #410 (KEYSTONE tracker — envelope-mismatch; 13 issues wait on it) +- [ ] Deep-investigate #463 (KEYSTONE — fleet-mining engine asks · 👤 standing) +- [ ] Deep-investigate #747 (🛑 NEW P0b — production edits merge past the convergence seal; thread offers the cheap converged_sha shape) +- [ ] Investigate #750 (🛑 NEW P0b — errata cited as authority with no resolvable artifact; retrofit path is cheap) +- [ ] Investigate #756 (🛑 NEW P0b — do-NOT-merge dispatch ran the full lifecycle and merged with no convergence certificate; AUTHORIZE_MERGE contract) +- [ ] Fast-track #732 (quick-win ⏸ P1 — your own #526 conversion, two missed sites; lock renew unreachable installed) +- [ ] Fast-track #741 (quick-win — two-command gitlink removal + mode-160000 health check, covers #263 too) +- [ ] Fast-track #653 (quick-win — your own per-variant test-name enumeration ask) +- [ ] Fast-track #661 (quick-win — Red Gate non-compiling middle state) +- [ ] Fast-track #515 fix 2 (quick-win — the .gitignore half; fix 1 landed in PR #524) +- [ ] Fast-track #469 (quick-win ⏸ — traceability regex one-liner) + +``` +# Tier 2 — board-level maintenance requests (read/analyze/regenerate only — B2) +``` +- [ ] Reprioritize the whole board (fresh pass over the full open corpus, 479) +- [ ] Full refresh (re-enumerate, re-validate, re-render) +- [ ] Re-validate open/closed state of every listed issue +- [ ] Re-score intent alignment (manifest v0.4) across the corpus + +_Boxes are parsed on the next scheduled run (cheap-poll-then-act). Irreversible/public actions +still escalate per B2 — these verbs only read, analyze, and regenerate._ + + + + diff --git a/docs/fixtures/vsdd-factory-312-run17-classifications-rich.json b/docs/fixtures/vsdd-factory-312-run17-classifications-rich.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..00826a3 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/fixtures/vsdd-factory-312-run17-classifications-rich.json @@ -0,0 +1,105 @@ +[ + { + "alignment": "advances", + "cited_evidence": "Cross-refs #457 (stall family) and #683 (declared-vs-actual) are plausible in-range siblings; not verifiable locally. Local checkout is stale (531dacfb, 2026-06-29): stall/idle-recovery language confirmed present in plugins/vsdd-factory/agents/orchestrator/*.md, but the probe-hygiene mandate text (restore/shasum/scratch) is not in the stale adversary.md — likely post-checkout; graded from the body narrative, no hallucination signal given the batch's overall citation fidelity.", + "cluster": [ + "orchestrator-continuation", + "observability", + "scratch-isolation" + ], + "defect_nature": "design-architectural", + "integrity": false, + "integrity_anchor": null, + "kind": "classification", + "leverage": "systemic", + "number": 755, + "operational_impact": "degraded", + "priority": "P2", + "provenance": "pilot-derived", + "quick_win_disqualification": "Conceptual defect-nature (design-architectural protocol interaction between hygiene mandate and stall-recovery diagnosis), not mechanical; the fix is a protocol redesign (retention split + ask-not-assert nudges), not a bounded one-liner. 7a excludes design-end natures.", + "quick_win_eligible": false, + "rationale": "self_referential inversion applied: an engine process-gap in the stall-recovery/hygiene protocol pair is on-mission. Matches rubric 'a pilot-derived engine process-gap that hardens the factory's own gates/convergence': a real observed incident (completed adversarial review misdiagnosed as unstarted, full duplicate battery paid) with root cause (contradictory evidence requirements: hygiene deletes the traces recovery diagnoses from) and remedies already validated over subsequent passes. Systemic: every post-hygiene stall is forensically identical to pre-work death, structurally disabling the recovery protocol's partial-delivery cost-saver. Impact is degraded (duplicate compute; run continued), not halt; deleted run outputs are regenerable-tier, so not SDL. Mandelbug: activation requires the composite of a completed pass + hygiene + the separate nondeterministic stall class (#457 family).", + "report_type": "process-gap", + "reproducibility": "mandelbug", + "run": 17, + "silent_data_loss": false, + "target": "vsdd-factory", + "ts": "2026-07-23T15:35:06Z" + }, + { + "alignment": "advances", + "cited_evidence": "Verified in stale checkout (531dacfb): BC-5.39.001 exists (CLAUDE.md, validate-per-story-adversary-convergence hook-plugin, per-story-adversary-workflow.bats); AUTHORIZE_MERGE exists (crates/hook-plugins/pr-manager-completion-guard/src/lib.rs, plugins/vsdd-factory/agents/pr-manager.md); Step-4.5 present in per-story-delivery.md + adversary.md + orchestrator docs; pr-manager agent exists. Cross-refs #452/#707/#674/#162/#492 in-range, not locally verifiable. All checks out.", + "cluster": [ + "false-green-convergence", + "dispatch-contract" + ], + "defect_nature": "design-architectural", + "integrity": true, + "integrity_anchor": "ratchet/convergence gate — Step-4.5 per-story adversarial convergence (BC-5.39.001): merge onto the protected integration branch was authorized and executed with no convergence certificate in existence, silently", + "kind": "classification", + "leverage": "systemic", + "number": 756, + "operational_impact": "none", + "priority": "P0b", + "provenance": "pilot-derived", + "quick_win_disqualification": "HARD EXCLUSION: integrity=true (touches the convergence-gate integrity_anchor; finding-004 — never a quick win regardless of trigger size). Additionally design-architectural (dispatch-scope ceiling + hook/scope coupling), not mechanical.", + "quick_win_eligible": false, + "rationale": "The convergence gate is a spec_process-tier integrity anchor ('PASS must require committed artifacts'); here code reached protected develop with the mandatory 3-consecutive-clean gate skipped entirely and an AUTHORIZE_MERGE signal asserting yes on dispatches that explicitly forbade merge — a record (merge authorization / develop's implied gate invariant) disagreeing with reality without a signal, so integrity=true and P0b per the priority discipline. self_referential inversion + rubric 'tightens an existing gate / removes a drift surface': pilot-derived (engine 1.0.0-rc.22, observed greenfield run, counted 3 hook firings with 1 acted-on, remediation arc described), with explicit non-duplicate differentiation from #452/#707/#674/#162. Liveness impact none — the factory never stopped; severity travels entirely on the safety axis (integrity), which the SKILL says to score independently. Mandelbug: pr-manager acted on the first creation-only dispatch and refused the 2nd/3rd — agent-behavior-dependent, not systematically reproducible.", + "report_type": "process-gap", + "reproducibility": "mandelbug", + "run": 17, + "silent_data_loss": false, + "target": "vsdd-factory", + "ts": "2026-07-23T15:35:06Z" + }, + { + "alignment": "advances", + "cited_evidence": "Verified in stale checkout (531dacfb): test_e2e_BC_1_14_001_async_hook_output_reaches_sink_when_fast exists at crates/factory-dispatcher/tests/full_stack_plugin_invocation.rs:676 (issue cites 733:5 — line drift consistent with 3 weeks of commits), and the file's doc-comment table maps TC-5 to BC-1.14.001 EC-012 exactly as the issue claims. host-abi-hygiene.bats absent locally — expected, post-checkout artifact (#714 era). Run/job IDs not verifiable offline.", + "cluster": [ + "test-writer-gaps" + ], + "defect_nature": "concurrency-race", + "integrity": false, + "integrity_anchor": null, + "kind": "classification", + "leverage": "minutiae", + "number": 757, + "operational_impact": "degraded", + "priority": "P3", + "provenance": "pilot-derived", + "quick_win_disqualification": "Mandelbug reproducibility (load-dependent timing flake, observed once) fails 7a's Bohrbug-or-pure-docs requirement; the fix (bounded retry/poll replacing a fixed sleep) is timing-sensitive test surgery, not a mechanical one-liner.", + "quick_win_eligible": false, + "rationale": "Rubric 'neutral-to-advances depending on whether it surfaces a real drift surface' — graded advances: a fixed-timeout wait for an async terminal event is a real false-red drift surface in the CI gate, and the report carries a complete flake-vs-regression argument (diff is markdown/scripts-only; five sibling PRs on the same base passed the identical suite minutes apart; 31m47s vs ~4m typical build evidences runner load). Pilot-derived: cites run 29965645253, job 89076422203, PR #714, exact panic text and file:line. Impact degraded — a spurious CI red stalls one PR until rerun (fail-stutter), no stoppage, false-RED is the safe direction so no integrity concern. Priority P3: default-low discipline, single observation, bounded blast radius, author offers the PR.", + "report_type": "flaky-test", + "reproducibility": "mandelbug", + "run": 17, + "silent_data_loss": false, + "target": "vsdd-factory", + "ts": "2026-07-23T15:35:06Z" + }, + { + "alignment": "advances", + "cited_evidence": "Verified in stale checkout (531dacfb): .github/workflows/release.yml line 58 greps exactly `^## ${TAG_VERSION}` as the issue's ride-along claims; RELEASING.md exists but predates #714 (no `## [Unreleased]` anchor yet — expected staleness); SS-07 class token appears across plugins/vsdd-factory tests/hooks. #714 template-task-12 / create-story step 5 / story-writer bullet artifacts are post-checkout, not locally verifiable. Refs #714/#580 in-range.", + "cluster": [ + "spec-propagation-drift" + ], + "defect_nature": "spec-requirements", + "integrity": false, + "integrity_anchor": null, + "kind": "classification", + "leverage": "minutiae", + "number": 758, + "operational_impact": "none", + "priority": "P2", + "provenance": "pilot-derived", + "quick_win_disqualification": "spec-requirements nature: authoring a governing BC is spec work, which 7a excludes from the mechanical lane (design/spec/directional). The ride-along RELEASING.md one-line reword would qualify alone, but the issue's scope is the BC.", + "quick_win_eligible": false, + "rationale": "Rubric 'improves traceability' verbatim: authors the companion BC so ACs can trace and VPs can verify the mandatory story-CHANGELOG delivery task shipped in #714. Provenance graded maintainer-authored — the task transcribes an explicit maintainer request in #714's approval ('a tracking story/task to author the companion BC should be opened before or immediately after merge'), and maintainer comments are a high-weight dynamic intent source; the blocking canonicalization question is documented as settled by #714. P2 on the maintainer-request evidence (default-low overridden by the compass); leverage minutiae — one BC for one delivery task, bounded spec bookkeeping, no liveness impact. Bohrbug in the degenerate sense: the missing-BC state is consistent and isolatable, not a runtime failure.", + "report_type": "task", + "reproducibility": "bohrbug", + "run": 17, + "silent_data_loss": false, + "target": "vsdd-factory", + "ts": "2026-07-23T15:35:06Z" + } +] \ No newline at end of file